NVISION Pulls Pissed-off Pamphlet Passers

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
While NVIDIA’s LAN party, NVISION, is attempting to morph itself into an IDF “competitor” (and that is worth an entire editorial on its own), it seems that today while people are making their way into the keynote address, some group is outside making sure everyone is aware that NVIDIA is not all about wines and roses this quarter. Copies of WSJ’s recent article are being handed out as well as a another that takes a big swipe at NVIDIA’s failing notebook parts.

Nvidia Corp. often gets good reviews for its technology. But the way the chip maker and two computer manufacturers are handling a product defect hasn't pleased some critics, adding to a series of headaches for the Silicon Valley company.

Update: The flyers have "http://www.recallnvidia.org" on them.
 
I think my Compaq v3000z died beause of that. HP sent me a new one in replacement. So I'm not really complaining.
 
Heh, ATI Fanboys sure will go to extreme lengths. :D

What an ignorant comment.

Fanboyism has nothing to do with this. This is nVidia not owning up to their problems. I have one of the faulty 8400M so I would have been doing the same. I can't get a straight answer from Dell. I can't get a straight answer from NV. Bottom line is I have a faulty video card that I paid good money for and nobody is owning up to it and saying "here's how we're going to fix it."

nVidia needs to get off their high horse and make this problem right.

-V
 
What an ignorant comment.

Fanboyism has nothing to do with this. This is nVidia not owning up to their problems. I have one of the faulty 8400M so I would have been doing the same. I can't get a straight answer from Dell. I can't get a straight answer from NV. Bottom line is I have a faulty video card that I paid good money for and nobody is owning up to it and saying "here's how we're going to fix it."

nVidia needs to get off their high horse and make this problem right.

-V

C'mon bro, he was making a joke. Ligthen up.

How exactly if your 8400M "faulty?"
 
Did they ever bring up the mobile gpu issues for the press? Feels like that's what they want (and expect), which would be reasonable since they push PR everywhere for everything.
 
I know people are getting burned on shorting Nvidia from when it was under 11$, but this is a bit far...
 
Band aids and chewing gum fixes are the norm for years... You guys crack me up, this is a typical SOP maneuver from any company in the US or abroad.

I made quite a bundle of money on the 45% drop in stock and then the regain after the quarterly earnings came out; all while websites flung crap around on rumor or speculation. Ill take my check.

nVidia is a strong company and all the doomsayers will be surely disappointed when they stick around for quite a while longer.
 
I have a Dell Inspiron 1420 laptop and it's been tagged as one of the GPU's that could die because of heat issues when the card is being used. The card could die if I just do something simple like Folding.

It has a BIOS band-aid fix that causes the fan to run more often to keep heat down. Dell just extended warranties by 12 months. So instead of replacing the potentially faulty GPU I'm given a band-aid that causes my battery to die faster?

http://direct2dell.com/one2one/arch...ment-to-all-affected-customers-worldwide.aspx

I have a right to be mad. I paid good money to upgrade from the Intel IGP to the 8400M only to never be given a straight answer about the GPU and its problems which have been confirmed by HP, Dell, and nVidia.

-V

And I would suggest it is not "faulty" unless it breaks. I am not saying you should be happy about it, but the fact is that you have not had issues with it and now have an extended warranty on the unit. If you are so unhappy with the situation, sell it, and get something else.
 
Well if nVidia acutally stopped burying their heads in the sand and answered the many questions that we their customers have... maybe then the fury would die down. Being ignored, lied to, fobbed off with an barely adequate patch is not exactly good practise. There is a serious problem. It is affecting people and we'd like to know whats going to be done about it. I've already told friends not to buy nvidia based laptops until i get further answers.
They may not all be faulty but how can i give friends an honest opinion without knowing which ones are?

So currently they either buy a shitty intel GMA based machine, or grab a ATI gfx chip version.

And FYI... my partners machine is defective. My ex-gf's friends machine is faulty and has been replaced once already. Her hubby's machine is showing signs of it too. My sisters has been back twice already.

This is not a small issue.
 
why oh why do people keep defending the company rather than the individual?

Out of sight, out of mind does not fly here. Nvidia has faulty chips, Nvidia needs to answer for them. If this means a recall on a certain graphics chipset, then so be it.
 
I have to think that part of the problem is that Nvidia just will not fess up. That stonewalling has probably caused as much of the hate and rumor mongering as the chips themselves.

