AMD's answer to the i7?

Showing bias and preference as a fan is one thing, doing it as a moderator is surely another.

Where exactly is he being biased?
Financial records prove his claims about AMD's lack of profitability... and it doesn't take a genius to figure out that Nehalem has finally leveled the playing field in the server market with Intel now having QPI (star-networked multisocket setups) and onboard memorycontrollers (NUMA), making them more competitive.
 
Showing bias and preference as a fan is one thing, doing it as a moderator is surely another.

I'm not a moderator. :D

The things I post in the forum are my own personal opinions. I'd like to think my personal opinions are based on experience with hardware and that they are tempered with reason and logic. As far as bias goes, we all get accused of bias when someone feels like we are trashing their favorite company. I've been accused of AMD, ATI, Intel and NVIDIA bias all within a few days of each other. I go where ever the best performance is. If that's AMD then so be it. If that's Intel than that's what I'm going with. During the 486 and Pentium days I ran Intel processors (when I could afford to do so) because they were faster and didn't suffer from application compatibility problems. During the Athlon 64 days I ran an Athlon 64 setup then a dual Opteron 254 setup. In the early Pentium 4 (socket 423) days I ran a Thunderbird. Now I run a Core 2 setup. I will run a Core i7 setup very soon. Trust me I'm only biased against the products that under perform or suffer from terrible quality. I think my posts reflect this as a general rule.

The Phenom has been nothing but a let down since day one. In some ways it was even a step backwards from the Athlon X2. They haven't been able to beat Kentsfield's performance in the span of almost two years its' been around. They haven't answered Yorkfield at all. It is highly unlikely that a core based on the Phenom is going to leapfrog the architecture they can barely match and then pass Yorkfield, and then after that catch and or pass Nehalem. The thought of Deneb or Shanghai matching or passing Nehalem just seems totally implausible. It sounds like a fantasy. Right now all the evidence points to AMD's 45nm chips being a die shrink with more cache memory. I'm sorry but this will not get AMD's next processor to the pereformance levels they need in order to challenge Intel's performance dominance.

There are no reliable sources I've seen stating that there will be serious architectural improvements in the next generation of AMD processors and that those improvements will be enough to make Phenom a viable performance contender. The only people stating otherwise are fan boys who sit there behind their keyboards fantasizing about AMD kicking Intel's ass and hoping that AMD knew what they were doing when they put out Phenom and that some how the entire architecture wasn't a mistake or a cruel joke. That it was part of some far reaching plan and that the architecture would some day shine and wipe the smirk's off the faces of those Intel loving Core 2 Duo/Quad owners.
 
Where exactly is he being biased?
Financial records prove his claims about AMD's lack of profitability... and it doesn't take a genius to figure out that Nehalem has finally leveled the playing field in the server market with Intel now having QPI (star-networked multisocket setups) and onboard memorycontrollers (NUMA), making them more competitive.

Exactly my point. I also conceed that I am simply speculating concerning the performance of AMD's next generation processor parts. I do not know what levels of performance they will bring to the table but I just think that the likely hood of AMD being able to leapfrog Yorkfield and Nehalem from near Kentsfield performance levels is highly unlikely given what we know about the Phenom's architecture.
 
I think we have to wait a little bit to have this argument. When the core I7 becomes available we will know.
 
I think we have to wait a little bit to have this argument. When the core I7 becomes available we will know.

Well I have had hands on experience with the Core i7. Not as much as Kyle has, but I've got to tell you, it seems VERY unlikely to me from looking at the performance numbers. I've seen the numbers compared between the Phenom, Core 2, and Core i7 and it just seems unlikely that AMD is going to match them.
 

I liked Intel's response quoted at the bottom of the TG Daily article.

"Update August 19, 10:50 am EDT: Intel spokesman Nick Knupffer provided us with Intel's view on this announcement. Not surprisingly, Intel has a different opinion:
"Indeed, this is the smallest SRAM cell that has been demonstrated, but producing a single cell is merely an exercise in lithography scaling. The announcement admits that they only have demonstrated a 22 nm SRAM 'cell', not a 22 nm SRAM 'array' of any given density. A single SRAM cell has 6 transistors in it. Intel's 32 nm SRAM array, which we announced back in September, has 290 million cells or bits, and a total of 1.9 billion transistors. IBM has yet to report a large working 32 nm SRAM array as Intel did last September. Intel's 32 nm technology will use our 2nd generation of high-k + metal gate transistors."


Still even if AMD will end up with 32nm chips in late 2009 it still doesn't change anything in regard to Deneb or Shanghai.
 
The architecture it not obsolete. It would be obsolete if there was a new architecture from AMD or the Phenom architecture wasn't in use any longer - but it's neither of those things. Something is not obsolete just because it isn't the best/fastest at what it does.

Fine. It's not obsolete, it's just outdated, and it has been since day 1. The fastest Phenom chip is barely competitive with the slowest C2Q, and that's without taking overclocking into consideration.
 
