Will putting my harddrives in RAID affect overall desktop performance?

VulcaN

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
1,917
If I had enough money I would build a separate file server with a sever hundred dollar controller and ten 1.5TB drives... but I don't! I have enough space in my case for two more drives and purchased two of the WD Green 1TB drives for storage.

Since this is my everything computer will putting the drives in RAID 1 using the motherboards raid controller affect my performance? Gaming or doing anything else on it.

If it will I might as well just install them as stand alone drives and manually copy the data from one drive to the other. This data only changes a few times a year so its not a big deal at all to copy some files over!

Thanks
 
RAID 1 might be a bit slower but its worth a try.
Alternatively, create a batch file to copy your relevant data so its quick and easy to do a backup.

This is the method I use for clients personal backups.
I give them an external IDE 2.5", USB powered hard drive.
They plug it in, double click a batch file and it copies all of their data that is new or changed to the hard drive.
It takes seconds each time.
I also recommend making periodic backup DVDs as a secondary safeguard.
 
RAID 1 might be a bit slower but its worth a try.
Alternatively, create a batch file to copy your relevant data so its quick and easy to do a backup.

This is the method I use for clients personal backups.
I give them an external IDE 2.5", USB powered hard drive.
They plug it in, double click a batch file and it copies all of their data that is new or changed to the hard drive.
It takes seconds each time.
I also recommend making periodic backup DVDs as a secondary safeguard.

+1 for DVDs back up since you cant trust RAID that much
 
+1 for DVDs back up since you cant trust RAID that much

Its RAID 1, 100% redundancy.
Each drive can be used separately if there is a problem.
A power surge could kill everything though so it is wise to backup on other media :)
 
Its RAID 1, 100% redundancy.
Each drive can be used separately if there is a problem.

Wait so with raid 1 can you rip out a hard drive and put it in any computer and the data will all be there, and accessible?

I thought you always had to have the same raid controller?
 
Yes, you may not be able to boot it but you should be able to get all the data with it plugged in as a secondary drive.
Striped arrays have a format which is often tied to a particular controller. These will likely require the same controller to access the data.
 
Its RAID 1, 100% redundancy.
Each drive can be used separately if there is a problem.
A power surge could kill everything though so it is wise to backup on other media :)

RAID anything is NOT %100 reliable. A virus, controller failure, or a power glitch right when the drives are writing to the lookup tables will render your data, DEAD!

It is always wise to copy your data to other media. But for me, the only other media that is big and hassle free enough is external USB hard drives.

Don
 
Its RAID 1, 100% redundancy.
Each drive can be used separately if there is a problem.
A power surge could kill everything though so it is wise to backup on other media :)

I've lost Raid1 arrays due to controller failures. Then you have the other problems as you mentioned such as power surges or anything else that can clean your entire array out.
 
ive been looking for something i could use to manually copy all of a customers uesd files with
one click. all .pdf /.doc .xcl .ppt .pub .mov .rl .jpg .tiff .bmp .gif etc .etc etc ....
is this what you have created. I would love to have a copy if you are willing?
 
RAID 1 might be a bit slower but its worth a try.
They plug it in, double click a batch file and it copies all of their data that is new or changed to the hard drive.

Would you mind posting the code for this batch file?
 
It would be one line of Robocopy. Something like:

robocopy D:\ E:\ /MIR
 
MIR actually includes /E, and looking at my own scheduled task I have /r:1 and /w:1 in there as well.

Man I remember when I first left this running without that and I nuked a file in the middle of the task running. I didn't understand why the scheduled task kept running after five days.
 
Would you mind posting the code for this batch file?

I use this for most applications.
xcopy Folder1 Folder2 /M /E /V /R /K /O /Y

It will copy new files and files with the archive bit set. The archive bit is reset.
It copies all folders inside the chosen folder.
User permissions are retained.
All file copies are verified.
Overwrites read only files and maintains the read only attribute.
Doesnt prompt to overwrite.


