Studios Want Interoperable DRM

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This article claims that studio executives are pushing for interoperability among digital rights management schemes. Well, if the big studios want a universal solution that works on all devices…why don't they simply ditch DRM altogether?

According to Michael Arrington, the plan calls for "a set of policy decisions and a software and services framework that will allow interoperability of various formats and DRM schemes that are currently splintering the market."
 
I would tell the studios; "Hey, just don't waste your money on DRM cause it ain't working". But they wouldn't listen. DRM on music does not even stop the casual thief these days.
I can't be sure how much they a wasting on DRM but, I bet a whole lot of music/movies have to be bought to pay for it.

That said, one inter operable DRM scheme for the different download services, hard media, OS's, and players would be much better than the current situation.
 
They don't want to ditch DRM because they are just like everybody else in the world, who feel that a false sense of security is better than not feeling secure at all, regardless of the cost. :D
 
Yeah right, unified DRM will never work out. The second any of them actually believe they can MAKE the consumer behave the way they want, they all start getting greed fueled dreams of verticly integrating their DRM into a whole product line they cram down the consumer's throat. Then, of course, they blame piracy and insufficient DRM when it fails. The net result is that they usually walk away from their DRM and leave the customer hanging. The customer who DIDN'T have a clue about circumventing DRM, now must become more educated on the subject or be ripped off.
 
I really wonder how much piracy is actually prevented by DRM. Sure, it prevents (only very) casual copying, e.g. Joe Sixpack sticking a DVD in the drive, a DVD-R in another drive, and hitting "copy". It used to be that such copying (like mix tapes) constituted a majority of piracy.

The world is different nowadays. A vast majority of piracy happens online. As such, it only takes one person to crack the DRM on a movie, and everyone gets free access to it. This is one of the main reasons why I don't think any form of DRM is likely to ever work. In order for any form of DRM to have any significant effect on piracy, it has to be 100% bulletproof. It must never be broken. One crack, and the game is up. The other main factor is this: the media companies want to give you access to the data, but only let you use it in specific ways. With current computer architecture, such a restriction is inherently impossible to enforce 100%.

Remember, the "10 years to crack" BluRay got cracked in a matter of...weeks, was it?
 
This might actually be an advantage though. If they make a common DRM engine, theoretically, we'd only have to crack it once and we'd have a common workaround for all media types. :p
 
Remember, the "10 years to crack" BluRay got cracked in a matter of...weeks, was it?
BD+ took a few months.. but we still haven't even seen a BD+ re-work yet, so we don't know if it's cracked for good.
 
This might actually be an advantage though. If they make a common DRM engine, theoretically, we'd only have to crack it once and we'd have a common workaround for all media types. :p

^This. I don't download illegal material (anymore), but this will be the outcome of a unified DRM scheme.

I just wonder how long it will take studios to realize that no matter what they do, the people that want to steal the content will. Their money would be much better spent making the people willing to pay happy, rather than creating arbitrary obstacles to fair use.

The fact that Congress hasn't bitch-slapped them for this behavior annoys me to no end.
 
BD+ took a few months.. but we still haven't even seen a BD+ re-work yet, so we don't know if it's cracked for good.
AACS took about 10 months to break, from what I gather, not weeks as I stated.
 
AACS was broken nearly as soon as we had PC HDDVD drives. The Xbox 360 HDDVD drive to be exact.

But BD+ and AACS are two completely separate DRM implements.
 
Funny, I just sent this e-mail to Puretracks today...

"Hello, thank you for offering DRM free MP3 music for affordable prices. I am more than happy to pay for the music I listen to from the artists I continue to support. Although I've noticed some of the albums you sell are available in wma format only with DRM tied to them. From reading your terms & conditions I'm under the impression that this is imposed upon your company from the individual bands/labels. I would like you to know that I personally will never purchase music with DRM tied to it. Since I live in Canada, and it is not illegal for me to download music off the net I am fully capable of downloading music elsewhere for free. Although, I would like you to know (and the bands/labels that provide you with the music) that if they would offer their albums in MP3 format with no DRM, I will gladly pay for it. One album I am interested in is the new release from Disturbed, which is currently available in WMA only."

Just my position on the topic of DRM, and I suspect there are probably millions more that share my point of perspective.
 
BD+ took a few months.. but we still haven't even seen a BD+ re-work yet, so we don't know if it's cracked for good.

I'm sure Sony will add more DRM. Sony loves DRM even when it's illegal, rootkits, and are the most anti-consumer company on the face of the planet.
 
If I buy something that has DRM the first thing I do is usually strip it. Just on principle. not to mention it usually works better afterward. and I did download the entire metalica catalog (this was kind of a worthless statement, I have bought most of there stuff to start with). This is the type of knee jerk reaction that this tends to make in people.

+1 karma to sboucher for giving feedback to the vendors.
 
