Can't decide on a 4850 1GB

GJSNeptune

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Mar 31, 2004
Messages
12,372
I'm going berserk choosing a video card. I'm currently planning an Intel build. So far I have an E8400 with an Asus P5Q Pro.

Pending choices:
Antec Twelve Hundred
Corsair HX620
Corsair 2x2GB XMS2 DDR2-1066 DHX, memory fan, blah blah

I don't have the funds for Crossfire, so I'd like a solid, cool video card. I'm pretty set on a 4850 1GB, but I have no idea which one to get. The HIS card with IceQ4 looks nice, but this Asus board seems a bit cramped. I suppose down the road sometime I could get another 4850 1GB. I'd like to keep that option open.

But I need a card that runs as cool as possible without aftermarket cooling.

HIS (dual) $199 AR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814161245

Gigabyte (dual) $180 AR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814125237
 
I would get the HIS, its heatsink looks like it has more copper rather than aluminum
 
If you plan on gaming, do not get a passive heatsink model, you'll need to cool that puppy down. I also recommend the HIS model. I have two 3870 IceQ's & they treat me well.
 
Neither. Either spend a lot less and get an HD 4850 512MB or spend a few bucks more (like $20-$40) and get an HD 4870 512MB - or another $80 and get an HD 4870 1GB (where the extra RAM would be worth it). There's almost no difference in performance between the two HD 4850 versions at any resolution. There IS a difference between the two HD 4870 versions.
 
I remember reading a review that showed that the passive cooled one is really nice, especially if you add a 80 mm fan or some thing to it. The passive cooler does a great job, plus the gigabyte overclocks well.

what if you did a 512mb one? a new one and then an open box one?
 
I'd like to get one really good card right now. Great performance and as little heat as possible.
 
The ICE-Q is your best bet for cool temps on a stock sink. You won't be disappointed.
 
DO NOT get 512MB! The extra 512MB in 1GB cards is making a huge difference in some of the newer titles like far cry 2, this will only continue.
 
$20-40 isn't a few bucks more. I don't want to spend more than $200.

Fine, go with the first part of my post if you think 20-40 bucks is a lot of money. Get an HD 4850 512 MB. You'll see no appreciable difference between it and the 1GB and save yourself some dough in the process. Single slot, dual slot - you'll still save money over the 1GB.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814161243

Just saved you $30 you didn't need to spend on your first choice.
 
I would get the
68d30a9594728bc39aa24be94b319d21.jpg
HIS.
 
HIS uses painted aluminum, no copper in it.

haha! I wouldn't put it past em, cheap basterds.

I'd go with the gigabyte for almost that reason. HIS will look for any excuse to deny an RMA should you ever need one. Gigabyte isn't exactly the best for help, they're slow, but they wont screw you over. industry standard 3 years instead of the 2 year from HIS IIRC.

$20-40 isn't a few bucks more. I don't want to spend more than $200.

QFT. I've been in this business a couple years now and you have to draw a line in the sand. People on this forum don't seem to get it sometimes, an extra $20 ALWAYS gives you 300% more performance. You just gotta state a number and go with it. Also people seem to figure a total build cost doesnt include a copy of windows or a DVD drive :\.


Good point, right now its hard to go with ATI at ATI's current pricing. ATI needs money off this one (you think agena (Phenom X4) is profitable? They're cannabalizing their GPU profits with low CPU pricing), and I'm sure their math guys have figured there making maximum profit right now, and I'm sure Nvidia's profit margines on the GTX series is razor thin (if not non-existant), so its hard to argue for an HD4870 or HD4850 right now.

If I were the OP, I'd take a serious look into a GTX260, its a really slick card.
 
But it's a Crossfire board, so if I ever did want multiple video cards, it'd be wisest to get a Radeon.
 
Well true but you said you wanted a fast single card and the GTX 260 is MUCH faster than the 4850.
If you do have your mind set on a 4850 then get the 512MB version because that core doesn't have enough power to need that extra RAM unless your doing high AA at 19x12 or bigger, which that card doesn't have the power to do in new games. Once you get to the 4870 however it helps.
 
But it's a Crossfire board, so if I ever did want multiple video cards, it'd be wisest to get a Radeon.
actually its wisest to get the best bang for buck single card and not even worry about multi card solutions and all their issues.
 
But it's a Crossfire board, so if I ever did want multiple video cards, it'd be wisest to get a Radeon.

thats a bit of a touchy subject. Usually the next generation video card at the same price is twice as fast as the previous gen, making SLI and CrossfireX nothing more than buzzwords. EX: You have a 7800GTX thinking when the 8 series starts It'l cause 7800GTX prices on ebay to drop significantly, then you get the performance results from an 8800GTS and its destroying the numbers put up by a 7800GTX SLI setup, (with alot less hassle too). In a similar situation with say an X800 to an X1800 this is obviously not the case (well, keeping in mind the SM3.0 support).

Using myself as an example (and assuming my 680i board never commited harry karry), I could grab a 2nd 8800GTS 640mb for $100 on ebay, or sell this one for the same price (or more, got my RMA back, shipped out my broken black PCB'd 8800GTS 96SP and got a green PCB'd 8800GTS SSC (112SP) back :D) + another $40 and grab a GTX 260. I'd say the better choice would be to sell and go with the GTX 260.

Its your call, and the GTX 260 is an extra $30 up front.
 
