India Lands Probe on Moon

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
India joined the US, Russia, the European Space Agency, Japan, and China in the lunar club by landing a probe on the moon on Friday. Don’t look for the flag next time you’re bouncing around the Shackleton crater though. It’s likely scattered into tiny bits after the probe slammed into the lunar surface at more than 3,100 MPH.

The violent landing was planned and Indian scientists hope to study the images and data sent back by the probe during its 25-minute descent to prepare for a future "soft" landing, Guruprasad told The Associated Press. It carried a video imaging system, a radar altimeter and a mass spectrometer.
 
Wow and I thought NASA was a waste of money. Having a space program that is just redoing decade old endeavors is silly and expensive.
 
Can you honestly call slamming a probe into the moon at 3,100 MPH a 'landing'?
 
My first thought was.....great, now they can set up more tech support call centers.

Then, after seeing that it slammed into the surface, it makes me think it wasn't planned. They can now just say, "We meant to do that...uhh...for science."
 
This immediately made me think of North Korea. A large portion of your country lives in extreme poverty and you are spending millions sending things into space.....:rolleyes:
 
There is an old saying that a "landing is just a very controlled crash", but it still doesn't make it to the "any landing you walk away from" club though.
 
Wow and I thought NASA was a waste of money. Having a space program that is just redoing decade old endeavors is silly and expensive.

How can you say this.. With the discovery of exoplanets and the fact that we are blowing up our own planet, I think NASA needs a much larger budget..
 
My first thought was.....great, now they can set up more tech support call centers.

Then, after seeing that it slammed into the surface, it makes me think it wasn't planned. They can now just say, "We meant to do that...uhh...for science."

the other thing they dont want to tell you..... it was manned ;)
 
How can you say this.. With the discovery of exoplanets and the fact that we are blowing up our own planet, I think NASA needs a much larger budget..

so... you think that, us humans, that seemingly cant even take care of the planet perfect for us (we evolved here)... you think we can rehabilitate another planet unknown light years away to an acceptable living standard?? ridiculous..... nasa is a waste of money....


we aint moving to another planet dude... get over it... it just AINT gonna happen...
 
Considering there many far more advanced and richer nations that haven't made a mark on the moon it's a remarkable feat no matter what year it is :rolleyes:.

Until now it's been considered a waste of time. We did it before because we wanted to beat the Soviet to the moon. It was more or less politics.

Recent probes and telescopes and scans have shown a possibility of there being water (or ice, rather) on the moon's polar surface which makes it ideal to obtain fuel from space so we can travel further. A vast amount of fuel is wasted trying to break through our atmosphere, hence we can't go very far right now.

Personally I think India should have saved their money and efforts and collaborated with other countries who already did all this and work from there. I see this as reinventing the wheel.
 
They DID collaborate with other nations...

Apart from the above indigenous payloads/experiments, ISRO solicited proposals through an Announcement of Opportunity (AO) from International and Indian Scientific Community for participating in the mission by providing suitable scientific payloads, complementing the overall Chandrayaan-1 scientific objectives. Out of the proposals received, six experiments were selected for inclusion in Chandrayaan-1 mission; two of the AO payloads, C1XS and SARA are developed by ESA jointly with ISRO.

There is more to India then Mud huts & call centers....
http://www.isro.org/Chandrayaan/htmls/psexperiments.htm
 
Until now it's been considered a waste of time. We did it before because we wanted to beat the Soviet to the moon. It was more or less politics.

Recent probes and telescopes and scans have shown a possibility of there being water (or ice, rather) on the moon's polar surface which makes it ideal to obtain fuel from space so we can travel further. A vast amount of fuel is wasted trying to break through our atmosphere, hence we can't go very far right now.

Personally I think India should have saved their money and efforts and collaborated with other countries who already did all this and work from there. I see this as reinventing the wheel.

I don't judge other countries if they prioritize space exploration. Just because other countries have done it does not preclude them from trying themselves. Other moon landing countries don't share their data as far as space travel goes, those are top secret information. Landing (crashing) a chunk of earth-bound object on the moon requires considerable research and they are learning alot from this. And it being considered a waste of time is just your opinion, not the the consensus. I'm sure the scientific community would beg to differ.

