How Linux Might Look in 2012

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Information Week broke out the crystal ball and made some educated guesses on what desktop Linux might look four years from now. Check it out if you’re interested in this sort of thing.

The single biggest change you'll see is the way Linux evolves to meet the growing market of users who are not themselves Linux-savvy, but are looking for a low-cost alternative to Microsoft (or even the Mac).
 
System Configuration
Is it optimistic to expect that by 2012, command-line hacking for basic Linux system configuration will be a thing of the past? One can hope, especially for things like display configuration, which should be auto-detected and configured touchlessly. This is crucial if Linux is to make headway with regular users, although putting Linux on devices like netbooks, where the hardware is a predictable and controllable factor, should help.
That's going to be a huge battle.
 
"The single biggest change you'll see is the way Linux evolves to meet the growing market of users who are not themselves Linux-savvy, but are looking for a low-cost alternative to Microsoft (or even the Mac)."

This should have been an obvious change 10 years ago.
 
From someone who has the years of experience with Linux to actually make such predictions without requiring everyone to break out the hip-waders:
- Support for older but still in use systems will be broken because nobody wants to fix it.
- A monolithic kernel will now take 200MB of memory.
- There will be five new distributions, and three will die off.
- Vendors will still have to develop their own 'appliance' distributions because nobody wants to work on it or they want to keep control of proprietary hardware.
- There will be another dozen schedulers to choose from, only some of which actually work.
- New shiny-things will still be prioritized over making existing ones work.
- Linus will do little more than running his mouth, and insulting a random person every week.
- Idiots at Information Week and similar will still prove their ignorance by thinking Gnome and KDE are Linux.

Hey, it's worked this way for over ten years. Why change?
 
"The single biggest change you'll see is the way Linux evolves to meet the growing market of users who are not themselves Linux-savvy, but are looking for a low-cost alternative to Microsoft (or even the Mac)."

This should have been an obvious change 10 years ago.

I can hear the Linux zealots say this: NEVER!!!!!!!

Me I've believed this is what Linux has always needed and has been missing in Its battle to be recognized as a Mainstream OS:), Instead of a sideshow like It is now.:( :p
 
From someone who has the years of experience with Linux to actually make such predictions without requiring everyone to break out the hip-waders:
- Support for older but still in use systems will be broken because nobody wants to fix it.
- A monolithic kernel will now take 200MB of memory.
- There will be five new distributions, and three will die off.
- Vendors will still have to develop their own 'appliance' distributions because nobody wants to work on it or they want to keep control of proprietary hardware.
- There will be another dozen schedulers to choose from, only some of which actually work.
- New shiny-things will still be prioritized over making existing ones work.
- Linus will do little more than running his mouth, and insulting a random person every week.
- Idiots at Information Week and similar will still prove their ignorance by thinking Gnome and KDE are Linux.

Hey, it's worked this way for over ten years. Why change?

You, sir, win an Internet or two. My breakfast cereal nearly ended up on my keyboard.

Anyway, Linux will never become a mainstream desktop OS. The average consumer requires hand-holding that the Linux community will never give. It's a fun toy for those of us with at least the basic skills to troubleshoot problems and jump through hardware compatibility hoops, but that's about it.

A buddy of mine used Linux as his exclusive desktop OS for over a year after he ran into some troubles with Vista at launch and got angry at MS. He's not a moron and is comfortably competent with Linux. However, he recently decided he wanted to play some games and installed Vista 64 SP1.

His reaction was priceless. Stuff was no longer inexplicably sucking up all his memory. He was no longer running into small annoying bugs every 2 minutes. Basic tasks which were a monumental effort in Linux, were suddenly effortless. It was all the little things. He could resize a video player window without the whole system locking up, for example.

Linux as a desktop will never reach the level of polish that a year old Windows release has. The developers within the Linux community just aren't interested in making that happen.
 
I cant stand the whole desktop OS "battle" mentality. Linux is a great alternative for those seeking one it will never be a mainstream competitor to microsoft.

The first time any distro does actually look like a threat to redmond they will sue them off the planet with thier army of lawyers. Microsoft has already shown that they are ready and willing to go that route.

If microsoft somehow fails with a lawsuit against said distro the Apple crew will simply steal what makes it great and sue them for patent rights like they do to everyone else.