And to the people that said that its not faulty until it fails, well I can't see it like that This was a manufacturing flaw that lessens the value of what they bought. That is the bottom line. there really is no way around it. I am not saying that a full recall is necessary, just that Nvidia attitude is pissing a lot of people.

and as the fix goes that is asinine, I know a fan does not draw that much power but in notebooks it will make a difference.

but to be fair extending the warranty is a good start. I think it should be more then 12 months though (at least for the affected parts) And nvidia should foot the bill
 
Holy cow. Looks like I barely jumped ship in time. I just sold my 8800GTS and bought a 4850. Hehehe. I do prefer the Intel chipsets, and I get to support the underdog as they force nVidia to drop prices.

nVidia has been pissing quite a few off lately. I surely have been disappointed in their chipsets on all their boards I've had.

Oh well. Better to be pissed off than pissed on, I always say.
 
Holy cow. Looks like I barely jumped ship in time. I just sold my 8800GTS and bought a 4850. Hehehe. I do prefer the Intel chipsets, and I get to support the underdog as they force nVidia to drop prices.

nVidia has been pissing quite a few off lately. I surely have been disappointed in their chipsets on all their boards I've had.

Oh well. Better to be pissed off than pissed on, I always say.

This problem applies only to Nvidia laptop GPUs, and even then it is being overblown by a few radicals.
 
Holy cow. Looks like I barely jumped ship in time. I just sold my 8800GTS and bought a 4850. Hehehe. I do prefer the Intel chipsets, and I get to support the underdog as they force nVidia to drop prices.

nVidia has been pissing quite a few off lately. I surely have been disappointed in their chipsets on all their boards I've had.

Oh well. Better to be pissed off than pissed on, I always say.

I don't think it applies to your card. at any rate if I understand it right its a problem with changing temps, desktops are not nearly as affected.
 
http://www.theinquirer.net/gb/inquirer/news/2008/08/25/nvidia-changes-desktop-g86

The PCN is dated May 22, 2008 on the bottom of pages 2-5, July 25 on the bottom of Page 1, and Page 6 is undated. The first big problem is that it is entitled "G86 Desktop Products" with a subtitle " Change Namics 8439-1 Underfill material to Hitachi 3730". Above that there is " Product/Process Change Notice", the usual NDA only disclaimer.

So... its only laptop parts? No particular reason why you'd be changing an EOL part?

I smell more rotting bodies under the floor... and its getting worse.
 
I don't think it applies to your card. at any rate if I understand it right its a problem with changing temps, desktops are not nearly as affected.

Nods. Its thermal cycles. Laptops tend to get a hell of a lot hotter and will do more thermal cycles. Your desktops will stay on a lot more and hence have less cycles. (mine stays on 24/7).

Given the way they are currently handling the laptop issue... I'd say that desktop boards will proberbly fail in about 2yrs and that they will say "out of warrenty. tough shit buy a new one."

Lovely customer service.
 
So... its only laptop parts? No particular reason why you'd be changing an EOL part?

I smell more rotting bodies under the floor... and its getting worse.
Why not read the vr-zone article instead of taking hits from the charlie crack pipe? http://www.vr-zone.com/articles/NVIDIA_Die_Package_Problem_Might_Affect_Desktop_Parts/5996.html

Your assumptions are curious, especially since there is no proof of desktop parts failing in larger than typical numbers. This pretty much sums up the "problem": http://www.techreport.com/discussions.x/15318
 
So if your car has a faulty radio that may or may not fail and your manufacturer just kind of brushes it under the carpet you'd be OK with that or would you rather them fix it regardless?

NV isn't doing anything. They're not answering questions about anything and if they're stopping people was spreading the word they're just covering it up even more. Dell and HP aren't saying anything either. Let's say my GPU dies tomorrow. I get it replaced. Is it being replaced with another defective GPU that has the same problem? Some people have gone through 3 of these GPU's already.

I understand what you're saying about just selling it if I'm unhappy but why should I have to spend more money to get another laptop due to a defect in the one I already purchased? I don't recall my order form saying "1 defective nVidia 8400M GPU that may or may not die early."

1) You have a warranty on your GPU.
2) If it dies after 1 year, you have zero right to be pissed, you didn't opt for a higher warranty. They have provided exactly what you asked for.
3) They went above and beyond already and have issued a warranty extending the warranty on that part for twice the length of the orginal warranty.

4) If my car's radio had a potential problem, but was expected to function fine until it died suddenly and then they would replace it, I wouldn't give a damn.