DRM isn't and probably never was about preventing piracy. It's all about the studios trying to exert greater control for their own benefit.

Interoperable DRM would be very difficult to implement for the mere fact that everyone has their own agenda. Good luck convincing everyone that a unified standard is for everyone's benefit.
 
If I buy something that has DRM the first thing I do is usually strip it. Just on principle. not to mention it usually works better afterward. and I did download the entire metalica catalog (this was kind of a worthless statement, I have bought most of there stuff to start with). This is the type of knee jerk reaction that this tends to make in people.

+1 karma to sboucher for giving feedback to the vendors.


hmm... where can I get more info on how to strip DRM ?
 
DRM = fail. It doesn't work and only serves to annoy legitimate users. If you look at my posts on this forum, you'll see that I hate piracy and torrents, but I'm not afraid to admit that DRM is completely useless for anti-piracy purposes.
 
yeah, I see that. Looks simple enough.

But to hell with it, I'm gonna stick to my guns and not support anything that has DRM in it. Pretty easy to find what I'm looking for on a torrent if I can't buy it DRM free.

I'm looking forward to Amazon offering their mp3 downloads in Canada DRM free. How's that been workin out for you guys down south of the border?
 
yeah, I see that. Looks simple enough.

But to hell with it, I'm gonna stick to my guns and not support anything that has DRM in it. Pretty easy to find what I'm looking for on a torrent if I can't buy it DRM free.

I'm looking forward to Amazon offering their mp3 downloads in Canada DRM free. How's that been workin out for you guys down south of the border?

so far so good, but sometimes you can't avoid the DRM. (think DVD or blue ray). If you want your fair usage you don't have a lot of choice.

The damn thing is that HOCP4ME is right, it does NOTHING to stop people from pirating anything, hell I had to hack someones XP installation and he HAS a valid key, two of them in fact. the idiot at Microsoft just pissed me off the point that it was easier then reactivating it. That is just sad. (all of this was over a scratched cd BTW)

nothing like punishing the people that pay you for your product.
 
I really wonder how much piracy is actually prevented by DRM. Sure, it prevents (only very) casual copying, e.g. Joe Sixpack sticking a DVD in the drive, a DVD-R in another drive, and hitting "copy". It used to be that such copying (like mix tapes) constituted a majority of piracy.

The world is different nowadays. A vast majority of piracy happens online. As such, it only takes one person to crack the DRM on a movie, and everyone gets free access to it. This is one of the main reasons why I don't think any form of DRM is likely to ever work. In order for any form of DRM to have any significant effect on piracy, it has to be 100% bulletproof. It must never be broken. One crack, and the game is up. The other main factor is this: the media companies want to give you access to the data, but only let you use it in specific ways. With current computer architecture, such a restriction is inherently impossible to enforce 100%.

Remember, the "10 years to crack" BluRay got cracked in a matter of...weeks, was it?


Don't underestimate determination when it comes to lack of technical skills or knowledge to make it work.

People WILL find a way that works for them.

DVD? DeCSS.
Alternative? DVD Player hooked up to an RF Modulator hooked up to a DVR. (Dead serious. I even saw someone attempting to get a setup working where he would use DVD Player > RF Mod > Video Capture Card > Burn to DVD.) Before it was a digital format, DVDs were widely copied with RFModulators to VHS.

People have tried the same things for above with video streams on their computers. VGA plugs wired into a box that will output as SVideo for a video capture card. People WILL try.

Audio streaming? Loopback plugin or using a streamripper to save the file outright.
Alternative? Streaming to DAT. Streaming to Metal Type IV cassettes. Streaming to another computer that's recording from inputs. Streaming to a CD Recording deck. Streaming to MP3 player that has a line in record option. Same holds true for DRM encrypted tracks that could be downloaded but not burned (Napster WMA Playsforsure)

DRM encoded files? Crack it with FairUse4WM or FairPlay.
Alternative? Most of the ones I mentioned above. People just burned their stuff to CD and reripped it when it came to iTunes.

People will find a way even if they don't know there already are programs out there that will break the DRM like it was a toothpick. For one who is determined to have something in a format that is more usable to themselves, they WILL find a way to get around it. Short of disabling VGA out, Audio out... there's really not much you can do about it.

Here's the sad irony about it. When people go through these lengths to make a copy of something, because of the effort they had to go through in order to make a copy... I've found they're MORE LIKELY to share it with other people.

DRM, in all forms, intents and purposes... needs to outright die.
 
I'm looking forward to Amazon offering their mp3 downloads in Canada DRM free. How's that been workin out for you guys down south of the border?
It actually works quite well. I don't buy a lot of music, but we recently hosted a 50's-themed murder mystery, and wanted to get a bunch of classic 50's songs for ambience. Once my wife compiled a list of songs, it took just a few minutes to find and download the ones we needed. It was dead easy.
 
Back
Top