Android: Google's Dream, Apple's Nightmare?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The HTC Dream from T-Mobile is scheduled to hit the market tomorrow making it the first Android powered mobile phone to hit retail shelves. As you can imagine, the comparisons to Apple’s iPhone have already begun. Will Android overtake the world?

The sweetest part of the Dream is the add-on applications available from the Android Market — Google's answer to the Apple App Store. Whereas many Apple apps cost money (typically anywhere from $.99 to $9.99), at launch all Android Market apps will be free.
 
I don't think it's hideous. Check out this YouTube clip. I think Android's got a lot going for it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5PjoOPZcQwQ

I wonder if Android supports Flash.

In any case, I don't think Android will be an iPhone killer, but it WILL be an awesome non-AT&T alternative.
 
Well, my contract is up and i'm in line for an upgrade. I'm gonna pick up the G1, it'll be my first smart phone. I'm currently rocking a 2 and a half year old RAZR, i need something new, haha.

Also, I think the Black HTC Dream they had in the youtube videos of the Android demo looks pretty slick.
 
Sure, you'll get all these apps for free, but which would you want to write for? You can write for one that pays you or one that doesn't.

That doesn't even mention market share...

Personally, I haven't seen anything on (yes, I'll admit, that could change one day) Android that looks as good as the iPhone, let alone better.
 
You guys act like Android is a phone. I think once we start to see other phones come out then it will be a nightmare for Apple.
 
You guys act like Android is a phone. I think once we start to see other phones come out then it will be a nightmare for Apple.

Thank you Captain Obvious, but I'm well aware of the fact that Android is an OS for a phone.
 
Guh, T-Mobile. When will Sprint actually carry a phone exclusive that isn't the Instinct? Sorry, I tried it out in store, and wasn't impressed. I can see why others would be, but I personally wasn't. Then again, I only toyed around with it for five minutes.
 
What I'm hoping for, and whats probably going to become the case, is that Android will work like STEAM. You buy any Android enabled phone from any future company, and instantly, you have all your shit, right there, at your fingertips. No muss, no fuss, no hoping the address book functions the same. And with the apps being free, there will be boundless customizations, many immitating the iPhone itself I bet. Shit, with an SDK, you will probably be able to make the apps yourself.

It'll make the iPhone look like the iMac... like the white padded cell for the less-than-rational crowd that it is.

Android is STEAM for your celly.
 
I must say, Android seems to be superior to the iPhone OS. It appears more flexible, and therefore more powerful. I don't want Apple holding my hand when I use a computer or a phone - I want to make the device work in whatever way I see fit. I don't need or want Apple controlling what programs I install on my computer / phone.

Apple seems to lull people into trusting their "better judgment"... No thanks.

common opinion is that android is very underwhelming

I didn't know there was such a thing. Judging by the opinions shared in this thread, no consensus has been reached.

I know quite a few people who feel the same way about Apple that I do, and I know that most of us have been waiting for a powerful alternative to the iPhone.

Oh, and I almost forgot to mention how much iTunes sucks - which is one more program Apple shoves down your throat when you purchase an iPhone. No thanks Apple!
 
Interesting that, what's common is all of the anti-Apple prattle that people spew when equipment that aspires to be half as good as equipment that has logged years of research and development. The iPhone and Apple have proven time and again that R&D costs large sums of money and with that investment comes large rewards. The single most telling statement in the article...

"The sweetest part of the Dream is the add-on applications available from the Android Market — Google's answer to the Apple App Store. Whereas many Apple apps cost money (typically anywhere from $.99 to $9.99), at launch all Android Market apps will be free."

Whats so great about P.O.S. software thats free? Whats so great about wading through hip deep P.O.S software to find maybe a useful tool? Finally, whats so great about the next pretender for the effectiveness and usefulness of the iPhone at a cut rate with little to no R&D? Consumers in this country need to quit expecting something for nothing. What are we a bunch of beggars looking for a hand out?
 
Interesting that, what's common is all of the anti-Apple prattle that people spew when equipment that aspires to be half as good as equipment that has logged years of research and development. The iPhone and Apple have proven time and again that R&D costs large sums of money and with that investment comes large rewards. The single most telling statement in the article...

"The sweetest part of the Dream is the add-on applications available from the Android Market — Google's answer to the Apple App Store. Whereas many Apple apps cost money (typically anywhere from $.99 to $9.99), at launch all Android Market apps will be free."

Whats so great about P.O.S. software thats free? Whats so great about wading through hip deep P.O.S software to find maybe a useful tool? Finally, whats so great about the next pretender for the effectiveness and usefulness of the iPhone at a cut rate with little to no R&D? Consumers in this country need to quit expecting something for nothing. What are we a bunch of beggars looking for a hand out?

I suggest you pay a visit to freshmeat.net and sourceforge.com someday. It might enlighten you to quality of free software that people actually do as a hobby and without pay.

