Android Wooing App Store’s Rejects?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks like Google’s Android might benefit from what some are calling Apple’s “arbitrary and restrictive App Store policies.” While I understand what people are saying, wouldn’t this essentially turn Android into a repository for rejected iPhone apps? I mean, that’s what it sounds like.

After being rejected by Apple, coder Alex Sokirynsky said he'd be an Android convert. The wannabe iPhone developer recently gained widespread attention when Apple rejected his application Podcaster -- because it allegedly "duplicates" iTunes. Then, Sokirynsky tried to sell his application through other means, and Apple shut down his operation. As a result, Sokirnysky on Tuesday announced in a blog post (before removing it, presumably in light of Apple's new non-disclosure policy regarding rejections) that he would cease developing applications for Apple and code for Android instead.
 
Yes Steve it could be shelter for many rejected iPhone apps, but the real question you need to ask is why are they rejected? Apple has shown it's willingness to reject Apps from the App Store simply because it will compete with some of their own features. I'll gladly take applications good enough to scare Apple into not putting them on their store.
 
This makes me wonder why Apple is rejecting these apps? Is because they do not meet some Apple requirement or is it because they are competing with Apple's own apps. :confused:
 
Apple rejects them because Apple sucks. Read the SDK EULA. It's like Fight Club. The first rule of the SDK is that you cannot talk about the SDK. It's insane and a reflection of Steve Jobs and his OCD micromanagement insanity.
 
This makes me wonder why Apple is rejecting these apps? Is because they do not meet some Apple requirement or is it because they are competing with Apple's own apps. :confused:

First post spells it out from Apples perspective
The wannabe iPhone developer recently gained widespread attention when Apple rejected his application Podcaster -- because it allegedly "duplicates" iTunes.
 
If they were rejected because they were poor apps, then I would say this is a bad thing.

The reality is that piles of apps are rejected because they're simply better then Apple's apps. It's always been Apple's business model to shove sub-par crap down the throats of their idiotic masses and the iPhone is no different. Want to tether your phone? Too bad, you have to go suck off Jobs before you get that feature, despite the phone being fully capable of it.

Can't wait for some nice Android phones to hit the market. Better product, cheaper price, more features, and best of all, not subject to rules designed to shove money into Apple's pockets. Let the idiots keep using the iPhone, those with a brain will be on Android in a year or two.
 
Rejected apps generally fall into two main categories.

One is where the application conflicts with the deal that Apple has with AT&T. Tethering applications are the main thing here. AT&T charges for tethering on their other phones and laptop adapters since they feel they should charge additional fees for 2G and 3G bandwidth that is being used by a standard laptop or desktop. Someone doing it for "free" via their unlimited data plan on the iPhone breaks this, so they put the kabosh on it. Skype will hopefully be fine, but I will be disappointed if AT&T forces them to restrict usage of that application to Wifi.

Other rejected or pulled applications are those that are a privacy or security risk to user data. Apps have even gotten through the cracks and then pulled because they did things like that. An MMO puzzle game was temporarily pulled shortly after release because Apple found that it scoured the user's address books and then stored them on a remote (and presumably unsecure) server. It did this to see if any of your friends are also playing the game and could then alert you, but it was obviously a really stupid way of going about it and the application was pulled until this was changed.

On the one hand its nice that Android has more lenient (actually, zero) guidelines as far as application submissions go, but on the other hand it opens up the Android user base to gaping huge security risks if an application author decided he wanted to write a piece of malware for it.
 
And there's of course the third category as detailed in the article with the podcasting software story, which is asinine.
 
If they were rejected because they were poor apps, then I would say this is a bad thing.

The reality is that piles of apps are rejected because they're simply better then Apple's apps. It's always been Apple's business model to shove sub-par crap down the throats of their idiotic masses and the iPhone is no different. Want to tether your phone? Too bad, you have to go suck off Jobs before you get that feature, despite the phone being fully capable of it.

Can't wait for some nice Android phones to hit the market. Better product, cheaper price, more features, and best of all, not subject to rules designed to shove money into Apple's pockets. Let the idiots keep using the iPhone, those with a brain will be on Android in a year or two.

With no common hardware platform to develop for, Android is just going to be a moving target and a bitch to develop for once the novelty wears off. Touchscreen? Who knows. QWERTY keys? Maybe. Screen resolution? Another toss up. So what is going to happen once various Android devices start getting onto the market is the app devs are going to get split and any attempt at an App Store is going to turn into a bunch of apps that work with phones 1, 2, and 3, but will not work correctly at all on phones 4, 5, and 6. This is what Apple is doing right, only two versions of the phone, both with the same baseline hardware, and all of the apps from the app store work for everyone that wants them.
 
ocellaris - Be aware of who you are responding to. Nemesis999 makes blatantly wrong posts like this because of his strong anti-Apple bias: http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1033068355&postcount=32

Wrong because developers can release applications for free and Apple takes no cut, all while distributing them gratis on iTunes along with the pay apps. That's just the tip of the iceberg with him; its like trying to argue for nvidia cards with an ATI zealot.
 
