Did 'Spore' Copy Protections Backfire on EA?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Copy protection is a touchy subject with consumers but, for the most part, people don’t have a problem with it when it is implemented correctly. Apparently EA has learned this yet because they are pissing off fans of the new game Spore by limiting the times they can install the game to three. Smooth move.

What's the fuss about? Electronic Arts imposed copyright protections that limited the number of times a user can install the game to three. EA has likened the system to the limits imposed on songs bought through Apple's iTunes store (though in the case of iTunes, users can easily manage their libraries by specifying which computers are authorized to play their purchased content).
 
yes and no

Most people dont know what securerom even is - so it didnt affect them at all
Some people who know what it is, dont care
Some people who know what it is and what it really does - prob didnt buy it, and those same people likely know where to download it from.

SecureRom isnt an excuse to download it, just dont buy it. downloading it doesnt stick it to the man in any way shape or form, all it says is "hey i like your game!" as opposed to your game sucks, your protection sucks, i am boycotting you.
 
when are the publishers going to learn? How can any consumer be happy with any type of copy protection. Who wants to buy something that is made to make things difficult than it has to be, or some kind of pain in the ass hoops to jump threw.

The purpose of copy protection and DRM is to stop or slow down piracy, right? Hello, McFly! It's not working! I couldn't justify spending $50 on a game that I could only install 3 times. I reformat and install windows at least that many times a year.
 
It's pretty funny that in trying to prevent piracy, EA has actually made it less onerous and much simpler to pirate than to purchase. That's been said about CD cracks and the like before, but this is substantially worse. Having to keep a CD in a drive is far less troublesome than having your legally purchased software up and tell you to fuck off because you have installed it one too many times.

The main issue with that sort of limited install scheme is that the definition of computer is very loose. I upgraded my video card and this caused another digital delivery service (Direct2Drive) to consider my computer as a new one entirely. I wound up simply pirating the game in question, because calling D2D resulted in nothing more than frustration on my part and a total lack of concern on theirs. Steam seems to have it right; copy protection that is invisible, at least to me. Running Steam before I play Bioshock or Crysis is pretty darned innocuous.
 
Most people dont know what securerom even is - so it didnt affect them at all

Wrong in that people who don't know what DRM is are more likely to be pissed when the game "magically" stops working. More so because in this case, the DRM contradicts the manual. GG EA.
 
I dont have any issues with DRM that stop the people trying to rip off the game.

I have a huge problem with DRM that only serves to punish the paying customer.
 
what i think of this.. uhm bad n right.

Limiting is FUCK OFF, dvd protection OMGZ please...

Activation every 10th day SUUURE, i dont mind it, what annoys me the most, dvd protection, since i dont have a dvd room, i cannot use a dvd in the drive, i install through my laptops dvd room. if i'd get a choice i'd get rid of that one too for extra battery or something, but since i got it from school for free its not much of a choice :p

anywayz, dvd protection, never worked, three times install never worked, and it is actually more simple to download the game, install it, crack it, play it. and faster, about 3 hours for the download.


any1 wud mind online activation or anything like that ? i wudnt, only people who dont buy games wud, anywayz, for that to happen, cut prices in half, make them avaible wiiidely on internet through for instance steam, and not have to have steam open... coop with xfire ? sell games through xfire, whatever, idc. :p

i just wanna play games without crack, and without dvd or cd
 
Copy protection does work, but only against the most casual of game swappers.
Against everyone else, it is useless.

How many sales this will cost them is impossible to say. Not every act of piracy is a lost sale, but some acts of piracy are lost sales.
Again, how many is an impossible number to calculate without anonymously asking every single pirate whether they would have bought it if piracy was not possible, and they all answered honestly. .
 
This is complete and utter bullshit. Its the same reason I didn't buy Bioshock when it first came out.
Haven't these publisher's ever thought that maybe not everyone has several large harddrives to keep everything installed on permanently? Or what about a virus, hard drive failure, or any thing else that prompts a re-install of an operating system? Or how about the fact that I upgrade every few years and the hardware is different, causing the DRM to not allow the install?

I own a substantial game collection, and there are several games that I have re-installed and replayed over the years, especially during the downtime during summer months when few big titles are released.

I actually feel sorry for Will Wright (the creator of the game). He's getting shafted by EA.
 
I have purchased quite a few EA games but due to the copy protection schemes they put on Spore, I will not be purchasing Spore until they fix their DRM measures. If they do not do this then I simply will not purchase the game.
 
Copy protection does work, but only against the most casual of game swappers.
Against everyone else, it is useless.