I dont think most linux gurus know what it would mean to jump in the mess that is Apple vs microsoft. Personally im happy with the current position linux is in and would rather not see linux get bogged down by the bullshit that plagues microsoft and apple.
 
You, sir, win an Internet or two. My breakfast cereal nearly ended up on my keyboard.

Anyway, Linux will never become a mainstream desktop OS. The average consumer requires hand-holding that the Linux community will never give. It's a fun toy for those of us with at least the basic skills to troubleshoot problems and jump through hardware compatibility hoops, but that's about it.

A buddy of mine used Linux as his exclusive desktop OS for over a year after he ran into some troubles with Vista at launch and got angry at MS. He's not a moron and is comfortably competent with Linux. However, he recently decided he wanted to play some games and installed Vista 64 SP1.

His reaction was priceless. Stuff was no longer inexplicably sucking up all his memory. He was no longer running into small annoying bugs every 2 minutes. Basic tasks which were a monumental effort in Linux, were suddenly effortless. It was all the little things. He could resize a video player window without the whole system locking up, for example.

Linux as a desktop will never reach the level of polish that a year old Windows release has. The developers within the Linux community just aren't interested in making that happen.

I feel the same way, I am not a programmer, developer or engineer. I consider myself at the enthusiast level. I am not uncomfortable with a command line every now and then, i like being able to tweak my systems as needed. Every few years i pick up the latest "hot" flavor of linux and give it a try and every time it comes down to the same few issues.

1) GUI. I know that the gui isnt "linux" but come on, most of the guis i have tried remind me of using Windows 3.11. Cant a team somewhere work on polishing the GUI so it remotely competes with OS X or Windows. I know this seems "shallow" to think this way, but this is the interface that most users will be staring almost exclusively

2) Pre-installed crap. Once again not an issue with "linux" but rather the throw everything in including the kitchen sink approach of the distributions. When i go to browse my harddrive i want there to be a file explorer, not 12 of them. When you are picking up on something new you want it to be intuitive and trying to figure out which of your 12 file managers will do what you are looking to do isnt all that intuitive.

3) Configurations. The reason that Windows has been so popular is that you plug something in, it just works. At most you have to point a single dialogue box to your CD rom drive. In linux, especially if you are just coming to the platform you have to search the web on how to edit half a dozen config files, compile source code and copy several commands you found off of some random website that you have no idea what they do in hopes that your new hardware will work and you arent about to accidentally repartition your harddrive.

4) Hardware support. If you were lucky enough to have not formatted your harddrive in complaint 3, congratulations, however now there is a 50/50 shot that the hardware you installed actually works fully, or if your new sound card will play sound, but the recording functionality is still under development, or that your video card works, but dont expect full 3d acceleration. Again i know that this isnt so much a "linux" issue, but rather the manufacturers themselves, but still, it detracts from the experience overall.
 
You, sir, win an Internet or two. My breakfast cereal nearly ended up on my keyboard.

Can I get my Interwebs without Linux zealots screaming "DEATH TO MICRO$0FT" in every Unix forum? And then proceeding to look at big openings Microsoft leaves in the server market, and pissing them away so they can make a Gnome app that displays your NIC LEDs on your desktop?
 
Oh yeah, i forgot a point.

5) snobbery. This is the reason that i dont seen my above mentioned points being addressed or even acknowledged by many in the linux community as even faults. They are all beneath the linux community. You want something shiny and pretty, go buy jewelry, linux is for real men. You dont like all the crap, compile your own source, As for configurations its not our fault that you are too lazy to RTFM that is written for someone experienced in linux and hardware support, blame the manufacturers for being in the pocket of Micro$soft.

A perfect example of this is i have been tinkering with the LinuxMCE project in the past, and in all honesty if they ever really start working together rather than more or less fixing and tweaking the parts that they in particular use it will be an awesome platform. However a while back i was involved in a thread about media organization.

http://forum.linuxmce.org/index.php?topic=1842.0

Basically it came down to that currently MCE doesnt do foldering of media, everything is organized with metadata, which is great for new collections where you can apply metadata to everything, but for existing larger collections foldering is about the best you will get in terms of a usable navigation IMHO. Here are some of the comments that came out of the discussion from some of the more prominent members of the project team.

"come on, guys. You have filters.. ____USE THEM___ !!"

"so, you're talking about adding an additional layer of UI complexity just to satisfy your little edge case? nice. um, no."