These are all the settings you can use:

/A Copies only files with the archive attribute set, doesn't change the attribute.
/M Copies only files with the archive attribute set, turns off the archive attribute.
/D:m-d-y Copies files changed on or after the specified date.
If no date is given, copies only those files whose
source time is newer than the destination time.
/EXCLUDE:file1[+file2][+file3]...
Specifies a list of files containing strings. Each string
should be in a separate line in the files. When any of the
strings match any part of the absolute path of the file to be
copied, that file will be excluded from being copied. For
example, specifying a string like \obj\ or .obj will exclude
all files underneath the directory obj or all files with the
.obj extension respectively.
/P Prompts you before creating each destination file.
/S Copies directories and subdirectories except empty ones.
/E Copies directories and subdirectories, including empty ones. Same as /S /E. May be used to modify /T.
/V Verifies each new file.
/W Prompts you to press a key before copying.
/C Continues copying even if errors occur.
/I If destination does not exist and copying more than one file, assumes that destination must be a directory.
/Q Does not display file names while copying.
/F Displays full source and destination file names while copying.
/L Displays files that would be copied.
/G Allows the copying of encrypted files to destination that does not support encryption.
/H Copies hidden and system files also.
/R Overwrites read-only files.
/T Creates directory structure, but does not copy files. Does not include empty directories or subdirectories. /T /E includes empty directories and subdirectories.
/U Copies only files that already exist in destination.
/K Copies attributes. Normal Xcopy will reset read-only attributes.
/N Copies using the generated short names.
/O Copies file ownership and ACL information.
/X Copies file audit settings (implies /O).
/Y Suppresses prompting to confirm you want to overwrite an existing destination file.
/-Y Causes prompting to confirm you want to overwrite an existing destination file.
/Z Copies networked files in restartable mode.
 
I understand that the "archive bit" is either a 1 or a 0 (since its a bit) and is not part of the individual file but rather an attribute tacked onto the file. However, I am a little lost beyond that.

If i took a guess, is the archive bit just the way of showing that the file has been modified or is new since the last copy and thus should be included in the copy?

And if the archive bit was not set, then it would not be copied over?
 
Yep correct.
Every file that is created or modified has its archive bit set to 1.
When you copy files with it set to 1, you can set it to 0 (on the original file) so it doesnt get copied again.
This way, the only files that get copied are new or modified as you stated.
 
Awesome thanks so much. I just used it to move some data as a test and it worked great!!!

I am still curious though, is it okay to use a batch file like this to move 1 TB or more of data?
 
Since this is my everything computer will putting the drives in RAID 1 raid controller affect my performance? Gaming or doing anything else on it.

RAID 1 or RAID 5 they can all fail.. I am dealing with crap right now with my failed RAID 5, where one disk failed, and then somehow the other two, and I still cant get it working, and may have to get some RAID recovery tool to rescue... what a pain in the neck. My next setup is def a single VR 150 or 300GB and then a single storage internal drive and then one external backup with some DVD's for my videos and stuff.
 
Is it reccomended to have your backup drive(s) be from a different batch than your main drives? I just realized I ordered my backup drive at the same time, and it has a identical batch number on it... so if my main drive fails, the backup one might follow suit?


also... Would it be okay to leave the backup "external" inside the case bolted in, but with the power and data cables unplugged?
 
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned that he's trying to RAID 2 5400RPM hard drives.

That will NOT YIELD good results.
 
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned that he's trying to RAID 2 5400RPM hard drives.

That will NOT YIELD good results.

Why not? It will still be faster than 1 5400 RPM drives. My current NAS is running 3 5400 RPM drives in RAID 5 and it works just fine. Just uses less juice and would not be as fast as other drives. But it is just a RAID in a NAS, so who cares.
 
Why not? It will still be faster than 1 5400 RPM drives. My current NAS is running 3 5400 RPM drives in RAID 5 and it works just fine. Just uses less juice and would not be as fast as other drives. But it is just a RAID in a NAS, so who cares.

i just dont see it being worth it RAIDing 2 5400RPM drives.
 
Back
Top