5) Someone who claims they have recieved 2 additional replacement GPUs which has died on them is bullshit. It's a thermal packaging problem induced by cyclic thermal loading. The problem hasn't existed long enough for someone to get a RMA even with a defective part and then produce the number of cycles to destroy it again, twice. Sorry, but I'm calling bullshit on this one.

6) Get over it, your not going to get a new shinny lap top. There is currently nothing wrong with the functionality of the one you have.
 
Well its had a small effect in our family.

My dad was going to buy a new laptop. He asked me to check it over before he ordered.

The laptop had a 8400M in it. I had to recommend he go for a similar laptop with an AMD chip in it.

Close call.
 
all of my 6xxx and 7xxx video cards (i had 2 each) broke within 6 months... either they burnt out (display went black)... or the fans broke off under normal use.

I had no problems with 8600gt or 9600gt... after having my ati 2600... i wouldn't go back to nvidia. i got a 9600gt and although the games say they have higher fps... the image quality looks much worse and the games feel more laggy...than a card one year old (2600xt)...

on the flip side... if ati doesn't create affordable high end graphic cards soon they will be out of jobs then were stuck with nvidia all over again.

i miss amd and ati, please come back!
 
Supposedly the NVS 140M that my Thinkpad has is an 8400M GS ... yet it's performed very well in games and hasn't had any issues (so far)

Additionally, I haven't heard of any Thinkpads failing because of this bad batch of GPUs ... were the afflicted GPUs limited to Dell and HP laptops?
 
Supposedly the NVS 140M that my Thinkpad has is an 8400M GS ... yet it's performed very well in games and hasn't had any issues (so far)

Additionally, I haven't heard of any Thinkpads failing because of this bad batch of GPUs ... were the afflicted GPUs limited to Dell and HP laptops?

From what I have read is that the problem is exacerbated by poor internal cooling in the laptop. I have taken a few Dell and HP/Compaq laptops apart and have been surprised at the lack of cooling for some of their GPU chips. Some that have got a decent heatpipe running over them have to make contact to it through a thick (read 2mm+) wodge of that thick thermal putty stuff.

My Compaq R4000 has a ATI 200M in it and has nothing at all touching the chip, not even a heatsink. Not that its a powerhouse by any means.
 
So if your car has a faulty radio that may or may not fail and your manufacturer just kind of brushes it under the carpet you'd be OK with that or would you rather them fix it regardless?

NV isn't doing anything. They're not answering questions about anything and if they're stopping people was spreading the word they're just covering it up even more. Dell and HP aren't saying anything either. Let's say my GPU dies tomorrow. I get it replaced. Is it being replaced with another defective GPU that has the same problem? Some people have gone through 3 of these GPU's already.

I understand what you're saying about just selling it if I'm unhappy but why should I have to spend more money to get another laptop due to a defect in the one I already purchased? I don't recall my order form saying "1 defective nVidia 8400M GPU that may or may not die early."

If the car maker fixes it in a timely manner if it breaks, I am fine with that.

If you are truly concerned about beyond that, I would suggest a lawyer. If you have repeatedly had issue, I would suggest a refund is the solution. Just my personal opinions. Alls we have done on our website is make users aware of the issue. Don't be mad at me because I see things differently than you.
 
So if your car has a faulty radio that may or may not fail and your manufacturer just kind of brushes it under the carpet you'd be OK with that or would you rather them fix it regardless?

NV isn't doing anything.

You might want to do some research on this before you sound foolish.

NVIDIA set aside upwards of $200 million to take care of this issue. I would say they are handling it.
 
I am extremely lucky using an Asus laptop with a 8600m chip. Not a problem so far... (knocks on wood) :eek:
 
I am extremely lucky using an Asus laptop with a 8600m chip. Not a problem so far... (knocks on wood) :eek:


I stick with Intel Integrated Graphics on mine, but then again, I dont use them for much anything other than real work and none of that is 3d.
 
Not mad at you one bit Kyle, we're just stating opinons and facts here. :) And while I'm a little heated about the issue I'm not really mad at Dell or nVidia because stuff happens and I understand that. I'm more frustrated with the fact that nobody can get a straight answer about the problem. How many GPU's are effected? Was it just a certain batch? Do replacement GPU's have the same flaw? Are new laptop's still being sold with the faulty GPU's? The problem is we have gotten no further information so where is that $200 million going? Please refer to my above questions.

Who exactly did you ask these questions of? And what was their response that you are not happy with?
 