"we can go back and forth on this one...but the truth of the matter is, folders are essentially a band-aid, when you have the ability to zero in by real metadata instead of creating fixed points of heirarchy. You're just feeling chapped because you don't want to actually tag your data."

"so if you really want it.. click on view by Filename. If you're not happy, modify your version of the code. OR LEAVE."

"also, why don't you STOP pirating films off bittorrent, or better yet, concatenate the files together?

Funny, I imported all my legal store bought media into LinuxMCE, and everything has covers, indexed authors, directors, genres, and guess what? I don't need folders! *GASP!*."
 
Can I get my Interwebs without Linux zealots screaming "DEATH TO MICRO$0FT" in every Unix forum? And then proceeding to look at big openings Microsoft leaves in the server market, and pissing them away so they can make a Gnome app that displays your NIC LEDs on your desktop?

I'm not powerful enough to do that, sorry. You'll have to settle for a couple vanilla Interwebs.
 
Get real! I still have to use a console window in Windows sometimes. Now, the only reason Linux isn't easier to use is because the community at large doesn't want it that way. People seem to think that if they implement a specific visual control aspect, it will turn the kernel into a giant unwieldy monster. :rolleyes: I would use it more If I could. You can't just go buy a piece of hardware at the store and expect it to work. These days you might be able to get a video card to work half ass, but to what end? You can play Quake3 or maybe UT. Then the zealots say they don't play games anyway. Well if you don't play games and you don't cater to work hardware and you don't like an easy to use interface, when the hell will you stop bitching about people saying that the OS is damn near useless? Boy you can run a hell of a print server though. Or perhaps build a router with some old computer parts. Hey you can make it small enough to use in a wall bumping robot. All of the things it can do, amount to fuck all with 99.9% of the populace.

I wore my fire retardant clothes this morning. Bring the pain.:p
 
Get real! I still have to use a console window in Windows sometimes. Now, the only reason Linux isn't easier to use is because the community at large doesn't want it that way. People seem to think that if they implement a specific visual control aspect, it will turn the kernel into a giant unwieldy monster. :rolleyes: I would use it more If I could. You can't just go buy a piece of hardware at the store and expect it to work. These days you might be able to get a video card to work half ass, but to what end? You can play Quake3 or maybe UT. Then the zealots say they don't play games anyway. Well if you don't play games and you don't cater to work hardware and you don't like an easy to use interface, when the hell will you stop bitching about people saying that the OS is damn near useless? Boy you can run a hell of a print server though. Or perhaps build a router with some old computer parts. Hey you can make it small enough to use in a wall bumping robot. All of the things it can do, amount to fuck all with 99.9% of the populace.

I wore my fire retardant clothes this morning. Bring the pain.:p

Your sig should read:

The angle of the dangle is inversely proportionate to the slack in the sack.

Never heard the one you have before.
 
Get real! I still have to use a console window in Windows sometimes. Now, the only reason Linux isn't easier to use is because the community at large doesn't want it that way. People seem to think that if they implement a specific visual control aspect, it will turn the kernel into a giant unwieldy monster. :rolleyes: I would use it more If I could. You can't just go buy a piece of hardware at the store and expect it to work. These days you might be able to get a video card to work half ass, but to what end? You can play Quake3 or maybe UT. Then the zealots say they don't play games anyway. Well if you don't play games and you don't cater to work hardware and you don't like an easy to use interface, when the hell will you stop bitching about people saying that the OS is damn near useless? Boy you can run a hell of a print server though. Or perhaps build a router with some old computer parts. Hey you can make it small enough to use in a wall bumping robot. All of the things it can do, amount to fuck all with 99.9% of the populace.

I wore my fire retardant clothes this morning. Bring the pain.:p

QFT. and its why I don't think Linux will ever get off the ground. I've tried Slackware, I've tried Ubuntu, Mandrake, and a bit of RedHat way back in the day before it was all corporate/commercialized. It has all the necessities there, but nobody gives a damn about seriously making it a true Windows competitor. In order to compete with something, you have to be able to show that you can give it a run for its money. But if you can't even do something as simple as install without command line usage, then really, you've already turned off more than 90% of your core market. There are so many things you can do with Windows that you still can't with Linux, even after all this time with development between all the distros, and its kind of heartbreaking in a way, because it would really be nice to see an alternative that doesn't require proprietary hardware at a ridiculous price premium the likes of Apple. Just something that I can install, configure to my needs (i.e. which bootloader, KDE vs. Gnome, which file manager I'd like to use, install specific apps and leave all others on disc that I don't need/want, etc.) and just get my basic settings configured (i.e. network IP so I can have net access, email settings, etc.) and more or less just the simplicity that comes with Windows. As for paying for it? Shit, I have NO problem putting money into the hands of whatever magnificient bastard manages to make a true Windows alternative in Unix based-flavor that doesn't suck.
 
