Couple of midrange motherboard questions

Doogie2K

n00b
Joined
Jun 9, 2005
Messages
6
1) A friend of mine who works for a computer company (Voodoo) is a big proponent of the eVGA nForce 750i (actually, the 780i, but that's past $250 and that's well out of my price range). It's a bit pricier than the Intel P43/45 cards I had been looking at (~$200 vs. $100-$150), but he says that their techs had found the Intel chipsets tended to be buggier. Has this been others' experience? Considering my computer budget is targeted at $750-800, is it worth the extra dough? (Note: all prices Canadian, based on Memory Express and NCIX)

2) The procs I'm looking at are the E8400 or the Q6600, surprise surprise. Has anyone had problems with either of these procs working with the 750i? (Bearing in mind that, unlike most users of this board, I don't have much interest in overclocking.)

3) Do either the 750i or the P43/45 boot from the SATA optical drives?

For reference, the rest of the system: Corsair TX-650 PSU, OCZ Platinum 2x2GB PC2-6400 RAM, WD 640GB SATA2 HDD, Sapphire Radeon HD 4850; again, fairly standard choices from what I've seen.
 
1) I think the general consensus here is that the P35/45 chips are much better and cooler than their nvidia counterparts. So if you are not looking at SLi, then I would recommend you look at the cheaper p43/45 chips. I've not heard much about this "buggier" problem.

2) I dont own either chips nor a 750i so I cant comment on that, but I've seen many others with that combo with no problems.

3) my P35 and 780i both are able to boot off SATA optical drives. I dont see a problem unless theres a specific problem to a particular board.
 
1) WTF? It is widely known that Nvidia chipsets for Intel CPUs are more problematic than their Intel counterparts. Dunno what those techs have been doing but Intel chipsets are the better choice.

2) Before the release of the HD 4800 series, I did recommend the eVGA 750i FTW and the E8400/Q6600 to many others who wanted SLI. Haven't heard of a single problem with those combos

3) Both can do so.

So stick with the P43/P45 chipest. Besides SLI, there is no reason to go with an Nvidia chipset motherboard. They're usually less stable and reliable than their Intel counterparts. You'll won't see as much recommendations for an Nvidia motherboard if SLI wasn't a requirement.
 
1) WTF? It is widely known that Nvidia chipsets for Intel CPUs are more problematic than their Intel counterparts. Dunno what those techs have been doing but Intel chipsets are the better choice.

I was baffled by that myself, simply because of how bloody counterintuitive it is.

(On a side note, I've been perusing the various E8400 vs. Q6600 threads, and I think my head's going to issplode.)
 
(On a side note, I've been perusing the various E8400 vs. Q6600 threads, and I think my head's going to issplode.)

Yeah, as you can tell, there is no definitive answer to that debate. Just get the CPU that you think is the better choice and don't worry about anything else.
 
Just built an EVGA750i FTW Q6600, runs great. Yes, boots to sata dvd or cd.
 
So I guess the other related question would be, should I spend the extra dough on the P45 board, or just go with a P43? While I do plan on doing primarily gaming with the system, as stated above, I also don't have much intent to OC. The intended system build should appear in my sig here -- single GPU, single HDD, nothing fancy. I'm also seeing, upon browsing further, that the difference in price is more between the L and R models (at least for Gigabyte) than between P43 and P45. Is that what I should be more focused on?
 
I'm also seeing, upon browsing further, that the difference in price is more between the L and R models (at least for Gigabyte) than between P43 and P45. Is that what I should be more focused on?

Pretty much. The only difference between the P43 and the P45 chipset is that the P45 chipset has support for Crossfire. If you're not planning on a Crossfire setup, a P43 motherboard will be a good choice.

Some motherboard recommendations:
Gigabyte GA-EP43-DS3L Intel P43 Motherboard - $95
MSI P45 Neo3-FR Intel P45 Motherboard - $120
Gigabyte GA-EP45-DS3R Intel P45 Motherboard - $135
Asus P5Q Pro Intel P45 Motherboard - $150
DFI Lanparty DK X38-T2R Intel X38 Motherboard - $180
Asus P5E Deluxe Intel X48 Motherboard - $220
Gigabyte GA-X48-DS4 Intel X48 Motherboard - $225

Just to help you out: All of these motherboards have PCI-E 2.0 which may be useful for future GPU upgrades. If you don't need RAID, more than 6 SATA ports and only need semi-decent overclocking, check out the DS3L. If you need 8 SATA ports, RAID, 4 PCI slots, and legacy ports, then get the Neo3-Fr. If you don't need more than 6 SATA ports but want RAID, firewire, a second PCI-E x16 port, a second gigabit port, support for 16GB of RAM, optional eSATA, x8/x8 Crossfire, and high overclocks, then get the DS3R. If you like the DS3R but need 8 SATA ports, want an onboard pre-installed fast booting Linux setup, only need support for 8GB of RAM and don't need a second gigabit port, get the Asus P5Q Pro. If you want Crossfire with full x16/x16 bandwidth, get the Lanparty DK X38. Do note that the Asus website can be slow sometimes.
 
Back
Top