Best sub $200 video card?

Eiolon

Gawd
Joined
Apr 6, 2005
Messages
928
My 7800GTX has been good to me but it's time to move on. I have no more than $200 to spend and that needs to be the initial purchase price + shipping (no rebates please). I don't care if its ATI or nVidia.

Also, I won't have any monies to upgrade my PSU so it needs to run on what I have. Thanks!
 
HD4850 can be had for just under $200, how much better/easier choice can it get :)

99% of the recommendation should be the HD4850.

Heck I'll sell you an HD4850 in a couple days for $140 shipped :)
 
Looks like a lot of love for this card. Just to double check, does anyone see a reason why I would need a different PSU?
 
Looks like a lot of love for this card. Just to double check, does anyone see a reason why I would need a different PSU?
that single core cpu and 80gig hd would be the things I would worry about upgrading.
 
that single core cpu and 80gig hd would be the things I would worry about upgrading.

If he went for a CPU upgrade he would be overcharged out the ass for a 939 processor, it would be best if he tossed the motherboard and looked for a decent CPU+Mobo combo deal instead of just upgrading the CPU(939 can be so expensive that this option may even be cheaper)
 
I plan to build a new system at the end of the year so I've been holding off on it. Are you saying I would have a better performance if I upgraded the CPU and HDD over the video card?
 
I plan to build a new system at the end of the year so I've been holding off on it. Are you saying I would have a better performance if I upgraded the CPU and HDD over the video card?
no Im saying that an 80gb hd is small. also Im saying that you will be wasting quite a bit of the performance that the 4850 is capable of in modern games with a single core cpu. I promise that you will realize that when you build your new pc. ;)
 
that single core cpu and 80gig hd would be the things I would worry about upgrading.

+1, your PSU is fine for a 4850. You really need a dual core and a faster hard drive, the hard drive is the easier of the two here. If I were you I would replace that mother board and CPU (939 dual core CPUs run about as much as the pair) combo and just replace the whole thing.
 
If you want to wait to upgrade you can get a used 7800GTX for around 40 dollars shipped. Going SLI might hold you over til you can get some better funds. and most new games need a dual core CPU.
 
Though that PSU is rated 520W, it's an old design and only puts out 28A on the 12V. That's about what you'd see from a current 350W design. Guru3D recommends 30A minimum on the 12V line for stable operation. Seeing as his PSU is marginal on power to being with and now 4 yrs old, I wouldn't be surprised if some problems pop up. And +1 on the system refresh, 3700+ would really bottleneck a 4850.

OP if you really want an upgrade I would head off to CC and see if you can't pick up a 9600GT for $99. That's about the best vid card you can get that won't be too bottlenecked by your current setup.
 
Though that PSU is rated 520W, it's an old design and only puts out 28A on the 12V. That's about what you'd see from a current 350W design. Guru3D recommends 30A minimum on the 12V line for stable operation. Seeing as his PSU is marginal on power to being with and now 4 yrs old, I wouldn't be surprised if some problems pop up. And +1 on the system refresh, 3700+ would really bottleneck a 4850.
well with his current system that psu would be plenty. the 30 amp recommendation would be for a high end system with a quad core and such.
 
If you're going to do an overhaul later on this year, why not wait until then to buy the video card as well?

You will be able to buy it cheaper then, or possibly a better one for the same price you would pay today. You also won't have to worry about compatibility since you will be buying the other components at the same time, and can plan it properly.
 
well with his current system that psu would be plenty. the 30 amp recommendation would be for a high end system with a quad core and such.

No the recommendation was for a dual core system with a brand new PSU. Not a loaded out quad core rig.
 
I also recommend the 4850.



Really? Am I going to be able to run COD:world at war and Left4dead on my single core? I can't upgrade my CPU until next year :(

they might, but if they did it would be poorly. Most games are ment to run on two cores now, some are even starting to take 4 cores (they are out there a ways though) Really, for another 100 bucks you can get a new motherboard and CPU that would work. for 150 to 200 you could even get a decent setup
 
No the recommendation was for a dual core system with a brand new PSU. Not a loaded out quad core rig.
where does it say that? ..."In my view the Radeon HD 4850 series require you to have a 450 Watt power supply unit at minimum if you use it in a high-end system, and I think that's barely on the safe side. Also recommended is 30 AMP's on the 12 volts rails for stable power distribution (on a single card configuration). Notice that the card uses one 6-pin power connector."


also the OP does not even come close to having a system that would be considered high-end by todays standards.
 
where does it say that? ..."In my view the Radeon HD 4850 series require you to have a 450 Watt power supply unit at minimum if you use it in a high-end system, and I think that's barely on the safe side. Also recommended is 30 AMP's on the 12 volts rails for stable power distribution (on a single card configuration). Notice that the card uses one 6-pin power connector."


also the OP does not even come close to having a system that would be considered high-end by todays standards.