I think you're wading in your own FUD!:D
Good metaphor to use when sourcing theinq. In case you forgot how chips are made, it takes more than a future plan to bring it to market. AMD does not have a 45nm Hi-K process or a 32nm process. IBM does the research for AMD (and takes 10% of AMD's R&D money for that service) and is holding off until 32nm for Hi-K/MG. AMD's only word on Hi-K/MG is the vague "option" and has never said it would produce any Hi-K/MG chips in 2009.

The fantasy here really is entertaining though. Read ridiculous rumors from an unreliable site and pin all hope on it. :p

IBM's "22nm SRAM" wasn't even built on a process. It was a lab experiment using electron beam lithography. Big deal. Read the article update on the bottom of the dailytech link to compare it to what is done on a real process demonstration. Notice when you quoted "chips" in my message. Even IBM didn't claim to have made chips, just demonstration SRAM cells.

Face it, AMD's roadmap is looking pretty bad, with nothing to even start rescuing the company until at least Bulldozer... in 2011.
 
Ok you got me to post...

I did hear that AMD is looking to have produced some 45nm high-K chips 2nd quarter of 2009. AMD was also supposed to hit 32nm 1st quarter of 2010, but is hoping to move the schedule up.

The high-k Deneb was supposed to be the infamous FX chips. I guess we will see come april 2009.

I think AMD is going to try and pull a Tick Tock like stratagy. Tick being 45nm high-k bullzozer and tock being 32nm bulldozer.
 
Ok you got me to post...

I did hear that AMD is looking to have produced some 45nm high-K chips 2nd quarter of 2009. AMD was also supposed to hit 32nm 1st quarter of 2010, but is hoping to move the schedule up.

The high-k Deneb was supposed to be the infamous FX chips. I guess we will see come april 2009.

I think AMD is going to try and pull a Tick Tock like stratagy. Tick being 45nm high-k bullzozer and tock being 32nm bulldozer.

We will see. I just don't think we will see impressive results, or even really competitive results out of Deneb of Shanghai.
 
I really hope AMD come up with something competitive so that i7 prices would go down :).
 
Oh please, considering its performance, the i7 920 is already stupid cheap.
Not to metion stupidly hot too,, i mean cooking hot when the clocks go up...I know Phenom is hot and i run Phenom @ 1.72volts... I can only imagine I7 at 1.72volts.

Its amazing how fast things can turn around in the chip industry when things dont go smooth isnt it. Especially prices.
 
Have faith, we need AMD to do well, otherwise Intel will rationalize $300+ "mainstream" parts, lol
 
Not to metion stupidly hot too,, i mean cooking hot when the clocks go up...I know Phenom is hot and i run Phenom @ 1.72volts... I can only imagine I7 at 1.72volts.

Its amazing how fast things can turn around in the chip industry when things dont go smooth isnt it. Especially prices.


well you really cant imagine an i7 running at 1.72v because a 45nm core cant do 1.72v.. lol
 
yup but the rest of it isnt cheap..

Yes, and?
High-end CPUs have always been expensive. Competition or no competition.
Back (way, WAY back) when AMD was competitive, we had both the Athlon FX and the Pentium Extreme Edition at over $1000.
Yes, AMD really drove those prices down for us!
High-end CPUs are expensive because both Intel and AMD know that there's plenty of people who are willing to pay that amount for a fast CPU.

Competition on price is done in the low and mid-end market. And the 920 is the new mid-end.
 
Yes, and?
High-end CPUs have always been expensive. Competition or no competition.
Back (way, WAY back) when AMD was competitive, we had both the Athlon FX and the Pentium Extreme Edition at over $1000.
Yes, AMD really drove those prices down for us!
High-end CPUs are expensive because both Intel and AMD know that there's plenty of people who are willing to pay that amount for a fast CPU.

Competition on price is done in the low and mid-end market. And the 920 is the new mid-end.

and intel's own line kills it right now. I can literally make a system nearly on par with a i7 for about half the cost. this is kind of odd in that the main cost of the system is not the CPU at all. (really the cpu price is not bad at all considering the level of performance)
 
and intel's own line kills it right now. I can literally make a system nearly on par with a i7 for about half the cost. this is kind of odd in that the main cost of the system is not the CPU at all. (really the cpu price is not bad at all considering the level of performance)

Oh really?
You do know that what has been relased are CPU's and HIGH-END mobo's.

But I would like to see you "on par" i7 920 system?
 
Yes, and?
High-end CPUs have always been expensive. Competition or no competition.
Back (way, WAY back) when AMD was competitive, we had both the Athlon FX and the Pentium Extreme Edition at over $1000.
Yes, AMD really drove those prices down for us!
High-end CPUs are expensive because both Intel and AMD know that there's plenty of people who are willing to pay that amount for a fast CPU.

Competition on price is done in the low and mid-end market. And the 920 is the new mid-end.

Agreed.

and intel's own line kills it right now. I can literally make a system nearly on par with a i7 for about half the cost. this is kind of odd in that the main cost of the system is not the CPU at all. (really the cpu price is not bad at all considering the level of performance)

WTF?

I don't think you can.

Oh really?
You do know that what has been relased are CPU's and HIGH-END mobo's.

But I would like to see you "on par" i7 920 system?