With no common hardware platform to develop for, Android is just going to be a moving target and a bitch to develop for once the novelty wears off.

That is offset a lot by the fact that Andriod SDK is java based.
 
That is offset a lot by the fact that Andriod SDK is java based.

The problem is that physical interfaces vary from handset to handset. Some have touchscreens, others have trackballs, others use dials on the side, others use keyboards, others only use a 12 digit keypad, and others use a combination. Then there is the fact that the storage capacity and CPU/GPU speed of handsets can vary quite a bit. The point is that the Android isn't running on a standardized platform that can easily be targeted, developed, and optimized for.

For developers, it is one of the cons in the list of pros and cons that the platform has, exactly the same problem the WM platform has, that's all.
 
That is offset a lot by the fact that Andriod SDK is java based.

The problem is that physical interfaces vary from handset to handset. Some have touchscreens, others have trackballs, others use dials on the side, others use keyboards, others only use a 12 digit keypad, and others use a combination. Then there is the fact that the storage capacity and CPU/GPU speed of handsets can vary quite a bit. The point is that the Android isn't running on a standardized platform that can easily be targeted, developed, and optimized for.

For developers, it is one of the cons in the list of pros and cons that the platform has, exactly the same problem the WM platform has, that's all.

Yup, it doesn't matter if all use the same lanuage if all have different hardware. That is like saying that since a game can run on all windows machines it doesn't matter what hardware you have installed.

That said, for some programs you will just need to have features x,y and z just like how games require you to have hardware x, y and z to play them. For other, if possible and programmed by compatent people, they will be can be made to work with either feature set a, b or c. Even with computers, some people have touch screens, some don't. Some have 2 button mice, other 1 button, other 5+ buttons. Some use game pads, some don't.. yet programs can be made to accomidate all of these people.

Although it would be a lot harder to to test a cell phone app than it would be a computer program on different platforms with different specs.
 
The problem is that physical interfaces vary from handset to handset. Some have touchscreens, others have trackballs, others use dials on the side, others use keyboards, others only use a 12 digit keypad, and others use a combination. Then there is the fact that the storage capacity and CPU/GPU speed of handsets can vary quite a bit. The point is that the Android isn't running on a standardized platform that can easily be targeted, developed, and optimized for.

For developers, it is one of the cons in the list of pros and cons that the platform has, exactly the same problem the WM platform has, that's all.

That is a problem common to any mobile development unless you are catering to a specific phone (which is going to seriously limit your market), not something Android specific. What I'm guessing will happen is that it will be the same thing we have now, which is different versions of the app depending on which phone you have. A hassle for the devs, sure, but they're used to it by now ;)
 
ocellaris - Be aware of who you are responding to. Nemesis999 makes blatantly wrong posts like this because of his strong anti-Apple bias: http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1033068355&postcount=32

Wrong because developers can release applications for free and Apple takes no cut, all while distributing them gratis on iTunes along with the pay apps. That's just the tip of the iceberg with him; its like trying to argue for nvidia cards with an ATI zealot.

Yay for half-truths! Though I've read enough of your posts to know that you're too busy handing your paychecks to Apple to get a clue.

The argument was that free-apps were worthless and therefor buying apps through Apple's store made them better.

I responded pointing out that forcing someone to pay for an app didn't make it better, especially since the thieves at apple stole part of that money.

Maybe one day you'll learn how to use those oh-so-complicated PCs and you can stop paying 3 times as much for mediocre hardware.
 
If they were rejected because they were poor apps, then I would say this is a bad thing.

The reality is that piles of apps are rejected because they're simply better then Apple's apps. It's always been Apple's business model to shove sub-par crap down the throats of their idiotic masses and the iPhone is no different. Want to tether your phone? Too bad, you have to go suck off Jobs before you get that feature, despite the phone being fully capable of it.

Can't wait for some nice Android phones to hit the market. Better product, cheaper price, more features, and best of all, not subject to rules designed to shove money into Apple's pockets. Let the idiots keep using the iPhone, those with a brain will be on Android in a year or two.

Holy shit I agree with you! :D :eek:
 
Holy shit I agree with you! :D :eek:

...


...


...


hellfrozenoveryr3.jpg
 
Yay for half-truths! Though I've read enough of your posts to know that you're too busy handing your paychecks to Apple to get a clue.

The argument was that free-apps were worthless and therefor buying apps through Apple's store made them better.

I responded pointing out that forcing someone to pay for an app didn't make it better, especially since the thieves at apple stole part of that money.

Maybe one day you'll learn how to use those oh-so-complicated PCs and you can stop paying 3 times as much for mediocre hardware.

