Challenge: Beat my $460 Gaming System

Status
Not open for further replies.

Gaiden133

[H] Ninja
Joined
Aug 6, 2004
Messages
3,720
Hey all. Know there are some intelligent people here.

My sister's birthday is coming up and my brother, father and I are piecing together an upgrade for her.

She does gaming, will be using vista ult x64, photoshop work, etc. on a 22" monitor, so 1680 x 1050 res.

Anyway, the challenge is as follows:
  • Budget is a strict $460 MAX, including tax + shipping. MIR COUNTS towards total. So it can be 500, have 50 in MIR and still be good.
  • Popular retailer is fine, only restriction is that ALL components have to be bought from a single etailer. So all from newegg, or mwave, tigerdirect, zzf, etc.
  • All items have to be NEW. No open box/refurb.
  • The package is being delivered to 98006, tax from most sites are not applicable.
  • Keep in mind quality. a e8400, hd4850, $30 mobo, $10 PSU and bargain bin ram will not win the challenge. Don't sacrifice too much.
I only need:
  • Processor (has to be retail, not oem)
  • Mobo
  • PSU
  • Graphics Card
  • RAM
I will be reusing case, optical drives and HD (sata) from old setup.

Challenge: Come up with the best $460 performing system that will be the fastest in games/regular apps for the money.

This is what I have so far:
Post #24
  • Intel Core 2 Duo Processor E7200 & ECS GF7050VT-M Motherboard - $124.99
  • GIGABYTE GA-P35-S3G LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail - $74.99
  • Patriot Extreme Performance 4GB (2 x 2GB) - $77.99 - 20 MIR
  • Antec earthwatts EA430 430W - $64.99 - 30 MIR
  • ASUS EAH4850/HTDI/512M Radeon HD 4850 512MB - $187.99 - 30 MIR

That's it. Unless there's some insane combo that I don't know of yet, i think this build is pretty solid.

Total is 542.55 Shipped from Newegg - 80 MIR = $462.55 for one hell of a performance beast.

Still open to suggestions though.

Thanks :D
 
Are you staying away from Newegg Open Box? That will shave some cash off the motherboard.
 
You win. Click purchase and go! I doubt you're going to find better for less (than a few bucks).
 
There's a Fry's Electronics 8mi from 98006.

Fry's B&M:
$120 - E7200 + ECS GF7050
$25AR - Corsair 2GB DDR2-800
$120AR - XFX GeForce 8800GT 512MB
$45AR - Corsair 450W
======
$310

I guess you could upgrade the RAM to 4GB, lol, but not sure if rebate allows 2 submissions.
 
ATI 4850 w/ 2 gb OCZ ram ( 2x1) for 156 AR w/ free shipping
http://secure.newegg.com/Shopping/AddToCart.aspx?Submit=ADD&ItemList=Combo.114376

e8400 175 w/ FS
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115037

430W PSU ( Antec) 35 AR w/ FS
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817371006

GA-EP35-DS3L 94 shipped
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128337

Total is 460 exactly. if you wanted more memory you could go down to the e7200 and get 2x2 for 4gb. But for 30 more bucks ( from the 8800GT) you get a big jump in preformance for 30 bucks or so
 
There's a Fry's Electronics 8mi from 98006.

Fry's B&M:
$120 - E7200 + ECS GF7050
$25AR - Corsair 2GB DDR2-800
$120AR - XFX GeForce 8800GT 512MB
$45AR - Corsair 450W
======
$310

He needs 4GB of ram, and that ECS combo is just cheating. :p
 
He needs 4GB of ram, and that ECS combo is just cheating. :p

There's room for 2 more gigs, lol. That ECS combo works great, I've got one running right now. It can even OC that E7200, but he didnt' mention OC'ing, so it doesnt matter.
 
@ Stiletto : Thanks for the ZZF rig. Only thing is that I believe the 8800GT > 9600GT IIRC.

@ enginurd : Yep, there's a Fry's near me. Wouldn't mind picking it up in person.
Only thing is that there's tax applicable on that but no shipping!.. and sometimes prices in store don't reflect online -_-

Where are you getting those prices though? outpost?

and yes, this rig at least initially anyway would NOT be OC'ing. However, i don't want to pair it up with an ECS mobo and have problems down the road.. never used an ECS mobo and I hear it can go either way. opinions?

