What is Google Hiding?

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Forbes has an interesting article on a recently-discovered phenomenon: a significant percentage (between 11% - 30%) of the traffic coming from Google is missing the normal OS identification. This begets the popular rumor “Is Google developing an OS?” Time will tell.

"I'd be shocked if Google wasn't developing its own operating system," says Vince Vizzacarro, Net Applications' executive vice president of marketing. "They clearly want to ride online services without using Microsoft."
 
If the Google OS supports DirectX ... it'll be willing to be the guinea-pig early adopter.

I game a lot, and I dont use OSs that cant game.
 
I wish them luck if it's true,lord knows MS needs some real competition to give them a kick in the pants.
 
Wasn't google working on a full PC and OS combination that would be sold for a fraction of the cost of your average eMachine quite some time ago?
 
If the Google OS supports DirectX ... it'll be willing to be the guinea-pig early adopter.

I game a lot, and I dont use OSs that cant game.
LMAO because of this quote:
"They clearly want to ride online services without using Microsoft."

That's why you'll never get rid of Microsoft. They've got themselves inserted in too many things. You have to support Microsoft's products (and because of that: you support Microsoft) to have a system that it'd be worth switching to.
So, support Microsoft to have a successful OS (thus basically negating your whole purpose) or don't support Microsoft and have a less functional OS that nobody will want to use.

You can't just ignore Microsoft like that.

Heck, Apple learned this the hard way. They proclaimed their OS superior, and every year they add in more stuff to support what Microsoft and Windows do. :rolleyes:

I think it'd be a good niche OS, but heck: we already have Linux.
 
And I find this whole article a bit odd, being that Google is looking to cut products, and then they are also developing a new one? Sorry, but this new product won't be "Do no evil" because it will not only be ad-supported but have iffy TOS to collect "user statistics", and anyone that uses Gmail knows that involves checking the text of the emails. I'd sooner use a Mac.

We know the government won't care if they become a monopoly...

Google isn't a monopoly yet but they're definitely trying to get their foot in every door they can, it seems. I think it'll lead to their demise in the long run, but on the other hand it could prevent them from ending up with the likes of AltaVista.
 
The way I see it, it's either US govt'/military related (I know of several google-developed technologies that the military is currently using in Afghanistan/Iraq/abroad), or it's what people already mentioned about their new supposed OS. It could very well be a combination of both for all we know.
 
If the Google OS supports DirectX ... it'll be willing to be the guinea-pig early adopter.

I game a lot, and I dont use OSs that cant game.

Well, with their relatively high interest in the in-game ad business, I can't see them developing a crappy gaming OS.
 
Didn't Google have a custom in house only build of Ubuntu or something, Which everyone thought they were going to release? I even remember seeing a screenshot of it I think here. Don't tell me everyone forgot about it that quickly. It could be just that maybe?
 
Or it could be just like the article says - a bunch of traffic probably just streams through a proxy for whatever reason. I don't think that necessarily means they are trying to hide OS information.
 
And I find this whole article a bit odd, being that Google is looking to cut products, and then they are also developing a new one?

OSes aren't exactly developed overnight. If such a huge portion of their traffic were actually a OS in development, it probably means that they're well into development and probably were working on it during the 2006-2007 as their value skyrocketed.
 
And I find this whole article a bit odd, being that Google is looking to cut products, and then they are also developing a new one? Sorry, but this new product won't be "Do no evil" because it will not only be ad-supported but have iffy TOS to collect "user statistics", and anyone that uses Gmail knows that involves checking the text of the emails. I'd sooner use a Mac.
That is what I was thinking :\
 
I really doubt that over 10% of Google could be using a new OS without anyone else finding out. My guess is that it's some version of Linux that doesn't give a standard user-agent string.
 
Google have said many a time that they do use Linux internally (not just their servers, but desktop usage) and it is a custom/heavily tweaked distro.
They have also stated they have no plans to become a linux distributor
 
I'd say it's more likely they're using a proxy to get to the Internet, and that proxy is stripping the OS info from the headers... possibly for security reasons.
 
my friedn tried out google OS and it looked JUST like OSX same task bar crap and all, wiill this be another "chrome where they copy apple code (safari) ?
 
A: Google OS won't support DirectX. DirectX is a proprietary licensed technology, and Microsoft has no intentions of licensing DirectX to anybody. There's a reason why DirectX is a multi-billion dollar mistake for the gaming industry and why many developers are looking at Linux / GNU / OpenGL / OpenAL development stacks (first case in point: Valve confirming an x86 Linux client on the way ; second case in point : Apple Iphone ; Third Case in point : Android ; fourth case in point : Playstation 3 ; fifth case in point : Nintendo Wii... do I really need to point out how much money developers are saving by ditching DirectX and just using an API that is cross-platform... natively??)

B: I hate to be a bubble burster, but MANY Linux distributions don't identify themselves as an operating system. Also, if you install another browser besides the default FireFox, Iceweasel, Konqueror, and so-on insert your favorite *nix browser here, chances are it won't be posting an OS string either... e.g. Opera hasn't for me in the past. That so much traffic comes from Google with no OS indicator probably means that Google is using their own home-rolled Linux distribution... which... isn't exactly a big surprise to anybody since Google has pretty much been using their own home-rolled distro on their internal servers.