I've been building my own PCs for 15 years, been using Microsoft operating systems since DOS 4.1, and played games and used applications back when I had to write config.sys and batch files to make them run faster/properly.

I know my way around a PC just fine, thank you very much.

Back on topic, you should go earlier in the thread; I refuted his argument way before you did, albeit without saying something so blatantly wrong like developers are "forced to charge for applications and give Apple a cut".

And yay for half-truths on your part. Mac Pros are the cheapest 8-core Xeon desktop out there, period (talking $500-$1000 cheaper than the same specced Dell or HP), and 20" iMacs are both cheaper and faster than Dell's 20" all-in-ones. The 24" iMac uses the same H-IPS panel found in the $1100 NEC2490WUXi. You might not like spending that much on a display, but considering you're getting that awesome display with a fast computer included for only a few hundred more, I'd say its a good deal.

While I replace my PCs every two years or so, I kept my first Mac G4 desktop for five years. It was a Final Cut Studio workstation (the reason I bought that first Mac) that ended up running as fast as the day I bought it with no reformats/reinstalls by the time I gave it away. I went through three PCs during the same time period. I was replacing hardware but it also coincided with the 2/3 year point when XP would start running like crap, even with diligent maintenance (defrag, malware scan, registry cleaning, etc), and I'd want to do a reinstall anyway so I just replaced everything. I never once had to maintain that Mac; I could just do my work on Final Cut in peace. So yeah, great work machines and well worth the price considering how robust an OS X installation is and how long the machines last.

I've read enough of your posts to know that you have an aggressive anti-Mac agenda. You don't like them, no big deal, that's your prerogative, but you take it a step further into outright FUD and lies. Very strange that you spew so much hate at them considering that Microsoft takes so much of their inspiration from OS X. The proof is in the fact that Vista has features and UI paradigms that I'd been using for 2+ years in OS 10.3 and 10.4 (and they'd already moved onto 10.5). Seeing that was a big surprise for me when I starting using Vista. My friend who is an engineer at Microsoft even admits as much (also, yay for employee discounts on all my Microsoft stuff!). You should try Googling the Jim Allchin memo to Gates and Ballmer from 2003, and Steve Ballmer's recent comments about them, its clear as day. Let's not even get into the fact that Apple makes a piece of hardware and every other PC manufacturer (the same ones you presumably defend) race to imitate.

They do a lot wrong (and what company doesn't?) but they sure as hell get a lot right as well.

So yeah, LOL at Ockie and Nemesis999.
 
I've been building my own PCs for 15 years, been using Microsoft operating systems since DOS 4.1, and played games and used applications back when I had to write config.sys and batch files to make them run faster/properly.

I know my way around a PC just fine, thank you very much.

Back on topic, you should go earlier in the thread; I refuted his argument way before you did, albeit without saying something so blatantly wrong like developers are "forced to charge for applications and give Apple a cut".

And yay for half-truths on your part. Mac Pros are the cheapest 8-core Xeon desktop out there, period (talking $500-$1000 cheaper than the same specced Dell or HP), and 20" iMacs are both cheaper and faster than Dell's 20" all-in-ones. The 24" iMac uses the same H-IPS panel found in the $1100 NEC2490WUXi. You might not like spending that much on a display, but considering you're getting that awesome display with a fast computer included for only a few hundred more, I'd say its a good deal.

While I replace my PCs every two years or so, I kept my first Mac G4 desktop for five years. It was a Final Cut Studio workstation (the reason I bought that first Mac) that ended up running as fast as the day I bought it with no reformats/reinstalls by the time I gave it away. I went through three PCs during the same time period. I was replacing hardware but it also coincided with the 2/3 year point when XP would start running like crap, even with diligent maintenance (defrag, malware scan, registry cleaning, etc), and I'd want to do a reinstall anyway so I just replaced everything. I never once had to maintain that Mac; I could just do my work on Final Cut in peace. So yeah, great work machines and well worth the price considering how robust an OS X installation is and how long the machines last.

I've read enough of your posts to know that you have an aggressive anti-Mac agenda. You don't like them, no big deal, that's your prerogative, but you take it a step further into outright FUD and lies. Very strange that you spew so much hate at them considering that Microsoft takes so much of their inspiration from OS X. The proof is in the fact that Vista has features and UI paradigms that I'd been using for 2+ years in OS 10.3 and 10.4 (and they'd already moved onto 10.5). Seeing that was a big surprise for me when I starting using Vista. My friend who is an engineer at Microsoft even admits as much (also, yay for employee discounts on all my Microsoft stuff!). You should try Googling the Jim Allchin memo to Gates and Ballmer from 2003, and Steve Ballmer's recent comments about them, its clear as day. Let's not even get into the fact that Apple makes a piece of hardware and every other PC manufacturer (the same ones you presumably defend) race to imitate.

They do a lot wrong (and what company doesn't?) but they sure as hell get a lot right as well.

