4870 vs GTX 260...with overclocking.

Soodey

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 26, 2005
Messages
150
I know the HD4870 beats the GTX 260 in nearly all benchmarks at stock. But with the prices dropping like mad on the 260 I'm starting to consider it again.

My question is this:
How far can one expect to overclock each of the cards. I know overclocking is never guaranteed, every experience is different, yeah yeah yeah. Now I've heard people mentioning being able to overclock the 260 easily up to 280 levels, obviously the card is still limited by the physical architecture, but the performance gets pretty close or surpasses it.

However, I haven't heard much about how far the 4870 can overclock. I plan to edit the config/whatever to manually increase the fanspeed to get temps down to what we consider to be "normal" levels. But assuming that I'm willing to push each of the cards as far as they can go, without swapping out for a 3rd party cooler, which can I expect to see the greater performance out of?
 
well here is the thing the gtx 260 will most likly overclock 700 rock stable, well thats what most people get, and with gtx 280 the average overclock seems to be 670 or so, that is understandable as the the gtx 280 has 48 more shaders more rops and more texture units, at 700 the gtx 260 might be able to get the raw speed of gtx 280 but the minimum fps will still be higher with gtx 280 since it has more power under the hood.

none the less with price being good for gtx 260 it is a great buy.
 
I think the 4870 is superior especially with the Direct X 10.1 support.
 
show me 10.1 gaming and I'll show you 10.1 support for the GTX 260 :)
 
Several companies have committed to Direct X 10.1 including blizzard. Nvidia has publicly stated it will not support 10.1 and is going straight to directx 11.
 
well here is the thing the gtx 260 will most likly overclock 700 rock stable, well thats what most people get, and with gtx 280 the average overclock seems to be 670 or so, that is understandable as the the gtx 280 has 48 more shaders more rops and more texture units, at 700 the gtx 260 might be able to get the raw speed of gtx 280 but the minimum fps will still be higher with gtx 280 since it has more power under the hood.

none the less with price being good for gtx 260 it is a great buy.



my 4870 card came clocked at 750 factory settings and with the fan mod in the xml file it's idling temps are 45 to 47c down from 76c before increasing the fan speed 45 percent. Im not sure how well either card overclocks though. a distinct advantage of the 4870 would be its price 69 bucks less and even better if you buy it online, the 4870 card is also an inch and a half shorter than the gtx 260 card something alot of people dont think about before they buy one of these cards especially if you dont have a full tower sized case like. I have a stacker 830 and it can handle either card though but not everyone can say that. Drivers for both ati and nvidia cards are fairly new and therefore have opportunities im sure.
 
Most cards should be able to hit 700 core. Mine will do 750 and will do above that when I unlink the shaders, but when I go above 750, I get what seems like the downclocking issue.
 
^^^ You can't have too large of a difference between the shader and core clock or it will cause problems

Several companies have committed to Direct X 10.1 including blizzard. Nvidia has publicly stated it will not support 10.1 and is going straight to directx 11.

Game developers often do what NVIDIA wants. No Blizzard game looks that great graphically anway.

my 4870 card came clocked at 750 factory settings and with the fan mod in the xml file it's idling temps are 45 to 47c down from 76c before increasing the fan speed 45 percent. Im not sure how well either card overclocks though. a distinct advantage of the 4870 would be its price 69 bucks less and even better if you buy it online, the 4870 card is also an inch and a half shorter than the gtx 260 card something alot of people dont think about before they buy one of these cards especially if you dont have a full tower sized case like. I have a stacker 830 and it can handle either card though but not everyone can say that. Drivers for both ati and nvidia cards are fairly new and therefore have opportunities im sure.

The GTX 260 is slightly cheaper in most cases. Plus you get much better vendor support.
 
The GTX 260 is slightly cheaper in most cases. Plus you get much better vendor support.

Good vendor support + bad driver support or the contrary, hmm?

The probabilities of having a lemon are slim, while the thought of using Beta drivers as the only means of a good in-time driver... you'd have to live with that for the card's lifespan.

We haven't seen the 4870's real deal. I wonder what's the holdup for Rivatuner despite being promised a late July timeframe. Guess someone's being paid by an IHV on the opposing side now for a simillar clocking tool that the other guy doesn't matter at all, eh.
 