My personal take is that an official Google Branded Linux is probably going to happen... but I don't see it aimed at the home users. Rather, I see Google taking the approach Net-Itech took with Nitix, and selling their Linux roll-up as a search appliance OS.

I think Google is going to stay out of the home-user market and let Debian, Fedora, Suse, and the derivatives of each drive the home user market.
 
Google have said many a time that they do use Linux internally (not just their servers, but desktop usage) and it is a custom/heavily tweaked distro.
They have also stated they have no plans to become a linux distributor

disclosure: i've been at google for a few years now, working with our server infrastructure and datacenters. it's heaven for hardware geeks! :)

anyways: yes, we have an internal-only linux distro called 'goobuntu' and it's based (obviously) on ubuntu. i use it as my desktop OS, and it's pretty good. for 99.9% of the time it's a completely adequate and well performing distro, but i loathe project managers that enjoy sending out those silly multimedia powerpoint presentations. openoffice just doesn't always cut it.

as for a 'real' google OS, if i knew anything about it i (again, obviously) wouldn't be able to tell you about it. :)

but, as i'm just a systems administrator and am not privy to stuff like this, i can share my personal thoughts and opinions on this: entering the OS market would probably be a silly move. it takes a LOT of infrastructure (engineers, teams, etc) to properly support an operating system and i don't think (again, personal opinion) that google is set up to do that well. if you take a desktop OS as an example, things like device drivers and whatnot are a deal breaker.

has anyone else here tried installing slackware in the mid-90s? that was a nightmare if you had an 'uncommon' brand video or sound card...

so, these are just my thoughts on the topic.
 
i don't think (again, personal opinion) that google is set up to do that well.
Like I said before, they need to stick to search and email. That is their pot of gold, and that's what they know.

I've seen many companies try to branch out and utterly fail because they spread themselves too thin. Go from being the best at what you do, to just being another choice among many isn't a good thing.

do I really need to point out how much money developers are saving by ditching DirectX and just using an API that is cross-platform... natively??)
I agree.
But we can argue how it "should have" been all day long. Fact is that Windows is huge. It isn't going away in the foreseeable future. Xbox 360 won't go away either, too many folks on Live to ignore like that.

That said, we'll always have DirectX versions of games I think. Microsoft would have to take their first move (which IMO is changing the 360... As Windows can run just about everything- doesn't have to be DirectX). I just don't see them doing that. Could be wrong, but I don't see them changing their system to suit someone else's.
 
Like I said before, they need to stick to search and email. That is their pot of gold, and that's what they know.

I've seen many companies try to branch out and utterly fail because they spread themselves too thin. Go from being the best at what you do, to just being another choice among many isn't a good thing.

well, here i disagree. sure, google needs to stick to search/ads/email/webapps. they are definitely the 'pot of gold' and where the $$$ is.

however, google definitely prides itself on branching out, trying new and risky things, and supporting and developing what catches on. the company prides itself in not behaving like your regular techie-company and encourages people to work on fun/cool stuff (20% projects, etc).

if google were to just focus on search, webapps (email, etc) and ads, then they're setting themselves up for failure. i still think that rumors of a google OS, particularly for desktop machines, is just that: a rumor. and personally, i think it'd be stupid to go down that path.
 
if google were to just focus on search, webapps (email, etc) and ads, then they're setting themselves up for failure.
Why do you say that? Improve on your search. Add new features. Keep it 100% desirable. Yahoo's technology is pretty darn good, in case you haven't noticed, it just lacks the leadership and implementation to be wildly successful. Google loses its focus and it will get burned.

But in general, I'll just refer to my prior quote.

Google isn't a monopoly yet but they're definitely trying to get their foot in every door they can, it seems. I think it'll lead to their demise in the long run, but on the other hand it could prevent them from ending up with the likes of AltaVista.
 
I wish them luck if it's true,lord knows MS needs some real competition to give them a kick in the pants.

but do we want that competition to come from google... i think i feel safer at the idea of the chinese government funding their new os...
 
What makes you guys think Google will be successful in developing an OS?

To date, here are the only successful google products: Gmail, Google Adsense, and Google Search itself

I think they should focus on their core competency, which is building quality internet applications.

They constantly try to release new products that usually fail. For example, take a look at the Google Chrome web browser. Sure, it had a lot of hype, but it's not any better than Internet Explorer or Firefox. It takes a ton of work to build an operating system and I am pretty certain Google would not be successful in that venture.

Remember how they were supposed to create this revolutionary cell phone operating system called Android. If you haven't been keeping up with it, so far the reviews haven't been favorable at all. If they can't even code a cell phone operating system in 2 years, it will probably be 10 years before they make a PC operating system.
 
At least I'm not alone in thinking they need to stick with what they know ;)

I'd put money down on this fact: If Google loses sight of its primary goals (email, search, ads), they'll go belly up.

I'd bet money on that.

Live search, Yahoo search... These are both VERY good search engines. They just lack the implementation. Google hits a bump, and I'm sure Microsoft would have no issues with jumping on the opportunity.
 
Back
Top