5 in 3 SATA Backplanes, anyone use them?

Zepher

[H]ipster Replacement
2FA
Joined
Sep 29, 2001
Messages
21,887
I am looking at adding 2 more drives to my machine, I already have 8 inside and I don't want to double stack them in the rear since they will get quite hot.

I was looking at this Athena SATA Backplane,
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817995001

And this ICY Dock SATA Backplane,
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817994028

They are quite pricey as well. I am not sure which one to get and if there is another brand that is cheaper with good build quality.

This is what the drive configuration looks like right now,
4 IDE and 4 SATA, and will be adding 2 more SATA drives so I will need to get a SATA card as well.
8-drives-1.jpg


8-drives-3.jpg
 
The cost of the "5 in 3"s is about $20/drive. The cost for an SATA card is about $25/drive.

It may be more cost effective to simply buy larger drives and copy the contents of the smaller drives to the larger drives.

---

Your case has very poor cooling. My case has 1/4" between drives - 11 drives, and they never get too hot. Perhaps you should work on cooling first.
 
You should check directron, they have those Athena units for $92 each right now.

Yeah, I use these things like they are going out of style... search up for the galaxy project on the forums... it should give you many ideas.

If you want to save cash and are just looking for high density, checkout calpc's 5 in 3 fixed cooled unit.
 
Just shot you a PM, read it and see where it goes...

I have used both Athena and Icy Dock backplanes and I liked the feel of the drive sleds better in the Icy Dock, but the cable management was AWFUL!!!! I Like the way that the Athena are very short, do not take a lot of room in the case and wire management is beautiful!!
 
Ockie, I've read your worklogs in the past and they were very informative. I had forgotten about them until you posted and givrieze PM'd me.
btw, I LOVE cube cases. ;)

givrieze, I just finished reading your Plutonium 3 log and that is a beast as well. I replied to your PM.


GeorgeHR, the drives stay cool and if you look at the back of the case, you can actually put 8 drives back there but each pair will be almost touching.
 
I have 2x Supermicro M35T (1 in file server and 1 in Windows box) and an Adaptec 335SAS (in the fileserver). I effing love hot swap! :D
 
Just for those who may be looking at this thread but don't want to shell out for a 5in3, Kingwin has a trayless 4in3 (or similar 3in2) that I'm a huge fan of. It can't match the density of a 5in3, so it's not as good for a 20 drive setup or similar, but for a smaller number it's great. I love the trayless aspect, and it's pretty solid build quality, as well as being only $70 (compared to $100-140 for 5in3s).
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817990004
 
I have the tray-less units also, they are awesome. I really wish that they had made them in 5in3's, I would be all over them.
 
There's something fun about just taking a bare hard drive and just sliding it in as needed. Like a 1TB zip disk (but thankfully more reliable haha).

If I ever wanted to do a heavy duty home backup system, I'd just put trayless single caddies in all my systems and a bunch of bare drives.
Combined with a good Pelican case (and some anti-static bags) I'd have a very effective mechanism to do offsite backups - swap the drives and have them do incremental 1:1 images overnight - any failure and you're back up in as long as it takes for you to put a drive in the tray and switch your boot order.
 
There's something fun about just taking a bare hard drive and just sliding it in as needed. Like a 1TB zip disk (but thankfully more reliable haha).

If I ever wanted to do a heavy duty home backup system, I'd just put trayless single caddies in all my systems and a bunch of bare drives.
Combined with a good Pelican case (and some anti-static bags) I'd have a very effective mechanism to do offsite backups - swap the drives and have them do incremental 1:1 images overnight - any failure and you're back up in as long as it takes for you to put a drive in the tray and switch your boot order.


You can get plastic storage cases for hard drives, they look like vcr boxes.
 
You can get plastic storage cases for hard drives, they look like vcr boxes.
I've seen those, look okay but not as sturdy as I'd want for harddrives (fine if they're just sitting in a box on a shelf). I like the idea of a Pelican case for offsite transport however. They're pretty much indestructible.

Of course all of this is all just imaginary for me. The amount of actual data I have that would require true failsafe backup is small enough that some DVDs and emailing copies to my Gmail account is sufficient. The rest is just music and videos that are expendable (a hassle, but the only thing I lose is convenience).
 
I am moving my file server to the new Norco rack mount case and selling my 5>3s for a good price, pm me if interested......
 
I have 2 of the Athens that was listed in the first post, and have had a few odd problems.

On a Nforce4 raid controller the drives would intermittently drop, while the same drives on a Areca 1220 never had an issue. (also didn't have any issues with the old Dell sata raid that I had too)

Just a FYI...
 
I have 2 of the Athens that was listed in the first post, and have had a few odd problems.

On a Nforce4 raid controller the drives would intermittently drop, while the same drives on a Areca 1220 never had an issue. (also didn't have any issues with the old Dell sata raid that I had too)

Just a FYI...

Ive heard that if you change the signaling speed from 3.0gbs to 1.5 gbs it solves those intermittent problems.
 
Ive heard that if you change the signaling speed from 3.0gbs to 1.5 gbs it solves those intermittent problems.

I didn't see anything in the "documentation" that came with the backplanes, you know what the jumpers are for that? I'd like to run a test and see if still does it before I commit all my new drives and such to a permanent home.
 