I'd like to see this too.
 
WTF?

I don't think you can.
Waffles. You just don't understand how it works. While you can not overclock a cheap Intel CPU to match i7, AMD has no such limitations no matter how small the chance might be. Some guy water chilled a Phenom using ice cold water from a pond somewhere in the world to 3.8GHz, so that means AMD >> i7.

Does it make sense now? :p
 
Oh really?
You do know that what has been relased are CPU's and HIGH-END mobo's.

But I would like to see you "on par" i7 920 system?

See my rig in sig, high-end mobo, high-end RAM and high-end GPU. Even with X48 it will still be cheaper than 920 system.
 
See my rig in sig, high-end mobo, high-end RAM and high-end GPU. Even with X48 it will still be cheaper than 920 system.

But the i920 will outprefom you current setup, by a large margin...even if we "only" OC the i920 to 3.2Ghz...making your point a moot one.
 
But the i920 will outprefom you current setup, by a large margin...even if we "only" OC the i920 to 3.2Ghz...making your point a moot one.

If you mean 10-20% faster is a large margin with more than 20% extra cost then you are right.
 
We always end up paying a fortune for small % gain in the computer world. % gain almost never equals % increase in price.

True. There is no linear relationship between cost and performance. There never has been.
 
We always end up paying a fortune for small % gain in the computer world. % gain almost never equals % increase in price.

then you guys can have it. for myself I will consider the the systems "nearly on par" until Dan does an H review showing the i7 platform giving a higher game play experience outside of trisli/quadfire or some far better computing experience then say a P45/Q9550 set up. I perhaps should have quantified the statement better as the i7 is going to benchmark better and might make a good workstation for people that would use it but until it actually does something more then bring SLI to the intel chip sets I can't see the cost of the system, I really do think the money would be better spent going to other system components
 
then you guys can have it. for myself I will consider the the systems "nearly on par" until Dan does an H review showing the i7 platform giving a higher game play experience outside of trisli/quadfire or some far better computing experience then say a P45/Q9550 set up. I perhaps should have quantified the statement better as the i7 is going to benchmark better and might make a good workstation for people that would use it but until it actually does something more then bring SLI to the intel chip sets I can't see the cost of the system, I really do think the money would be better spent going to other system components

Well up to about 1600x1200 you won't see any difference between the Core i7 and the Core 2 given similar clock speeds and other components. I'm not sure about single GPU systems, but I know that Core i7 helps unleash the power of higher end multi-GPU setups. However those of us who run systems like that know how much they cost, and we don't care about the actual monetary cost so much as we care about having the best performance posible. (Assuming we can afford it.) Personally I game on a 30" LCD so I need all the power possible to get the most out of my gaming experience. I can't stand turning the detail or eye candy down in games and refuse to do it if it can truly be avoided.
 
Well up to about 1600x1200 you won't see any difference between the Core i7 and the Core 2 given similar clock speeds and other components. I'm not sure about single GPU systems, but I know that Core i7 helps unleash the power of higher end multi-GPU setups. However those of us who run systems like that know how much they cost, and we don't care about the actual monetary cost so much as we care about having the best performance posible. (Assuming we can afford it.) Personally I game on a 30" LCD so I need all the power possible to get the most out of my gaming experience. I can't stand turning the detail or eye candy down in games and refuse to do it if it can truly be avoided.

right now the most I am thinking of adding is a seconded GTX280 and a quad intel cpu. there really is not much gain in going with i7 even then (think kyle made that point). the only people that did well was when you went up to your system, tri sli. so not to sound stubborn but for 90% of the H users you can go "nearly par" with the current intel system for around half the cost. even then what I really want to see is if it will allow you to get a better game playing experience.

the one thing that is making me wistful right now is that sli on an intel board looks a lot nicer then even the 750i FTW,
 
right now the most I am thinking of adding is a seconded GTX280 and a quad intel cpu. there really is not much gain in going with i7 even then (think kyle made that point). the only people that did well was when you went up to your system, tri sli. so not to sound stubborn but for 90% of the H users you can go "nearly par" with the current intel system for around half the cost. even then what I really want to see is if it will allow you to get a better game playing experience.

the one thing that is making me wistful right now is that sli on an intel board looks a lot nicer then even the 750i FTW,

Well for the most part I'll agree with you. As I've said before while the Core i7 is a great product, it will really shine in the server market and not quite as much on the desktop side.
 
right now the most I am thinking of adding is a seconded GTX280 and a quad intel cpu. there really is not much gain in going with i7 even then (think kyle made that point). the only people that did well was when you went up to your system, tri sli. so not to sound stubborn but for 90% of the H users you can go "nearly par" with the current intel system for around half the cost. even then what I really want to see is if it will allow you to get a better game playing experience.

the one thing that is making me wistful right now is that sli on an intel board looks a lot nicer then even the 750i FTW,


who knows wht amd is cooking
 
Well for the most part I'll agree with you. As I've said before while the Core i7 is a great product, it will really shine in the server market and not quite as much on the desktop side.

don't get me wrong, cheap bastard or not I am still envious, I want to see your results when you get them.
 
Back
Top