Okay: My first RAID experience, I'm screwed !!

sram

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Jul 30, 2007
Messages
1,854
I was happily opening my two velociraptors boxes, and was really excited about putting them in a RAID0 configuration. Probably not worth it, but that's not the topic now. I re-read through this:

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1296887

and started working. It is not much to do. I just installed the two drives, changed my bios to raid mode and got into the raid configuration page and created my raid0 volume(straight forward) However, problems started after this. I couldn't get into windows! post will reach just before my boot menu, and will just sit there and I won't even be able to restart using ctrl + alt + del.

I will keep this short to see if my conclusion is right: After all sort of stupid problems I decided to uninstall my two velociraptors and only kept my hitachi drive with windows xp on it. I reset bios to normal mode and was able to get into windows. With things back to normal, I decided to use the raid mode with my hitachi drive being the only one installed. (It should WORK, right?) I rebooted and was shocked by a BSOD a moment after windows logo appeared. This same BSOD was occuring in several scenarios while I was suffering to run my first RAID.


Conclusion: My RAID controller/software RAID/ Whatever it is that is handling RAID in my P35-DQ6 is screwed/bad.

Now, is my conclusion right? And what is really this AHCI mode you see in the BIOS?
http://i51.photobucket.com/albums/f399/gholy/BIOS017.jpg

Other questions:

You can hook your two raid0 drives to just any sata port, and it should work out, right?

Is there any difference between the orange sata ports and the purple ones:
http://img204.imageshack.us/img204/8979/giga1un4.jpg

http://www.3dnews.ru/_imgdata/img/2007/06/15/51394.jpg
??

I think i'm not very lucky with this board!
 
The fakeraid drivers and AHCI drivers are different. The BSOD was most likely caused because Windows wasn't trying to use the correct driver. You need to keep the boot drive on the same controller (driver) or reinstall/repair.
 
The fakeraid drivers and AHCI drivers are different. The BSOD was most likely caused because Windows wasn't trying to use the correct driver. You need to keep the boot drive on the same controller (driver) or reinstall/repair.

I tried to install windows xp with the three drives connected and the raid mode on, and I also got a BSOD after setup is done loading files and was about to start windows.

What do you mean keep the boot drive on the same controller?? What is a controller in this case?? You know, it is connected to one of these orange sata ports and nothing else is installed in any other port.

I can't believe it is a configuration problem, there must be something wrong with my raid controller.
 
Intel does not guarantee that changing the BIOS setting after installing Windows will work. That's on their web site. It's not a problem with the RAID controller nor with the drivers. You just can't change the BIOS from IDE to RAID or to AHCI nor AHCI to RAID etc without re-installing the OS. That's why, if you have the appropriate Intel IHCx controller, I recommend setting it to RAID up front, since RAID includes AHCI.

You have to set up the drive configuration and then install Windows.

The purple SATA ports are controlled by the JMicron controller. Don't use it for your primary SATA drives, since it is the PATA controller and if you have any PATA devices, you can't run SATA reliably from the JMicron controller. Been there, done that...

Use the yellow/orange ports. They are controlled by the IHCx controller. Put all your SATA devices on those. You can set the BIOS to RAID and then use the RAID configuration utility (<ctrl><i> when you boot up) to select which drives are in a RAID array and which are not. You can mix freely, so you can have the v-raptors in RAID and the Hitachi non-RAID.
 
I agree. It's a bad idea to setup/enable a RAID after OS installation, even if it isn't the drive/OS affected.
 
Don't follow his "instructions." He follows a mess of attempts and does things in odd orders. You'll note he installs with SATA set to IDE and then swaps to RAID and has trouble. Intel states clearly this is not supported.

