YouTube User Charged Over Threats

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you make threats about poisoning baby food on YouTube, you shouldn’t be charged… you should have your ass stomped instead. Well, I guess if this guy goes to prison, he’ll probably get both anyway.

A New York man known for stirring up controversy on YouTube was arrested Thursday by federal authorities after allegedly claiming he had instructed Gerber employees to lace baby food with cyanide.
 
This wrong. He didn't posion any food and shouldn't be punished. If he didn't give out his name, address and other info then they had no right to charge him. Fucking goverment forcing youtube to give out personal information. If no babies died of posioning and he didn't give out his name then it is bullshit. Everyone knows that people on youtube are just dumbasses and are not really going to do anything that they say they are. This is the internet. We are meant to threaten to kill people on it, and they are taking away our rights. Damn the man. DAMN THE MAN.

:p <to understand this post go read the one about the yale students and their lawsuit>
 
You don't fuck with another persons food ever, no exceptions. You don't threaten to fuck with people's food ever, no exceptions.

You don't put drugs n people's drinks, you don't put laxatives in people's soup, you don't talk about doing it, you don't joke about doing it. You don't do it. You find something else to do, you accept the universal prohibition and move on. Only assassins contemplate poisoning others.

There's are no shades of Grey on this subject, there's no room for debate nor discussion as it's one of those things Modern Humans have to obey or suffer the worst possible consequences.
 
This is one prime example where freedom of speech, liberty and anonymity does not apply that I meant in the Yale post. Some people don't deserve freedom.
 
I'm all for civil liberties and freedom of speeh, BUT...

To those folks who say he shouldn't have been arrested, keep in mind that arrest != conviction. If there's probable cause to believe that someone is a threat to others (e.g., they've publicy announced their intention to poison people), then the reasonable thing to do is to detain them for questioning.

I suspect that this guy is disturbed at some level, but is primarily an attention whore.
 
The guy had to know they'd come down on him for this,and that they could easily find out his identity,unless he's terminally stupid.From the description of his behavior,he sounds at the least like a sociopath.There's no question the authorities had to act,how many times have things like this been ignored until a tragedy occurs?
 
i'm sorry but a world without jokes about laxatives.. is a world i dont want to live in... all the rest of the shit is downright evil.... no doubt
 
This is one prime example where freedom of speech, liberty and anonymity does not apply that I meant in the Yale post. Some people don't deserve freedom.

So where are you drawing the line? If you threaten to kill babies it is wrong, if you threaten to repeatly rape & sodimize a female classmate of yours it is ok?

Now, I don't think that any random troll should be hunted down and be forced to expose their idendity. However I think that anyone that makes any threat against somebody, or doesn't some to actually harm somebody in a real way (ie positing information about somebody children then telling a pedo to go have fun with them, posting slander about a person to cost them jobs...) then they should be brought out of their hiding place and forced to be known.

In this case. I don't care if the person was trying to be funny or what. When it comes to stuff like this I hope that they always take it serious and make sure to investigate weither or not anything has actually been done. I would hate for them to say, "He isn't be serious, nobody here would do that for him" only to find out a week later that 100s died due to it being true.

When it comes down to it, there are some things that you just don't due unless you are trying to cause a mass histaria. You don't make up lies about posioning food, you don't yell fire/bomb in a crowded place, you don't take a fake bomb on an airplane... Stuff like that normally will, and should, result in your ass being locked away for awhile due to you causing people to freak out.
 
even if that is a big joke youtube is not a closed community and is neither the time nor place to crack a joke like that
 
glad they got this fag, stupid &#9829;&#9829;&#9829;&#9829;, what the hell is wrong with him
 
i'm sorry but a world without jokes about laxatives.. is a world i dont want to live in... all the rest of the shit is downright evil.... no doubt

A world of Chaos are less "fun" than a world with order. As the say the grass isnt always greener on the other side.
 
Freedom of speech is an absolute right, with the exception of direct, plausible threats against others and the possible exception of slander/libel. Even given my strong position on freedom of speech, this guy absolutely deserved to be arrested. This is a very different scenario from some moron on Xbox Live making a half-assed remark about hunting another player down and killing him. This guy's blatant threat was believable enough at the outset to constitute probable cause, and it's only responsible to take someone like this into custody pending an investigation. Does he deserve to be convicted of something? Time will tell. As yagisencho aptly put, arrest != conviction...but when someone makes a threat this serious (particularly in such a manner as he did), it cannot go entirely ignored.
 