The test system he makes his recommendations on is a dual core system. Read through it instead of skimming over the details.

Just because his system isn't high end doesn't make it magically consume any less power. Single core A64 3700+ San Diego consumes more power than a high end duallie like an E8400. It has an 89W TDP as opposed to 65W because it's built on a 90nm process, 2 generations out of date. Power consumption for the NF4 board is similarly higher than on a P35/P45 board due to outdated construction methods and DDR1 RAM. On a whole his system is already consuming equal or greater power levels than a current "high end" system. Assuming the power draw is low purely because performance is subpar is naive.
 
The test system he makes his recommendations on is a dual core system. Read through it instead of skimming over the details.

Just because his system isn't high end doesn't make it magically consume any less power. Single core A64 3700+ San Diego consumes more power than a high end duallie like an E8400. It has an 89W TDP as opposed to 65W because it's built on a 90nm process, 2 generations out of date. Power consumption for the NF4 board is similarly higher than on a P35/P45 board due to outdated construction methods and DDR1 RAM. On a whole his system is already consuming equal or greater power levels than a current "high end" system. Assuming the power draw is low purely because performance is subpar is naive.
I see that the reviewer used an X6800 but he mentioned nothing about it in his assessment on choosing a PSU and he simply mentioned a high end system. the OPs system is very basic and is not even in the same realm as a high system.
 
Alright, how about we take this from a different angle.

All I play is The Witcher. I can run it at 1920x1200 with max settings and get 15fps avg. All I am looking for is to try and get a smoother game experience at this point. I hesitate to build a new system right now because there are no other games that I am interested in.

So basically, I am looking for a video card that will give me a higher frame rate and I am willing to shell out $200 for it. If it can be accomplished with a $100 9600GT then even better.

Thanks :)
 
Alright, how about we take this from a different angle.

All I play is The Witcher. I can run it at 1920x1200 with max settings and get 15fps avg. All I am looking for is to try and get a smoother game experience at this point. I hesitate to build a new system right now because there are no other games that I am interested in.

So basically, I am looking for a video card that will give me a higher frame rate and I am willing to shell out $200 for it. If it can be accomplished with a $100 9600GT then even better.

Thanks :)


i think you should get a $100 9600GT, and then use the other $100 to get a dual core opteron, then overclock...

i think that would prrolly hold you over for abnout 6 months.
 
add a seconded 7800GTX. 40 dollars.

other then that stay with the 4850. still the best bang for the buck and will meet your requirements. You will be CPU bound but it should be playable. then wait til you upgrade and you can take the card with you. The 9600GT is not the value that it was, even at a 100 bucks, and if your willing to do rebates then the 4850 has been seen for around 145 or so.
 
Alright, how about we take this from a different angle.

All I play is The Witcher. I can run it at 1920x1200 with max settings and get 15fps avg. All I am looking for is to try and get a smoother game experience at this point. I hesitate to build a new system right now because there are no other games that I am interested in.

So basically, I am looking for a video card that will give me a higher frame rate and I am willing to shell out $200 for it. If it can be accomplished with a $100 9600GT then even better.

Thanks :)

I'm curious, what kind of cpu utilization do you see while playing Witcher?
 
I 'd say 8800gts g92 or the 4850. I like the 8800gts g92 because it has a better cooler. I don't like the cooler on the 4850.
 
Have a Fry's nearby? E7200 + ECS mobo combo for $120, set bsel in bios to get over 3ghz stock voltage stock everything. Sell old stuff, buy $40 DDR2 2gb kit.

Buy a 9600gt for $100 or wherever you find that and that should last you quite a while.

And you're set, or just throw in a HD4850 and call it a day.
 
I'm running a 4850 overclocked 700/1150 with a dual core opteron 180@2.8, two 36 gig raptors/raid 0, and 5 case fans all on a 520 modstream, and not even a burp!
 
I am going for a 9800GTX+ for a $200 video card sometime soon. Yeah, not everyone is going to like it, but its faster in the games that I need the card for. Also runs cooler although you could just argue it produces the same amount of heat, but now adays dual slot coolers are becoming the rule, not the exception. Looking at the legit reviews review of the 9800GTX+, it seems like its the better overclocker (% wise) with the stock heatsink which is important to me since im going to overclock w/e card I get.

But then again the 9800GTX+ isn't available yet (haven't checked today) and its most likely going to retail for more, unless nvidia does something about that.
 
Though that PSU is rated 520W, it's an old design and only puts out 28A on the 12V. That's about what you'd see from a current 350W design. Guru3D recommends 30A minimum on the 12V line for stable operation. Seeing as his PSU is marginal on power to being with and now 4 yrs old, I wouldn't be surprised if some problems pop up. And +1 on the system refresh, 3700+ would really bottleneck a 4850.