So yeah, LOL at Ockie and Nemesis999.

You maybe didn't have to format or maintain the Mac because maybe you don't use it much? Just saying.
 
You maybe didn't have to format or maintain the Mac because maybe you don't use it much? Just saying.

I see what you're saying but I used it tons. Video editing, image editing, DVD creation, video encoding for the web and DVD, normal things like FTP, web/email, Office, and a little coding (if you can call writing HTML that :) ). At first it was leaning mostly on media creation since it was explicitly bought as a Final Cut workstation, but I started using it more for general use once 10.4 came out, about halfway through the time I owned it. It was on pretty much all the time, same as the current machine I'm using now.
 
I've been building my own PCs for 15 years, been using Microsoft operating systems since DOS 4.1, and played games and used applications back when I had to write config.sys and batch files to make them run faster/properly.

I know my way around a PC just fine, thank you very much.

Back on topic, you should go earlier in the thread; I refuted his argument way before you did, albeit without saying something so blatantly wrong like developers are "forced to charge for applications and give Apple a cut".

And yay for half-truths on your part. Mac Pros are the cheapest 8-core Xeon desktop out there, period (talking $500-$1000 cheaper than the same specced Dell or HP), and 20" iMacs are both cheaper and faster than Dell's 20" all-in-ones. The 24" iMac uses the same H-IPS panel found in the $1100 NEC2490WUXi. You might not like spending that much on a display, but considering you're getting that awesome display with a fast computer included for only a few hundred more, I'd say its a good deal.

Nice, you tried copying your argument from our other thread into this one, almost word for word. Just because I decided not to respond earlier, doesnt mean I conceded an inch.

Firstly, they're the cheapest 8-core Xenon because THEY HAVE TO BE, and not out of the kindness of their hearts. I mean, what moron would buy an 8-core that restricted to what hardware can be run along with it and a proprietary software and hardware system thats unfriendly to modification, plugins, or upgrades?

Smart people decide they need 8 cores, because it costs a lot, and smart & savvy people dont buy Apple unless its a hardware-based steal and they can replace the OS.

Where you go wrong in your comparisons and information rehashing that even I dont want to strain to look up, is you assume its Apple vs. Dell. No my friend. Its Apple vs. PC ... Where as in, Apple hardware is RESTRICTED, you cant change it, tinker with it, buy serious upgrades on your own. And by Serious, I mean multi-part upgrades, as in BUILDING your own Apple by tossing out and changing almost all the guts.

Why? Its market maneuvering... they KNOW people can build better computers than them, so they restrict their OS to pre-fabricated hardware. What, are you going to argue that I cant buy (double-digit percentile) better hardware than a mac, THE day that mac model is released @ 400% markup ?? No, you cant.

Perhaps you'd like to browse Newegg, and take your pick of the PCs and compare the prices. Heck, step into a best buy and compare the "bang for buck" on their PCs vs. Apples, in both hardware and software. Do we just ingore the "bang" factor?

When do enthusiasts stop caring how fast their computers go and how much they can do TO them as WITH them? I mean really, what is an Apple Enthusiast?

Which person has to make more irrational decisions, the Apple or PC enthusiast? I guess you have to ask yourself, just which one has enough 'crazy' in them, huh?

Apple knows when its software is restricted to only their computers and phones, that they can do with their software what CONSOLES do to their game prices. The catch is, PCs have better to equal software that runs on faster and more optimised machines, for which you can select parts necessary to your work ie: more ram, insane HD space, 8 cores, etc...

The Mac is the Prada purse to my Wenger Messenger bag of a PC. It costs a lot more, and does a lot less. And its 'grace' is only in the eyes of the name-brand delusional, happily slurping up imaginary status and patting each other on the back while the rest of the world goes by.

While I replace my PCs every two years or so, I kept my first Mac G4 desktop for five years. It was a Final Cut Studio workstation (the reason I bought that first Mac) that ended up running as fast as the day I bought it with no reformats/reinstalls by the time I gave it away. I went through three PCs during the same time period. I was replacing hardware but it also coincided with the 2/3 year point when XP would start running like crap, even with diligent maintenance (defrag, malware scan, registry cleaning, etc), and I'd want to do a reinstall anyway so I just replaced everything. I never once had to maintain that Mac; I could just do my work on Final Cut in peace. So yeah, great work machines and well worth the price considering how robust an OS X installation is and how long the machines last.

I dont know about you, but my XP installations lasted half a decade, given a lot were used as mere servers. I would like to know just how many different programs you ran on your Mac vs. PC. When the program count is in favor of PC by 98%, well no fucking wonder now then is it?

Which OS got more updates during that time period as well? Speed, security, and compatibility? .. because I've used Final Cut and the Premier that was released for Macs, and both were slower than Premier on my XP machine.