If that's what THEY think Linux will look like in about 4 years, I think those people need to hire someone at Lucasfilm and ILM or perhaps Dreamworks Entertainment or some other high end movie studio to come up with something far more "futuristic".

I loaded that gallery and... well... shit, I had to check to make sure it wasn't just a link to those Ubuntu 8.10 alpha pics from a few days ago.

Futuristic thinkers... idiots with no creativity. My god, if it still looks like that in the future, I'm going back to DOS.
 
our sig should read:

The angle of the dangle is inversely proportionate to the slack in the sack.

Never heard the one you have before.

Really? It's from one of the more famous MTV cartoons. I wont say which one. I wouldn't want to date my self.;)
 
I know the cartoon i must have missed that episode.

I first heard my version a long long time ago but probably after the one your referring. Apparently after googling there are a few different ones too.
 
I'm into the community with belif in the model of how its used, ive spent about 3 hours helping out, Report bug is contribution aswell btw ;) takes 3 mins tops...

Translation(Im norwegian) takes a short time, and is really easy any1 can do it =)

The hardware support is good, i remember flashing my 2900 xt 1000/1200 and playing ETQW OMFG was soo lovely compared to windows, no lagg spikes at all ;D and i had way higher fps, so the speed on ati is in, nvidia is good aswell, not big diffrence, the ease of use isnt there, everything is placed perfectly, why? cause millions have been apart of this..

Broadcom FUCK YOU BROADCOM, this is where most people get angry, cause they put in cd, ohh, net doesnt work so unfortunate... i need to connect with a cable, use some hours figuring things out, if you got the brand new broadcom chip, or a rare, GOOD LUCK.

LEts take this sys as example: intel c2d intel IGP intel wlan( all supported, IGP is craaaap tho) install all works. maybe you got a jackplug fix, easy to fix but annoying.

there are really just minor things, alot have happened the past 4 years, things have gone automatic in a rate as the lightning. gotten 300% more automized and supported better, and STILL got the costumizeability as b4, if you really want, do it youreself, EVERYTHING, or just let it do it for ya, when something bad happens, you can fix it, can you do it with any other OS, mb not with windows due to lack of info just from the os itself.

Things gone way more open source.

What would drive linux to a better os in like 3 years, 50% more opengl games, which gets ported, ALL STEAM GAMES GET PORTED BTW.

i aint a good writer at all, just writing my opinions here, there are lots of stuff i dont like about linux, but i can actually make it better, and you can, and you.. so do it, try compiz, use a month minimum on the system, are you a hardcore gamer, leaaaaave it for now.! ID games and epic games can be playd, search first, not too many :S
 
O-really? It's gonna be pretty fucking hard to port Direct 3d games there buddy. Most of the steam games are D3D these days. So what, in 10 years you'll be able to play CS1.6? The point is you should be able to already. You wanks have had plenty of time to figure this shit out. The point is you wont have a competitive OS until it actually competes. Making it intuitive and easy to use wont ruin it by any means. My grandma can use Windows. Can your grandma use Linux?:confused:
 
Ya know, I'm a big Linux fan. But, Linux stays off my desktop system. There are a few reasons for this:
1. All the Linux file managers that I have tried suck in some way. Either they can't support the sheer number of files I have in a folder (Over 8000 files at 2.8TB in one folder), or they are slow/unintuitive, or the quick-jump feature I use so often in Windows (When in a folder, start typing a file name, it takes you there as you type).
2. Multimedia functionality sucks in some way. VLC under Windows is miles ahead of VLC under Linux, go figure.
3. Games. Wine, while great in concept, sucks in reality.
4. Flash. Heh, 64bit Linux + Flash, hahhaha.
5. Open Office is slow and cumbersome. I prefer Office 97 over Open Office.

