Nehalem Thoughts on Gaming - Bleh

Status
Not open for further replies.

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
Johan De Gelas, of Ace’s Hardware fame, now with Anandtech, waxes on about Intel’s upcoming Nehalem processor. Keep in mind our first Nehalem processors will be sold under the i7 branding and will “only” be four cores with Intel’s HyperThreading technology at launch to later be expanded to eight physcial cores with HyperThreading, which is something we here at HardOCP have always appreciated.

Nehalem is about improving HPC, Database and virtualization performance, much less about gaming performance. - No, Nehalem was made to please the IT and HPC people. Bring it to it.anandtech.com, it is not that interesting for you gamers ;-)

Willy Deeplung, if you can actually put any trust in that name over at Hexus, had a few Nehalem thoughts as well.

Nehalem won't matter much if you play games that are limited by the graphics subsystem, usually at higher resolutions and image-quality settings, but it's always nice to have extra power under the hood, we suppose.

As we have been pointing our readers to for a while now, gaming is 95% GPU-limited. Once you cross into the 3GHz threshold, you will best served by spending your money on that big-ass monitor and GPU configuration.
 
with how so many games are GPU limited these days i'm almost thinking it would be better to keep my 'old' opteron 165, overclock it a little more if i need and just upgrade the video cards.
 
While I agree that most people are better served spending their budget on a better GPU and display, there will always be games (and certain parts of many more games) that are heavily CPU-limited. It just depends on what you play. Supreme Commander comes to mind.

That said, I agree that Nehalem will be an expensive and largely unnecessary upgrade for most gaming purposes, at least for a while.
 
While I agree that most people are better served spending their budget on a better GPU and display, there will always be games (and certain parts of many more games) that are heavily CPU-limited. It just depends on what you play. Supreme Commander comes to mind.

That said, I agree that Nehalem will be an expensive and largely unnecessary upgrade for most gaming purposes, at least for a while.


Even SupCom scales somwhat poorly beyond 2 cores albiet MUCH better in Vista than XP, although people that play with modded games (with tens of thousands of units) will tell you that Quad Core helps out.

Here is our research.

I would expect Hyperthreading to make more of a difference in SupCom more than anything else although I think you would have to be SupCom "expert" to know it.
 
I've told someone that it'd be best to simply wait for the Nehalem to release and buy a Core 2 Duo/Quad. There might be some price drops. But he somehow has seen reviews (god knows where), that says it Nehalem is gonna be like a 50+% increase in performance for games. I really don't know where he saw these reviews or if he's just making it up.

He's also wanting to get dual GTX 280s and a couple SSDs. Here's the thing too, he only has a 20" LCD and I've sent him reviews to show that SSDs aren't all that great for the price. Let alone for the desktop.
 
I don't think Nehalem is going to impact any prices except top-tier parts till middle of next year.
 
He's the type that's looking to get those $1000+ processors. I personally see that as a stupid purchase, since overclocking will put you at the same performance for 1/3 or less the cost. But not everyone is for overclocking, even though he wants me to teach him now.
 
I think the $800+ crowd is exactly who this will be pointed at. Then a new mobo and likely new RAM....
 
I wish I had a reason to buy a i7 Proc. I do, however, have one very important reason not to. This reason has boobs, a ring on her finger, and the ability to "eliminate" certain aspects of physical relations.

Damn that woman!
 
Im not sure what I am going to do. Normally I upgrade every year or so, but im 1.5 years into my current build and its still blazing fast. I like the fact we are GPU bound more than CPU bound. Dont run crappy games or just turn down the res/effects and you can still get decent FPS.
 
I am very excited about the Nehalem and I would very much like to build a brand new machine based on it. I realize that a good GPU is MUCH more important than a fast CPU. The reason I want to build one is for the simple fact that it is the only thing that would actually feel like an upgrade. I mean hell its a brand new socket. Why would I want to "upgrade" to a Penryn quad core when the upgrade path for LGA 775 is so uncertain?

