US Military Testing Tactical Laser

They have not tested the laser in question in an airplane shooting down a moving object.

They've tested the firing system in the air, and the laser on the ground. Consider that those lasers can only fire once (several seconds, really) before consuming consuming a plane-sized tank of chemical "fuel" and battery power, the practical airborne weapon suggested is at least a decade away.

What's interesting is that they're reintroducing this as a possible weapon against living targets-- that's very telling. The kilowatt range is not the necessary power needed to compromise the high-temperature skin on a ballistic missile, especially if you cannot sustain a tight enough beam on the target. So we've gone from shooting down ballistic missiles to horribly disfiguring a person and probably not even killing them unless they stay put for several seconds.
 
heh.. you need to talk to some soldier's in Iraq that have tested some prototypes of these..
 
I would like to see this employed as crowd control as well as a weapon of war. Reminds me of Akira when the police were using the lasers for crowd control, guy gets hit with it in the arm, and his arm falls off...talk about combat effectiveness, now nil.

yeah, and the 5.56 round...yeah, if I wanted to shot a glorified .22, I would. Oh, wait, I have. Horrible, Horrible, round...too many times have the Army and Marines complained about the effectiveness of the M16/M4, does not stop really anything. Hell, the Armed Services are contemplating bring the .45 handgun back, 9mm isn't effective as it should be.

.50cal is inhumane to shoot someone with, according to whoever, but it is effective as hell.
 
I love the "humane" argument when you're in the middle of war. We can be as humane as we want, but the enemy sure won't. I'd drop that BS as quick as possible, and I'd also drop out of the UN and cut off their US funding. ;)
 
I love the "humane" argument when you're in the middle of war. We can be as humane as we want, but the enemy sure won't.

And that is why LOAC and Geneva Conventions should be thrown out the window...It is only upheld when 2 civilized countries go to war...and if they abide by it.
 
.50cal is inhumane to shoot someone with, according to whoever, but it is effective as hell.

I'd rather be insta-killed than mamed laying and bleeding, waiting to die, but thats just me. :p
 
No kidding... I was over there myself and the most high tech things I came across are ECM for IED detonators and Thermal Cameras. In case you haven't noticed, missile attacks are not the biggest threat out there right now.

Have these lasers actually been tested to shoot missiles down? I'm having a hard time believing it'd work if they can't even melt though to a human's internal organs. How is it going to melt metal?

We (my unit) did stop using the MK19 because of collateral damage. But not due to inhumanity. If things picked back up in Al Anbar, I'm sure the MK19 would come back.
 
I cannot clarify, but there have been several prototypes used in the field for real world testing purposes. My friend who is now back in Falluja on his 2nd tour was telling me about them. He also said they were testing "cloaked" tanks too, but they didn't work so well because of all the dust. :p
 
Here is a cool example. Let s say we had the larger 747 based weapon in the air above Saddam when he was making his speeches in the square some years back and he instantly vaporized. Such an event would have saved many lives. Pin point accuracy with no collateral damage.

As of WWI political assinations are no longer permitted.
 
Yes, and wiping out a couple of hundred thousand of your own people with chemical weapons is not permitted either.

Yet its perfectly fine if these same chemical weapons are being used on Iranians, for some reason which escapes me to this day.
 
Yes, and wiping out a couple of hundred thousand of your own people with chemical weapons is not permitted either.

As Atheist Icon wrote:
And that is why LOAC and Geneva Conventions should be thrown out the window...It is only upheld when 2 civilized countries go to war...and if they abide by it.

So long as we "civilized" countries are bogged down with the politics that "uncivilized" countries arent then your argument just isnt going to hold that much weight. There are two rule books out there in war. The rulebook for "the gentlemen" (yea the suckers bet) and the rulebook for the guy who says "win at any cost, no matter the cost".

I'll let you figure out which one we're using and which one their using in your example and then let you realize the futility in your counter argument against me.


Says who? The ethics handbook?

This is the beauty in this machine, it leaves no fingerprints ;)

Heh yea that shitty lil ethics handbook that would try to get us to fight with rocks and sling shots (if we were lucky) while letting everyone else run around with nuke guns and sharks with lazer beams.