How many sales this will cost them is impossible to say. Not every act of piracy is a lost sale, but some acts of piracy are lost sales.
Again, how many is an impossible number to calculate without anonymously asking every single pirate whether they would have bought it if piracy was not possible, and they all answered honestly. .

exactly. stopping the most casual of game swappers with cumbersome DRM , is such an extremely insignificant number of pirates; no significant loss in sales there.

DRM is not the answer, the other extreme to fight piracy is isps monitoring traffic. As much as I'd hate the invasion of privacy, it would work.
 
huh? i don't understand what you mean.:confused:

He probably is misspeaking, however in the manual it states you can have an "unlimited" number of accounts online so you can have multiple users names associated to the creatures they create, etc. Then they said "its a typo" you can only have 1 account per CD key. Which in itself isn't bad, but to call it a typo when it so obviously is intended something else is quite silly.
 
It's a good thing BF2 didn't come that way. I had to install it 4 times one night since the patches kept failing, or I would patch it in the wrong order, when installing the SF add-on and the Booster Packs.
 
after here the reviews I have no intention of buying the game, but I can tell you that the first thing I would do to the game after I bought it would be to hack it. And if it was too hard I would download the pirate version just so I didn't have to put up the DRM.

EA needs to pull their head out of their ass.
 
what is even worse is that the pirated copies of the game actually run better because they are not bloated down with this DRM shit. Thanks again EA for punishing the people who pay for your games and letting the pirates have a very valide reason to steasl your shit. I know my money means nothing to EA but I have not and will not buy an EA product until they learn how to treat the people who made them who they are. Fuck off!
 
Honestly I buy my games, when available, on Steam. They have a form of DRM that is acceptable to me. They add value to the fact that you are somewhat limited. Buying discs with DRM only limits your purchase. Only problem is the fact that if we all buy on Steam we will be subjected to way too many "Is PC gaming dead?" articles. But whatever. This came up with a recent Crysis: Warhead purchase and the thought that EA would put the same shit in with Crysis. But lo and behold, a shining beacon. If you already play anything Half-Life you already have Steam crap on your PC. I don't see anymore harm with buying their versions. I may be missing something though.
 
Did it backfire? For me, it certainly did. Spore was going to be the second game I was going to buy this year (The only other one was the Orange Box) but the DRM hassles have turned me off completely on the game. The game looks and sounds fascinating but the DRM issue completely ruins any enjoyment I might have gotten from the game.

I won't pirate it, I'll simply ignore it. There are plenty of other games that are really fun that won't give me any hassles.

It's the same with music btw... I only buy DRM-free music from Amazon (Apple hasn't had the music I want available without DRM) and Apple is simply missing out on my business. I don't pirate (steal) music either, I simply limit my purchases to DRM-free stuff to avoid the DRM hassles. If it has DRM, then they obviously don't want to sell it to me so I save my pennies for hassle-free stuff.
 
He probably is misspeaking, however in the manual it states you can have an "unlimited" number of accounts online so you can have multiple users names associated to the creatures they create, etc. Then they said "its a typo" you can only have 1 account per CD key. Which in itself isn't bad, but to call it a typo when it so obviously is intended something else is quite silly.
oh. ok.... ouch...
. those silly fuckers at EA.
 
Copy protection only harms those who wish to buy it. Anyone who wants to download illegal will do so, and no copy protection in the world is going to stop them.

So if a store charges more for its good because it updated to a state of the art anti-shoplifting security system and the majority of people are still shoplifting is that really a wise investment? I'm not sure on numbers but doesn't copy protection add like $5 to the cost of every game as a "licensed" feature?
 
He probably is misspeaking, however in the manual it states you can have an "unlimited" number of accounts online so you can have multiple users names associated to the creatures they create, etc. Then they said "its a typo" you can only have 1 account per CD key. Which in itself isn't bad, but to call it a typo when it so obviously is intended something else is quite silly.

This, although less misspeaking and more intentionally avoiding going into a tirade on corporate bastards in a news thread. :D
 
I dont have any issues with DRM that stop the people trying to rip off the game.

I have a huge problem with DRM that only serves to punish the paying customer.

I have issues with both :D
DRM is why I haven't bought the game, but I don't want to download it....eh.
 
I wanted SPORE, and so did many of my friends who have been drooling over the videos and demo.
Not one of us will buy it due to EA's crap DRM and install limit (I'd like to see that shit pulled on the Sims, in kids PC's that need a reinstall every 6 months...Now that would be a mob of angry parents waiting to happen....).
I suggest anyone who values their money and expects to be treated like a valued customer avoid EA like the plague till they sort their shit out.
 
If you already play anything Half-Life you already have Steam crap on your PC. I don't see anymore harm with buying their versions. I may be missing something though.

