Apple Passes Microsoft… in Vulnerability Reports

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Now this is a category that Microsoft is probably happy to let Apple overtake them. A mid-year report shows that Apple and open-source content management system Joomla have passed Microsoft in disclosed vulnerabilities. Maybe Apple’s preoccupation with secrecy is catching up with them as hackers turn their baleful eyes on OSX and Safari.

Final results were close, according to the IBM X-Force 2008 mid-year report, with Apple achieving vulnerability disclosure score of 3.2 percent, followed by Joomla with 2.7 percent and Microsoft at 2.5 percent. IBM remained in fourth spot, followed by Sun, a newcomer to the top five, while Oracle and Cisco fell from their former positions to sixth and seventh respectively.
 
once again proving that mac's unbeatable "security" was only due to its obscurity.
 
[Comment stating how stupid Apple / Macs / People who use or like either are]
 
once again proving that mac's unbeatable "security" was only due to its obscurity.

agreed.

I'm curious whether
1) microsoft will start taking advantage of stats like these and "i'm a mac/i'm a pc" apple back in its face (rather than mojave consumers' ignorance)
2) apple will still be able to continue along with such snazzy-product-driven focus after being bogged down with things like patching OS holes or buggy mobile-me-like launches

either way, these stats don't detract from the fact that OSX is a very decent operating system...it's just a wake up call to apple that there was a very good reason why MS has spent so much time/had such a hard time securing its ubiquitous software.
 
Did anyone actually read the article? It says that Apple has passed Microsoft for disclosed vulnerabilities.

Read a bit further down and it says,
Microsoft held on to the top spot for the number of public exploits, followed by Hewlett Packard and Apple. The three vendors accounted for about half of all exploits found in the top ten list.
and even here, it's not exactly clear what they're talking about to me...
 
hmm interesting point...but given apple's secretive nature, I'd think they've tried their best to keep as many bugs undisclosed (again, unclear what this might mean in the context of the article) as possible ;); since MS is already under the spotlight, I'd doubt they'd care as much about another bug added to the pile.
 
agreed.

I'm curious whether
1) microsoft will start taking advantage of stats like these and "i'm a mac/i'm a pc" apple back in its face (rather than mojave consumers' ignorance)
2) apple will still be able to continue along with such snazzy-product-driven focus after being bogged down with things like patching OS holes or buggy mobile-me-like launches

either way, these stats don't detract from the fact that OSX is a very decent operating system...it's just a wake up call to apple that there was a very good reason why MS has spent so much time/had such a hard time securing its ubiquitous software.

Apple will just continue to lie like they always do.
 
Did anyone actually read the article? It says that Apple has passed Microsoft for disclosed vulnerabilities.

Read a bit further down and it says,

and even here, it's not exactly clear what they're talking about to me...

Even still, considering macs marketing team wants you to believe only windows has security vulnerabilities this is a big blow to them.

Their day will come and it will be interesting to see how they deal with it. No matter how much you dislike Microsoft they are hardened veterans in the malware/virus field.

I predict mac will eventually get hit by a nasty virus (Blaster worm anyone?) that will cripple them for a while. The question is how long will it take to fix it and how well will they cover it up.
 
once again proving that mac's unbeatable "security" was only due to its obscurity.

actually. No. And Terry doesn't understand computer security.

Let me repeat what the news post said, only with two words, and in bold.

disclosed vulnerabilities.

There's a difference between disclosed and undisclosed.

A disclosed bug or error is a bug or error that is documented. The attack path, be it a buffer overflow, flaw in the code, or just outright access permission error is known and the people affected by the bug are able to take steps to address the fault. Such steps include adjusting a firewall to shut down specific ports, or denying write execution privileges to the file, or simply uninstalling the affected application.


An undisclosed bug or error, on the other hand, is much worse. Microsoft and Apple have both been bit by 0-day malicious code written against undisclosed bugs and errors.

Which is better? Bugs that the vendor knows about that they tell you about... or bugs that the vendor knows about that they don't tell you about?

Clearly, the answer is, the bugs that are disclosed.

The numbers that aren't reported then, are the numbers that are of concern. How many undisclosed bug reports are Apple, Microsoft, and anybody else sitting on?

Case in point would be a major site like Alltel. Their text messaging page has 163 errors and 90 warnings when the HTML is validated against W3C. However, Alltel customers have no idea that any text message they enter on the Alltel site is at risk for anybody to read or access. Does this mean that somebody has actively hacked the Alltel site, or has malicious software installed on people's computers to read text messages they input? Not likely, but Alltel hasn't even bothered to inform their customers that their website fails even basic tests.


One of the amazing factors in the reports is where Linux sits. Yes, on the IBM report, Linux sat at number 10. That doesn't sound too good until you realize that Linux isn't a corporation. There is nobody to sit on undisclosed vulnerabilities. The minute somebody talks a vulnerability on the kernel mailing list, that's it, it's open, it's disclosed, people know about it and can start fixing it immediately.

Little wonder then that Microsoft, who has a long history of not disclosing vulnerabilities, retained the top spot of having the most public exploits.

In fact, check this quote from the IBM report:

Analyzing the availability of public exploits by vendor produces a somewhat
different list, and, after reviewing the numbers, there are a few clear leaders for
the first half of 2008. The top three vendors had approximately 50 percent or
more public exploits than any other vendor in the top ten.
In fact, more than 20
vendors would have been listed in the remaining spots in the top ten, so it was a
bit arbitrary to list the others along with the top three. The top three vendors
with the most public exploits published in the first half of 2008 are listed in
Table 3.

