Industry Rethinks Moneymaking Software Practice

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Is this the beginning of the end for bloatware? We can only hope so. We have been outspoken critics of bloatware for years and companies like Dell went to great lengths to remove unwanted software from its line of PCs a few years back but it seems the rest of the industry is just now catching up.

But Best Buy, the nation’s largest electronics retailer, tells computer buyers that the preinstalled software, also known as bloatware, can clutter their machines and slow them down. You’d be surprised how often consumers tell us to get rid of it,” said Robert Stephens, the head of Geek Squad, the technical support division of Best Buy that removes the software. He declined to say how many people were paying for the service, but said that “it’s going to increase in popularity.”
 
I remember that being the reason I used to recommend Dell back like 10 years ago! They didn't come with all that bloatware. In fact, they pretty much came with NOTHING on them! For me it was great.

But the general public (noobs :)) they looked at the empty desktop & where like "What can I do with this computer?" So Dell started adding crap to match what their friend's fancy HP's, etc. could do.

And the pendulum swong the other way too far. Maybe it can balance out in the middle now.... just right.

IE: Put the following as OPTIONS:
Office, DVD burning software, Virus scanner, Spyware scanner, decent photo editing software, Back up software, all with at least 1 year versions, if not 3 year nag-free (don't nag you to upgrade to better) versions to cover the life of the PC. Where you can also opt. out and have the software NOT installed.
 
I like HP's new idea: set the IE (or Firefox, whatever the future holds :p) homepage to a part of the manufacturer's site with links to all the software (trials of course). You can download what you want, or just ignore it and change your homepage if you don't want any of it. That model will force the consumer to at least once (the first time they visit the web) look at the choices and decide for themselves, after which they can just ignore it/change it.
 
Now if everyone would start including real Windows install disks with the PCs we'd be all set.
 
But the general public (noobs :)) they looked at the empty desktop & where like "What can I do with this computer?" So Dell started adding crap to match what their friend's fancy HP's, etc. could do.

Nope, they did it to subsidize the constant undercutting of prices that PC manufacturers do.

As to BB doing this, good. Bloatware may subsidize PCs but it makes for a very poor customer experience when their machine comes loaded with crap that makes the machines run significantly slower than a clean Vista installation. What I see with new Mac owners (the ones who have only bought pre-built PCs in the past) is how blown away they are by how fast and clean their new machines are. Just fire it up for the first time, enter their email info, and they're up and running with nothing but the software they need to get started (email, browser, iLife). Having the same thing happen with new Vista installations in HP boxes, etc, will only be a very positive thing for them from a customer experience standpoint, especially now that Vista comes with pretty much everything you need OTTB.

I just wonder what the impact will be on PC manufacturer bottom lines. The end result will either be an increase in wholesale prices or lower profit margins. I lean towards trimming profit margins being more likely to happen, but we'll see.
 
And the cynical part of me thinks Best Buy should keep their mouth shut and put down "remove bloatware & clean install OS" as a specific service from Geek Squad, then promote the hell out of it. >:)
 
I remember that being the reason I used to recommend Dell back like 10 years ago!

They also had the best customer service at that time. I got my sister into a Dell in 98 (I build my own PCs but I have no time for family tech support) and I was really blown away by how great their support was. The company has fallen quite a ways ever since, as far as I can tell.
 
They also had the best customer service at that time. I got my sister into a Dell in 98 (I build my own PCs but I have no time for family tech support) and I was really blown away by how great their support was. The company has fallen quite a ways ever since, as far as I can tell.

I agree. I purchased a Dell (something) for my mother last year and spent 20 mins. in add/remove deleting all of the garbage they installed. Cleaned up the rest of the "bits" using a registry cleaner. Thing runs great now.

I suppose all that bloatware keeps costs down but it's a shame that we've come to that.
 
HAHAHAHA

Best Buy makes money when bloackware is installed

+

they make money when people get them to take it off

+ ?