I've read enough of your posts to know that you have an aggressive anti-Mac agenda. You don't like them, no big deal, that's your prerogative, but you take it a step further into outright FUD and lies. Very strange that you spew so much hate at them considering that Microsoft takes so much of their inspiration from OS X. The proof is in the fact that Vista has features and UI paradigms that I'd been using for 2+ years in OS 10.3 and 10.4 (and they'd already moved onto 10.5). Seeing that was a big surprise for me when I starting using Vista. My friend who is an engineer at Microsoft even admits as much (also, yay for employee discounts on all my Microsoft stuff!). You should try Googling the Jim Allchin memo to Gates and Ballmer from 2003, and Steve Ballmer's recent comments about them, its clear as day. Let's not even get into the fact that Apple makes a piece of hardware and every other PC manufacturer (the same ones you presumably defend) race to imitate.

They do a lot wrong (and what company doesn't?) but they sure as hell get a lot right as well.

So yeah, LOL at Ockie and Nemesis999.

Please, tell me, what in your opinion did Apple do "a lot of wrong" with, as you're saying? Because you cant just discount notebooks worth of arguments with a list of arbitrary facts by saying "they got a lot wrong but a lot right".

What do you define as their 'wrong' and their 'right' ... and if all you're able to state in the 'right' column is from a shiny, locked-in, restricted, expensive, proprietary hardware and marketing perspective, then what kind of objective enthusiast would that make you?

What you absolutely need to understand is that Apple FUNCTIONS on IRRATIONAL Buyer Behavior. And you TRUST these people? How do you not see that all Apple products are priced on hype float and restrictions? I mean, if you were seriously blown away by the I-bricks, then the Sprint Instinct must warp your mind. (Fancy comparison here) I'm blown away by neither, but you'd be seriously ignorant to just close your eyes and plug your ears, to not see and hear this.
 
Blah blah blah

First off, it is Mac vs Dell or HP or whatever. It is PC builder vs PC builder, period. To compare the price of a Mac with a machine that I put together myself with parts from Newegg is an absolutely ridiculous argument. Any PC I put together myself will be cheaper than anything I get from Dell, HP, whatever. If we're starting down that road then we might as well talk about what a ripoff every other PC builder is.

And BTW, put together a Mac Pro from Newegg with comparable parts (dual Xeons, mobo with SAS support), PSU to drive it all, case, and Vista, and see what the difference is. It is negligible, we're talking within $100, except that you're getting comprehensive warranty and support with the Mac.

Again, compare their Xeon workstations and all-in-ones against the same from other PC builders, you will find that the Macs actually cost less. Ditto their ultrathin Macbook Air against the Voodoo Envy and Lenovo x300, all loaded with DVD drives.

Your logic there is completely screwed. Next.

Firstly, they're the cheapest 8-core Xenon because THEY HAVE TO BE, and not out of the kindness of their hearts.

Wow, you went from "facts" to opinion and conspiracy theories awfully fast. Apple charges enough not to eat into their profit margins, this is well known. Now you are saying that on their high end workstation for working professionals, for whom price is not a factor, that they are going to lowball themselves because they know that people can build faster machines themselves?

Give me a fucking break.

Next.

I mean, what moron would buy an 8-core that restricted to what hardware can be run along with it and a proprietary software and hardware system thats unfriendly to modification, plugins, or upgrades?

Morons in visual effects, graphic design, plenty of people. I work in the film business so I see plenty of OS X and Linux machines used in post-production and visual effects houses. Guess they're all idiots for spending that cash on Macs and BOXX workstations! Ditto all those SGI machines I used to see. :rolleyes: Sure, Shake licenses (compositing software used on pretty much every major motion picture) are cheap as hell on OS X, but fuck it, you must be right! Furthermore, it is very easy to upgrade the CPUs in those Mac Pros, they use socketed Xeons like everyone else. Ditto the PCI-E cards. RAM and hard drives go without saying, works like anything else.

I've used Final Cut and the Premier that was released for Macs, and both were slower than Premier on my XP machine.

This is meaningless without hardware stats. I dual boot OS X and Vista on several machines, and everything from the operating system itself (boot up, sleep, file copying and file transfers, application startup time and speed), to the video editing software itself, to Photoshop CS3, to operations like video encoding, are faster on the OS X partition than the Windows partition on the exact same hardware. Next.

I dont know about you, but my XP installations lasted half a decade, given a lot were used as mere servers.

That's cute. I've seen Avid workstations on the 20th Century Fox lot running System 9 (bleagh) on ancient G4s that are older than the one I gave away last year, and they were tanks. The machine wasn't even an issue, we just used them and that was that, everything worked great. If that doesn't speak for stability then I don't know what does.

