US Military Testing Tactical Laser

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
US Special Forces are test firing the Advanced Tactical Laser (ATL), according to this blog. The ATL is not the Star Wars-esque blaster that your favorite stormtroopers use to blast walls (since they always seem to miss their actual target). The article likens the laser to a “long range blow torch.” Less boo hoo, more pew pew? :D

With this type of weapon, the effects are more like napalm than bullets. Humanitarian protests are likely. And one accidental lasering of a civilian could be enough to prevent the ATL being used as an anti-personnel weapon.
 
Hambling does realize that the both the ATL and ABL were designed to shoot-down missiles, right? You know, the OTHER Star Wars...
 
I'm still trying to understand the logic behind a potential protest.
Are there groups that protest bullets? Wait a sec. There IS an actual ban on expanding bullets for use by the military. That makes no sense at all. Why be forced to shoot the enemy with a bullet that is less effective at killing them??? In most if not all states it's illegal to use a solid bullet for deer hunting because it's not effective at humanely killing a deer or any other animal.
An anti-personnel laser may be more effective at toasting a potential threat than a tiny non expanding projectile.
 
can someone tell me why when i click on the link in your thread it takes me to the same thing on your front page and i have to click yet another link to actually read the article? call me crazy but that's just annoying as heck man....let the link in the forums go to the article and bypass the front page already, everyone here knows they could just go to the front page directly to get to it, we dont need to be forced do we? or does it have to do with generating page hits and loading ads on another page before you actually get to read the article?
 
can someone tell me why when i click on the link in your thread it takes me to the same thing on your front page and i have to click yet another link to actually read the article? call me crazy but that's just annoying as heck man

I mentioned it once and all i got back from the admins was....."thats the way it is" lol :(

On topic : How often is this laser going to be affective......i mean if the target is in a building/cave/house/etc whatever, then its not going to penetrate through the walls. I wonder what happens if you put a mirror up to it :p
 
can someone tell me why when i click on the link in your thread it takes me to the same thing on your front page and i have to click yet another link to actually read the article? call me crazy but that's just annoying as heck man....let the link in the forums go to the article and bypass the front page already, everyone here knows they could just go to the front page directly to get to it, we dont need to be forced do we? or does it have to do with generating page hits and loading ads on another page before you actually get to read the article?

Yeah it's probably about page hits and ads. No other reason to do it. I suspect they feel they'd lose too many page views if they allowed people to go directly from the thread to the article.
 
Accidental lasering of a civilian in testing=grounds for concern.
Accidental lasering in a real world operation="shit happens".
 
I'm still trying to understand the logic behind a potential protest.
Are there groups that protest bullets? Wait a sec. There IS an actual ban on expanding bullets for use by the military. That makes no sense at all. Why be forced to shoot the enemy with a bullet that is less effective at killing them??? In most if not all states it's illegal to use a solid bullet for deer hunting because it's not effective at humanely killing a deer or any other animal.
An anti-personnel laser may be more effective at toasting a potential threat than a tiny non expanding projectile.

While I agree with you, yes, there is opposition to the use of soft tip or hollow point bullets by the US Military. It's not just the US though, I believe it's due to NATO standards of humane warfare or something. Current 5.56mm rounds in use actually have hardened tips. Advantage is they do a bit better at piercing *slightly* hardened targets (soft armor). Disadvantage is that they generally go right through flesh without causing as much damage, so it can take more than one shot to kill someone.
 
I'm still trying to understand the logic behind a potential protest.
Are there groups that protest bullets? Wait a sec. There IS an actual ban on expanding bullets for use by the military. That makes no sense at all. Why be forced to shoot the enemy with a bullet that is less effective at killing them??? In most if not all states it's illegal to use a solid bullet for deer hunting because it's not effective at humanely killing a deer or any other animal.
An anti-personnel laser may be more effective at toasting a potential threat than a tiny non expanding projectile.


This would be because a large portion of the world's population does not get their rocks off destroying human life.