Free does not always mean POS.
 
Interesting that, what's common is all of the anti-Apple prattle that people spew when equipment that aspires to be half as good as equipment that has logged years of research and development. The iPhone and Apple have proven time and again that R&D costs large sums of money and with that investment comes large rewards. The single most telling statement in the article...

"The sweetest part of the Dream is the add-on applications available from the Android Market — Google's answer to the Apple App Store. Whereas many Apple apps cost money (typically anywhere from $.99 to $9.99), at launch all Android Market apps will be free."

Whats so great about P.O.S. software thats free? Whats so great about wading through hip deep P.O.S software to find maybe a useful tool? Finally, whats so great about the next pretender for the effectiveness and usefulness of the iPhone at a cut rate with little to no R&D? Consumers in this country need to quit expecting something for nothing. What are we a bunch of beggars looking for a hand out?

I've allways had a mental image of Apple R&D guys being a bunch of turtle necked, chain smoking, coffee addicted, frenchman, arguing about how to make existentialism into a marketable commodity.

If you want to argue over price vs quality of software and hardware, please do. Apple prices its products for how much it thinks they're ego can float them, irrelevant of out-dated hardware, and software that all but locks in your dna.

While apple can get away with murder by pretending that their mistakes are 'sincere' ... the rest of us have been so polarised by their mud-slinging campaigns that could almost make the republicans blush, that to the dis-enchanted masses, Apple holds as much sincerity in it as a white padded cell at the locan insane asylum.

Put down the kool-aid and open those ojos, Apple siezed its market share using the Karl Rove playbook. Between the frivolous lawsuits, infringements, patent disputes, and enough screaming, and hand wringing by Jobs to drive employees at apple to admire him the same way Musolini was admired for his handywork... they could give tips to McCain

The PC was Swiftboated.
 
Whats so great about P.O.S. software thats free?

Uh, most of the software on Apple's own app store is free, and a lot of it is really excellent...

Urbanspoon and Remote on OS X Touch are among the two best applications I've used on any platform, and they're free! What's to say that good free software won't end up on Android?
 
T-Mobile to compete with AT&T? I must be missing some kinda sarcaism in that somewhere.

Why? Despite the fact that they use a different 3G standard from the rest of the world (grr), T-Mobile's network is still better than AT&T's as far as coverage and quality goes. If it wasn't for the iPhone being locked into AT&T (which only makes sense since AT&T has the only 3G network that the rest of the world uses), I'd still be on T-Mobile, no question.
 
I've allways had a mental image of Apple R&D guys being a bunch of turtle necked, chain smoking, coffee addicted, frenchman, arguing about how to make existentialism into a marketable commodity.

Right, which Microsoft, Dell, HP, etc, then spend the next few years playing catch-up with. You want to talk about useless pipe-dreams, pull up any interview with Gates talking about how the future of computing is in projected surfaces. Ridiculous! Good thing they have Windows and Office to sell. Believe me, as someone who builds his own PCs and uses Macs, it is frustrating not to see more leadership from the PC side of the fence as far as something useful coming out of their own R&D departments, instead of watching them play catch-up with what Apple turns out. All the new features and UI paradigms in Vista (which I really like BTW) was basically a poor copy of stuff that was already in OS X for two years by the time Vista launched, and Apple had already moved past that in the new version. Not all of their stuff is successful or good btw (Apple TV? Mac Mini?), but nobody has a 1.000 batting average.

Apple prices its products for how much it thinks they're ego can float them, irrelevant of out-dated hardware, and software that all but locks in your dna.

The Mac Pro is the cheapest eight-core Xeon workstation out there, period. Cheaper than Dell, cheaper than HP by $500-$1000 with identical specs. The iMac is both cheaper and faster than Dell's Core 2 Duo all-in-one. The 24" iMac uses the same H-IPS LCD panel that the $1100 NEC 2490WUXi uses (its actually the best deal on that monitor since you get a fast computer along with it for just a little bit more). Macbooks are cheaper than 13" Dell XPS notebooks in the first few months from when they are initially refreshed. Obviously you can get a lower end notebook from Dell, plus Dell slowly drops prices as time goes on, both of which Apple doesn't do.

You're not going to get a decent econobox from them (the Mac Mini suuuuucks) and you can obviously build a Core 2 Duo machine yourself for less (a DIY eight-core Xeon with parts from Newegg actually comes out to about the same price as a Mac Pro, except without the warranty and support). All that said, for the components Apple uses and form factors they offer (all-in-ones and notebooks), they are extremely price competitive with other PC builders. All they're missing to be totally 1:1 competitive with other PC builders are Core 2 Duos with PCI-E expansion, but I doubt we'll see that anytime soon.

Since most of us are DIYers here, buying from Apple makes as much sense as buying a desktop from any other PC builder.