The catch is, PCs have better to equal software that runs on faster and more optimised machines

Really? I can't think of any software I'm missing in OS X aside from videogames. Hell, I'd love to have Windows ports of the IM, Usenet, and FTP software that I use in OS X. This is disregarding the fact that lots of things like image mounting and file viewing for pretty much everything is already built into the OS, and it works better than any third party software I have to download to do the same thing with on my Windows machine (IRFanView, Daemon Tools). There is tons of great software on OS X. Just because there is a greater quantity on Windows doesn't mean that you automatically get more quality. There is a point of diminishing returns and I think that all of us can agree that there is a ton of crapware out there. There is more software available in Windows but I guarantee that we are all using just about the same ones despite the extra choice (mIRC, Filezilla or WS_FTP, Pidgin, etc etc).

As for operating system, no contest, OS X hands down, and I like Vista SP1 a lot. Look up threads in the operating system forum where I'm defending Vista against ridiculous FUD if you don't believe me. Thing is stable as a rock and a massive improvement over XP.


You wanted my wrongs? I've made them clear here many times, but here goes:

- No Core 2 Duo Mac with PCI-E expansion. This is the big one. The one place Apple is not competitive relative to other PC builders (or DIYers) is Core 2 Duo machines with PCI-E expansion. All-in-ones are your only option for Core 2 Duos, which by nature cost more since engineering-wise they are in between notebooks and desktops. I mean, if freaking Dell can't get their all-in-ones to be cheaper or faster than what Apple offers, who can?

Either way, it is a hole in their product line that I wish would get filled. PCI-E expansion options that you get with a Mac Pro without the incredibly expensive Xeons to go with it. Something like the G4 Cube but without the completely retarded pricetag. Based on the price difference with the rest of their product line relative to Dell, I believe it would be very price competitive.

I would buy one in a heartbeat. Eight Xeon cores is overkill for me, its the main reason I went with the iMac instead of a Mac Pro. Core 2 Duo is plenty fast for my purposes. That I got an excellent monitor, silent operation, and a minimal footprint along with it is added bonus.

- The price premium on the 15" and 17" Macbook Pros, especially the 17". On the one hand you are getting a great aluminum case that is significantly thinner, smaller, and lighter than the competition's. You are getting a SWOP certified S-IPS panel, another thing that costs more but is much better suited for image work. You are getting superior accessories, a huge plus for travel. Compare the airline seat power adapter for the Mac compared to those you get for a Dell. One is a thin cord while the other involves a huge power brick. I travel for work all the time and the streamlined, smartly designed accessories with the Mac are a massive plus as far as packing goes. On the other hand, it is the only Mac notebook option you have with dedicated video. If you want to do Final Cut or anything like that, you should get the Macbook Pro over the Macbook. While the 13" Macbook is competitively priced against other lines like the Dell XPS when initially refreshed, there is nothing about the Macbook Pro that says "deal"; it carries a premium price from go. Considering all the pluses, it is the one place in the Mac lineup with an undeniable price premium compared to their other products, and it sucks. Hopefully the rumored across-the-board drop in the MBP line actually comes true when they get refreshed next month.

- The Mac Mini sucks. The only headless Core 2 Duo option out there is a tiny box with no easy expansion. The Macbook, Macbook Pro, iMac, and Mac Pro are all very easily upgraded with additional RAM, and the iMac is the only one that is difficult to make hard drive upgrades for (not a real issue with 750GB HD being the norm now and external hard drives being so cheap). Not so with the Mini, got to pry that fucker open with a putty knife!

I mean, I guess its cool that they crammed a computer into a tiny box but I really question the utility of it. You lose significant performance per dollar since you have to use expensive notebook CPUs and slow 1.8" hard drives. Extremely poor performance per dollar ratio there. I wish they'd discontinue the damn thing. It hasn't even been upgraded in over a year while every other Mac has gone through multiple upgrades in the same time period. Just update it or let it die. Without Plex or XBMC and a spot in the living room plugged into your TV, I think the Mini is a bust.

So yeah, some right, some wrong. There's the "wrong" since you think I am completely biased.

Fact of the matter is that computers are just tools to me. I use PCs and I use Macs. The gaming PC in my sig built from parts bought at Newegg didn't just come out of nowhere. That you think everyone who likes OS X and Mac hardware are delusional is ridiculous. Sure, there are some people who buy it for looks or whatever, but there are plenty of us who buy it because it is a robust, fast UNIX platform with a lot of good applications and a nice work environment. Its pretty simple.

PS - I'm not editing this ridiculously long post, so apologies in advance for misspellings and half sentences I didn't complete. :)
 
SO, why has no one considered suing Apple for anti competitive software practices?
 
SO, why has no one considered suing Apple for anti competitive software practices?

Because it isn't anti-competitive. Many companies sell operating systems that are made to run only on specific hardware. SGI, Amiga, countless numbers of devices with embedded operating systems including the XBox 360 (try installing that OS on custom hardware and then sell it on the open market and see how fast a SWAT team of lawyers takes you down). Apple aren't keeping anybody from buying a computer running Windows, Linux, Solaris, etc etc etc, so it isn't anti-competitive.