And the fingerprint is the 747 that just so happened to be "coincidently" flying over the assinated target at the time of the assination. Not really that slick, not really that stealthy, and wouoldnt take more than 24hrs for forensics to put 1 and 1 together with how the victim died and whose the only country with the capability to pull it off.

And there is a .50 assualt rifle. It's called the beowulf. Only downside to .50 cal assault rifles is their lack of accuracy at long range. Put close range and med range they do work on anything in the sights. Perfect for urban warfare.
 
I wonder what happens if you put a mirror up to it :p
The problem i see is that it should be fairly easy to block this kind of attack on your missiles with some way of reflecting the light. I mean what happens if i coat the missile with some advanced mirror like surface.......is that it, is the laser beaten?
To properly understand the flaw in that thinking, you must first understand that a "mirror" only reflects a certain frequency bandwidth... e.g. a household mirror reflects visible light. The actual frequency of the lasers being used is probably the most classified specification of the program. Yes, if the actual frequency was known, a reflective surface could be made that is impervious to the laser.
mirrors are not perfectly reflective. they absorb percentage of the light that hits them. Even a small percentage of the capacity of a laser light this will vaporize the mirror very quickly.
Mostly true. Absorption is due primarily to the fact that the reflective surface is not 100% matched to the frequency of the energy being intercepted. Think about it, the generated laser is channeled, focused, and directed within the weapon (or aircraft). If the equipment in the weapon (or aircraft) were to absorb the energy, it would vaporize itself. :p

While I agree with you, yes, there is opposition to the use of soft tip or hollow point bullets by the US Military. It's not just the US though, I believe it's due to NATO standards of humane warfare or something. Current 5.56mm rounds in use actually have hardened tips. Advantage is they do a bit better at piercing *slightly* hardened targets (soft armor). Disadvantage is that they generally go right through flesh without causing as much damage, so it can take more than one shot to kill someone.
Well, if I were serving, I'd certainly want the option that gives ME the best chances of survival. Of course from the receiving end of a bullet, that would be hard-case ammo. From the shooting end, that would be soft-points and a quick drop.

We do use such inefficient warfare. Thousands of soldiers, and thousand of rounds of ammo whizzing through the air. I respect the elite personnel... trained to approach in stealth, target skillfully, and drop with a single round.

No kidding... I was over there myself and the most high tech things I came across are ECM for IED detonators and Thermal Cameras.
Yeah, like the top-secret, classified, prototype testing is going to land in the hands of enlisted personnel with no security clearances... LMFAO!

Have these lasers actually been tested to shoot missiles down? I'm having a hard time believing it'd work if they can't even melt though to a human's internal organs. How is it going to melt metal?
Believe me, I've seen armor plating test targets. These lasers can penetrate the skin of a tank quite easily. Missiles are far less rugged. :p
 
To properly understand the flaw in that thinking, you must first understand that a "mirror" only reflects a certain frequency bandwidth... e.g. a household mirror reflects visible light. The actual frequency of the lasers being used is probably the most classified specification of the program. Yes, if the actual frequency was known, a reflective surface could be made that is impervious to the laser.

On the other hand, measuring the frequency of EM radiation is not exactly a difficult process. This of course requires witnessing the weapon being used though...
 
ummm, yeah... and actually measuring the wavelength without being vaporized as well... :p
 
As long as you aren't measuring it from within the direct line of fire you'd probably be safe.
 
can someone tell me why when i click on the link in your thread it takes me to the same thing on your front page and i have to click yet another link to actually read the article? call me crazy but that's just annoying as heck man....let the link in the forums go to the article and bypass the front page already, everyone here knows they could just go to the front page directly to get to it, we dont need to be forced do we? or does it have to do with generating page hits and loading ads on another page before you actually get to read the article?
I thought I was crazy for a while.. thanks for the sanity.
 
Iraq is a testing ground for these things. Nothing like having a real world testing, great opportunity.

As I understand it, when you field test it you are testing it's suitability for the battlefield environment, not the efficacy of the weapon. Only a laboratory or highly controlled scenario can produce the measurable results required.