Steam isn't that bad.
I just reinstalled XP on my machine and have about 20 or so games in my Steam Account.
I reinstalled Steam and all my games loaded up fine. They were all still in the Program Files directory.
All of my other games, Bioshock, Blacksite, BF2, 2142, etc... have to be reinstalled again from the DVD's.
 
Steam isn't that bad.
I just reinstalled XP on my machine and have about 20 or so games in my Steam Account.
I reinstalled Steam and all my games loaded up fine. They were all still in the Program Files directory.
All of my other games, Bioshock, Blacksite, BF2, 2142, etc... have to be reinstalled again from the DVD's.

yep, steam is great! At first it felt is was a major inconvenience, but it works, and I like how my games are always up to date. I love being able to format my rig, and logging into steam, and it takes care of the rest.
 
I have a problem with any DRM that installs something OTHER than what I wanted to install on MY system.
 
Friend of mine was talking about how much he liked the game a few days back. Enough that I was interested in buying to see if I liked it. I am not touching it with the current DRM practice.

I'd lose two installs off the bat, desktop, and laptop for when I am traveling. With no intention of playing on both at the same time.

The next upgrade (and I am a frequent upgrade) and/or windows "event" would take care of the third install. And I was looking at some of the new asus main boards closely too.

This is unconscionable business behavior. I agree with the boycott. /sign
 
The only way to get people to stop pirating your games is to give them a reason to buy it. Look at Blizzard, and why they are so successful. All of their games have great online-play. Sure you could pirate the game, but then you'd be missing out on half of it...

Other than that, if people can get the same game for free, they will.
 
I completely agree, EA drm will ultimately fail. The 3~6 limit install makes it impossible to lend it to my cousin without having him or her tell me the games doesn't work and then go through the hassle of calling EA. It almost makes it more troublesome and doesn't open the market to new gamers. Steam, only works because most of their games I buy are multiplayer games I like and still play. They're DRM style are not that different from EA and sometime actually worse, because one game = one account, Not transferable!
 
WTF? I could have sworn I posted in this thread already and it was 4 pages long earlier. Maybe [H] delete for the win? The thread did turn into a spat between adults who know pirating a game is stealing and children who think it is something else. However, maybe next time a more surgical removal is in order.
I wont repost the whole bit. but I will rehash my point. That was I don't buy or steal DRM games. I just don't play them and I don't recommend them to anyone. Oh yea, and BF2142 blows and EA blows.:D
 
Ahh nope it was a different thread.

to answer the thread question. I don't have any clue how many will buy this or if it will backfire for them in the end. For me, yea I'm not buying it and I wont buy anything with DRM like this.
 
Copy protection only harms those who wish to buy it. Anyone who wants to download illegal will do so, and no copy protection in the world is going to stop them.
You would think they would learn this. There has never been a copy protection method that has actually worked. They might as well stop punishing paying customers.
 
Steam is a far more sensible online distribution method than using Install Limited DRM.

As stated above, if I reinstall windows I can simply keep my Steam folder and all my games are reactivated more or less instantly once I reload Steam.

But far more important than that, as long as Steam stays in business they never limit my installs. I can travel half way around the world, sit down at some random computer with internet access, log into Steam and download/play any of the games I own any time. THAT is the sole, Single, ONLY reason I put up with and like Steam. They never, EVER tell me I can't download my game right now and play it.

Everyone else needs to take notes.
 
I have never pirated a game, and I never will.

I will also never buy or play Spore, on principle.

If I pay full price for a game, I expect to be treated as a legitimate licensee, not a potential thief.

Fuck you DRM.
 
I completely agree, EA drm will ultimately fail. The 3~6 limit install makes it impossible to lend it to my cousin without having him or her tell me the games doesn't work and then go through the hassle of calling EA. It almost makes it more troublesome and doesn't open the market to new gamers. Steam, only works because most of their games I buy are multiplayer games I like and still play. They're DRM style are not that different from EA and sometime actually worse, because one game = one account, Not transferable!


That is the behavior they are trying to stop. Not piracy so much as, the giving/selling/trading/lending of used games to others. The stuff that nobody has any moral issue with, but EA/Valve/Id/every publisher has a financial stake in stopping. The pirates, for the most part, really were not going to buy it anyway. A very few might of, but, we can't say how many.

They know that DRM/Copy Protection schemes only dissuades a very, very few people. I guess the Dev/Pubs think that it is worth the cost of the measures, and any lost sales as a result of those measures.

Another thing I would like to point out to the Devs/Pubs out there is this:
Pirates do not complain about DRM on single player games, they don't have to worry about it anyway. Especially since most games are cracked within a week of release, many are cracked the same day as released, and others are even cracked prior to release. The DRM measures only affect the paying customer.
 
Back
Top