I just thought I would add this little tidbit since there will be alot of gamers reading this. The problem is that neither nVidia nor ATi has a single card that can provide 60fps average @ 1080p at Very High 4xAA 16xAF in Crysis. I honestly don't feel like I am really upgrading at all until that milestone is passed. I know alot of you complain about bad programming and whatnot when people mention Crysis, but that does change the fact that we are still not able to max out the game on a reasonable budget. Crysis is the best looking game on PC and not one video card can play the game the way games are meant to be played on PC. PC's are supposed to be the cream of the crop as far as graphics and sound are concerned. That is why console gamers laugh at PC gaming. Screw the piracy excuses. The real issue is the fact that there are hardly any good new PC games coming out. This is simply due to the fact that people are less inclined to buy a nice PC when they can't even expect to play the best looking games maxed out. This is the only reason I am holding out on buying a new PC. I should not have to spend over $1000 on video cards alone just to barely break 30fps average. That is bullshit and EVERYONE knows it.
 
I wish I had a reason to buy a i7 Proc. I do, however, have one very important reason not to. This reason has boobs, a ring on her finger, and the ability to "eliminate" certain aspects of physical relations.

Damn that woman!


:( They will do that to you
 
I should not have to spend over $1000 on video cards alone just to barely break 30fps average. That is bullshit and EVERYONE knows it.

When Quake came out, it was pretty much impossible to max out the settings, even with the fastest CPUs available. But back then people weren't so hell-bent on getting the highest resolutions and full AA/AF and all that (AA/AF options didn't even exist yet, it was all software rendered). We pretty much accepted that 320x200 was the common gaming resolution, even though our desktops could run at 800x600 or 1024x768. For me it felt like a great achievement when the first games became playable in 640x480.

So I think people these days have pretty extreme and unrealistic demands. It's just not possible to make a GPU that's 2 to 3 times faster than the previous (which is about the extra performance required), everytime a new monitor comes on the market with even higher resolutions.

This situation is a result of the fact that the PC gaming industry was already complacent, and for years did not push the envelope of gaming, allowing GPUs (and consoles) to catch up and people running at ever higher resolutions and AA/AF settings. Obviously, the games were still using 2003/2004 technology and graphics, and 2006-2007 GPUs just are way too powerful for that.
I wish there were more developers like Crytek, who still dare to push the envelope. I don't really care if I have to disable AA or run at a lower resolution if the overall game is great. I'll increase the resolution again after my next upgrade and play through the game again with the improved graphics, just for kicks. That's how I've always done it.
 
When Quake came out, it was pretty much impossible to max out the settings, even with the fastest CPUs available. But back then people weren't so hell-bent on getting the highest resolutions and full AA/AF and all that (AA/AF options didn't even exist yet, it was all software rendered). We pretty much accepted that 320x200 was the common gaming resolution, even though our desktops could run at 800x600 or 1024x768. For me it felt like a great achievement when the first games became playable in 640x480.

So I think people these days have pretty extreme and unrealistic demands. It's just not possible to make a GPU that's 2 to 3 times faster than the previous (which is about the extra performance required), everytime a new monitor comes on the market with even higher resolutions.

This situation is a result of the fact that the PC gaming industry was already complacent, and for years did not push the envelope of gaming, allowing GPUs (and consoles) to catch up and people running at ever higher resolutions and AA/AF settings. Obviously, the games were still using 2003/2004 technology and graphics, and 2006-2007 GPUs just are way too powerful for that.
I wish there were more developers like Crytek, who still dare to push the envelope. I don't really care if I have to disable AA or run at a lower resolution if the overall game is great. I'll increase the resolution again after my next upgrade and play through the game again with the improved graphics, just for kicks. That's how I've always done it.
Potential PC gamers are very aware that even $3000 PC's can't achieve smooth gameplay at HD resolutions on new games like Crysis. No one wants to play games like Crysis lower than High. It sucks to have to drop your settings on a brand new high end card. That basically keeps them from buying games and hurts the PC gaming market WAY more than piracy. I wish developers would stop blaming piracy. All they have to do is figure out a way to develop better games that require less hardware to max out. Honestly the way the PC gaming market is right now frustrates me to high heaven. I really dislike gaming on consoles so I feel like I am stuck. I need a new hobby that much is certain.
 
Potential PC gamers are very aware that even $3000 PC's can't achieve smooth gameplay at HD resolutions on new games like Crysis. No one wants to play games like Crysis lower than High. It sucks to have to drop your settings on a brand new high end card.