It is not necessary to kill someone to render them incapable of fighting. Hard-tip non-expanding bullets may go in one end and out the other without causing a lot of damage, but they still transfer energy to knock you down and inflict severe pain, to the point of draining your will to continue fighting.

By the same token, melting/burning a hole through someone is far, far beyond what is necessary to remove them as a tactical threat.
 
however, vaporizing one could greatly diminish the will to fight of the others. i mean if you dont have much exposure to scifi materials, it would be some crazy shit.
 
This would be because a large portion of the world's population does not get their rocks off destroying human life.

It is not necessary to kill someone to render them incapable of fighting. Hard-tip non-expanding bullets may go in one end and out the other without causing a lot of damage, but they still transfer energy to knock you down and inflict severe pain, to the point of draining your will to continue fighting.

By the same token, melting/burning a hole through someone is far, far beyond what is necessary to remove them as a tactical threat.
In Vietnam US soldiers were using M16 A1 assault rifles against Charlie in the jungle. We would unload tons of rounds at them and the scenario you mentioned about going right in and right out played out exactly to their advantage. They could still keep coming at you and still be shooting. I would prefer to be able to guarantee that the guys shooting at me will go down...afterall the most preferred outcome in a combat situation is for you to stop your enemy and for you to live to fight another day right? Otherwise what reason would your enemy have to stop fighting with you?
 
however, vaporizing one could greatly diminish the will to fight of the others. i mean if you dont have much exposure to scifi materials, it would be some crazy shit.
You are very right. This technology would literally be one of those things that would work as a deterrent. Problem is though that the UN would probably try to pass some kind of bullshit resolution of some kind to demonize the use of such a weapon by the US claiming that it gives an unfair advantage to the US. Crazy world we live in isn't it? If China were to have this tech the UN would probably give them a pass.
 
LOL, are we really arguing about humane bullets? Care to guess what a mortar round detonated within ten feet of enemy personnel will do? Or perhaps what what will happen to a human when hit by a FMJ .50cal round.:eek: Keep in mine that the USA is the only country to ever attack civilians with an atomic bomb. The Vietnam argument is only a testament to how bad the M16 A-1 really was. Moreover, the large failure of the NATO 5.56mm round in general. There has to be some middle ground between accuracy and stopping power. .30cal is where it is at. The round it self is capable of high accuracy. It wont ever be like shooting a glorified .22 but at least it will stop the enemy. Recently, some military personnel where under investigation for a high number of head shots leading some to believe that there was more going on than just killing enemy combatants (Execution). The truth is the gun is accurate enough to aim for the head and that the only guaranteed way to stop someone with one hit from the current generation of .223cal weaponry.
 
The requirement for fullmetaljacket is part of the Geneva Conventions on Warfare. Using hollowpoint or mercury filled, etc is considered inhumane.

If you want more stopping power you use a bugger bullet. Tha AK uses a 7.62, while the M16 uses a 5.66. The best compromice in stopping power and ammo weight, clip size, etc seems to be 6.80. I'd love an LWRC with a 20" barrel and some futuristic optics for all-condition scopage. But I think a hydraulic version, without the long rod would be a better design.

I would prefer 10.00mm aka a 50 cal. No reason we cant make a 50 cal assault rifle, with a smaller version of the 50 round.

Meantime, the laser is a gimmick, won't be practical for many years, but by all means research the shit out of it. Use it on the Taliban/AQ and anyone stupid enough to end up in the xhairs gets fried, end of story.

Cool adaptation would be a mobile base station combined with a "phase congegate tracking mirror" mounted on a Predator so the laser could see over the horizon and give serious continous firepower to the Predator :eek::rolleyes::p

It'd be like frying little AQ Ants with a magnifying glass :cool:


DIE HAJJI DIE !!!!!!
 
The requirement for fullmetaljacket is part of the Geneva Conventions on Warfare. Using hollowpoint or mercury filled, etc is considered inhumane.