What's the noise level on those 5-in-3 enclosures? I just replaced 12 400GB drives with 1TB ones (at work) and now have all the 400's and no place to put them.

I have a spare Silverstone TJ03 (which I got because it seemed appropriate and functional, which it really wasn't, the TJ07are far better, imho anyway), and I have been stacking those 400's into that, but the just the drive noise propagates through the entire case and makes it unsuited for under-the-desk placement.

When using HDD coolers no-name version of the ZALMAN ZM-2HC2 NP the drives are quiet, but I can only reasonably fit 5 into the case.

How much noise do the 5-in-3 enclosures create in terms of fan noise?
 
How much noise do the 5-in-3 enclosures create in terms of fan noise?

IMHO, Alot. My server box is about double the noise when I had them in bays, but now I can have 16 drives in this box if I need, so it was worth it.

I saw, I think on here somewhere, were someone put in quiet fans, it may not be a big deal to swap.
 
The 92mm exhaust fans on the swap bays I have are pretty damn loud on full blast. My file server is under the house so I don't really care about noise there. I have the fan on the M35T in my Windows box plugged into the motherboard and I run it at 60% from the BIOS in order to maintain a quiet system.
 
How much noise do the 5-in-3 enclosures create in terms of fan noise?

Depends which units you are buying, if you buy the istarusa, buffalo, etc, they are not very loud and they have a selective switch on them. Icydocks are a little louder. Supermicro units are very loud.
 
Depends which units you are buying, if you buy the istarusa, buffalo, etc, they are not very loud and they have a selective switch on them. Icydocks are a little louder. Supermicro units are very loud.

Plutonium with the Supermicro backplanes on their low fan speed setting was pretty quiet, I and friends thought, when I put them on high, the noise went way up......
 
I have a 3 in 2 backplane in my server, along with a sata conroller card, I think an 8 port?

I am liking my back plane. I plan to add another when I am in need of the space.
 
Another +1 for the supermicros. The very first thing I did was replace the fan with a slower panaflo.
 
I tried the IcyDock 5 in 3 and it did not work out for me. I have 4 samsung drives and 1 seagate, all 500GB 3.0Gbps. It kept saying the seagate drive was faulty, which wasn't the case.

Aside from that, the icydock one was made of plastic and just felt cheap.

I would go for the Supermicro CSE-M35T. Its sturdy and works perfectly.
 
I have two of these things in an old Enlight server case:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817990004

When I got these, Frys had them for <$100 each in store (They also had WD10EACS 1TB OEM drives for cheap at the time). If you rate the build quality of a HP/Compaq OEM rail setup at 10/10, these things are 8/10. They are aluminum, have a fan and seem to be stable, but they are not what I would call industrial.

My major focus was getting my server as quiet as possible as it was becoming a marital issue. The fans that come in the unit are pretty noisy. They are an extra thin 80mm fan. There is a switch that is selectable from low to high. I origonaly used one of these Silenx things as it was the only quiet, thin fan I could find:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835226002

Then they started crapping out. If you look at the Newegg forum, lots of people are having trouble with these things. I did some examination of tolerances and you can fit a full sized fan in there, so I got two of these dual ball bearing thermaltakes:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835999111

I initially used the temperature sensor on the fan, but it was letting the drives get too hot, so I changed over to using the pot to control the fan RPM. I can set these where they are fiarly quiet and keep the drives reasonably cool. While I was at it, I snipped out the plastic finger guard that was molded into the back cover of the unit and drilled out the mounting holes for the fan (the old holes won't work as they are for a weird screw that will only mount a 15mm fan). I put one of those standard wire finger guard things on it and attached the new fans with the fat "fan screws" that came with it. I drilled out a hole in the case to mount the speed pot and hot-glued it in. I can now twiddle the fan speed without removing the bays from the case.

I'm certain a panaflow or something like that could be a better fan, but that is what Frys had in stock the day I went.... It is nice to have a more granular speed control.

If I get a chance, I will post some pictures.
 
I have 3 of the Supermicro units in the link below and I changed the fans out for the 92mm fan that I have also linked. I do have to give credit to Ockie for the idea. I have a CM Stacker holding them. Its super quiet and never had one problem. The build quality is great.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817121405

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835185066


I've used these before as well, overall pretty pleased with them. My friend built a server with 25 drives and these, other than the loud fan which is easy to swap, they are rock solid. I'm curious though as I'm going to use one of these on my new setup, if these support sata2, or are they limited to 150?? Gonna raid5 5x seagate 1.5tb drives when they come out hopefully on an areca 1220 :D
 
I have 3 of the Supermicro units in the link below and I changed the fans out for the 92mm fan that I have also linked. I do have to give credit to Ockie for the idea. I have a CM Stacker holding them. Its super quiet and never had one problem. The build quality is great.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817121405

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835185066

+1
Following that suggestion I bought a couple of those Supermicro enclosures and the fans to go with it, and I am just oh-so-pleased.

Thanks a lot Ockie!

Those things are awesome. They are not totally silent, but they are vey very very quiet, certainly below ambient noise (unless it's the middle of the night and all is quiet) at 3ft. The airflow those fans deliver is pretty awesome as well.

This setup is also great for testing things out without to actually place the enclosure inside of the case (if you just want to monkey with things). Totally awesome product combo and advice, thanks again!
 
Back
Top