Some of you are the ones who scare me. Why are you supporting the idea of thought crimes? Have you ever heard of presumption of innocence? Making stupid videos on the internet is in no way comparable to shouting FIRE in a crowded building. People can die in a panicked crowd, no one will die will die or be injured from being nervous about an internet retard. Just because his rambling might worry you, he has done nothing to endanger anyone.

If he was simply detained for questioning that's one thing, but if he was put in jail, then that's an entirely different, and unacceptable thing.

Also, enjoy your future police state.
 
Some of you are the ones who scare me. Why are you supporting the idea of thought crimes? Have you ever heard of presumption of innocence? Making stupid videos on the internet is in no way comparable to shouting FIRE in a crowded building. People can die in a panicked crowd, no one will die will die or be injured from being nervous about an internet retard. Just because his rambling might worry you, he has done nothing to endanger anyone.

If he was simply detained for questioning that's one thing, but if he was put in jail, then that's an entirely different, and unacceptable thing.

Also, enjoy your future police state.

I would definitely enjoy a world without Internet retards. As others have said, this guy does not deserve Freedom of Speech.

Oh, and it isn't thought crime. He can keep his thoughts to himself. Or perhaps he could phrase them in a less specific manner.
 
The idiots who stampede when some shouts "Fire!" in a crowded theater, not the person shouting, are the problem. If you want to save your life at the expense of someone else, fine, I totaly understand that. However, if you are such an abject coward, or so phenomenally stupid, that you will shove, crush, or trample someone because some random individual has shouted a warning (or made a threat), of some occurence that none of your other senses (or any available evidence) can backup, that is 100% on you.

The only thing that causes people to "freak out" in situations like these, is the ignorance, gulibility, or weakness of those people.

Trashman's videos are obviously BS. There is nary a plausible word to be found in the lot of them.

Personally, I'd be inclined to round up anyone who, for even a second, took this guy seriously, and have them all shot. However, as someone who believes strongly in freedom of most forms of expression, I recognize that those people have a right to their stupidity, just as Trashman has a right to his.

If you don't like what someone has to say, you are free to not listen.

I would definitely enjoy a world without Internet retards

Suicide would be a step in the right direction.
 
The idiots who stampede when some shouts "Fire!" in a crowded theater, not the person shouting, are the problem. If you want to save your life at the expense of someone else, fine, I totaly understand that. However, if you are such an abject coward, or so phenomenally stupid, that you will shove, crush, or trample someone because some random individual has shouted a warning (or made a threat), of some occurence that none of your other senses (or any available evidence) can backup, that is 100% on you.

The only thing that causes people to "freak out" in situations like these, is the ignorance, gulibility, or weakness of those people.

Trashman's videos are obviously BS. There is nary a plausible word to be found in the lot of them.

Personally, I'd be inclined to round up anyone who, for even a second, took this guy seriously, and have them all shot. However, as someone who believes strongly in freedom of most forms of expression, I recognize that those people have a right to their stupidity, just as Trashman has a right to his.

If you don't like what someone has to say, you are free to not listen.



Suicide would be a step in the right direction.

When you walk up and tell someone you are intending to poison infants, you are committing a crime, if the person believes you.

The same is true if you do it over the phone or other electronic means including the internet. This is not some new thing. This has been law for a long time. If you make threats like those, you have to except the possibility that some one, somewhere, is going to take you seriously. If I worked at Gerber in a position of responsibility, I might take this guy seriously, cause if I did not and he really did it, my head would be the on a chopping block as well. Once someone somewhere takes you seriously, the odds of the law getting involved go up.

He abused his right to free speech, and is now being called to account for it.
As for people who stampede when some one yells "fire", that is classic herd/mob behavior rooted in instinct. Even the best and brightest fall prey to it.
 
Obviously,the guy was looking for attention.But people who are just shrugging this off as just that are failing to ask one question - what happens when the attention stopped?Sooner or later,people would get tired of his act,stop finding him amusing,and move on.Given his disturbed,perhaps psychotic methods of seeking that attention,what might he do to get it back?
 