The mere fact that you chose the words 'drop settings' proves exactly what I'm saying: people expect to max everything out these days, which is unrealistic.
Drop a few settings and Crysis is still a great game with excellent graphics, and then you can play it very nicely.
I myself played it on an 8800GTS320. The first time I played it in DX9 mode with everything to High, in 1280x1024. Worked fine.
After the Crysis 1.2 patch and the updated drivers, I started playing in DX10 mode on Very High in 1280x1024. I've completed it a few times on Delta level, so apparently it's quite playable.
 
I enjoyed the heck out of it actually. I still play it every once in a while, and I've already pre-ordered Crysis Warhead.

You must have missed the "my opinion" part :p

I played through Crysis with an 8800GTX at the same res on Very High and the performance was so poor by the later levels that I had to turn it down. Sure I "could" have played the rest of the way on Very High, but it would've been like playing a slide show. If you were able to enjoy that, more power to you, but I question that your definition of "playability" would suit many others here.
 
I played through Crysis with an 8800GTX at the same res on Very High and the performance was so poor by the later levels that I had to turn it down. Sure I "could" have played the rest of the way on Very High, but it would've been like playing a slide show. If you were able to enjoy that, more power to you, but I question that your definition of "playability" would suit many others here.

You must have missed my point about the 1.2 patch and later drivers.
Initially it was unplayable in DX10, but currently it probably plays better in DX10 than it originally did in DX9 on my system. The performance improved a LOT because of those updates, especially in those problem-areas in the snow levels and such.

If you haven't tried Crysis on Very High with the 1.2 patch and the latest drivers, I suggest you do so, because you'll be pleasantly surprised.
 
You must have missed my point about the 1.2 patch and later drivers.
Initially it was unplayable in DX10, but currently it probably plays better in DX10 than it originally did in DX9 on my system. The performance improved a LOT because of those updates, especially in those problem-areas in the snow levels and such.

If you haven't tried Crysis on Very High with the 1.2 patch and the latest drivers, I suggest you do so, because you'll be pleasantly surprised.

I've played enough of the parts that used to chug on my 8800GTX with a single 4850 (and the 1.2 patch) to tell you that I still consider VH DX10 to be "eh, so-so," which is not enjoyable to me. I can only imagine what it must be like on a 320MB G80. Like I said, you're entitled to your opinion, but don't try to convince me that it's any more than an opinion, like my own. Is it better with the 1.2 patch? Sure. But do I like playing it? Not really. I'd much rather play on all high and get double the frames.

Question for you though - do you play the 32 or 64 bit version?
 
You mean an Athlon 4850+ processor? That might be your problem. I run a 3 GHz C2D.
And I played the 64-bit version obviously. 32-bit is so 2004 :)
 
The mere fact that you chose the words 'drop settings' proves exactly what I'm saying: people expect to max everything out these days, which is unrealistic.
Drop a few settings and Crysis is still a great game with excellent graphics, and then you can play it very nicely.
I myself played it on an 8800GTS320. The first time I played it in DX9 mode with everything to High, in 1280x1024. Worked fine.
After the Crysis 1.2 patch and the updated drivers, I started playing in DX10 mode on Very High in 1280x1024. I've completed it a few times on Delta level, so apparently it's quite playable.
That is where we disagree. It is NOT unrealistic. What is unrealistic is releasing a game that requires hardware that is not available and then bitching about sales and piracy. The game is playable like you say, but 1280x1024 should not be the target resolution. The resolution that alot of gamers are using today is 1920x1200. That is the target. Pretty much the way I see it every single PC game developer should shoot for at least 60fps avg minimum @ 1920x1200 4xAA 16xAF on the highest settings on the highest end single card. I am sure I am not alone in thinking this. Game developers and video card makers should be answering to us not the other way around.
 
Crysis Warhead to run on Cheap PCs at High Detail

http://www.hardocp.com/news.html?news=MzMxNTgsSnVuZSAgICAgLDIwMDgsaGVudGh1c2lhc3Q=

For what it is worth.

"That was our goal; we want to take the fear away from the player that it cannot play our product. Warhead is a play, which can play everyone. It becomes playable with a PC, which costs 400 euros, its - on High Settings. The play will with a very good Framerate, thus I think with 30 to 35 Fps for running on the average."
 
So to get back on topic Nehalem is more to take AMD on in the server market and the like rather then the regular H community? I am assuming that means the core 2 CPUs are going to be around for quite a while?
 