If you want more stopping power you use a bugger bullet. Tha AK uses a 7.62, while the M16 uses a 5.66. The best compromice in stopping power and ammo weight, clip size, etc seems to be 6.80. I'd love an LWRC with a 20" barrel and some futuristic optics for all-condition scopage. But I think a hydraulic version, without the long rod would be a better design.

I would prefer 10.00mm aka a 50 cal. No reason we cant make a 50 cal assault rifle, with a smaller version of the 50 round.

Meantime, the laser is a gimmick, won't be practical for many years, but by all means research the shit out of it. Use it on the Taliban/AQ and anyone stupid enough to end up in the xhairs gets fried, end of story.

Cool adaptation would be a mobile base station combined with a "phase congegate tracking mirror" mounted on a Predator so the laser could see over the horizon and give serious continous firepower to the Predator :eek::rolleyes::p

It'd be like frying little AQ Ants with a magnifying glass :cool:


DIE HAJJI DIE !!!!!!

We have modified rifles that shoot the 7.62
 
This would be because a large portion of the world's population does not get their rocks off destroying human life.

It is not necessary to kill someone to render them incapable of fighting. Hard-tip non-expanding bullets may go in one end and out the other without causing a lot of damage, but they still transfer energy to knock you down and inflict severe pain, to the point of draining your will to continue fighting.

By the same token, melting/burning a hole through someone is far, far beyond what is necessary to remove them as a tactical threat.

It has nothing to do with "get their rocks off destroying human life".

Now if you really want to get down to the nitty gritty though you are sort of correct. Ideally you would want to maim your opponent as YOU have said because when you maim someone it takes more than one person to care for the person, more than one person to move them, and requires significantly more logistical support/time than a dead body. All of these things take the person maimed out of combat AND takes out the people who have to cares/support/move them out of combat and uses up the enemies supplies faster (and slows them down) thereby reducing their ability to fight effectively and giving you a tactical advantage.

So while YOU think its about "getting their rocks off" it isn't, but the "large portion of the world's population" that thinks "neutralizing" (the always politically correct way of saying maim) them rather than killing them is better that YOU are representing is arguably a much more sadistic lot.
 
The requirement for fullmetaljacket is part of the Geneva Conventions on Warfare. Using hollowpoint or mercury filled, etc is considered inhumane.

Find the exact clause that disqualifies hollowpoint bullets in the Geneva Conventions. Seriously.














Because it isn't there. The actual clause you are looking for is in the St. Petersburg Declaration which the US is not actual apart to. NATO adheres to the clause in The Hague Convention of 1899 that restated it mostly but not for aircrews. And no its not covered by the misintrepreted maiming clause.
 
With the AC-130 employing 105MM Howitzers from the air, I don't see the point in this laser.

Because the ABL is designed to shoot-down MISSILES from long range, not to take down buildings and tanks and harry infantry. Lasers are basically the next generation of the current missile defense system that uses other missiles to destroy incoming missiles. Lasers are extremely effective at this because the laser itself travels at the speed of light and these lasers are powerful enough to detonate the explosive within the warhead or to just melt the damned thing if it's purely kinetic.

The AirBorne Laser is a very long range (~400 miles as I recall) platform meant to safeguard against long-range missile attacks (for example, if someone launched a nuclear warhead at the US, the theory is that we should have an ABL in the air somewhere that can take it down). The ATL has a much shorter range and is meant to safeguard bases and etc... from cruise missile attacks and the like.

For example, US naval vessels- such as the Aegis Cruiser- currently utilize missile defense systems that deploy missiles to destroy other missiles. Lasers will, eventually, assume that vital role.
 
Lasers are extremely effective at this because the laser itself travels at the speed of light and these lasers are powerful enough to detonate the explosive within the warhead or to just melt the damned thing if it's purely kinetic.

The problem i see is that it should be fairly easy to block this kind of attack on your missiles with some way of reflecting the light. I mean what happens if i coat the missile with some advanced mirror like surface.......is that it, is the laser beaten?
 
