sli 8800gt or single 260

rjolin01

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 31, 2008
Messages
1,399
should i just stick with my current 8800gt sli setup or sell the cards and go for a 260 or 280 card? i play games and currently have a 24in monitor that has max res of 1600x1200.
 
I disagree with the whole 260&280 > than a SLI setup. If you already have 2x8800GTs, you are not going to notice a performance increase switching to the 2x series of Nvidia cards. The micro-stuttering issue is overblown.

Having used both, I much preferred my 2x8800GTS in SLI to the 260.
 
The 8800GT in SLI vs the 260 are equal in performance. In some tests, the 8800gt SLI beat the 260
 
Just silly wasting cash on the 260 when you already have 8800GT SLI. That SLI setup is still pretty much on-par, in many cases even better, than the latest single-GPU cards at that resolution; you need a higher resolution and lots of AA before those cards start showing an improvement in FPS, and even then the SLI setup( and the 9800GX2 ) still manages to keep up if the game's got decent SLI support.

In short, there's really no games out there( except StalkerCS and Crysis, but even the 280GTX and 4870X2 have big problems with those games ) that needs a better graphical setup, unless you run them at the highest resolutions. Save your cash for now, and wait for better GPUs and more demanding games.
 
if op ran at 19x12 the 260 would be the better performing part across the board.
 
^^^ At the least, some of these guys haven't read the thread. I.E., the OP already owns 2x8800GT. Also, considering a 9800GX2 ran faster than my GTX 280 in several situations, saying that a GTX 260 runs better than 8800GT SLI "across the board" is quite false.
 
^^^ At the least, some of these guys haven't read the thread. I.E., the OP already owns 2x8800GT. Also, considering a 9800GX2 ran faster than my GTX 280 in several situations, saying that a GTX 260 runs better than 8800GT SLI "across the board" is quite false.

i too own a gx2 as well as 260's and 280's, and i can say with great certainty that both the 260 and 280 play better at 19x12 than the inconsistent stuttering mess that i get with the gx2.
 
i too own a gx2 as well as 260's and 280's, and i can say with great certainty that both the 260 and 280 play better at 19x12 than the inconsistent stuttering mess that i get with the gx2.

But even at 19*12 the GX2, and the slightly slower 8800GT SLI setup, still easily outperforms the 260, and some of the time the 280, fps-wise. So it boils down to if you're one of the 'MICTOSTUTTERING KILLED MY CAT' people or not, really.

At any rate, it's all a moot point since he's running at 16*12 and already owns the 8800GT's, at which point most sane people should advice that he save his cash this time around. Upgrading to anything other than at least a 280 or 4870X2 will result in a net loss of fps.
 
At any rate, it's all a moot point since he's running at 16*12 and already owns the 8800GT's, at which point most sane people should advice that he save his cash this time around. Upgrading to anything other than at least a 280 or 4870X2 will result in a net loss of fps.

agreed.
 
So it boils down to if you're one of the 'MICTOSTUTTERING KILLED MY CAT' people or not, really.

:D

Apparently, this rare and elusive "mictosuttering" also causes blindess, baldness, and erectile dysfunction.
 
did not realize this was such hot topic. But seems the panel is split as to which is better although seems more evidence I should just sit on my 8800gt sli for now. At least till 280's drop in price.
 
I've always been skeptical of multi-GPU solutions, so I'd recommend the single GTX260. If you already have one 8800GT and you're considering an upgrade you could go for the 2nd 8800GT and get about equal performance at a lower price.
 
I've always been skeptical of multi-GPU solutions, so I'd recommend the single GTX260. If you already have one 8800GT and you're considering an upgrade you could go for the 2nd 8800GT and get about equal performance at a lower price.

Yet another person fails to read the OP's post.
 
Yeah, no one seems to be reading the OP's post. HE ALLREADY HAS TWO 8800GT's in SLI!

It would be a waste of time and money to get a single GTX260. Sure, the GTX260 doesn't have microstutter - But the 8800GT's in SLI perform better in most games - And he allready owns them!

Now, if he didn't allready own the 8800GT's - Then the 260 would be the better choice. However, he does own them; making the suggestion of buying a single 260 rediculous.
 
I was thinking about the same thing, OP. I ended up sticking with my SLI 8800GTs, just seemed like a waste of money to get a GTX260 for very minimal gain or hardly any gain at all.
 
I'm actually on SLI 8800GT's right now and ordered a GTX260 for $205 w/ free shipping off of newegg. Even though I will see hardly any performance gains - I'm doing it because once I sell off both 8800GT's on ebay - I will have recouped the cost of the GTX260 anyways. If I wait longer, the GTX260 will be pulled off the shelves anyways, and the 8800GT's will never be worth as much as it is now.

So while there are a few AAA titles where my SLI 8800GT's would perform better in - I'm tired of dealing with the beta driver BS whenever a new game comes out. Even in the games where the SLI 8800GT's tend to do better then the GTX260 - I can notice micro-stutter/flickering every now and then - And there will be some points in time where the FPS will dip for no reason and then continue just fine.

So those issues, combined with the fact that the GTX260 has more VRAM, and overclocks quite substantially - I'll take the GTX260 right now since I can recoup the cost by selling my 8800GT's anyways.

Now, if the GTX260 were still $250+ - I wouldn't have thought about it.
 
i agree that it would be a waste of money, since you already have the 8800 gt sli setup. but if you just had one 8800 gt and you wanted to upgrade i'd say go for the 260. thats what i did, i couldn't find another 8800 gt to sli. so i just bought a 260.:D
 
thanks again everyone...think i am staying with my current sli until maybe tax time when i think 260 will go down even more in price. also i am starting a new thread in memory as to is it worth getting sli ram. this kinda combines this and my how much is enough memory thread.
 
rjolin01 you should overclock that cpu, it will help with your fps and general rig performance. Some have got our cpu's stable to 3.6g im happy @ 3.2g but I definitely saw a difference. Simple adjustment and increase cpu voltage.
 
i have tried to figure out how to oc this mobo but its different than my gigabyte and doest have it where u can oc it the same way...but i will figure it out and give it a try sometime soon.
 
Keep your current setup.. unless you are playing alot of games that don't utilize sli worth a crap it does not make sense to me. Wait for next gen cards if you want to upgrade.

Definitely oc the cpu, my 6750 ran at 3.4ghz stock volts, I am sure it will do 3.2 without any issue at stock volts. Don't add volts unless you have to, more volts equals alot more heat.
 
Well if you even considering a gtx 260 get the gtx 260 core 216 as it is >= 4870 1gb with latest drivers and stock clocks, as to what i would do if i was you and "chose to upgrade," depending on your budget... I would be seriously considering the 4850x2, i know you seem to like the green team, but from every review site i have scoured the conclusion seems to be unanimous that the $289.00 4850x2 2gb beats the gtx 280 in nearly all benchmarks. You can pick up a 4850x2 2gb from newegg for $309.00 plus $20 mail in rebate.
 
Back
Top