As for software, most of iTunes is DRM free now (I still recommend that people go Amazon; their download service is awesome) and things like Mail, Address Book, and Calendar uses open file formats. Me moving items between Thunderbird and those OS X apps is much easier than if I were to do the same with Outlook.

The PC was Swiftboated.

No, PC got lazy and the other guy was hungry. They're finally starting to wake up again. This is why competition is good. Your of argument makes as much sense to me as an nVidia or ATI fanboy wishing the other guy would just go away. We all know what happens when competition stops: no product refreshes and stagnant pricing from nVidia for over a year while ATI flounders with nothing to push back with.
 
I am a fan of what I have seen so far. I like the black version a lot more than the silver version of the Dream.

The UI looks pretty slick. Although - kind of gimicky - the lock on the phone is pretty slick.
 
So let me make a few predictions that will seem like no brainers 2 mos. after the release of android hardware and the apps that run on it.

1. You always get what you pay for.
2.The malicious software apps made available through a clearinghouse with no oversight or system of quality control will be astounding.
3. The effect of #2 will be to create a system of oversight and quality control.
4. Android will be a sad little ghost of the iPhone and will end in utter failure. This one, considering Googles resources, may take a couple phone cycles to be realized.
5. We will see a ton of pathetic Android vs iPhone Commercials ala pc vs mac ads, and you'll have no one to blame but yourselves.

Now to those that would assume that I besmirched OpenSource programers, read it again and quote me on that charge. Fact is I am a HUGE advocate of GPL and the dissolution of all forms of EULAs. You missed wide with that assumption. What I find deplorable is that brilliant minds have been convinced that what they have to offer the world should be had by all for no compensation other then a great little blurb somewhere at the end of a ReadMe file. The other gripe, if you could call it that, is that a large portion of the consumers in the US have this sense of entitlement that every piece of software should somehow be free.
Apple invested TONS of resources to a ballsy move into the Cellular Phone market and reaps the rewards, then encourages others to reap the rewards of their own efforts and seek compensation, and all we hear is "waaaaaaa but they charge for apps that I find useful waaaaa" "Android will show them just wait for the free to start flowing..." I can hardly wait for the flow to begin.
 
I've allways had a mental image of Apple R&D guys being a bunch of turtle necked, chain smoking, coffee addicted, frenchman, arguing about how to make existentialism into a marketable commodity.

If you want to argue over price vs quality of software and hardware, please do. Apple prices its products for how much it thinks they're ego can float them, irrelevant of out-dated hardware, and software that all but locks in your dna.

While apple can get away with murder by pretending that their mistakes are 'sincere' ... the rest of us have been so polarised by their mud-slinging campaigns that could almost make the republicans blush, that to the dis-enchanted masses, Apple holds as much sincerity in it as a white padded cell at the locan insane asylum.

Put down the kool-aid and open those ojos, Apple siezed its market share using the Karl Rove playbook. Between the frivolous lawsuits, infringements, patent disputes, and enough screaming, and hand wringing by Jobs to drive employees at apple to admire him the same way Musolini was admired for his handywork... they could give tips to McCain

The PC was Swiftboated.

Agreed. Serpico, Not so much. Both good posts though.

Fuck this POS Dream, the Andriod Phone I'm waiting for is the HTC Touch Diamond.
http://www.htc.com/www/product.aspx?id=46286
 
Android won't pose a threat to Apple simply because people outside of the tech circles don't care and even if they did they won't have an effective way to distribute apps. Tech Savvy people won't have a problem finding apps but lets face it, we account for a very very slim portion of the market. iTunes gives people an accessable way to access new apps and Android will fail because of that. I hate to say it but Thomb Thumb had it right, you get what you pay for and open source stuff has yet to impress me. If Android is banking on a very small group of open source followers and an even smaller market to prop up their software they'll never compete with Apple.
 
Interesting that, what's common is all of the anti-Apple prattle that people spew when equipment that aspires to be half as good as equipment that has logged years of research and development. The iPhone and Apple have proven time and again that R&D costs large sums of money and with that investment comes large rewards. The single most telling statement in the article...

"The sweetest part of the Dream is the add-on applications available from the Android Market — Google's answer to the Apple App Store. Whereas many Apple apps cost money (typically anywhere from $.99 to $9.99), at launch all Android Market apps will be free."

Whats so great about P.O.S. software thats free? Whats so great about wading through hip deep P.O.S software to find maybe a useful tool? Finally, whats so great about the next pretender for the effectiveness and usefulness of the iPhone at a cut rate with little to no R&D? Consumers in this country need to quit expecting something for nothing. What are we a bunch of beggars looking for a hand out?


Here's a thought for you, fanboy.

How does Apple forcing developers to charge for apps, and then taking a cut of the money, make apps better?