Now, you could sue Apple for anti-competitive behavior if they did something like threaten to either levy fines against or pull iPods/iPhones/Macs from other stores like Best Buy or whatever if they also carried competing products (ie - Zunes, Blackberries, Dells & HPs). That is textbook anti-competitive behavior that is explicitly there to punish competition in the marketplace. The thing is that Apple explicitly sells end-to-end products that also work with products from other companies. They aren't keeping anyone from buying anything else, they aren't breaking compatibility with other hardware or preventing other operating systems to run on their own hardware, nor are they punishing retailers for carrying competing products, so it isn't anti-competitive.

What Microsoft did in the 90s by threatening PC builders that were going to carry OS/2, slowing Windows 95 shipments to IBM when it was clear that they were also going to push OS/2, levying fines or raising license fees against PC builders that pre-installed applications like Netscape, Lotus SmartSuite, AOL, that is anti-competitive behavior of the first order and fortunately it doesn't happen anymore. Now companies like Dell can bundle other operating systems like Ubuntu or even XP without fear of reprisal from Microsoft.

Speaking of which, companies were punished with multiple license fees for offering to sell both Windows 3.1 and Windows 95 if they decided to do so (like XP/Vista, it was another shaky transition for business customers). So then Compaq gets charged twice by Microsoft whether they sold Windows 3.1 or 95, instead of being charged per individual license as they do now. Another means of coercion in the marketplace. Could you imagine the uproar if they tried this more recently with XP and Vista? XP installs were still pretty popular up until very recently, and if it came out that Microsoft punished PC buiders in this way it would be very bad for their image. Fortunately Microsoft isn't nearly the bully they used to be (thank you justice system).

Remember, having a monopoly doesn't constitute anti-competitive behavior, anti-competitive behavior does. :)
 
Because it isn't anti-competitive. Many companies sell operating systems that are made to run only on specific hardware. SGI, Amiga, countless numbers of devices with embedded operating systems including the XBox 360 (try installing that OS on custom hardware and then sell it on the open market and see how fast a SWAT team of lawyers takes you down). Apple aren't keeping anybody from buying a computer running Windows, Linux, Solaris, etc etc etc, so it isn't anti-competitive.

Now, you could sue Apple for anti-competitive behavior if they did something like threaten to either levy fines against or pull iPods/iPhones/Macs from other stores like Best Buy or whatever if they also carried competing products (ie - Zunes, Blackberries, Dells & HPs). That is textbook anti-competitive behavior that is explicitly there to punish competition in the marketplace. The thing is that Apple explicitly sells end-to-end products that also work with products from other companies. They aren't keeping anyone from buying anything else, they aren't breaking compatibility with other hardware or preventing other operating systems to run on their own hardware, nor are they punishing retailers for carrying competing products, so it isn't anti-competitive.

What Microsoft did in the 90s by threatening PC builders that were going to carry OS/2, slowing Windows 95 shipments to IBM when it was clear that they were also going to push OS/2, levying fines or raising license fees against PC builders that pre-installed applications like Netscape, Lotus SmartSuite, AOL, that is anti-competitive behavior of the first order and fortunately it doesn't happen anymore. Now companies like Dell can bundle other operating systems like Ubuntu or even XP without fear of reprisal from Microsoft.

Speaking of which, companies were punished with multiple license fees for offering to sell both Windows 3.1 and Windows 95 if they decided to do so (like XP/Vista, it was another shaky transition for business customers). So then Compaq gets charged twice by Microsoft whether they sold Windows 3.1 or 95, instead of being charged per individual license as they do now. Another means of coercion in the marketplace. Could you imagine the uproar if they tried this more recently with XP and Vista? XP installs were still pretty popular up until very recently, and if it came out that Microsoft punished PC buiders in this way it would be very bad for their image. Fortunately Microsoft isn't nearly the bully they used to be (thank you justice system).

Remember, having a monopoly doesn't constitute anti-competitive behavior, anti-competitive behavior does. :)

Ok, I see your point...somewhat. But, Apple is suing one manufacturer who is selling Mac Clone hardware that accepts OS-X natively if you want to install it (licensed OS copy of course).

Then again, MS can not prevent any other apps from being installed now, where Apple does (Just install some non-Apple approved software on your I-Phone and then let an automated update fry the damn thing for you).
 
With no common hardware platform to develop for, Android is just going to be a moving target and a bitch to develop for once the novelty wears off. Touchscreen? Who knows. QWERTY keys? Maybe. Screen resolution? Another toss up. So what is going to happen once various Android devices start getting onto the market is the app devs are going to get split and any attempt at an App Store is going to turn into a bunch of apps that work with phones 1, 2, and 3, but will not work correctly at all on phones 4, 5, and 6. This is what Apple is doing right, only two versions of the phone, both with the same baseline hardware, and all of the apps from the app store work for everyone that wants them.