You mean an Athlon 4850+ processor? That might be your problem. I run a 3 GHz C2D.
And I played the 64-bit version obviously. 32-bit is so 2004 :)

Is that supposed to be a joke? I'm talking about a Radeon HD4850 (video card). My CPU is a 3.2ghz C2Q.

Anyway, as I said thrice before, to each their own.
 
So to get back on topic Nehalem is more to take AMD on in the server market and the like rather then the regular H community? I am assuming that means the core 2 CPUs are going to be around for quite a while?
Naw I doubt it. The lowest end Nehalem @ 2.66Ghz will be priced around $300. That is not that expensive considering the fact that they say that a 2.66Ghz Nehalem is roughly 30% faster @ 2.66Ghz than the QX9650 is @ stock speeds. I am sure that the Nehalem will just end up replacing the Core2Quads.
 
Naw I doubt it. The lowest end Nehalem @ 2.66Ghz will be priced around $300. That is not that expensive considering the fact that they say that a 2.66Ghz Nehalem is roughly 30% faster @ 2.66Ghz than the QX9650 is @ stock speeds. I am sure that the Nehalem will just end up replacing the Core2Quads.

I had read that but 30% faster at what is what I am wondering. I wish had kept up to date with the programing. I am also wondering when the EOL for the core two architecture is.
 
That is where we disagree. It is NOT unrealistic. What is unrealistic is releasing a game that requires hardware that is not available and then bitching about sales and piracy.

It doesn't *require* that hardware. That's what people like you make it out to be, by accepting nothing but the highest possible in-game settings. That's the unrealistic part
The minimum requirements are MUCH lower. Crysis even runs on SM2.0 cards like the age-old Radeon 9700.
These minimum requirements aren't unrealistic either. I've actually installed and played it on my old XP1800+ system with a Radeon 9600XT, and the game could be played quite well, in the range of 25-30 fps. This is better than a lot of games today, because a game like BioShock won't work at all on the 9600XT, it requires SM3.0.

The game is playable like you say, but 1280x1024 should not be the target resolution. The resolution that alot of gamers are using today is 1920x1200. That is the target.

If you want that resolution, it's perfectly doable with Crysis. Even on medium detail level the game looks better than pretty much everything else out there. That's because every other game is built on game engines designed around 2003-2004 hardware.

Pretty much the way I see it every single PC game developer should shoot for at least 60fps avg minimum @ 1920x1200 4xAA 16xAF on the highest settings on the highest end single card. I am sure I am not alone in thinking this. Game developers and video card makers should be answering to us not the other way around.

So you're saying that a game like Crysis should get lower detail, so you can run them at higher resolutions?
Then why don't you just turn down the detail yourself?
You are the problem here, not the game.
 
I tried that "Very High in DirectX 9" trick which everyone claimed to be the "same but faster" as DirectX 10 Very High, but noticed a siginificant degradation in motion blur used. An easy way to test it is to switch to your fists and start swinging around.

Well yes, DX10 uses a different motion-blur technique, that is object-related, rather than just screenspace blur like DX9 does.
So obviously DX10 will be slower, it does something more advanced.
I'm not sure what people were thinking anyway? It's not like the GPU knows whether it's running DX9 or DX10 code. It won't magically run slower if you feed it the same code through DX10.
DX10 is slower because it uses more advanced algorithms. Sure, you can hack the game so that DX9 uses more detailed geometry and such, but it's still not the same as DX10 mode. If it was, it would run at the same speed, because the GPU doesn't know the difference.
 
It doesn't *require* that hardware. That's what people like you make it out to be, by accepting nothing but the highest possible in-game settings. That's the unrealistic part
The minimum requirements are MUCH lower. Crysis even runs on SM2.0 cards like the age-old Radeon 9700.
These minimum requirements aren't unrealistic either. I've actually installed and played it on my old XP1800+ system with a Radeon 9600XT, and the game could be played quite well, in the range of 25-30 fps. This is better than a lot of games today, because a game like BioShock won't work at all on the 9600XT, it requires SM3.0.



If you want that resolution, it's perfectly doable with Crysis. Even on medium detail level the game looks better than pretty much everything else out there. That's because every other game is built on game engines designed around 2003-2004 hardware.