Some of the best software in the world is freeware, and little to none of it is from Apple.
 
I'm using some seriously incredible free programs on my Nokia N810. My favorite has to be Vagalume; it's astounding what it does using my Last.FM's user profile.
 
Here's a thought for you, fanboy.

How does Apple forcing developers to charge for apps, and then taking a cut of the money, make apps better?

Some of the best software in the world is freeware, and little to none of it is from Apple.

Here's a thought for you, fanboy.

Developers can release applications on iTunes for free and Apple doesn't take a cut.

There's tons of great freeware on the service.
 
I'd drop it, get it wet, sit on it or lose it within a month.

Did that to a girl once. Was a good time.
===============================================
Like someone else said in this thread. It's good to have competition. There will be differences between the two and there will be people who like one above the other. And some of those people will take it personally when someone says they don't like their phone which is very evident in this thread. Remember folks. It's just a phone, not your Momma.
 
Macbooks are cheaper than 13" Dell XPS notebooks in the first few months from when they are initially refreshed. Obviously you can get a lower end notebook from Dell, plus Dell slowly drops prices as time goes on, both of which Apple doesn't do.
Two things here. Number one, the build quality of a Macbook (not pro) is far inferior to the build quality of a Dell XPS let alone ANY Thinkpad. Number two, you say that Apple doesn't drop prices as time goes on, which is right. That is one of the main reasons that Apple is accused of selling overpriced products in these forums.
 
So let me make a few predictions that will seem like no brainers 2 mos. after the release of android hardware and the apps that run on it.

1. You always get what you pay for.
2.The malicious software apps made available through a clearinghouse with no oversight or system of quality control will be astounding.
3. The effect of #2 will be to create a system of oversight and quality control.
4. Android will be a sad little ghost of the iPhone and will end in utter failure. This one, considering Googles resources, may take a couple phone cycles to be realized.
5. We will see a ton of pathetic Android vs iPhone Commercials ala pc vs mac ads, and you'll have no one to blame but yourselves.

Now to those that would assume that I besmirched OpenSource programers, read it again and quote me on that charge. Fact is I am a HUGE advocate of GPL and the dissolution of all forms of EULAs. You missed wide with that assumption. What I find deplorable is that brilliant minds have been convinced that what they have to offer the world should be had by all for no compensation other then a great little blurb somewhere at the end of a ReadMe file. The other gripe, if you could call it that, is that a large portion of the consumers in the US have this sense of entitlement that every piece of software should somehow be free.
Apple invested TONS of resources to a ballsy move into the Cellular Phone market and reaps the rewards, then encourages others to reap the rewards of their own efforts and seek compensation, and all we hear is "waaaaaaa but they charge for apps that I find useful waaaaa" "Android will show them just wait for the free to start flowing..." I can hardly wait for the flow to begin.

Steve Jobs, you li'l lurker, you! Where's the *plant* emoticon?

I hope Android makes Microsoft kick Windows Mobile 7 in the ass and get its shit together.

I don't think that Android will keep people that want to get an Iphone and willingly participate in Apple foolishness from getting their fix. Apple's not going to step up their game, they only need to release the bare minimum in the most locked down, jack-booted way possible and people here in the States will buy it anyway.
 
Two things here. Number one, the build quality of a Macbook (not pro) is far inferior to the build quality of a Dell XPS let alone ANY Thinkpad. Number two, you say that Apple doesn't drop prices as time goes on, which is right. That is one of the main reasons that Apple is accused of selling overpriced products in these forums.

I agree with you on the Thinkpad and disagree with you on the XPS. And yes, Apple keeps its prices consistently fixed, that's why I said it. I try only to post points that I can back up. :) The Macbook is usually the cheaper option when it is first released, which then goes away as they keep prices fixed and others go down, then the process repeats again at the next product refresh. The point still stands with the Mac Pro being much cheaper than an identically specced Dell or HP, same with the iMac being cheaper and faster than all-in-ones by other PC builders. The Macbook Air is cheaper than the same class/specced notebooks by Voodoo and Lenovo. The place you are paying a significant premium is with the Macbook Pro. They are expensive compared to other 15" notebooks out there. Then again, you are getting all that power in a very thin and light aluminum case (1" thick and 5lbs) and an IPS panel, not to mention the only Apple portable to do real image editing work on, so for some people the price can be justified.

So its a mix. Some items you're paying a premium on, others you really aren't. Things like RAM and hard drive upgrades should only be purchased online from Newegg or some place like that. If you're comparing Apple's prices with building a PC yourself (even though a Mac Pro will cost about the same as if you built the same machine yourself) then you're obviously paying more, but the same can be said when comparing that with any other PC builder. I think that's why we all build our own PCs in the first place. :)
 
I just order T-Mobile G1 last night. The phone should be release in mid Oct.
 
Back
Top