Care to guess who those top 3 were?

Microsoft, HP, then Apple.

So, what can be taken from the report then? Well, obviously Apple is learning their lesson. They are talking about bugs and errors earlier on, giving downstream vendors and clients the ability to set up safeguards and work-arounds before official patches or newer application versions are available.

Microsoft is in a position between a rock and a hard place though. Yes, it looks good on paper that other vendors are reporting more bugs. However, as demonstrated, anybody remotely familiar with the security industry knows that is a bad thing for Microsoft. Microsoft's publishing less vulnerabilities, and is getting socked with more 0-day exploits, more proof-of-concept malicious code, and clients are getting.. well. There's a reason why all OEM's and ODM's are pushing Linux alongside Windows.

Microsoft therefor has to stop sitting on their undisclosed vulnerabilities and start informing vendors and clients about the bugs, so that the vulnerabilities can be patched or have work-arounds made available. That places Microsoft in the very embarrassing position that they really don't want to let anybody know exactly how bad their software is. It doesn't matter that you, or I, know that Microsoft software is the base standard for how to not write code. As long as Joe Blow over in the local government, school system, or non-computer related business doesn't realize how bad Microsoft code is, there's still a sales market.

Oh, and Terry, if you really want help understanding the security industry, start talking with the guys who write this application ; http://klamav.sourceforge.net/klamavwiki/index.php/Main_Page
 
once again proving that mac's unbeatable "security" was only due to its obscurity.

QFT - and obvious to anybody who's been around the block. However, Apple's marketing team made hay while the sun was shining.

It has taken Apple 20+ years to reach that phase in their maturity where they become the victims of their own success. It will be interesting to see how they grow beyond it - prepare to either be impressed or entertained :D
 
As their market share increases so will vulnerabilities. Why try to crack something with very little market share?
 
actually. No. And Terry doesn't understand computer security.

Let me repeat what the news post said, only with two words, and in bold.

disclosed vulnerabilities.

There's a difference between disclosed and undisclosed.

A disclosed bug or error is a bug or error that is documented. The attack path, be it a buffer overflow, flaw in the code, or just outright access permission error is known and the people affected by the bug are able to take steps to address the fault. Such steps include adjusting a firewall to shut down specific ports, or denying write execution privileges to the file, or simply uninstalling the affected application.


An undisclosed bug or error, on the other hand, is much worse. Microsoft and Apple have both been bit by 0-day malicious code written against undisclosed bugs and errors.

Which is better? Bugs that the vendor knows about that they tell you about... or bugs that the vendor knows about that they don't tell you about?

Clearly, the answer is, the bugs that are disclosed.

The numbers that aren't reported then, are the numbers that are of concern. How many undisclosed bug reports are Apple, Microsoft, and anybody else sitting on?

Case in point would be a major site like Alltel. Their text messaging page has 163 errors and 90 warnings when the HTML is validated against W3C. However, Alltel customers have no idea that any text message they enter on the Alltel site is at risk for anybody to read or access. Does this mean that somebody has actively hacked the Alltel site, or has malicious software installed on people's computers to read text messages they input? Not likely, but Alltel hasn't even bothered to inform their customers that their website fails even basic tests.


One of the amazing factors in the reports is where Linux sits. Yes, on the IBM report, Linux sat at number 10. That doesn't sound too good until you realize that Linux isn't a corporation. There is nobody to sit on undisclosed vulnerabilities. The minute somebody talks a vulnerability on the kernel mailing list, that's it, it's open, it's disclosed, people know about it and can start fixing it immediately.

Little wonder then that Microsoft, who has a long history of not disclosing vulnerabilities, retained the top spot of having the most public exploits.

In fact, check this quote from the IBM report:



Care to guess who those top 3 were?

Microsoft, HP, then Apple.

So, what can be taken from the report then? Well, obviously Apple is learning their lesson. They are talking about bugs and errors earlier on, giving downstream vendors and clients the ability to set up safeguards and work-arounds before official patches or newer application versions are available.

Microsoft is in a position between a rock and a hard place though. Yes, it looks good on paper that other vendors are reporting more bugs. However, as demonstrated, anybody remotely familiar with the security industry knows that is a bad thing for Microsoft. Microsoft's publishing less vulnerabilities, and is getting socked with more 0-day exploits, more proof-of-concept malicious code, and clients are getting.. well. There's a reason why all OEM's and ODM's are pushing Linux alongside Windows.

Microsoft therefor has to stop sitting on their undisclosed vulnerabilities and start informing vendors and clients about the bugs, so that the vulnerabilities can be patched or have work-arounds made available. That places Microsoft in the very embarrassing position that they really don't want to let anybody know exactly how bad their software is. It doesn't matter that you, or I, know that Microsoft software is the base standard for how to not write code. As long as Joe Blow over in the local government, school system, or non-computer related business doesn't realize how bad Microsoft code is, there's still a sales market.

Oh, and Terry, if you really want help understanding the security industry, start talking with the guys who write this application ; http://klamav.sourceforge.net/klamavwiki/index.php/Main_Page

Excellent post.

Oh yeah, and this has me worried about my Vista machine now: http://www.neowin.net/news/main/08/...ty-rendered-completely-useless-by-new-exploit

:(
 
can we seriously go a week without some thread that turns into PC vs. Mac?

"can't we all just get along?". :D
 
Back
Top