Game developers often do what NVIDIA wants. No Blizzard game looks that great graphically anway.

All the more reason to make it look better with Direct X 10.1, right?
According to Dave Baumann, Technical Marketing Manager at ATI Technologies Inc., Blizzard, EA, and Sega have signed onto a deal in which they will develop games that will use DirectX 10.1 technology, an API currently supported only by ATI's graphics cards.
 
I wonder what's the holdup for Rivatuner despite being promised a late July timeframe. Guess someone's being paid by an IHV on the opposing side now for a simillar clocking tool that the other guy doesn't matter at all, eh.

The rivatuner dude doesn't have a sample yet .
 
I think the 4870 is superior especially with the Direct X 10.1 support.
I have HD4870 but I couldn't care less for DX10.1 or DX10 because Vista is so damn expensive. Vista Home Premium is as expensive as HD4870 here. OEM versions are out of question because you aren't allowed to change your computers motherboard if you have OEM Vista.
 
Unwinder is on vacation. The next version of Rivatuner won't be out until mid August.

My 4870 does 800 / 1100 with fan set to 35%. Runs cool to, AMD really needs to officially release fan control because the 4870's actually run quite cool with a moderate increase in fan speed.
 
I have HD4870 but I couldn't care less for DX10.1 or DX10 because Vista is so damn expensive. Vista Home Premium is as expensive as HD4870 here. OEM versions are out of question because you aren't allowed to change your computers motherboard if you have OEM Vista.

I have before and haven't had any issues.
 
Simple fact is that banking on DX10 + PhysX or DX10.1 is pointless at this stage since neither have the wide support.

The other issue is that we don't know how much of DX11 is backwards compatible. DX11 states that it can be run on DX10 and DX10.1 hardware so that's a bonus. DX11 does state a tesselation unit so that seems to give an advantage to the 4800s in terms of future proof, but we don't know if the rest of the card is DX11 compliant. For that same reason, we don't know if CUDA is going to last since DX11 supposedly brings "Compute Shade" - in other words, MS's own standardized API for using shaders to perform calculations, so who knos if CUDA or PhysX will even last when DX11 comes out.

So my opinion: get the card you want most and stop worry about whether the card is future proof, cause technology isn't.
 
im going to be in the market for a new GPU when i get back from vacation in the end of august..

First i was going to get a 4870, but ive changed, and im going to be getting a 260. Reasons are

260 is cheaper with rebates as of now
260 is overclocking to around stock speed of 280 which is almost always faster than the 4870
260 has more memory, so that might help down the road
I wont feel like a beta tester with the 260, because there is no fan problem, and i can overclock it higher than 40mhz without flashing the bios

we´ll see what happens in a month..but if I were to buy today 260 would be my choice
 
All the more reason to make it look better with Direct X 10.1, right?

DX10.1 offers NO image quality differences. Period. It offers "cheaper" AA. i.e. AA with out as much horsepower required. Last I checked the only demanding game DX10.1 capable was AC, and that got "fixed" and DX10.1 is no longer avaliable with it.
 
I run both my 4870's at 850/1000. Don't want to push the memory past what it's rated. And 128 GB/s is lots of bandwidth anyway.
 
So what I've gotten so far from this thread is confirmation that the GTX 260's overclock like beasts. However, I haven't gotten much input from the 4870 crowd. Will the 4870 be able to overclock past what the GTX 260 can? I know the latest rivatuner isn't out yet, but aren't people still able to overclock using another program?

I've been NVIDIA my whole life, mainly because at the time of each of my purchases they've had the most appealing products. I can go either way with this one, just want to get the best performance of the two.
 
I have HD4870 but I couldn't care less for DX10.1 or DX10 because Vista is so damn expensive. Vista Home Premium is as expensive as HD4870 here. OEM versions are out of question because you aren't allowed to change your computers motherboard if you have OEM Vista.

yes, uhh vista was very expensive!:D
 
So what I've gotten so far from this thread is confirmation that the GTX 260's overclock like beasts. However, I haven't gotten much input from the 4870 crowd. Will the 4870 be able to overclock past what the GTX 260 can? I know the latest rivatuner isn't out yet, but aren't people still able to overclock using another program?