1 - Use the Intel SATA controller for all SATA devices if possible.
2 - Use the JMicron (Gigabyte) controller for PATA or SATA but not both. If you use it for both, SATA on these ports seems to require IDE mode only. Other configurations don't always work with things like DVD drives. If you have DVD/CD drive problems look at this.
3 - Set the Intel controller to RAID if that setting clearly supports RAID+AHCI. Older ICH7 and older don't or only with certain other chipsets or something - not sure what combination is significant. ICH8 and newer probably do. RAID+ACHI means you can run ACHI now and add RAID drives later without re-installing Windows.
4 - Make sure you get the Intel drivers on a floppy - the last machine I built I scrounged a floppy drive for the sole purpose of doing this and took the drive out afterwords.
5 - Make sure you install the drivers (F6) at the start of the install process. Hitting F6 doesn't make things happen immediately - hit it immediately and wait till you're prompted for further action.
6 - When you reboot for the first time, you may need the stupid floppy on that reboot. That happened to me once and I can't explain why. It was happy after that.
7 - Enjoy.
 
It seems like I have some work to do. I'll need to rest now. I'll play with it later and report back.


Thanks to all.
 
Don't follow his "instructions." He follows a mess of attempts and does things in odd orders. You'll note he installs with SATA set to IDE and then swaps to RAID and has trouble. Intel states clearly this is not supported.

1 - Use the Intel SATA controller for all SATA devices if possible.
2 - Use the JMicron (Gigabyte) controller for PATA or SATA but not both. If you use it for both, SATA on these ports seems to require IDE mode only. Other configurations don't always work with things like DVD drives. If you have DVD/CD drive problems look at this.
3 - Set the Intel controller to RAID if that setting clearly supports RAID+AHCI. Older ICH7 and older don't or only with certain other chipsets or something - not sure what combination is significant. ICH8 and newer probably do. RAID+ACHI means you can run ACHI now and add RAID drives later without re-installing Windows.
4 - Make sure you get the Intel drivers on a floppy - the last machine I built I scrounged a floppy drive for the sole purpose of doing this and took the drive out afterwords.
5 - Make sure you install the drivers (F6) at the start of the install process. Hitting F6 doesn't make things happen immediately - hit it immediately and wait till you're prompted for further action.
6 - When you reboot for the first time, you may need the stupid floppy on that reboot. That happened to me once and I can't explain why. It was happy after that.
7 - Enjoy.


Which intel driver are you talking about here? The intel driver for the raid controller? Where can I get it? Should it be in the mobo cd? or should I go to intel's website and get it from there?

Thanks.
 
Which intel driver are you talking about here? The intel driver for the raid controller? Where can I get it? Should it be in the mobo cd? or should I go to intel's website and get it from there?

Thanks.

You need the Intel AHCI or RAID drivers when installing Windows XP.
 
If you are installing XP on the drives in AHCI mode you will need this driver on a floppy or slipstreamed into your copy of XP. Slipstreaming can be difficult but I recommend nlite (nliteos.com) as a utility that makes this simple.

Your board has 2 raid controllers
The orange ports are hooked to the intel chipset
The Purple ports are hooked to the gigabyte Chipset

If you only intend to use 2 drives in raid I would just hook them to the gigabyte chip and raid 0 them on their own chipset. Then I would go ahead and use your intel chipset for the OS drive as I am assuming that your OS is on a separate sata drive from what you have explained thus far. If you want more expansion capabilities for RAID in the future then I would switch things around where the OS is on the gigabyte controller and the raid is on the intel controller. Do set whichever controller you are using for your OS drive to legacy/IDE in the bios and you will not need any drivers or any slipstreaming and you may not have to reinstall windows if it is not already too corrupted.

I hope this helps. I have a raid 5 running on my intel chipset with my DQ6 and my OS is running in AHCI mode on the gigabyte chipset. i did use nlite to slipstream my drivers into my XP cd for ease of use and since I did not have a floppy.

Here is an article on slipstreaming that is old but has some links to more updated information as well. A good starting point if you are trying to put your OS on your velociraptors.

http://www.maximumpc.com/article/How-To--Slipstream-your-XP-installation
 
Okay. All is well now. I was able to install winxp64 on my raid0 volume. I now have a question: From within windows, the Raid volume is viewed just like a single physical disk, which I can partition freely using my favorite partitioning software....right? I want to split the ~555 GB volume into two 270GB partitions to dual boot vista and xp............I can do this right?