Have sent e-mails to both Dell and nVidia. nVidia refers me back to Dell and Dell techs don't have a clue and just keep telling me to install the BIOS "fix". ;)

At this point though I'm just about done with it since I doubt those questions will ever get answered. Maybe I'll just dump Linux on it and get a new laptop anyways. :p
 
Have sent e-mails to both Dell and nVidia. nVidia refers me back to Dell and Dell techs don't have a clue and just keep telling me to install the BIOS "fix". ;)

If you will send me copies of these emails I would like to read them and see exactly what is being said.
 
Not mad at you one bit Kyle, we're just stating opinons and facts here. :) And while I'm a little heated about the issue I'm not really mad at Dell or nVidia because stuff happens and I understand that. I'm more frustrated with the fact that nobody can get a straight answer about the problem. How many GPU's are effected? Was it just a certain batch? Do replacement GPU's have the same flaw? Are new laptop's still being sold with the faulty GPU's?

Dell's response of extending the warranty for 12 months (HP gave 24 months to their customers) was a very good thing but it still leaves the questions above unanswered. I don't see why it's so hard to get an answer to questions like that. I'm asking questions because I prefer being an informed consumer when I make decisions about purchases or future purchases especially when family and friends come to me for advice. If I don't like what I hear (or don't hear) or how I'm treated then I cut my losses and my money goes to somebody else from now on but that doesn't mean I have to be happy about it.

Oh and I would never take something like this to a lawyer. I'd end up paying more for the lawyer then the laptop is worth. ;)



We all know that NV admitted the problem during their quarterly conference call and are taking roughly a $200 million hit and that's not the issue. The problem is we have gotten no further information so where is that $200 million going? Please refer to my above questions.

The $200 million goes towards fixing your shit IF it breaks + recalling some chips in production, etc..

From the stories I've read on the internet it sounds like the bga pads/contacts on the bottom of the chips could possibly fail over time. Especially on laptops as their under more extreme heating & cooling conditions, being powered on & off more often, and often reaching higher temps b/c of confined spaces. Dell & other companies have released BIOS's which I THINK tune the fan to keep temperatures lower / and more consistent so hopefully the chips won't fail.

If you're that concerned pull your laptop apart and look for the nFail model #. :p

I don't think they've released details b/c its just going to make people overly concerned like you... when its just a higher chance of failure... not definite failure... and noone knows which chips exactly are going to fail. Its probably a random thing where its just a higher percentage so they've budgeted extra money to cover those failures.

Why don't you just put a blow torch to your chip and make it fail.... then you'll get a new one. :(
 
We all know that NV admitted the problem during their quarterly conference call and are taking roughly a $200 million hit and that's not the issue. The problem is we have gotten no further information so where is that $200 million going? Please refer to my above questions.

http://www.vr-zone.com/articles/NVIDIA_Die_Package_Problem_Might_Affect_Desktop_Parts/5996.html

1) The issue is limited to a few notebook chips only; we have not seen and don't expect to see this issue on any NVIDIA based desktops
2) Only a very small percentage of the notebook chips that have shipped are potentially affected and the problem depends on a combination of environmental conditions, configuration and usage model
3) We continue to work closely with our partners and have taken the necessary steps to ensure that all NVIDIA chips currently in production do not exhibit the problem.
 
http://www.tgdaily.com/content/view/39045/135
According to our sources, the failures are caused by a solder bump that connects the I/O termination of the silicon chip to the pad on the substrate. In Nvidia’s GPUs, this solder bump is created using high-lead. A thermal mismatch between the chip and the substrate has substantially grown in recent chip generations, apparently leading to fatigue cracking. Add into the equation a growing chip size (double the chip dimension, quadruple the stress on the bump) as well as generally hotter chips and you may have the perfect storm to take high lead beyond its limits. Apparently, problems arise at what Nvidia claims to be “extreme temperatures” and what we hear may be temperatures not too much above 70 degrees Celsius.
 
That is some awesome HTML code there.
Must have taken then hours to write it.

http://www.recallnvidia.org
Code:
<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/1999/REC-html401-19991224/strict.dtd">
<!-- <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01//EN"
"http://www.w3.org/TR/html4/strict.dtd"> -->
<HTML>
<HEAD>
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Refresh" CONTENT="0.1">
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Pragma" CONTENT="no-cache">
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Expires" CONTENT="-1">
<TITLE></TITLE>
</HEAD>
<BODY><P></BODY>
</HTML>
 
Back
Top