You should check out the new "SAW", they had it on future weapons the other day, MG-48 or something, basically a SAW but with 7.62
 
It has nothing to do with "get their rocks off destroying human life".

Now if you really want to get down to the nitty gritty though you are sort of correct. Ideally you would want to maim your opponent as YOU have said because when you maim someone it takes more than one person to care for the person, more than one person to move them, and requires significantly more logistical support/time than a dead body. All of these things take the person maimed out of combat AND takes out the people who have to cares/support/move them out of combat and uses up the enemies supplies faster (and slows them down) thereby reducing their ability to fight effectively and giving you a tactical advantage.

So while YOU think its about "getting their rocks off" it isn't, but the "large portion of the world's population" that thinks "neutralizing" (the always politically correct way of saying maim) them rather than killing them is better that YOU are representing is arguably a much more sadistic lot.
That is true when you are fighting against an army. Terrorists do not give two shits about other terrorists. They do not care for the fallen, after all they died fighting in the name of Allah. The last thing they would want is for someone to come over and shovel up their remains just so that they can survive and not get their 72 virgins.
 
While I agree with you, yes, there is opposition to the use of soft tip or hollow point bullets by the US Military. It's not just the US though, I believe it's due to NATO standards of humane warfare or something. Current 5.56mm rounds in use actually have hardened tips. Advantage is they do a bit better at piercing *slightly* hardened targets (soft armor). Disadvantage is that they generally go right through flesh without causing as much damage, so it can take more than one shot to kill someone.

Heh, anyone find the irony in "humane" warfare.

This would be because a large portion of the world's population does not get their rocks off destroying human life.

It is not necessary to kill someone to render them incapable of fighting. Hard-tip non-expanding bullets may go in one end and out the other without causing a lot of damage, but they still transfer energy to knock you down and inflict severe pain, to the point of draining your will to continue fighting.

By the same token, melting/burning a hole through someone is far, far beyond what is necessary to remove them as a tactical threat.

Injuries works only on structured millitaries with taxpayers backing them. Injuries consumes transport, hospitals, soldiers, you name it, a lot of effort is used to save a life. On the other hand, rouge nations and even groups, they don't care to heal those they fight with, to some, it's an honor to die.

Saddams son was shot how many times again? And he continued to be a threat and got even worse until we sent him a little JDAM package.

Take Osama for instance, he was injured, do you think he's off on a peace mission now because he was "deterred"?

In Vietnam US soldiers were using M16 A1 assault rifles against Charlie in the jungle. We would unload tons of rounds at them and the scenario you mentioned about going right in and right out played out exactly to their advantage. They could still keep coming at you and still be shooting. I would prefer to be able to guarantee that the guys shooting at me will go down...afterall the most preferred outcome in a combat situation is for you to stop your enemy and for you to live to fight another day right? Otherwise what reason would your enemy have to stop fighting with you?

Yep, when you deal with such an army that really could care less about thier own, the single little pinholes does nothing for you except give you another chance at encountering the person again.

With the AC-130 employing 105MM Howitzers from the air, I don't see the point in this laser.

I have yet to see a howitzer shoot down a missile, let me know when one does. Also, a C130 isn't something I could consider covert when breaching airspace, a 747 isn't covert either, but will blend in. Also, no fingerprints will be left behind (aka shells) that could point it to the nation making the aggression.
 
The problem i see is that it should be fairly easy to block this kind of attack on your missiles with some way of reflecting the light. I mean what happens if i coat the missile with some advanced mirror like surface.......is that it, is the laser beaten?

mirrors are not perfectly reflective. they absorb percentage of the light that hits them.

even a small percentage of the capacity of a laser light this will vaporize the mirror very quickly.
 
That is true when you are fighting against an army. Terrorists do not give two shits about other terrorists. They do not care for the fallen, after all they died fighting in the name of Allah. The last thing they would want is for someone to come over and shovel up their remains just so that they can survive and not get their 72 virgins.

