Is Net Neutrality an American Problem?

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Australia’s top three ISPs have stated that the Net neutrality debate is a US issue, according to this Cnet article. Furthermore, they believe that the US could get clues on solving the problem by studying how the Aussie market handled it. Interesting read.

"From my point of view, (Net neutrality is) an artificial problem created out of fear of modifying the business model," says Hackett. "The idea that the entire population can subsidize a minority with an extremely high download quantity actually isn't necessarily the only way to live," said Malone.
 
BS, they are just trying to push caps across to the consumer, I refuse to pay for a set amount of 'bandwidth' so far ATT and Time Warner have been great as a ISP to me with no caps
 
Anyone who's been following this knows that it is a problem in many countries. Britain and Canada both have ISPs who are messing with access, for example.

The larger problem of net neutrality is not just what the ISPs do but what the governments themselves do. This is definitely a global problem.
 
It is very much a problem in Canada as well. Several companies, most notably Bell (which is a monopoly -- or at least close to it -- in many locations) have made numerous attempts to destabilize the way we access the Internet, making it necessary for us to approach our leaders and government to implement and enforce net neutrality.
 
I think the article is right on the money.

Charging content providers to prioritize content or allowing/disallowing content is just absurd. ISPs should not be in the business of saying what content is good/bad.

Wal-mart will not sell certain music unless they offer a "clean" version... It may be ok for stores like wal-mart to due this, since there are generally other stores in the area to buy the same thing.

The case is NOT the same for ISPs, especially in the United States where most people have 1 maybe 2 choices for internet service.

It is VITAL to keep content unrestricted and everything available.

I don't want internet service to turn into cable where I have to decipher ISP A offerings of: the basic package with Yahoo, the Silver package with google, youtube etc ISP B offerings of: the basic package with ESPN, Ask.com, etc...

If there is a problem with bandwidth then I see NO problem with charging the consumer for that bandwidth. Of course given that limits/usage are clear and easy to monitor.

I would much rather make the choice of 1gb/mo, 5gb/mo etc etc then content.

As a matter of fact this would be best for ISPs and consumers. If they charges for usage they could then offer all their plans at the same speed and blow open a whole new market that probably would make then money had over fist!!!!

I have tons of family members that use the internet so infrequently that they cannot see paying $50 for high speed internet. The $30 plans are normally slow, so they may or may not go this route. Most of my family (older generations) are still on dial up because of the costs!!!

If they were to offer a $30 low bandwith plan, a ton of them would switch over from Dial-up or slow DSL and start actually USING the internet, which then would get them hooked (like me) and probably upgrade to a higher more costly plan.

I personally don't have a problem with bandwidth charges, the market will determine fair limits just as with cell phones. Though it would be nice to have a few more options for the consumer to ensure this.
 
I think the article is right on the money.

Charging content providers to prioritize content or allowing/disallowing content is just absurd. ISPs should not be in the business of saying what content is good/bad.

Wal-mart will not sell certain music unless they offer a "clean" version... It may be ok for stores like wal-mart to due this, since there are generally other stores in the area to buy the same thing.

The case is NOT the same for ISPs, especially in the United States where most people have 1 maybe 2 choices for internet service.

It is VITAL to keep content unrestricted and everything available.

I don't want internet service to turn into cable where I have to decipher ISP A offerings of: the basic package with Yahoo, the Silver package with google, youtube etc ISP B offerings of: the basic package with ESPN, Ask.com, etc...

If there is a problem with bandwidth then I see NO problem with charging the consumer for that bandwidth. Of course given that limits/usage are clear and easy to monitor.

I would much rather make the choice of 1gb/mo, 5gb/mo etc etc then content.

As a matter of fact this would be best for ISPs and consumers. If they charges for usage they could then offer all their plans at the same speed and blow open a whole new market that probably would make then money had over fist!!!!

I have tons of family members that use the internet so infrequently that they cannot see paying $50 for high speed internet. The $30 plans are normally slow, so they may or may not go this route. Most of my family (older generations) are still on dial up because of the costs!!!

If they were to offer a $30 low bandwith plan, a ton of them would switch over from Dial-up or slow DSL and start actually USING the internet, which then would get them hooked (like me) and probably upgrade to a higher more costly plan.

I personally don't have a problem with bandwidth charges, the market will determine fair limits just as with cell phones. Though it would be nice to have a few more options for the consumer to ensure this.