I've been NVIDIA my whole life, mainly because at the time of each of my purchases they've had the most appealing products. I can go either way with this one, just want to get the best performance of the two.

Obviosly not a 4870 owner here but from reading other threads written by 4870 owners here at [H] and xs 4870 pretty much flies by a stock 280 when @ to CCC limits. It would be very nice if 4870 owners posted some benchies here stock and @ clocked.
 
Obviosly not a 4870 owner here but from reading other threads written by 4870 owners here at [H] and xs 4870 pretty much flies by a stock 280 when @ to CCC limits. It would be very nice if 4870 owners posted some benchies here stock and @ clocked.

OCing one card and comparing it to a stock other card is a useless comparison. Compare stock to stock, or OC to OC, but otherwise its as useful of a statement as a geo metro going 80mph can pass a enzo going 60mph.
 
Soodey, if and when to you plan to purchase either the gtx260 or the 4870? No one can really give you a clear cut answer because the newest version of rivatuner is not out supporting higher oc of the 4870. Although no one can say for sure that it can oc higher, no one can also say for sure that it can't with the newest version of rivatuner and it may be better to wait for it to come out. Personally, I would say the gtx260 is the much higher ocer for now. Checking these forums as well as various others, in terms of core clock, stock gtx260 is 576 and the stock 4870 is 750. Ive sceen overclocks of the gtx260 all the way up to 750 (stable I think). As for the 4870, people in this thread have posted up to 850 (stable I would assume). So atleast in terms of core clock the gtx260 is the higher overclocker but it really depends on your card. Some people with a gtx260 haven't been able to get passed 700 core so I mean what can we say? It is all depending on your card. Also note that 4870 is compatible with more coolers (particularly the thermalright options) than the gtx260.

Honestly though, wait atleast until the 4870x2 to come out for the prices of the gtx260 and the 4870 to get lower and purchase either based on price.
 
^^^ You can't have too large of a difference between the shader and core clock or it will cause problems



Game developers often do what NVIDIA wants. No Blizzard game looks that great graphically anway.



The GTX 260 is slightly cheaper in most cases. Plus you get much better vendor support.

have not seen ANY WHERE that the nvidia card is cheaper
 
Obviosly not a 4870 owner here but from reading other threads written by 4870 owners here at [H] and xs 4870 pretty much flies by a stock 280 when @ to CCC limits. It would be very nice if 4870 owners posted some benchies here stock and @ clocked.


there are plenty of benchmarks from reputable sites across the web, I fail to see why anyone should waste their time posting more for either nvidia or ati cards, the info is out there you just have to google it.
 
So what I've gotten so far from this thread is confirmation that the GTX 260's overclock like beasts. However, I haven't gotten much input from the 4870 crowd. Will the 4870 be able to overclock past what the GTX 260 can? I know the latest rivatuner isn't out yet, but aren't people still able to overclock using another program?

I've been NVIDIA my whole life, mainly because at the time of each of my purchases they've had the most appealing products. I can go either way with this one, just want to get the best performance of the two.

Well I have no benchmarks for my 4870, but when I originaly had one installed I OC'd it to 800/1100, fairly easy OC too, I imagine my card has more room I didn't attempt to OC it anymore and the memory can't go above 1100 or it won't boot. When I installed my 2nd one the next day I removed all OC's and now run stock crossfire.

Both the 4870 and 260 OC pretty damn good.
 
there are plenty of benchmarks from reputable sites across the web, I fail to see why anyone should waste their time posting more for either nvidia or ati cards, the info is out there you just have to google it.

Links? Cause from the dozen or so reviews on the 4870 nowhere did I see a good oc comparison for it.
 
I had hd 4870, I tried overclocking with amd gpu tool and I was able to get 850, but after that the nightmare started happening, the card worked fine for 2 days at 850 and than I would get stuck pixels even in 2d, and artifacts in 3d, and than tried downclocking to 840/830/820 and no go, it actually used to pass atitool at 830 with 35% fan speed, it was not even stable in games at 810, and it would be stable at 790 though and anything higher I just could not get.

the sad part is while it was stable at 790 but it still gave me artifacts in atitool after a few mins, so I really dont recommend overclocking hd 4870 past 790-800

and no it does not fly by the gtx 280 at 790(total bull), only time it matches up is when you turn on 8xAA and in few games it is faster period.

my card only got slightly faster with 790 core clock and I would gain about 3fps on average in games.

the reason is simple, Nvidia cards benefit more from overclock than ati cards do, why? because you are raising the shader clock 2+mhz for each mhz on the core clock and that is why if you want to overclock nvidia card is the best way to go, because those shaders scream in games.