I would definitely enjoy a world without Internet retards. As others have said, this guy does not deserve Freedom of Speech.

Oh, and it isn't thought crime. He can keep his thoughts to himself. Or perhaps he could phrase them in a less specific manner.

So he doesn't deserve his freedom of speech because some stupid fucks believed that a guy making shock videos on youtube poison baby food? That's stupid. At the very most, he should have only been questioned and released once the cops see that he just making stupid videos for the internet.

Or we could continue with your logic and lock up anyone who says Judgement Day is coming or says that the Mayans said the end of days is in 2012, because well, you know, it freaks me the fuck out.
 
Obviously,the guy was looking for attention.But people who are just shrugging this off as just that are failing to ask one question - what happens when the attention stopped?Sooner or later,people would get tired of his act,stop finding him amusing,and move on.Given his disturbed,perhaps psychotic methods of seeking that attention,what might he do to get it back?

What the fuck is your point? Innocent until proven guilty. You don't lock people up "just in case".
 
What the fuck is your point? Innocent until proven guilty. You don't lock people up "just in case".

A. Everyone is innocent until proven quilty in the court of law. People still get locked up though now dont they?

B. People definitely do get locked up "just in case".


The Bill of Rights doesnt give you a free pass to be a complete retard. Act like an f'ing idiot and you'll be treated as such.
 
A. Everyone is innocent until proven quilty in the court of law. People still get locked up though now dont they?

B. People definitely do get locked up "just in case".


The Bill of Rights doesnt give you a free pass to be a complete retard. Act like an f'ing idiot and you'll be treated as such.

There is a big difference between direct and unmistakable threats and internet shenanigans amounting to fictional conspiracy.
 
A. Everyone is innocent until proven quilty in the court of law. People still get locked up though now dont they?

B. People definitely do get locked up "just in case".


The Bill of Rights doesnt give you a free pass to be a complete retard. Act like an f'ing idiot and you'll be treated as such.

Also, he was talking about if no one ignores him he may go unstable and do SOMETHING BOOGA BOOGA BOOGA. Not the fact that he made threats.
 
What the fuck is your point? Innocent until proven guilty. You don't lock people up "just in case".

Don't keep up much with the news,do you? Did you even read up on this guy? He wasn't out to make people laugh,there wasn't anything funny about how he presented his threats.Making terroristic threats on a public forum is illegal,period.It doesn't matter if he intended to carry them out,he broke the law and got arrested for it.His punishment is up to the courts.
 
Don't keep up much with the news,do you? Did you even read up on this guy? He wasn't out to make people laugh,there wasn't anything funny about how he presented his threats.Making terroristic threats on a public forum is illegal,period.It doesn't matter if he intended to carry them out,he broke the law and got arrested for it.His punishment is up to the courts.

That weird because the article even said some found it funny.

Some found his videos funny, but others were offended and plenty of "response" videos pepper the site.

But hey, if you think some guy on youtube who wears a goofy mask and claims to have given aids to hundreds of women and somehow controls the workers of Gerber, like he's some sort of real life Joker, I feel sorry for you.
 
That weird because the article even said some found it funny.



But hey, if you think some guy on youtube who wears a goofy mask and claims to have given aids to hundreds of women and somehow controls the workers of Gerber, like he's some sort of real life Joker, I feel sorry for you.


You don't see where the guy crossed the line. I suppose it is a matter of opinion, and taste whether he did or not. He may just have been doing it "all in good (if tasteless) fun".
However, he made a threat, when you make a threat, it is up to other people to try and decide if you are serious or not. If a few think you are, and go to the police, the police have to investigate. They have to take every precaution to insure that you are not actually going to carry out your threat.

If the guy is harmless he will spend a little time in city/county jail while they figure out that he really is harmless. Then he will be on his merry way. And he will prolly think long and hard about making threats in the future, he will not forget how gullible his fellow man can be..

If he is not harmless, well, then, the courts can figure out what to do with him.
 
Im all for spending a few of my taxpayer dollars to run this guy through the system and teach him a painful lesson about abusing your Internet anonymity.
 
Back
Top