As for reinventing the wheel, you're were probly trying to sound smart but that doesn't make any sense. They're not trying to reinvent anything, they're just trying to do it.

All this India shoulda, coulda, woulda just seem to me more about an exclusive club not being exclusive anymore.
 
My first thought was.....great, now they can set up more tech support call centers.

Then, after seeing that it slammed into the surface, it makes me think it wasn't planned. They can now just say, "We meant to do that...uhh...for science."

It was planned to impact...no conspiracy here for that look into Fed R...

http://www.isro.org/Chandrayaan/htmls/mip.htm

The impact probe of 35 kg mass will be attached at the top deck of the main orbiter and will be released during the final 100 km x 100 km orbit at a predetermined time to impact at a pre-selected location. During the descent phase, it is spin-stabilized. The total flying time from release to impact on Moon is around 25 minutes.
The primary objective is to demonstrate the technologies required for landing the probe at a desired location on the Moon and to qualify some of the technologies related to future soft landing missions.
Major Objectives:
#
Design, development and demonstration of technologies required for impacting a probe at the desired location on the Moon.

#
Qualify technologies required for future soft landing missions.
 
Can you honestly call slamming a probe into the moon at 3,100 MPH a 'landing'?

I was thinking the same thing. They also claimed that they had planted a flag on the moon becuase their crash bound probe was painted in indias colors.
 
Considering there many far more advanced and richer nations that haven't made a mark on the moon it's a remarkable feat no matter what year it is :rolleyes:.

I'm pretty sure that most nations can hit the moon with something, it's landing and being able to return to earth that is the tricky part ;)
 
Wow and I thought NASA was a waste of money. Having a space program that is just redoing decade old endeavors is silly and expensive.


If you did any reading on this topic you would know that this mission is mapping the moon in more detail then ever before done by ANY nation..


Scientific Objectives
The Chandrayaan-1 mission is aimed at high-resolution remote sensing of the moon in visible, near infrared (NIR), low energy X-rays and high-energy X-ray regions. Specifically the objectives are
#
To prepare a three-dimensional atlas (with high spatial and altitude resolution of 5-10 m) of both near and far side of the moon.

#
To conduct chemical and mineralogical mapping of the entire lunar surface for distribution of mineral and chemical elements such as Magnesium, Aluminum, Silicon, Calcium, Iron and Titanium as well as high atomic number elements such as Radon, Uranium & Thorium with high spatial resolution.

The Simultaneous photo geological, mineralogical and chemical mapping through Chandrayaan-1 mission will enable identification of different geological units to infer the early evolutionary history of the Moon. The chemical mapping will enable to determine the stratigraphy and nature of the Moon's crust and thereby test certain aspects of magma ocean hypothesis. This may allow to determine the compositions of impactors that bombarded the Moon during its early evolution which is also relevant to the formation of the Earth.

http://www.isro.org/Chandrayaan/htmls/objective_scientific.htm
 
I don't judge other countries if they prioritize space exploration. Just because other countries have done it does not preclude them from trying themselves. Other moon landing countries don't share their data as far as space travel goes, those are top secret information. Landing (crashing) a chunk of earth-bound object on the moon requires considerable research and they are learning alot from this. And it being considered a waste of time is just your opinion, not the the consensus. I'm sure the scientific community would beg to differ.

As for reinventing the wheel, you're were probly trying to sound smart but that doesn't make any sense. They're not trying to reinvent anything, they're just trying to do it.

All this India shoulda, coulda, woulda just seem to me more about an exclusive club not being exclusive anymore.

Yeah you got me. I was trying to sound smart. :rolleyes:

Piss off.
 
not to mention nasa is interested in the mapping information for base locations.
 
If you did any reading on this topic you would know that this mission is mapping the moon in more detail then ever before done by ANY nation..
Relax, man. People were making some jokes...no need to get your underoos all bunched up. It's okay...trust me. the sun will rise tomorrow.
 
Way to discuss maturely and intelligently. :rolleyes:

Wait, if you insult people, it's intelligent conversation, but if someone else tells you to piss off when you insult them, it's not?