So you're saying that a game like Crysis should get lower detail, so you can run them at higher resolutions?
Then why don't you just turn down the detail yourself?
You are the problem here, not the game.
Do you read what you type before your hit reply? I am saying that Crytek should have the game playable on the highest ingame settings on the highest end single card available at the time. Why is that so crazy to ask? The problem is that Crysis is there to sell hardware. Funny thing is the hardware can't deliver a playable experience at HD resolutions on Very High. Why should I have to turn down my settings with a 8800GTX or Ultra? Those cards were the high end when that game came out. If I buy a HD 4870x2 for instance I expect to play every single game out at the time at 1920x1200 with everything maxed. Why would you defend the game dev or the hardware companies? Which side are you on? Like I said before they work for us.
 
When Quake came out, it was pretty much impossible to max out the settings, even with the fastest CPUs available. But back then people weren't so hell-bent on getting the highest resolutions and full AA/AF and all that (AA/AF options didn't even exist yet, it was all software rendered). We pretty much accepted that 320x200 was the common gaming resolution, even though our desktops could run at 800x600 or 1024x768. For me it felt like a great achievement when the first games became playable in 640x480.

So I think people these days have pretty extreme and unrealistic demands. It's just not possible to make a GPU that's 2 to 3 times faster than the previous (which is about the extra performance required), everytime a new monitor comes on the market with even higher resolutions.

This situation is a result of the fact that the PC gaming industry was already complacent, and for years did not push the envelope of gaming, allowing GPUs (and consoles) to catch up and people running at ever higher resolutions and AA/AF settings. Obviously, the games were still using 2003/2004 technology and graphics, and 2006-2007 GPUs just are way too powerful for that.
I wish there were more developers like Crytek, who still dare to push the envelope. I don't really care if I have to disable AA or run at a lower resolution if the overall game is great. I'll increase the resolution again after my next upgrade and play through the game again with the improved graphics, just for kicks. That's how I've always done it.
I think the perception is because of LCD monitors. Breaking out of native resolutions seems as a let down. When on a CRT people didn't care too much about running at 640x480 or 800x600 because it filled the screen without any degraded qualities LCD monitors have when stretching an image. So when most buy a 22", 24", or even a 30" monitor they want to run the native resolution all the time. I remember when 1024x768 was the sweet spot. The sweet spot now is whatever your native resolution is on your LCD monitor.
 
Do you read what you type before your hit reply? I am saying that Crytek should have the game playable on the highest ingame settings on the highest end single card available at the time. Why is that so crazy to ask? The problem is that Crysis is there to sell hardware. Funny thing is the hardware can't deliver a playable experience at HD resolutions on Very High. Why should I have to turn down my settings with a 8800GTX or Ultra? Those cards were the high end when that game came out. If I buy a HD 4870x2 for instance I expect to play every single game out at the time at 1920x1200 with everything maxed. Why would you defend the game dev or the hardware companies? Which side are you on? Like I said before they work for us.

Do you bother reading what others type?
I think I made perfect sense. You say you want better performance in high resolutions. The only way to get better performance is to make the workload lighter, in other words lower the detail. Why did you not answer that?

Also, what makes you think that games DO need to run at maximum settings?
We've had HD resolutions for years, but until recently (8800GTX/Ultra?), there wasn't any card that could run at such resolutions at a decent framerate period. You neither had the memory nor the GPU power.
What are your expectations based on? Because there's no historical base for your expectations, as I tried to illustrate with the Quake-example, which was ignored?
 
I think the perception is because of LCD monitors. Breaking out of native resolutions seems as a let down. When on a CRT people didn't care too much about running at 640x480 or 800x600 because it filled the screen without any degraded qualities LCD monitors have when stretching an image. So when most buy a 22", 24", or even a 30" monitor they want to run the native resolution all the time. I remember when 1024x768 was the sweet spot. The sweet spot now is whatever your native resolution is on your LCD monitor.

Yes obviously, but that doesn't mean it's realistic to expect hardware to be able to deliver the maximum resolution AND get maximum detail.
Yet that is what people DEMAND from games these days.
There are only two options:
1) Keep maximum detail and lower the resolution.
2) Lower the detail and keep the maximum resolution.

Crysis offers both options, so I don't see where the problem is.
As far as I can tell, they're arguing that games should have lower detail, so they can run at higher resolutions... But why should games be limited to a low detail? People with smaller screens can run higher detail with the same card. Why would you want to limit them?
And what does it matter when you run a game at medium or high settings instead, if the game still looks great and plays well?
I think it's just completely irrational.
 
Well now that this has no chance of being on topic we will close it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top