Its your call, and the GTX 260 is an extra $30 up front.
actually the the GTX260 is only 10 bucks more up front because it has free shipping. then when you get your rebates back for whatever card you choose the GTX260 is just that much better.
 
its good to see you sticking to your guns on the price thing. people might forget that you have already looked at total cost, shipping, tax perhaps and lookin at say almoast 200 with shipping verses pushing 300 might be a deal breaker unless you want to say screw and pay the 300.

I being poor and haveing a family and all and other bills and still wanting to game have had to make (A LOT OF COMPROMISES). some people think money should be no big thing sometimes i think. Just my thaught.
 
its good to see you sticking to your guns on the price thing. people might forget that you have already looked at total cost, shipping, tax perhaps and lookin at say almoast 200 with shipping verses pushing 300 might be a deal breaker unless you want to say screw and pay the 300.

I being poor and haveing a family and all and other bills and still wanting to game have had to make (A LOT OF COMPROMISES). some people think money should be no big thing sometimes i think. Just my thaught.
well sometimes you have to look at the big picture. if you have a budget of 200 bucks but theres a substantially better product for 10-20 bucks more then you make adjustments. once you buy something the value drops tremendously so saving a little money for something inferior that only makes you want to upgrade sooner anyway is silly. of course everybody has a limit somewhere but if you are going to get something make sure it will meet your needs.
 
lol, there's no reason not to get the GTX 260 cannondale06 linked, it's only $10 more out the door, and you get a way faster card.

Forget crossfire, you're board isn't even an x16 by x16 board, it's 8 x 8.

HD4850 1gb and HD4870 512mb is a horrible value right now with the GTX 260 192core in the market and at this price point.
 
In almost 95% of the tests i have seen the 1Gb versus the 512Mb its only faster by maybe 2-3fps so save your pennies and get you the 512mb
 
DO NOT get 512MB! The extra 512MB in 1GB cards is making a huge difference in some of the newer titles like far cry 2, this will only continue.

on the 4850 even? 4870 maybe, but is the 4850 powerful enough to really use 1G ?
 
In almost 95% of the tests i have seen the 1Gb versus the 512Mb its only faster by maybe 2-3fps so save your pennies and get you the 512mb
2-3 fps can be a lot when you are only getting in the 30-40fps range in newer games. also playability is much improved in situations where 512mb just isnt enough. you are right that in most cases 512mb is enough for the 4850. now with a card like the 4870 it would be foolish to not get the 1gb model as even 2 or 3 current games show nice improvements.
 
Are you sure the P5Q Pro would drop to x8 by x8 with two cards? If that's the case, then I'll definitely consider whichever company has the best solution for $200ish.

But how significant of a performance hit would it be to operate both cards at x8 instead of x16?
 
Are you sure the P5Q Pro would drop to x8 by x8 with two cards? If that's the case, then I'll definitely consider whichever company has the best solution for $200ish.

But how significant of a performance hit would it be to operate both cards at x8 instead of x16?
yes all P45 boards drop to 8x. to be honest that would not make much difference with 4850 crossfire setup. you have pci-e 2.0 so it just like the old pci-e 1.0 or 1.1 x16 in performance. if you actually listen to what everybody says then you would realize that a single card is best.

the GTX260 card I linked to is only 10 bucks more than the 4850 card you were looking at and is even cheaper by the time you get rebates back on either card. that GTX260 IS the best bang for buck right now. if you keep sitting around twiddling your thumbs you will miss out on that killer deal.

hey if you want to spend more in the long run for less card then knock yourself out. you want to go with a dual card solution then again I wish you luck and I am sure you will be back on the forums asking for help dealing with issues in some games.
 
I only was only recommending ATI because it seemed that's what the O.P. was settled on, but you're right - this is much better than any of those listed.
well actually my reply was in response to the OPs selection. I probably should have quoted him. well I have done my part in suggesting the best card for the money and I know I am looking forward to my GTX260.
 
Why are the GTX 260s so goofy with 896MB of 448-bit memory?

Would a Core 216 card be a better buy? The reason I'm having a hard time with components is because I'm trying to sell my current computer before I build the new one. But I, of course, don't want to spend more than I need to.
 
THe 260 with 216 cores actually out performs the 4870hd 512mb, not sure about the 1mb version, but it only comes down to like a few fps were talking about like i said earlier.
 
gogogadget gtx 260 for single card goodness. when it all boils down when you want to get dual, sell it get your duals. i say this for the price its really hard to argue.
 
Why are the GTX 260s so goofy with 896MB of 448-bit memory?

The GTX 280 is 1GB 512-bit. Disable a block or two (from manufacturing defects when making GTX 280 cores) and you get the "goofy" 448-bit memory that results in 896MB RAM. Its all about maximizing defective cores. Since ATI is still on a 256-bit bus (thanks to GDDR5), it isn't as much of a problem for them.

Would a Core 216 card be a better buy? The reason I'm having a hard time with components is because I'm trying to sell my current computer before I build the new one. But I, of course, don't want to spend more than I need to.

From what I remember in the [H] review the Core 216 was only slightly better. If you are concerned about cost, either get a 4850 512mb for $150 or less, or get the GTX 260 for $215. There really isn't any cost effective choice that fits between those two.
 
Do you have a link that shows the performance increase was slight? If it is indeed slight, I'd be happy to save some money.

I'm pretty sure I'll be getting a 24" monitor, so I'll need the extra memory.

EDIT: Nevermind. I saw the Far Cry 2 graph showing a 1fps increase with a Core 216.
 
Back
Top