Thanks.
 
Okay. All is well now. I was able to install winxp64 on my raid0 volume. I now have a question: From within windows, the Raid volume is viewed just like a single physical disk, which I can partition freely using my favorite partitioning software....right? I want to split the ~555 GB volume into two 270GB partitions to dual boot vista and xp............I can do this right?

Thanks.

Yes you can do that...I did that for a while on my box but I wanted the space for other things, and ive found that running a vm is just as good if not better than dual booting
 
correct. What steps did you take to get it working? Also, your raid controller can make multiple volumes within the array if you wanted instead of seperating it with partitions. However this step is even more destructive than repartitioning if you need to change it.
 
correct. What steps did you take to get it working? Also, your raid controller can make multiple volumes within the array if you wanted instead of seperating it with partitions. However this step is even more destructive than repartitioning if you need to change it.


Here is what I did:

I have three drives. Two velociraptors and 1TB hitachi partitioned into c: which has windows in it and D: I disconnected the hitachi drive. I installed the two Vraptors ino two orange sata ports, went into BIOS and selected RAID mode after which I was able to get into the RAID configuration page using ctrl+I and created raid0 volume with the maximum possible capacity. (I did notice that I can create a smaller volume).

In another machine, I went to giga-byte's p35-dq6 page and downloaded the sata raid driver for winxp64. It was a self-extracting file. I extracted it into one empty floppy disk. I now have a floppy disk ready with the raid driver. I then inserted the windows xp64 cd and started the installation. I pressed f6 and at the end I was prompted to install the driver I want from the floppy. I did that(there was more than one driver........I had to choose the one before the last) and then the installation continued smoothly with no problems. I then opened my case and connected the hitachi drive. Started the machine and all my drives were correctly detected.

That's how and sorry for the bad english.

Interesting question: How much different it is to create two ~275 GB volumes from repartitioning the 556GB volume into two ~275 GB partitions
 
I agree that it is an interesting question. I would guess that it would gum up the works by adding more data to be managed per second causing a bottleneck somewhere since the raid chips on that board are not fully managed in hardware. It would be something to experiment with if I didn't have too many drives dedicated to raid 5 configurations anyway. Really though the best bet is just to create a partition as they can later be re-sized without losing any data with the right software. It would be interesting though to see some benchmarks between the two! And your English is excellent! Especially on such a technical topic I would not have guessed that it might not be your first language if you had not said so.
 
so basically.....you had to reinstall windows?

I had my first RAID experience as well..with xp (which forced me to use vista64 as I didn't have a floppy drive at the time nor did I want to use one). It took awhile for me to figure out setting the mode....and then setting up the array.

Did you find out why you couldn't boot into windows. What i beleive, and sorry if someone said this already...i just read your initial post and a few others....is that after setting the controller to RAID, that messed up the active/primary drive. Someone correct me if I am wrong, regarrdless, glad you got it working. Was going to get a velociraptor for myself but will stick with my raptorx's annoying noises
 
What i beleive, and sorry if someone said this already...i just read your initial post and a few others....is that after setting the controller to RAID, that messed up the active/primary drive.

I think that the actual problem is within windows, not which drive is plugged in where. The boot drive is all controlled from within the BIOS so it should not matter. What happens when a drive is switched from IDE mode to AHCI/SATA mode is that windows no longer understands how to interface with the drive unless the proper boot drivers have been installed. The problem is once you try to boot windows like this it tends to corrupt itself, the last time something like this happened to me windows' HAL.DLL file corrupted which is basically irreparable. I believe the OS drive could have been moved to any sata controller that was set to legacy IDE mode and worked fine.
 
What happens when a drive is switched from IDE mode to AHCI/SATA mode is that windows no longer understands how to interface with the drive unless the proper boot drivers have been installed.

exactly....:D

Thanks!
 
Back
Top