That all said, I wouldn't run anything else for my fileservers. I love my Linux fileservers. There are Open Source programs that make my life so much easier, like HellaNZB. Granted, I only interface with them through Putty or SMB or HTTP, but they do their job beautifully.

So, Linux on the desktop? I'm not getting my hopes up.
 
I'm hoping by 2012 people will stop assuming that Linux is intended for mainstream consumption. Really, aside from a couple distributions out of hundreds, the target audience is not the general public.
 
I'm hoping by 2012 people will stop assuming that Linux is intended for mainstream consumption. Really, aside from a couple distributions out of hundreds, the target audience is not the general public.

Its no coincidence that the couple "mainstream friendly" distrobutions have larger communities than the other hundreds combined.

The target audience is the general public its just not going to happen without some radical changes which would essentially kill the linux we know and love today.
 
Its no coincidence that the couple "mainstream friendly" distrobutions have larger communities than the other hundreds combined.

The target audience is the general public its just not going to happen without some radical changes which would essentially kill the linux we know and love today.

pfunkman, I've been dealing with Linux for longer than many, many people here have even been dealing with computers. And that's just professionally. Linux isn't, hasn't been, and never will be "mainstream." The "mainstream friendly" distros have the exact same problems the rest do - fix it yourself attitude, couldn't care less about documentation, and my favorite. Reinstall, don't upgrade, upgrading is hard.

Frankly, the only folks who love Linux at this point are the management people who puffed on a vendor's pipe too long, or the zealots. Most real Unix people don't want to touch that crap with a 30 foot pole. We know exactly what a Linux environment brings - headaches, migraines, and back injuries from trying to rip 90lbs machines out of racks in a blind rage because they just wiped the production database. And that's with supposed support contracts. Don't ask how many times I have heard "we're not actually responsible for N" in response to a bug, when I've been migrating people who got suckered back onto a platform that isn't crashing daily.
 
Sure, but the majority of the people actually writing the OS are writing for business or research purposes.
 
I feel the same way, I am not a programmer, developer or engineer. I consider myself at the enthusiast level. I am not uncomfortable with a command line every now and then, i like being able to tweak my systems as needed. Every few years i pick up the latest "hot" flavor of linux and give it a try and every time it comes down to the same few issues.

1) GUI. I know that the gui isnt "linux" but come on, most of the guis i have tried remind me of using Windows 3.11. Cant a team somewhere work on polishing the GUI so it remotely competes with OS X or Windows. I know this seems "shallow" to think this way, but this is the interface that most users will be staring almost exclusively

2) Pre-installed crap. Once again not an issue with "linux" but rather the throw everything in including the kitchen sink approach of the distributions. When i go to browse my harddrive i want there to be a file explorer, not 12 of them. When you are picking up on something new you want it to be intuitive and trying to figure out which of your 12 file managers will do what you are looking to do isnt all that intuitive.

3) Configurations. The reason that Windows has been so popular is that you plug something in, it just works. At most you have to point a single dialogue box to your CD rom drive. In linux, especially if you are just coming to the platform you have to search the web on how to edit half a dozen config files, compile source code and copy several commands you found off of some random website that you have no idea what they do in hopes that your new hardware will work and you arent about to accidentally repartition your harddrive.

4) Hardware support. If you were lucky enough to have not formatted your harddrive in complaint 3, congratulations, however now there is a 50/50 shot that the hardware you installed actually works fully, or if your new sound card will play sound, but the recording functionality is still under development, or that your video card works, but dont expect full 3d acceleration. Again i know that this isnt so much a "linux" issue, but rather the manufacturers themselves, but still, it detracts from the experience overall.

Loki, I really don't care if people criticize Linux but for chrissakes at least make them factual. Most of the people in this thread have essentially done that, don't like OpenOffice? Fine, you don't have to there are alternatives and you don't have to like those either.

That is an opinion, but when you make the sort of comments you made here which aren't just flamebait but also transparently false I'll have to ask you to stop.

1) There are two desktop environments that are used in between 80 and 90 percent of all Linux installs. Those are Gnome and KDE, even the less pretty of the two (Gnome) can't even be tenuously compared to Windows 3.11. I've used Windows 3.11, have you? Because if you haven't you're only being ignorant instead of disingenuous. Windows 3.11 is pretty clearly not the same thing as Gnome. KDE, XFCE, and Enlightenment are all entirely different as well. The popular programs in all of these are simple to use with a good GUI..GIMP possibly notwithstanding.