So your saying that people would not pay 30 dollars for an uncapped access connection that is over 10 times faster than dial up, but they would pay 30 dollars for a capped connection that may be faster? If they are content with dial up speeds then they would never suddenly switch just because they can get even more than 10 times the speed.

Besides that illogical garbage, the rest of your post is just justifying the bullshit reasonings behind capped connections by throwing out even worse possible limitations on internet access to make transfer caps seem more appealing.

Then, on top of that, you suggest that gouging customers in order to rake in profits is somehow a good side effect.

Holy shit, consider my mind blown.
 
In the Asian markets, the speeds keep going up and ISPs make no effort to cap their users.
 
ISPs, quit crying, stand up, grab your fucking balls, and put a flat per gig or tiered billing system into place and shut the hell up about it already. Bitches, I swear. :confused:

You will have a sustainable billing model for the future that easily allows for growth, infrastructure upkeep/upgrades, and maintaining a fair profit margin to boot. You will no longer have to go to content providers threatening to "shape" their traffic if they don't cough up some extra dough. You will be getting the dough from the consumers for what they use, as it should be. Then, Net Neutrality will be quietly forgotten and we can all go on our merry way. :p

ISPs really need to keep lawmakers out of this, they do not want the government to get too involved. Overly tight government oversight or regulation is seldom good for any one in the long term.
 
I think the article is right on the money..
And I think you're dead wrong. So, some people, like your family members NOW only use their connection a small amount. What about the future when content is provided digitally? When the average consumer wants to buy or rent a 25-100 GB HD film, and does that several times a month rather than go to their local video store or rent through Netflix? Assuming there's ANY actual physical media to even still rent or buy. Ten films a month will easily become 500-1,00 GB of data, and if EVERYONE is doing this, what then?

All this whining (and that's what it is) is coming from a bunch of CEOs who simply don't want to spend the money to upgrade their infrastructure.
 
In the Asian markets, the speeds keep going up and ISPs make no effort to cap their users.

Well, with the human pileups that exist in those regions, you get economies of scale. I'll stick with having more room in my home and more open areas in the country over even more internet access that I do not really need.
 
net neutrality have never been taken up in norway.

not in sweeden i think, and i think its somekinda US thing, alot is a US thing, sue's are an american thing, we call it American condition.
I can list all the things you guys sue eachother for, if it'd happen in norway, the judge would just laugh of you.

Suvs are american thing.

Usa is a world on its own :p
 
So your saying that people would not pay 30 dollars for an uncapped access connection that is over 10 times faster than dial up, but they would pay 30 dollars for a capped connection that may be faster? If they are content with dial up speeds then they would never suddenly switch just because they can get even more than 10 times the speed..

Well... YES, the cheap DSL services are still fairly slow for the internet today. I remember myself when I switched from DSL ~1mb/s to cable ~3mb/s years ago, the performance of the internet was night and day. What I truely envisioned the internet to be, pages instantly load etc.

These family members come to my home and say WOW when they use the internet, some have the cheap DSL and some don't. ALL of them say they won't pay $50 per mo for it though. If it was $30 per mo, they would and these are not people that would use a lot of bandwidth. So in essence the high bandwidth users are taking customers away from ISPs just because they want to have "unlimited" 1 cost plans for everyone.

If low use users were to get full speed, they would be able to experience all of the internet just as everyone else. They would be able to easily and quickly stream video music etc. This would then give them the confidence to do more with the internet and then probably "up" their plan to a higher bandwidth one.

Most users do not use gigs apon gigs on bandwidth, they just do the everyday shopping, news, some youtube etc etc.

And I think you're dead wrong. So, some people, like your family members NOW only use their connection a small amount. What about the future when content is provided digitally? When the average consumer wants to buy or rent a 25-100 GB HD film, and does that several times a month rather than go to their local video store or rent through Netflix? Assuming there's ANY actual physical media to even still rent or buy. Ten films a month will easily become 500-1,00 GB of data, and if EVERYONE is doing this, what then?

All this whining (and that's what it is) is coming from a bunch of CEOs who simply don't want to spend the money to upgrade their infrastructure.

Just as with Web hosting and cell phones, plans will increase their bandwidth allotments as the customer needs and competition dictates. So I don't understand your thought here, no one is saying when you hit your limit you get turned off you just get charged extra just like with cell phones.

We are nowhere near the stage where most of our entertainment is coming from the internet. A vast majority still use TV/DVD for that... So cross that bridge when it come to it...

When that time does come, what is the point of having cable service? hmmm maybe the ISP could charge twice as much for internet (for bandwidth useage) and since you save on your cable bill you would you essentially pay the same as you are now.