Don't you think Google thought of this already? I mean, what you are suggesting is kinda silly and just a guess on your part. We all don't know the details just yet, but it makes sense that any phone running Android will have the same base hardware/feature set such a touchscreen, qwerty kb, and a minimum screen resolution.
 
Ok, I see your point...somewhat. But, Apple is suing one manufacturer who is selling Mac Clone hardware that accepts OS-X natively if you want to install it (licensed OS copy of course).

Then again, MS can not prevent any other apps from being installed now, where Apple does (Just install some non-Apple approved software on your I-Phone and then let an automated update fry the damn thing for you).

Yeah, Psystar. Those people were being stupid. Although I think fighting the EULA might stand a chance in court, you need the money and legal resources to fight it out with the juggernaut legal team that a NASDAQ 100 company would have. A backwater company like them didn't.

What Psystar should have done was to sell machines that could accept OS X installations (I'm not sure what exactly they did, maybe they had EFI instead of BIOS on the motherboards, no idea), but with no operating system preinstalled. There is nothing that is litigation worthy about that. After that the customer is free to buy a copy of OS X and install it by himself (or Windows, or Linus, or whatever). By selling systems with OS X already preloaded on the machines they were asking for trouble. So yeah, they went about it the wrong way.

Its like people who sell modified XBoxes. Again, nothing illegal about that. Now, selling modified XBoxes that come pre-loaded with ROMs, that's cause for trouble.

As for the iPhone, I have yet to hear about any jailbroken phones that have gotten bricked by software updates. For one thing, jailbreaks, generally come out only 1 or 2 days after the update, plus they are fully compatible with mainstream downloads (it will still work with app store downloads). They all work flawlessly as far as I know. Second, iPhones that are messed up for whatever reason up can easily be restored to factory default firmware, if need be. Bricking and iPhone from either jailbreaking or running it on another cell carrier is something that hasn't happened yet.

I understand where you are coming from but so far it has nothing to do with reality.
 
As for the iPhone, I have yet to hear about any jailbroken phones that have gotten bricked by software updates. For one thing, jailbreaks, generally come out only 1 or 2 days after the update, plus they are fully compatible with mainstream downloads (it will still work with app store downloads). They all work flawlessly as far as I know. Second, iPhones that are messed up for whatever reason up can easily be restored to factory default firmware, if need be. Bricking and iPhone from either jailbreaking or running it on another cell carrier is something that hasn't happened yet.

Oh really?

http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&articleId=9039479

Owners of unlocked iPhones who proceeded with the update have filed somewhat conflicting reports, but the most credible accounts conclude that their devices are incapacitated.

Apple has discovered that many of the unauthorized iPhone unlocking programs available on the Internet cause irreparable damage to the iPhone's software, which will likely result in the modified iPhone becoming permanently inoperable when a future Apple-supplied iPhone software update is installed. Apple plans to release the next iPhone software update, containing many new features including the iTunes Wi-Fi Music Store (www.itunes.com), later this week. Apple strongly discourages users from installing unauthorized unlocking programs on their iPhones. Users who make unauthorized modifications to the software on their iPhone violate their iPhone software license agreement and void their warranty. The permanent inability to use an iPhone due to installing unlocking software is not covered under the iPhone's warranty.
 

Yeah, really. I know several people who have jailbroken their iPhone ever since it was possible and it has never been a problem. There are frequent threads on Shacknews about jailbreaking them, pretty much every day (here's one I spotted before I headed out this morning: http://www.shacknews.com/laryn.x?id=18042655#itemanchor_18042655 ), and I have yet to hear of any problems, not even having to do a factory restore.

Your article link was from almost exactly a year ago, and not only are phones not being bricked, jailbreaking with full app store support is thriving under firmware 2.1 right now. Brickings could still happen in theory, but in practice it is has absolutely nothing to do with reality.
 
Sooo Serpico,

What do you think about app store rejects going to android?

Like I said earlier, more power to them. I know the certification process can be tough. One iPhone developer I know (who made the awesome Latestchatty.app for reading Shacknews and posting in a streamlined version of their threaded forum) had to go through it twice before getting approved. It isn't easy. Part of that is because standards for security and standards are tight (both times it had to go back for very obscure reasons), part is that there is a long queue for approval which makes turnaround take days, and finally the big problem is that there is no dedicated person from Apple that is there to interact with iPhone developers and let them know more obscure guidelines before sending an app off just to get rejected and get send to the back of the line.

Its a problem, and I think that Android will benefit from having both people who develop for the iPhone and those who don't want to deal with that hassle. Android has hassles of its own (non-standard hardware and physical interfaces, unfriendly development tools), but no platform is perfect. I don't like HTC's handsets but I still can't wait to get my hands on a G1 when its finally out.
 
Back
Top