@ Rydawg : Sweet build. How are those lower end Antecs though? I think esp in Vista, 4GB of ram is almost a minimum though as I've ran it with 2 and it was slooow compared to 4 :D
 
I have a 430 and it works great with my 8800GT on girlfriends rig ( who games on 2 GB of ram with Vista and has no issues or speed)
 
@ Stiletto : Thanks for the ZZF rig. Only thing is that I believe the 8800GT > 9600GT IIRC.

Actually, performance wise they're about even at 1680x1050. Also mentioned the Earthwatts earlier so consider that two votes.
 
Forgot to add, why don't you want to order from different stores? You would probably save a good chunk of change
 
ECS boards, if kept at stock with intel chipsets are pretty good budget boards. Now, I realize this isn't an intel chipset, but it is for the intel platform, and its worked well for me so far. These are budget boards, so I wouldn't recommend OC'ing with them. However, they run great at stock. Even if you do run into problems down the road, the mobo is basically free anyway, so you could easily replace it later - but I doubt you'll have to if you keep the chip at stock speeds and have a good quality PSU.

I'm getting my prices from the LA Times and OC Register Fry's ads, lol. All these prices are B&M, not online. Even if something is no longer on sale, it still might fit into the budget. Just go down there and get the total price for everything I listed. If it comes out over budget after rebate/taxes, then don't buy it -- simple as that. You can actually check Fry's ads online. Just google for "Fry's ad" and you should get some results. I typically use www.frys-electronics-ads.com, but the OC Register and SJ Mercury websites work well, too.

Thats not a lower end Antec, its a lower power Antec. Lower end would be the Basiq lineup. The Earthwatts line is great, since most of it is OEM'd by Seasonic -- so they're quiet and have good enough quality.
 
Do you live near a Microcenter?

Nope, just fry's. (Seattle/WA)

Actually, performance wise they're about even at 1680x1050. Also mentioned the Earthwatts earlier so consider that two votes.

Good to know. Opinion wise though, is the Corsair 450VX any more future proof than the Antec?

Forgot to add, why don't you want to order from different stores? You would probably save a good chunk of change

I was thinking about that actually. Initially my father was going to pay for everything, but since I'll now be putting it on my CC.. IF you can provide a list that blows mine in comparison for equal or less cash, then I will consider doing separate stores. Else, it's just more of a hassle for me to track 5 different stores and pay CC with different stores. Again, they have to be reputable stores.
 
ECS boards, if kept at stock with intel chipsets are pretty good budget boards. Now, I realize this isn't an intel chipset, but it is for the intel platform, and its worked well for me so far. These are budget boards, so I wouldn't recommend OC'ing with them. However, they run great at stock. Even if you do run into problems down the road, the mobo is basically free anyway, so you could easily replace it later - but I doubt you'll have to if you keep the chip at stock speeds and have a good quality PSU.

Yeah since this is going to be her computer, and not mine to maintain, I really doubt I'll be OC'ing it. Is that e7200 in the package retail or OEM ?
 
... Good to know. Opinion wise though, is the Corsair 450VX any more future proof than the Antec?...

They're both made by Seasonic, but the Corsair is slightly better in quality. It also has a 120mm fan instead of an 80mm fan, so its more quiet, too.

edit: Just now checking the Fry's ad for today, and it looks like the Corsair PSU deal is over. I'm not sure what the in-store price is now, but you can drive over and check... still might be within budget (price might be $65).

Yeah since this is going to be her computer, and not mine to maintain, I really doubt I'll be OC'ing it. Is that e7200 in the package retail or OEM ?

Retail.
 
I think you got your build. I just tried to find cheaper items and I couldn't find anything really. GJ!
 
OK.. what about this now:

  • Intel Core 2 Duo Processor E7200 & ECS GF7050VT-M Motherboard - $119.99 + tax = 130.79 [Fry's]
  • Patriot Extreme Performance 4GB (2 x 2GB) - $77.99 - 20 MIR
  • Antec earthwatts EA430 430W - $64.99 - 30 MIR
  • ASUS EAH4850/HTDI/512M Radeon HD 4850 512MB - $187.99 - 30 MIR

$330.97 [ram,psu,videocard] + $6.99 [newegg shipping] + $130.79 [cpu,mobo] - 80 MIR = $388.75.