=

Profit
 
But Best Buy, the nation’s largest electronics retailer, tells computer buyers that the preinstalled software, also known as bloatware, can clutter their machines and slow them down. You’d be surprised how often consumers tell us to get rid of it,” said Robert Stephens, the head of Geek Squad, the technical support division of Best Buy that removes the software. He declined to say how many people were paying for the service, but said that “it’s going to increase in popularity.”
haha.lol

I can believe it when i've seen them dupe customers:

1) "Your computer won't work until the software removal service is done. No, that's not something you can do yourself"

and

2) "The only (sale) computers we have available include the software service. Do you want the sale computer or the one that costs $200 more?"
 
I think bestbuy used to include a bunch of bloatware in it's own clone of the operating systems and charge fee's to remove those shortcuts and 'optimize' the pc. I was there when one of my relatives bought a machine from them about 5-6 years ago, and I told them they didn't need the optimizations or bloatware removal and would like to be on our way. Confused, he went back and talked to the guys that were about to do the startup tests on the machine and came back saying that they would either have to charge the optimization fee or remove our bestbuy warranty if the pc doesn't startup when we get home because there was no way to do the startup test without running their optimization tools. Instead of hassling with morons they simply paid the fee.
 
haha.lol

I can believe it when i've seen them dupe customers:

1) "Your computer won't work until the software removal service is done. No, that's not something you can do yourself"

and

2) "The only (sale) computers we have available include the software service. Do you want the sale computer or the one that costs $200 more?"

Its sickening but it is the only real way these companies can make money on PCs that are so heavily discounted.

Looking at Dell's earnings disappointment makes it all even more clear. These companies are skating on thin ice as far as profit margins go. Cheap computers only really work when subsidized by bloatware. The only way it can work without that stuff is with more expensive lines (aka - computers properly priced to cover labor, materials, support, and operations) like the XPS series, or charging a "removal fee", aka "this is what we lose in subsidized revenue if we sell computers without this pre-installed crap, and oh yeah, and thanks for your cash".
 
I worked for Best Buy for 3 years from 2003-2006. I eventually left after finishing college, and was happy to do so as the awesome tech service we provided became maligned by the greed of the geek squad.

We charged people $30 for a "tune-up" of their pc when they purchased it. We would remove all the crap software, or at least disable it from start up and clean up the desk top. Then we would run windows updates and a quick registry clean. It was kinda crucial during the worm craze of 2003, but after that I dunno.

I was always more then happy to get rid of those norton and mcafee installs. Once Norton Internet Security goes in, it doesn't come back out.
 
On that note, we never made any money on 90% of the machines in the store laptop or desktop. The only ones that were profitable were the bleeding edge machines that we just got in stock. We made all of our money off accessories like surge protectors and service plans. It is ridiculous that the profit margins are so razor thin on pc's.
We would actually be better off not selling a "3 box special" (PC, Monitor, Printer only) as we would usually end up losing money if it was one of the ones on special that week.
 
I was always more then happy to get rid of those norton and mcafee installs. Once Norton Internet Security goes in, it doesn't come back out.

Not true. I used the norton uninstaller that can be found from their website (after some searching) and it did a pretty good job of uninstalling the crapware norton comes with.

But...there is only one real good set of norton software packages, it's the corporate versions which you just can't 'buy' if your a normal consumer.
 
haha.lol

I can believe it when i've seen them dupe customers:

1) "Your computer won't work until the software removal service is done. No, that's not something you can do yourself"

and

2) "The only (sale) computers we have available include the software service. Do you want the sale computer or the one that costs $200 more?"



1) Sounds like a shady sales person that isn't representative of most other employees.

2) More like $129.. and if they still want the computer but not the crap removal and av softare, it actually gets zeroed out at the register so they get it for free. :)
 
I was happily surprised by my latest computer purchase at best buy for my parents. I picked up a $500 dell desktop and set it up for my parents. Once Vista came up, I noticed that the only things that were there (besides what comes with Vista) was: Norton Internet Security Suite, Microsoft Works and Roxio DVD/CD burning suite. Of course, I ended up adding some more software for them: Firefox 3.0 and Thunderbird 2.0.
 
Back
Top