Blu-ray 2008: The Studio Report Card

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Sound & Vision Magazine has taken on the task of grading the major studios on the quality of their Blu-ray titles. While most triple A titles have great audio, visual quality and tons of extras, some studios are shamelessly putting DVD movies with standard definition bonus features onto a Blu-ray disc and calling it good. Hit the link to see who got an A and who got a big fat F.

Studio grades were based on a wide range of factors — most importantly the technical prowess of the audio and video presentations. Then, to a lesser degree, the adoption or avoidance of available Blu-ray exclusive technologies (BD-Live functionality, Profile 1.1 interactivity, etc), and, finally, the breadth and diversity of their releases as well as their reaction to the unique challenges of the latest evolution of the BD market.
 
Ocean's 13 was GARBAGE on Blu-ray. I needed to get that off my chest..
 
Bluray should set standards on quality requirements so companies like some of the mentioned ones don't just stick dvd quality crap on a disk without labling it as such.
 
Great to see this list, it really confirms what we've been seeing the last few years. BluRay and HD-DVD (RIP) are excellent formats but nothing can make a crappy encoding job or bad source look good. There should be stricter standards on baseline encoding quality. The Game on HD-DVD (a good looking film BTW) is the absolute worst looking encoding job I've ever seen. It was bad for a DVD, let alone an HD format disc.
 
Part of why BD adaption isn't as quick as certain investors would like it to be (coughSONYcough) is because of what some of these studios are doing, such as putting DVD movies on as you pointed out, Steve. I think there should be a set standard as to what can be put on Blu-Ray and be called high definition. I don't even care if Sony makes the standard as long as there is a definitive, 1080p w/ HD audio standard that no studio can go beneath, but only exceed. And I don't even own an HDTV, a PS3, or an HD-DVD player. But if I were to get into the whole HD experience, I'd like to avoid this bullshit of having to guess if I should get the BD version or just get the DVD one and just deal with an upconvert and save myself some cash. Does that make any sense or am I just crazy?
 
sounds like exactly what they did with DVD early on, they copied a bunch of analog content over to digital with not much care of how they did it.
 
Part of why BD adaption isn't as quick as certain investors would like it to be (coughSONYcough) is because of what some of these studios are doing, such as putting DVD movies on as you pointed out, Steve. I think there should be a set standard as to what can be put on Blu-Ray and be called high definition. I don't even care if Sony makes the standard as long as there is a definitive, 1080p w/ HD audio standard that no studio can go beneath, but only exceed. And I don't even own an HDTV, a PS3, or an HD-DVD player. But if I were to get into the whole HD experience, I'd like to avoid this bullshit of having to guess if I should get the BD version or just get the DVD one and just deal with an upconvert and save myself some cash. Does that make any sense or am I just crazy?

I think you're absolutely crazy but you do have a point in there somewhere.

The point is that in order for a movie to be considered HD it should have a set standard for audio, video and extras that are not included in a standard DVD movie because of the monetary price difference in the two formats. If I was to buy a Blu-Ray movie then I should at least expect to see a distinctly DIFFERENT product than if I were to purchase the movie on standard DVD format.

/rant off: We now return you to your regular DVD quality programming.
 
I learned some time back that even if you spend big $$ on video equipment, there is no guarantee that the source material is the best possible quality.

I quit obsessing over video quality since then.
 
28 Days Later is by far the worst... it was shot on miniDV in standard def, then they transferred it to Blu-ray.. rofl. Another bad one is 12 Monkeys on Blu-ray & HD DVD, but that was more the camera lenses they used for some scenes.
 
You could get away with it for regular DVD's for awhile since the quality was not going to degrade anywhere as fast as it did on VHS, and there were VERY little things called "extras" in the beginning because all the studios were doing WAS making sure you could get the same movie in the new format.

Once they saw how much room was left over then they decided to see what/how much on could be placed on one and they competed until they h
 
Is there a website I can go to that reviews the BD movies so i don't waste my money on a bad one? I mean rating the studios is cool, but if you RTFA, they each put out shit except Sony (which I would hope to be on the top side).

If I paid $30 for a movie and it was just a transfer, I am gonna be pissed. And you know what? I don't watch the special features unless it's a gag reel. Why would I watch LotR with Peter Jackson talking like a mad monkey on extacy? I want to watch the movie not listen to some Jackass ramble on and on about the lighting for a scene.
 
Is there a website I can go to that reviews the BD movies so i don't waste my money on a bad one? I mean rating the studios is cool, but if you RTFA, they each put out shit except Sony (which I would hope to be on the top side).

If I paid $30 for a movie and it was just a transfer, I am gonna be pissed. And you know what? I don't watch the special features unless it's a gag reel. Why would I watch LotR with Peter Jackson talking like a mad monkey on extacy? I want to watch the movie not listen to some Jackass ramble on and on about the lighting for a scene.

http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/reviews.html
 
AVSforum also has quite an extensive list of Blu-ray movies reviewed.

Guess the old programmers moto still stands,

Garbage IN, Garbage OUT!
 
I learned some time back that even if you spend big $$ on video equipment, there is no guarantee that the source material is the best possible quality.

I quit obsessing over video quality since then.

Evidently you're not alone. It would seem that the vast majority of consumers just don't care either. Kinda sucks for the video fanatics but...meh!
 
Back
Top