Holy. Shit. :eek:

Good call on that Fry's deal enginurd.. considering it'll be remaining at stock.. I think that is KILLER.. Only thing like I said, is that I hope that it won't give any problems as far as performance or reliability down the line.
 
Oh shitty. the ECS GF7050VT-M is a micro atx mobo. Hmm. Don't think it'll fit in the previous case as the case i'm reusing is an atx alienware tower
 
  • Intel Core 2 Duo Processor E7200 & ECS GF7050VT-M Motherboard - $124.99
  • GIGABYTE GA-P35-S3G LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail - $74.99
  • Patriot Extreme Performance 4GB (2 x 2GB) - $77.99 - 20 MIR
  • Antec earthwatts EA430 430W - $64.99 - 30 MIR
  • ASUS EAH4850/HTDI/512M Radeon HD 4850 512MB - $187.99 - 30 MIR

That's it. Unless there's some insane combo that I don't know of yet, i think this build is pretty solid.

Total is 542.55 Shipped from Newegg - 80 MIR = $462.55 for one hell of a performance beast.

Will be making the purchase in a day~ so if there's anything better, let me know

Special thank you to Rydawg, Stileto and enginurd for comments :D
 
if all you care about is the after rebate price, buy the memory and videocard combo i suggested earlier as the ram is basically free after rebate. And you can keep it for yourself!
 
if all you care about is the after rebate price, buy the memory and videocard combo i suggested earlier as the ram is basically free after rebate. And you can keep it for yourself!

Hmm very interesting.

Do you think that this set of buffalo firestix 2x1gb will play well with that set of OCZ ram (2x1GB) ? (just normal use, not heavy OC'ing or anything)

I ask, since I already have a pair of those Firestix modules just gathering dust, and that could save me some cash on buying 2x2GB and using the "free" OCZ for 4GB total.
 
Better to ask that to someone else, im just a interenet pricing whore!

I would think* so since both are ddr2-800. I've had some g.skill with some other types and seem to work good. Though i would wait for a word from one the more knowing peeps like eng.
 
Oh shitty. the ECS GF7050VT-M is a micro atx mobo. Hmm. Don't think it'll fit in the previous case as the case i'm reusing is an atx alienware tower

microATX is just a smaller version of ATX. The board length is cutoff at the 4th expansion slot, to fit in smaller cases. Since you have an ATX case, the mATX board will fit just fine. :D

Hmm very interesting.

Do you think that this set of buffalo firestix 2x1gb will play well with that set of OCZ ram (2x1GB) ? (just normal use, not heavy OC'ing or anything)

I ask, since I already have a pair of those Firestix modules just gathering dust, and that could save me some cash on buying 2x2GB and using the "free" OCZ for 4GB total.

Yes, they should play well together, but unfortunately, that ECS board only has 2 DIMM slots. :( So, you could sell those Firestix to help recoup the cost of the 2x2GB kit. ;)
 
microATX is just a smaller version of ATX. The board length is cutoff at the 4th expansion slot, to fit in smaller cases. Since you have an ATX case, the mATX board will fit just fine. :D



Yes, they should play well together, but unfortunately, that ECS board only has 2 DIMM slots. :( So, you could sell those Firestix to help recoup the cost of the 2x2GB kit. ;)

Gotcha :)

I think i'll stick with ponying up 70 for the Gigabyte board because I just know that it'll come to bite me later that I'll have to get a new board if she wants more sata ports/dimms/PCI slots :p

i did do a search on mixing brands of memory and a lot of people seem to advise against it, so I may just do 2x2GB kit to lessen hassle down the road.

In any case though, thanks for all the comments everyone.
 
The board is basically free, if you drive to fry's, so I'd still go for the E7200 from Fry's. If you don't want the extra board, there's a buyer for it in the FS/FT forums here ($25 shipped is the offer, PM me if you cant find the WTB thread). So, essentially, that chip would be around $110, depending on how much shipping will actually cost you.
 
Thanks everyone for all the comments :)

Pulled the trigger this morning and went with:

* Intel Core 2 Duo Processor E7200 & ECS GF7050VT-M Motherboard -
* GIGABYTE GA-P35-S3G LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard -
* Patriot Extreme Performance 4GB (2 x 2GB) -
* Antec earthwatts EA430 430W -
* SAPPHIRE 4850/HTDI/512M Radeon HD 4850 512MB -

Much props to all the help. Def glad I came here and i'm sure my sis will be too.

Thanks again. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top