For example, if they are testing armor-piercing shells, they'll probably fire them from a real gun/cannon, but they will be x-raying or slicing the penetrated test material to see the results.

I suppose they could be videotaping or dragging back the severed limbs for analysis, or perhaps interviewing the armless/legless militants to describe the experience.
 
To properly understand the flaw in that thinking, you must first understand that a "mirror" only reflects a certain frequency bandwidth... e.g. a household mirror reflects visible light. The actual frequency of the lasers being used is probably the most classified specification of the program. Yes, if the actual frequency was known, a reflective surface could be made that is impervious to the laser.
...
Mostly true. Absorption is due primarily to the fact that the reflective surface is not 100% matched to the frequency of the energy being intercepted. Think about it, the generated laser is channeled, focused, and directed within the weapon (or aircraft). If the equipment in the weapon (or aircraft) were to absorb the energy, it would vaporize itself. :p
...
Believe me, I've seen armor plating test targets. These lasers can penetrate the skin of a tank quite easily. Missiles are far less rugged. :p

Very interesting post, btw, wjogert.

I'm confused about the last part. A tank has many layers of steel / composite and has high thermal conductivity from any given point (partly because of its thickness) - this is on purpose because the tank-killing shells rely on melting through the armor to work. Moveover, the metal has to melt away / evaporate (or evaporate) to expose the layer underneath it, which takes time and that waste stuff disrupts the beam. So, the laser must sustain its energy on one fine point for a good period of time to really penetrate.

In the case of a regular missile, it's probably just thin aluminum, so that's like butter to a laser. But a ballistic missile deals with reentry and probably has a carbon-carbon shell (not unlike KITT) and I'd think that it would be very difficult for a laser to deal with, even if it could sustain the beam on target.

You obviously have a good understanding of this, I'm curious what you think of these apples, sir.
 
Say they invent an ablative armor that boils to a fine reflective chaff and scatters the laser?

(actualy, didn't they have that in Mass Effect?)
 
I'm confused about the last part. A tank has many layers of steel / composite and has high thermal conductivity from any given point (partly because of its thickness) - this is on purpose because the tank-killing shells rely on melting through the armor to work. Moveover, the metal has to melt away / evaporate (or evaporate) to expose the layer underneath it, which takes time and that waste stuff disrupts the beam. So, the laser must sustain its energy on one fine point for a good period of time to really penetrate.

You obviously have a good understanding of this, I'm curious what you think of these apples, sir.
My job involvement with these programs is limited to the optical aspect. I have almost no knowledge of the mechanical attributes of tank plating. :p

While visiting a classified facility to field service one of our systems, the engineers in charge showed me a series of metal plates with various sized holes melted through them. The holes were fairly clean edged, with small run-off trickles from the lower corners. Each plate was marked with a beam power-rating and duration of test fire. All I can say is that, I was told the plates were actual military tank armor, most of the holes went clean through, and firing durations were all significantly less than one minute... ;)
 
Say they invent an ablative armor that boils to a fine reflective chaff and scatters the laser?

(actualy, didn't they have that in Mass Effect?)
Consider this. A majority of high-power laser systems are run in a purged environment... that is, the air has been evacuated and replaced with a pure inert gas. This is to prevent any contaminants in the system, because just a single particle of dust can transfer enough energy for the laser to burn through a primary optic.

Therefore, it stands to reason that your "reflective chaff" would still vaporize unless it was (as stated before) matched to the wavelength of the laser.

Besides, at that power, scattering the laser could be catastrophic... just a percentage of the overall power would still be enough to cause serious damages to unintended targets.
 
I love it when people who to have security clearances talk openly about classified stuff on the internet and put thier security clearance and by extension thier job and future jobs at risk.
 
LOL, if you're talking about me (and I believe you are), I am very careful about what I say and don't say.

Most of what I share here can be found on the internet, in public domain, if you know where to look.
 
LOL, if you're talking about me (and I believe you are), I am very careful about what I say and don't say.

Most of what I share here can be found on the internet, in public domain, if you know where to look.