2) This one isn't as bad if it weren't for your horrendous example. An argument can be made that certain distributions include too many programs by default..its an issue I have with KDE actually. The example of 12 file managers on the other hand is entirely without merit. Some distros may include 2 or 3 for all I know, but that is nothing I've ever heard of. Gnome uses Nautilus, KDE uses Dolphin, XFCE uses Thunar, I don't know what Enlightenment uses but it's just one as well. I've already established that Gnome & KDE are the only ones you're likely to run into without hunting so you only need to consider two (which are pretty similar to each other).

3) If something works on Linux-and that is the expected behavior by now-the vast majority of the time it is as simple as plugging it in and you will NEVER have to do any configuration. The system detects it and sets it up for you no adding drivers or other configuration necessary. Lets assume then that you do run into issues, the only ones that cause real problems are some graphics cards and some wireless NICs, with graphics issues use EnvyNG, if wireless issues use ndiswrappers. Those both configure pretty much everything for you. Simply put if you're toying around in config files you're doing it wrong or it just won't work to begin with and that is pretty rare.

4) Seems redundant but not anything seriously wrong with it except the format your HDD jab. Once again, if you are screwing around in config files you're doing it wrong, the same applies for entering obscure commands.

I do have one other person I would like to respond to though, SamuraiInBlack:

You pretty clearly haven't used any major Linux distro aside from Slackware in the last decade if you "have" to install things over the command-line. Synaptic or YaST..take your pick, they're both simple to use GUIs that install and update software for you easier than you would on Windows. If you're installing from source, you're doing it wrong.
 
Ya know, I'm a big Linux fan. But, Linux stays off my desktop system. There are a few reasons for this:
1. All the Linux file managers that I have tried suck in some way. Either they can't support the sheer number of files I have in a folder (Over 8000 files at 2.8TB in one folder), or they are slow/unintuitive, or the quick-jump feature I use so often in Windows (When in a folder, start typing a file name, it takes you there as you type).
1) Organised your fscking folders betters, FFS the point of folder is to make navigation easier... WTF is the point of an OS/Filesystem (any OS/filesystem) providing support for folders if someone is just gonna flatten their folder...
2) what browser have you tried? I just touched 8000 files in a tmp folder and nautilus listed them fine. Also Dolphine from KDE4 does it fine. Not to sure abt Thunar (not near an XFCE box atm)
WHAT you could run into tho is if you have preview enabled

2. Multimedia functionality sucks in some way. VLC under Windows is miles ahead of VLC under Linux, go figure.
I don't tend to use VLC that much (only for the most stubborn of files which my main player [xine] fails at) but ever tried another mediaplayer? VLC isn't the only player by a LOOOONG shot
3. Games. Wine, while great in concept, sucks in reality.
yes games is a sticking point. Linux is (technically) great for gaming and with gamers need to squeeze the most out of their system it is also a great tweaking OS. HOWEVER... the "market" isn't perceved to be there
WINE may "suck" to some degree but pls suggest something better to get around the proprietory, vendor-locking that DX and windll is?

4. Flash. Heh, 64bit Linux + Flash, hahhaha.
Funny enough 64bit Win + Flash+JAVA is a bigger joke HAHAHAHAHA
Do you know why
1) there is ONLY 32bit FLASH plugin for windows
2) there is ONLY 32bit JAVA plugin for windows
Do you know how 64bit windows does it? it launches a 32bit version of IE.
Do you know how you have todo it in 64bit linux? USE A FSCKING 32BIT BROWSER FFS... (that or live with the odd problems with nspluginwrapper - which I have never had btw)

OH yer btw linux has 64bit JAVA :D

Adobe have stated they hope to have 64bit flash for Flash11 (win and lin)

/me posts this from a 64bit Linux system using a 64bit compiles Firefox3 with 64Bit JAVA and 32bit-Flash (via nspluginwrapper) very happily

5. Open Office is slow and cumbersome. I prefer Office 97 over Open Office.
the problem with OOo is it has JAVA riddled through it (yer I know excuses excuses...) but it is getting faster and OOo3-beta is lush
Its personal preference whether you like OOo or not (but at least you have the choice). Personally I prefer MSO-Excel over OOo-Calc but that is because I live in Excel and OOo-Calc is still lacking (but only just with OOo3)