As for ISP whining? Do you know how much it cost to upgrade an infrastructure? Its not cheap, at my work we add fiber runs to new locations and it can cost anywhere up to 20k per location just for putting the fiber there, nevermind the monthly costs.

So expansion of service to new customers is one thing, more revenue potential. These same costs to keep existing customers will literally sink them. Remember this is the internet/computer technology which requires expensive upgrades more regularly then other services like landline phone, cable etc.

All things being equal, if internet use goes up (which we both agree will) there HAS to be some way to quantify the cost based on usage. Otherwise EVERYONE will get charged large amounts to keep the infrastructure fast enough to support the small % of users that use a disproportionate amount of the bandwidth.

If high demand users pay more, they will be able to upgrade more, they then will be able to offer lower users a better option and get more customers. Win-Win.

It amazes me that people complain about how their cable internet goes up each year... yet they download more each year at the same time... hmmm how they are ripping us off!!!


Now don't get me wrong, I am ALL for competition! I feel at least in USA the high-speed market doesn't have enough of it! I pretty much only have 1 choice and that is comcast, DSL is 1.5mb/s in my area which I don't consider at all.

No competition is the primary reason why users feel ripped off.
 
to the above poster ...errr no it wont..

I live in australia, and beleive me they do not spend the increased revenue on upgrades.. we are so far behind on speed and performance its redicolous (sp?) we need to do a nation wide upgrade or our economy will tank or suffer in the next 3 years as more and more of it goes online.

We are heading towards a Fibre To The Node (bad idea should be Fibre To The Home). it is still being debated. at present it looks like our labour government will give it to our largest carrier (telstra) who will only do it if they have total control, our other 9 carries wont get a piece of the pie. (no other carrier will be able to use it.)

Telstra have admitted they will be the only carrier, and with this new network all home phones will have to go thru them as the current network will be decomissioned and replace with FTTN. basic packages will start at 69.99 per month for 200megabytes (including uploades), 5 gig will be at 129.99 per month and 12 gig will be at 179.99 per month and finally 20gig pack (only one with slow down once cap reached) 199.99 per month for the house hold consumer. all other plans have been projected at 1.50 per megabyte over the cap. with no slow down, max speed will be 12~20megabits down and 120k ~ 1 megabits up.. (all uploads are counted..)

so no the capped planes are crap, our FTTN will only work if more than one company ownes it, more can use it, plans will be cheapper and speed better..

so when Telstra get the FTTN deal here (and they will, labours way) we will be buggered for net access here, and things will plummet.. i am a high net user and when they get this i will more than likely shut my net down.. i simply dont need the net to live, its nice and fun but not needed. all console updates for modern games are (well for my ps3 and wii) are on the discs anyway..)

capped plans will only work if the download is worth it and the cost is worth it.. and i the consumer get to use it anyway i want.

my current plan is 20gig on peak (12 hours a day) and ony 60 gig off peak.(uploads uncounted).. this is a grandfather plan (it no longer exists) and has been replaced with a 12 gig off peak and on peak of 8gig with a $1.50 per meg there after for 79.99 per month.. speed 8megabits down 350k ~ 1 meg up.. (uploads are counted)

is that truelly far...??? think twice before you go down that path ... its bad really bad idea..
 
I think you just reinforced my point that competition and customer choices are direly needed especially if going to a system like this.

Maybe I should have included that, without competition then yes a pay per use system would suck if a company decides to shaft its users and doesn't really have an incentive to improve service in the first place.

If you look at web hosting and cellular phones, with proper competition the services and/or prices continuously improve.

Given proper choice one can assume the same thing for internet service.
 
The problem with "competition" is that the entry price for suppliers is very high and the end result is a small number of suppliers (telco and cable usually) who have no interest in real competition. They may grudgingly provide access to independent retail ISPs who lease their connection, but the connection is still in the hands of the oligopoly. They then control the net anyway.

Canada has exactly this situation. There is no real competition in Internet access (or mobile telephony for that matter) and the result is the highest prices in the western world with some of the poorest service levels.

Reducing the cost of providing large-scale access by eliminating the costliest parts of the infrastructure would help - Wimax, for example, should in principle offer cheaper "last mile" provision, as would the next gen mobile (4G or LTE(? whatever they're calling it now)). However, no one seems ready to step up with such a system independent of the big players with deep pockets.

Providing competition in the real world is often easier said than done.
 
Back
Top