OP if you really want an upgrade I would head off to CC and see if you can't pick up a 9600GT for $99. That's about the best vid card you can get that won't be too bottlenecked by your current setup.

Correct me if i'm wrong, but that sounds a little funny to me.

Watt=amp*volt

So 520watt/12v=43 amp.

Whereas:

350 watt/12V=29.2 amps.

These are maximum values of course. Do you mean to say that for the 520 watt PSU the maximum draw on any one power line is 28 amps, for a total combined maximum draw of 43 amps?

I found my 450 watt PSU was insufficient for my e8400 with a 8800 GT, and upgraded to a 600 watt unit, although it was a few years old and possibly not as good as when new. Seeing as how the power draw for his cpu and vid card are much higher than mine, I think he definitely needs a minimum 550 watt PSU. Probably better off with a 600 watt.
 
Correct me if i'm wrong, but that sounds a little funny to me.

Watt=amp*volt

So 520watt/12v=43 amp.

Whereas:

350 watt/12V=29.2 amps.

These are maximum values of course. Do you mean to say that for the 520 watt PSU the maximum draw on any one power line is 28 amps, for a total combined maximum draw of 43 amps?

I found my 450 watt PSU was insufficient for my e8400 with a 8800 GT, and upgraded to a 600 watt unit, although it was a few years old and possibly not as good as when new. Seeing as how the power draw for his cpu and vid card are much higher than mine, I think he definitely needs a minimum 550 watt PSU. Probably better off with a 600 watt.
Power supplies aren't that simple, as they have the different rails (3.3V, 5V, 12V) that they put power out on, as well as they vary in quality. A cheap generic 500W PSU might fry when it's only putting out 400W while a quality 400W PSU can put out 450W with no problem. When looking at PSUs, always look at the manufacturer. Also, the ratings given by manufacturers of hardware seem to follow generic PSUs to cover their asses. If you look at the actual power draw of systems in reviews, very few systems draw more than 400W at load, save for a new GTX 280 or HD 4870X2 (or similar high end SLI or Crossfire set-ups), and any quality 450W+ unit is more than sufficient for most systems.

To answer the OP's question, get a cheap intel CPU/mobo combo. Hell, you might be able to get a PSU in with that as well. If you can't do it now, wait. At the latest Black Friday (day after Thanksgiving Day) will have some great deals for sure :). It makes much more since to just save your cash and build a completely new system, and that way you'll reduce the chance of any kind of bottle-necking as well as see some major leaps and gains in performance.
 
Power supplies aren't that simple, as they have the different rails (3.3V, 5V, 12V) that they put power out on, as well as they vary in quality. A cheap generic 500W PSU might fry when it's only putting out 400W while a quality 400W PSU can put out 450W with no problem. When looking at PSUs, always look at the manufacturer. Also, the ratings given by manufacturers of hardware seem to follow generic PSUs to cover their asses. If you look at the actual power draw of systems in reviews, very few systems draw more than 400W at load, save for a new GTX 280 or HD 4870X2 (or similar high end SLI or Crossfire set-ups), and any quality 450W+ unit is more than sufficient for most systems.

I see - I suppose if there is any significant wattage draw at 3.3V/5V it must use up a lot of amperage. Never really looked too closely at that. I hear you on the quality of these units. My Antec 450W couldn't cut it for my setup, although generally Antec is supposed to be good. I bought the supply used though, so it may have had some issues. cheers :)
 
I see - I suppose if there is any significant wattage draw at 3.3V/5V it must use up a lot of amperage. Never really looked too closely at that. I hear you on the quality of these units. My Antec 450W couldn't cut it for my setup, although generally Antec is supposed to be good. I bought the supply used though, so it may have had some issues. cheers :)
I find it hard to believe that an Antec 450W couldnt handle your very basic setup. Even most generic 450W power supplies should handle 250 watt load. Hell look at my comp that I am now using a 9600gt with on the stock generic 300 watt psu with no probs whats over.
 
I find it hard to believe that an Antec 450W couldnt handle your very basic setup. Even most generic 450W power supplies should handle 250 watt load. Hell look at my comp that I am now using a 9600gt with on the stock generic 300 watt psu with no probs whats over.
The PSU might have been bad for the start. Also, it was a few years old and could have started to give. I know Antec had some trouble with its PSUs a few years ago (TruePower II I think, please correct me if I'm wrong). Like most computer hardware, there's always many factors that can contribute to the problem :eek:.
 
9800GTX+ if you're very pro nvidia and want their vendor support. Else, go with the 4850.
 
Back
Top