Perhaps that would be the results after an investigation is completed, but those of us "in the know" realize that even if an investigation reveals no impropriety, the fact that someone was investigated at all throws up red flags.

/mission impossible theme music
 
I say this is far more awesome... vids and all

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/Zcs0d0pDeQA&hl=en&fs=1"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/Zcs0d0pDeQA&hl=en&fs=1" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>
 
Say they invent an ablative armor that boils to a fine reflective chaff and scatters the laser?

(actualy, didn't they have that in Mass Effect?)

While you may have armor that can boil, keep in mind, you have munitions and people inside the thing. You also have other components like tracks and wheels that can be taken out, which renders a tank useless and a sitting duck.
 
LOL, if you're talking about me (and I believe you are), I am very careful about what I say and don't say.

Most of what I share here can be found on the internet, in public domain, if you know where to look.

wjogert said:
While visiting a classified facility to field service one of our systems, the engineers in charge showed me a series of metal plates with various sized holes melted through them.

If the above tests are not classified, which they would be because the goverment classifies way more crap than is necessary, then your intentionally misleading people by saying "while visiting a classified facility".

Your just trying to wish yourself into being more than you are, while at the same time trying to claim to be one of the elite "in-the-know". I get tired of reading it, and so I'm calling you on it. Feel free to backpeddle now and explain how this is not classified, yet you felt the need to imply that it was.
 
Vengence, don't get mad if people have been places you haven't. If anything, just ignore it. You don't have to believe anything you read on the internet.
 
If the above tests are not classified, which they would be because the goverment classifies way more crap than is necessary, then your intentionally misleading people by saying "while visiting a classified facility".

Your just trying to wish yourself into being more than you are, while at the same time trying to claim to be one of the elite "in-the-know". I get tired of reading it, and so I'm calling you on it. Feel free to backpeddle now and explain how this is not classified, yet you felt the need to imply that it was.

Metal plates with holes hardly sounds like to me like a millitary classification. While it may be a classified facility or not, there is nothing wrong with what he said... he might as well have said "the scientists at the facility loves wearing green crock sandals.

Now if he said, the holes were through x mm plate made of xxxx materials and the holes took xxx seconds to appear using an xxx laser, I can see the issue.

But holes in plates, isn't that expected?
 


LMAO It's an infomercial of death and destruction. I kept expecting to see the starship troopers logo.

Wiretap, I think your full of shit. I could be wrong. I doubt it. I know if I was your CO you'd be cleaning shitters with your toothbrush...In Alaska. Somehow I don't think a blow hard braggart like yourself would be entrusted with anything even remotely sensitive.
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/braggarts
brag·gart (brgrt)
n.
One given to loud, empty boasting; a bragger.
adj.
Boastful.
 
Metal plates with holes hardly sounds like to me like a millitary classification. While it may be a classified facility or not, there is nothing wrong with what he said... he might as well have said "the scientists at the facility loves wearing green crock sandals.

Now if he said, the holes were through x mm plate made of xxxx materials and the holes took xxx seconds to appear using an xxx laser, I can see the issue.

But holes in plates, isn't that expected?

Yes, it is to be expected lasers will make holes in plates. However, that doesn't mean it isn't classified.

Projects get classified, not individual measurements. Simply saying he saw a hole in a metal plate would be more than he could say. But obiviously since he's saying it, he either 1) doesn't value his job much or 2) is lying.
 
Ockie... EXACTLY!!
(btw, they were more the jeans & sneakers type) :p

I've never claimed to be amongst the elite. What knowledge I have of the programs I work on, hundreds of fellow employees have knowledge of also. I try to share bits of information that many here would not be privy to.

I do however claim to be fortunate enough to have visited many interesting locations, for field service... some classified, some not (ok most are, lol)...
That is my exceptional experience, as these are locations that many of my higher paid and "superior" peers have never set foot in... and never will. My involvement is something I take pride in.

If you think I'm full-o-shens, don't read my posts. It won't hurt my feelings.
I will continue to offer up informative tid-bits in these threads, for anyone who IS interested.
 
So WHEN can this be mounted and amplified to be on an indestructible space station that looks like a moon?
 
Back
Top