I returned my hd 4870 and got the gtx 280 now and it is really a great card, I got mine running at 692/1400/1250, my card is not the best overclocker but it is pretty damn fast, the shaders wont go any higher and I have to set the fan speed higher than auto in games, and I turn it down after I start gaming.
 
OCing one card and comparing it to a stock other card is a useless comparison. Compare stock to stock, or OC to OC, but otherwise its as useful of a statement as a geo metro going 80mph can pass a enzo going 60mph.

Wow. With all due respect sir, that is one of the more retarded statements I've ever seen on the internet. I mean really what IS the point in oc'in cheaper cards to see if they can match or exceed more expensive cards in terms of real world performance. Then what is the point of overclocking a cheaper q6600 past 3.2GHz when a $1500 QX9770 can obviously do 3.8GHz. Think of what you write before you put it down and hit post?
 
Wow. With all due respect sir, that is one of the more retarded statements I've ever seen on the internet. I mean really what IS the point in oc'in cheaper cards to see if they can match or exceed more expensive cards in terms of real world performance. Then what is the point of overclocking a cheaper q6600 past 3.2GHz when a $1500 QX9770 can obviously do 3.8GHz. Think of what you write before you put it down and hit post?


:rolleyes:


We are talking about price/preformance here.

Comparing the price/preformance of an overclocked card to the price/preformance of a stock card is worthless. If you are going to OC, you would OC either card you would buy, not just the cheaper one so you have to look at the OC ability of both cards not just the cheaper one.
 
:rolleyes:


We are talking about price/preformance here.

Comparing the price/preformance of an overclocked card to the price/preformance of a stock card is worthless. If you are going to OC, you would OC either card you would buy, not just the cheaper one so you have to look at the OC ability of both cards not just the cheaper one.


The reason it has a point to compare an OC 4870 to a stock GTX280 is because as far as this thread is concerned, we aren't comparing the 280 and 4870 anyway, we're talking 260 to 4870. :p That means anything else you compare it to in the context of this thread is pointless unless the other card is also compared to that same thing.

Someone earlier in this thread said the GTX260 could OC beyond the GTX280, so then it is natural to also compare the OC 4870 to a GTX280. ;)
 
The reason it has a point to compare an OC 4870 to a stock GTX280 is because as far as this thread is concerned, we aren't comparing the 280 and 4870 anyway, we're talking 260 to 4870. :p That means anything else you compare it to in the context of this thread is pointless unless the other card is also compared to that same thing.

Someone earlier in this thread said the GTX260 could OC beyond the GTX280, so then it is natural to also compare the OC 4870 to a GTX280. ;)

Core clock wise a 260 can go higher then a stock 280 but performance wise that will just bring it on par with a stock clocked 280. Here's fudzilla with their take on an @ 260.
 
Better how? Please elaborate in the multiple ways the 4870 is better than an overclocked 260.
4870 on average is cheaper, its faster by up^to 10% and when you apply AA its even faster than a 280 so its kinda hard to go with a 260 with all that
 
Thats the garantied performance of stock vs stock between the 2. You cant garanty that everyone who will buy a 260 in the hopes of getting close to 280 performance will be able to oc it.
 
I just ran auto-tune on my 4870, and it went to 780/1090.
 
Reasons to go with a 260 instead of 4870. Evga and XFX.
Reasons to go with a 4870 instead of 260. Intel motherboards.

I run my 4870s at 825core and 1100mem. Any higher and i start getting crashes. Need a volt mod. On water, at 100% load they run at 41c and 45c. NEED MORE VOLTAGE!!!

BTW, i'm on my 5th motherboard with the same OEM vista home premium 64 key. You dont have to activate it anymore with SP1.
 
Back
Top