Technology Doesn’t Dumb Us Down

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
There are people out there that believe that technology is making us st00pid. Then there is the rational segment of our population that believes technology doesn’t dumb us down. While arguments can be made either way, I believe technology is a phenomenal learning tool (for obvious reasons) and I'm sure you guys agree.

It is hard to think of a technology that wasn’t feared when it was introduced. In his Atlantic article, Mr. Carr says that Socrates feared the impact that writing would have on man’s ability to think. The advent of the printing press summoned similar fears. It wouldn’t be the last time.
 
Technology allows people to be lazy. Once again, it's the individuals misusing the tool, not the tool it's self, giving everyone a bad name. Same goes for drugs, alcohol, guns etc. There's always responsible ways to use these things, yet those that don't, allow their downsides to generalize across an entire population.
 
One example in favor of tech is electronic databases. Lexisnexis/west law for example have made legal research drastically quicker and easier which has lead to very significant improvements in the quality of workproducts depending on such research as well as a reduction in costs for them:)
 
One example in favor of tech is electronic databases. Lexisnexis/west law for example have made legal research drastically quicker and easier which has lead to very significant improvements in the quality of workproducts depending on such research as well as a reduction in costs for them:)

I'm scared to think of how big index files would be for big law companies. Instant search would be insane haha. I wonder if we're there yet.
 
Technology doesn't dumb down, it is created by smart people... it's the people that plop down and waste their life on tv or video games that are the dumb ones... I thought that was obvious
 
i use technology to research things (more than just wikipedia). I also use technology to automate repetitive or basic tasks to free up my own time to stick my head in a book or to further my learning. Also I make it a point to understand technology itself and how it works in detail.

I hope thats not considered dumbed down...
 
Tech doesnt help stupid people become lazy or lazy people become stupid, it frustrates the hell out of them and makes them bug us technophiles.
 
Technology doesn't make people stupid, it just makes it easier for stupid people to humiliate themselves in public.
 
I can agree on SOME points, the only notable one would be math... I know I can't do division and multiplication in my head as well as some people because I always use a calculator, at least on oddball stuff, I dont mean 30 divided by 3, I mean like 2369 divided by 782.

Plus all the 12 year old kids who don't seem to understand english, like kthx <3.

But for the most part, it makes smart people smarter, and dumb people bug us.
 
Its dumb to say that tech makes humans dumb

Technology is civilization's progress. Techology is not just eletrocnic computers, its everything including transportation, communication and medicine. Its what made us different from other animals, it makes us intelligent beings. Since the day cavemen invented simple tools, which is a technology, humans have only evolved into smarter beings, not dumb ones. And today, it aids our learning process, and speed up or even make possible for certain knowledge acquisition

Whoever that claims technology make us dumb must have forgotten that today, their life depends on technology
 
I guess it all depends on how you decide to use the technology available to you.

I can't see how surfing MySpace for hours on end can possibly make you smarter. Not to mention the fact that some people's entire lives can be viewed in its entirety on some MySpace pages (and that would truly make you stupid, especially with the ease of the reset password trick that's been recently publicized).

To each his own though, I guess. Let evolution take its course. Doesn't seem to me that this forum falls into that 'dumb' category.
 
I think one problem is that a lot of people don't understand technology (and its limits) and therefore don't use it properly, while still getting dependent on it.

I can think of grammar/spellchecking or translation software for example. A lot of people don't really know how spell/translate, but they mistakenly think that the software will do it for them. The software will help by giving you suggestions, but the software has only a very limited grasp of context, so oftentimes it will choose the wrong option and make text unintelligible.

Or people using a navigation device in their car, but aren't able to read a map... so if the device fails, they have no idea how to get anywhere.
 
Im trying to remember the last time I used more complicated math than basic add/sub for my check book...and since all my phone numbers exist in my blackberry/outlook contacts list, I dont remember any of them. Its not so much im st000pid now, but people dont remember what they dont use.
 
I can agree on SOME points, the only notable one would be math... I know I can't do division and multiplication in my head as well as some people because I always use a calculator, at least on oddball stuff, I dont mean 30 divided by 3, I mean like 2369 divided by 782.

~2400 / ~800 = ~3. You don't always need to be exact for that stuff, sometimes approximating is a more useful skill. :)
 
I believe technology does make the majority of people dumb. Some people like us (or we wont be here on hardocp) makes us more intelligent because we embrace the technology and reinforce our lifestyles with it.

I cant tell you how many people I have come across who does not know how to use a map (they used navigation in the past), how many people know what a land-line is (cell phones and wireless), how many people are surprised when their phones don't work during power outages (wireless phones uses power), how many people can't even get around to the most staple things of life such as using the yellow pages, or as simple as finding a section in a news paper.
 
~2400 / ~800 = ~3. You don't always need to be exact for that stuff, sometimes approximating is a more useful skill. :)

HardOCP_FAIL_250-Forum.jpg
 
I believe technology does make the majority of people dumb.

I wonder... These people probably would fail at life anyway, just in different ways than they do today.
So technology doesn't make them dumb, they already were dumb to start with.
 
I wonder... These people probably would fail at life anyway, just in different ways than they do today.
So technology doesn't make them dumb, they already were dumb to start with.

hehehehe I liked that one
 
Problem solving is a skill any person interested in there own well being needs. Relying on some gadget to do that for you (going all-out on a Calculus exam with the TI-89 Titanium, for example) isn't going to take you far; you gotta use your brain.
 
In other words (sorry, meant for this to be in the last post), people have probably become lazier with technology. Or maybe it allowed them to stay as lazy as before.
 
I wonder... These people probably would fail at life anyway, just in different ways than they do today.
So technology doesn't make them dumb, they already were dumb to start with.

I'd say that is pretty accurate too.
 
I'm scared to think of how big index files would be for big law companies. Instant search would be insane haha. I wonder if we're there yet.


for law companies?

Try the US goverment where Pacernet has all court opinions on file, along with trials and all associated evidence etc. Very powerful tool to look someone up too ;)
 
Seems most of you aren't looking beyond the computer. Technology can be many things. Automobiles, factories, automation, entertainment, engineering, physics, space, environment..

I fully agree that technology is definitely not making people dumb. It's making us learn more than what we could only theorize in the past.
 
Seems most of you aren't looking beyond the computer. Technology can be many things. Automobiles, factories, automation, entertainment, engineering, physics, space, environment..

I fully agree that technology is definitely not making people dumb. It's making us learn more than what we could only theorize in the past.

how about houses, chairs, beds, forks, the wheel
 
Back
Top