I'm confused. :rolleyes:

Stop trying to uh.. sound smart. Yeah.

Everyone's got opinions, and I'm pretty sure you don't work for NASA and know what they're thinking about just as much as I don't.
 
I don't judge other countries if they prioritize space exploration. Just because other countries have done it does not preclude them from trying themselves. Other moon landing countries don't share their data as far as space travel goes, those are top secret information. Landing (crashing) a chunk of earth-bound object on the moon requires considerable research and they are learning alot from this. And it being considered a waste of time is just your opinion, not the the consensus. I'm sure the scientific community would beg to differ.

As for reinventing the wheel, you were probly trying to sound smart but that doesn't make any sense. They're not trying to reinvent anything, they're just trying to do it.

All this India shoulda, coulda, woulda just seem to me more about an exclusive club not being exclusive anymore.

Wait, if you insult people, it's intelligent conversation, but if someone else tells you to piss off when you insult them, it's not?

I'm confused. :rolleyes:

Stop trying to uh.. sound smart. Yeah.

Everyone's got opinions, and I'm pretty sure you don't work for NASA and know what they're thinking about just as much as I don't.

Nothing in my previous statement was insulting you. That you did get offended is your personal issue. I'm done with this so called conversation.
 
so... you think that, us humans, that seemingly cant even take care of the planet perfect for us (we evolved here)... you think we can rehabilitate another planet unknown light years away to an acceptable living standard?? ridiculous..... nasa is a waste of money....


we aint moving to another planet dude... get over it... it just AINT gonna happen...

your right actually.. we will most probably destroy ourselves one way or another way before we can make any kind of major progress with deep space exploration
 
your right actually.. we will most probably destroy ourselves one way or another way before we can make any kind of major progress with deep space exploration

Exactly what I was going to say. When we are finally pushed to evacuate this lovely gem of a planet it will be to late.
 
^Funny :rolleyes:
Anyway, this is a great achievement for our space programme. How come no one criticised the CHinese for spacewalks and putting taikonauts into space? After all, the Soviets and the Americans had done it as well, right? Why reinvent the wheel?
 
i think your confused. the chinese were doing MOONWALKS, and it was only because they saw a michael jackson music video.
 
Maybe they'll establish a new tech support call center on the moon...
 
Manned flight actually had validity a long time ago though. Birds could fly- we could observe this. Using the same principles we can fly.

Living on a different planet? Totally different.

Right now we have not A CLUE of how we'd make it viable.
We've got to get oxygen, water, figure out some way to grow plants, animals, deal with radiation, all that mess while lacking gravity. The reports on the astronauts in the ISS of all the radiation they're exposed to is not encouraging, either- and the only solution right now is to limit their time up there.

Then you've got to shuttle BILLIONS of people out to many different planets. What do we have now? The moon, maybe Mars???


I'd agree our days would be over with by the time that happened. Whatever you believe: apocalypse, nuclear warfare, bio attack... We won't be around long enough to see that day.
 
I'm an advocate for manned space exploration... let me respond to this post:

Right now we have not A CLUE of how we'd make it viable.

Actually, we do have quite a big clue. We have ISS crews staying up there in 6 month intervals. We have plans to have a moon base in about 10 years. Obviously, space exploration is very challenging. But compare what we know now compared to when NASA was created about 50 years ago... that knowledge is more valuable than any dollar amount.

We've got to get oxygen, water, figure out some way to grow plants, animals, deal with radiation, all that mess while lacking gravity. The reports on the astronauts in the ISS of all the radiation they're exposed to is not encouraging, either- and the only solution right now is to limit their time up there.

There is a lot known about all this... I'm not going to go into specific details, but trust me I am pretty sure that NASA and all other space-faring organizations are aware of the needs of the astronauts.

Then you've got to shuttle BILLIONS of people out to many different planets. What do we have now? The moon, maybe Mars???

I'd agree our days would be over with by the time that happened. Whatever you believe: apocalypse, nuclear warfare, bio attack... We won't be around long enough to see that day.

True... but that's not the reason we're going into space. We as human beings have a need to learn, explore, and take on big challenges. The Earth has been explored mostly, so space is the next step. There are many unanswered questions still.
 
Back
Top