Linux for the desktop has been a reality for over a decade for me BUT for the casual/granny/non-tech user its better BUT not quite there
It has got the the point where the likes of Ubuntu you don't even need to use the command-line (wife hasn't had to touch it at all, and I havn't touched her Ubuntu setup, just talked her through some menu-clicks, but I have todo that with her and windows).
It aint quite there for everything mind (but then again it seems the command prompt has to be use for Vista w.r.t. network shares :D)

The main stumbling block is apps. Granny wants her family tree app that she got from the church club to werk... guess what Windows-only using some obsure ActiveX hook that WINE does't support/dev's not aware of (real case for me trying ubuntu out on my nan).
The FOSS apps out there are FANTASTIC *IF* you get their UI way of thinking (for some its a bit hard :( )
When the main app writers start actually taking linux seriously and linux-native apps appear in a propper form (I mean Neroburner for linux is a very poor attempt when you compare it to k3b - a FANTASTIC app) then you will start seeing linux for the desktop as a real possiblity
 
Linux for the desktop has been a reality for over a decade for me BUT for the casual/granny/non-tech user its better BUT not quite there
It has got the the point where the likes of Ubuntu you don't even need to use the command-line (wife hasn't had to touch it at all, and I havn't touched her Ubuntu setup, just talked her through some menu-clicks, but I have todo that with her and windows).
It aint quite there for everything mind (but then again it seems the command prompt has to be use for Vista w.r.t. network shares :D)

The main stumbling block is apps. Granny wants her family tree app that she got from the church club to werk... guess what Windows-only using some obsure ActiveX hook that WINE does't support/dev's not aware of (real case for me trying ubuntu out on my nan).
The FOSS apps out there are FANTASTIC *IF* you get their UI way of thinking (for some its a bit hard :( )
When the main app writers start actually taking linux seriously and linux-native apps appear in a propper form (I mean Neroburner for linux is a very poor attempt when you compare it to k3b - a FANTASTIC app) then you will start seeing linux for the desktop as a real possiblity

I agreed with most of what you said up to about here. Linux on the desktop has been a joke except for all but the nerdiest until about 3 years ago, a decade ago my ass.

Its not just obscure apps that are the problem in fact i have had better luck with the few obscure apps i have than mainstream. For the most part wine is fantastic and does great up until you get a program that relies heavily on drivers, direct x, activeX, etc. then it just seems to crap out.

Nero in windows has become a bloated joke of its former powerfull self. Cdburnerxp is a hell of alot better and k3b is better than both.
 
I agreed with most of what you said up to about here. Linux on the desktop has been a joke except for all but the nerdiest until about 3 years ago, a decade ago my ass.
THAT is the problem I have with the whole "linux on the desktop" statement :D it is /very/ subjective. I found my GNOME-1.x desktop a hell of alot more useful then the Win95+Novell network my Uni was using in 1998 and I did my Uni work all on Linux quite happily (And I was grateful I did and stored my doc's in RTF when a few MS-Doc macro virus's did their rounds biyearly).

So for me it has been usable for ~10years. For my wife I would only say it has had the potential for the last 2years esp after GNOME got really newbie-friendly (but that was still with me in the background managing the system). AND only with hte last Ubuntu release where I have not had to really interfere with my lasses computer use (from a system P.O.V.). Its all subjective from the end-users capability/expectation/needs

Its not just obscure apps that are the problem in fact i have had better luck with the few obscure apps i have than mainstream. For the most part wine is fantastic and does great up until you get a program that relies heavily on drivers, direct x, activeX, etc. then it just seems to crap out.
very true, but DX support is getting better (there is a good screenshot of DawnOfWar:Soulstorm on my 64bit system somewhere in the linux subforum on [H])

Nero in windows has become a bloated joke of its former powerfull self. Cdburnerxp is a hell of alot better and k3b is better than both.
cdburning is just an example and in hindsight a poor one. KDE do make fantastic apps (Amarok is great), but the point is the majority of common computer uses don't know such an app as a "CDBurner" (and thus make that independent thought leap to find an "equiv" linux CDBurner app) BUT know it as Nero.

Breaking that applications usage from its proprietory name (like Hoover for vacuum cleaner...) is 1/2 the battle, there are alot of apps out there for linux but how do you tell ppl to use "pidgin" when they want MSN and are not really open-minded to make the extra step in linking the app's functionality together
 
Back
Top