I always thought we were supposed to be better than the terrorists, and not stoop to their level.

The word terrorist is thrown around far too often these days. Hell in the 80s we were helping these "freedom fighters". It was clear during the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan, the Ba'ath military coupe against the Qassim government, and the Iraqi invasion of Iran, that one does not win, in the middle east, an urban guerrilla war.

Why we continue to make the same mistakes over and over again is beyond me. Perhaps thuggish cold war foreign policy, in which the enemy of my enemy of my friend, is not the correct approach to take. Oh well more meat for the grinder.
 
I think I saw a similar anti-personel device demonstrated on the Military Channel's "Weaponology." It was a large invisible laser which basically amounted to intense focused heat.

It didn't seem like anything amazing.. it was invisible afterall, but it didn't cause their clothes to smoke or their skin to redden. Just looked like extreme discomfort and results in the subject jumping out of the target area. I'd wager with some refinements, it can be made into something much worse, perhaps lethal with prolonged exposure.
 
I think I saw a similar anti-personel device demonstrated on the Military Channel's "Weaponology." It was a large invisible laser which basically amounted to intense focused heat.

It didn't seem like anything amazing.. it was invisible afterall, but it didn't cause their clothes to smoke or their skin to redden. Just looked like extreme discomfort and results in the subject jumping out of the target area. I'd wager with some refinements, it can be made into something much worse, perhaps lethal with prolonged exposure.

Different laser- its purpose is primarily crowd control.
 
If you want more stopping power you use a bugger bullet. Tha AK uses a 7.62, while the M16 uses a 5.66. The best compromice in stopping power and ammo weight, clip size, etc seems to be 6.80. I'd love an LWRC with a 20" barrel and some futuristic optics for all-condition scopage. But I think a hydraulic version, without the long rod would be a better design.

Stopping power has more to do with the energy of the projectile, than the caliber. This is why a rifle round in a similar caliber to a pistol round is going to pack a lot bigger punch. You can get away with a far smaller round with all the extra power behind it. Especially in an automatic configuration where you will be firing multiple rounds to drop the opponent. Oh, and the M16 uses a 5.56 NATO round, though I'm assuming you just had a typo.

I would prefer 10.00mm aka a 50 cal. No reason we cant make a 50 cal assault rifle, with a smaller version of the 50 round.

10mm rounds are approximately the same size as a .40 S&W cartridge, not a .50. Remember, caliber is the bullet diameter in decimal portions of an inch. In addition, the reason .50 is restricted to heavier guns is because of the large round. If the round is shrunk, then it loses much of its effectiveness. The biggest advantage of .50 rounds are their high power, making them equally effective against personnel and light vehicles. A 50 caliber assault rifle would either be ridiculously ineffective, or too unwieldy to use. I'm surprised you would even suggest such a thing.
 
I thought the whole reason for the use being the 5.56 was specifically because it wounds more than kills, and a wounded soldier costs 3x as many resources to deal with than a dead one (or something along those lines). Of course this is for a strictly conventional war, and not the "new war".
 
10mm rounds are approximately the same size as a .40 S&W cartridge, not a .50. Remember, caliber is the bullet diameter in decimal portions of an inch. In addition, the reason .50 is restricted to heavier guns is because of the large round. If the round is shrunk, then it loses much of its effectiveness. The biggest advantage of .50 rounds are their high power, making them equally effective against personnel and light vehicles. A 50 caliber assault rifle would either be ridiculously ineffective, or too unwieldy to use. I'm surprised you would even suggest such a thing.

10mm rounds have much more powder behind them than 40.'s. Equal in diameter, yes, but not in length.
 
I thought the whole reason for the use being the 5.56 was specifically because it wounds more than kills, and a wounded soldier costs 3x as many resources to deal with than a dead one (or something along those lines). Of course this is for a strictly conventional war, and not the "new war".

"New war"? Wtf was Vietnam!?
 
Back
Top