iPhone 3G Improved, But Still Flawed

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Not to discourage anyone standing in line for one of the new 3G iPhones or anything but the reviews for the next-gen Apple phone aren’t that great. It seems new buyers will be happier than people that are upgrading and battery life, among other things, seems to be big concern.

The New York Times' David Pogue, Wall Street Journal's Walt Mossberg and USA Today's Ed Baig, the Holy Trinity of Apple's marketing department, all received the phone about two weeks ago. (Most other reviewers, including ours, will have to wait with everyone else to buy one tomorrow morning.) All three reviewers liked the first generation iPhone and they all like the second generation even better.
 
Sadly, none of these reviews will amount to a hill of beans: those who want to waste, er spend their money on a iAnything will do so, no matter how craptastic a review portrays the product to be. It could be a steaming turd and someone is going to buy it. (dare I say iTurd? ROFL) I'm sure there will be a handful of people who bought the last iPhone and are going to sue/demand/boycott/B&M because of price differences, etc.
 
What gives you the impression that the reviews aren't that great? Sounds like your taking your own spin on their words. I didn't expect the battery life to be better, so I'm realistic about the device. It's a well known fact that 3g uses more power then edge, sounds kind of duh to me.

The article even says that they liked the first generation, but liked the second generation better.

They can't fit EVERYTHING into the phone, come on. Voice dialing, crappy camera, yeah iphone has it, but its still hands down the best phone device out there IMO.

None of those complaints, though, seriously dimmed the reviewers admiration of the new iPhone. "While not everything on my wish list made it onto the new device," Baig says, "Apple has raised the bar with iPhone 3G. To which I offer an enthusiastic thumbs up."

last para from the review itself. Include that on the front page.
 
They can't fit EVERYTHING into the phone, come on. Voice dialing, crappy camera, yeah iphone has it, but its still hands down the best phone device out there IMO.
.

Another zealot...

My old phone has more features, and it's 4 years old.
 
What gives you the impression that the reviews aren't that great? Sounds like your taking your own spin on their words. I didn't expect the battery life to be better, so I'm realistic about the device. It's a well known fact that 3g uses more power then edge, sounds kind of duh to me.

The article even says that they liked the first generation, but liked the second generation better.

They can't fit EVERYTHING into the phone, come on. Voice dialing, crappy camera, yeah iphone has it, but its still hands down the best phone device out there IMO.

None of those complaints, though, seriously dimmed the reviewers admiration of the new iPhone. "While not everything on my wish list made it onto the new device," Baig says, "Apple has raised the bar with iPhone 3G. To which I offer an enthusiastic thumbs up."

last para from the review itself. Include that on the front page.


Sounds like that is what you are going. They are saying "bad" things about them while saying theying they are happy with it. That isn't a good review in my opinion, it is a basis one. Just like you are doing. Apple fanboys can't and won't give an honest opinion about a apple device. Thus your "but its still hands down the best phone device out there IMO" isn't really a opinion, it is the idea that is stuck in your head due to brain washing.

Ok, so the battery can't last the entire work day. I don't care if this is due to the phone, the network or both. If you can't use your phone for more than a few hours before it is dead that is a problem. I don't care if you knew that is how it would be, or if you accept it, that doesn't change the fact that it is a negative for the device. Just like how only having 512 MB of storage is a negative for the Wii. I still have one and like it, but I still consider that a negative. GPS doesn't work in a lot of places or from the sounds of it, in most places. Important phone calls get droped so much that you have to borrow some strangers phone to finish the call. I'm sorry isn't that the point of a phone to be able to use it to make calls. That alone screams stay away from me, what the hell good is a phone if you can't use it to make calls. So what if it is pretty or slick, if the damn thing can't be used as a reliable phone then it is worthless.
 
Another zealot...

My old phone has more features, and it's 4 years old.

Sorry no, I don't own the first gen, nor plan on buying the second gen. I'm not on some miracle ibandwagon riding a wave that is iApple. I do really like technology and electronics though. I have tested and used the first gen iPhone for 2 months though and was very pleased with it.

As a mass consumer device, price and At&t aside it's loads of fun and performs remarkably well.
 
Sounds like that is what you are going. They are saying "bad" things about them while saying theying they are happy with it. That isn't a good review in my opinion, it is a basis one. Just like you are doing. Apple fanboys can't and won't give an honest opinion about a apple device. Thus your "but its still hands down the best phone device out there IMO" isn't really a opinion, it is the idea that is stuck in your head due to brain washing.

Ok, so the battery can't last the entire work day. I don't care if this is due to the phone, the network or both. If you can't use your phone for more than a few hours before it is dead that is a problem. I don't care if you knew that is how it would be, or if you accept it, that doesn't change the fact that it is a negative for the device. Just like how only having 512 MB of storage is a negative for the Wii. I still have one and like it, but I still consider that a negative. GPS doesn't work in a lot of places or from the sounds of it, in most places. Important phone calls get droped so much that you have to borrow some strangers phone to finish the call. I'm sorry isn't that the point of a phone to be able to use it to make calls. That alone screams stay away from me, what the hell good is a phone if you can't use it to make calls. So what if it is pretty or slick, if the damn thing can't be used as a reliable phone then it is worthless.

Sounds like you've had a bad experience with the device, or hate Apple as a company for some reason. Sorry to hear that. I never experienced any of those problems that you might have, or might have heard about. The battery lasted me 2 full days with normal use, or 1 day easy, with heavy use when I was testing the device. Charging at the end of the night by my bedstand was no problem with me.

It also sounds like the problems your talking about have more to deal with At&t then the iPhone. If so, i'm with you there, i'm not a fan of them, instead i'm happy with my little cheapy t-mobile phone and reliable service.
 
Umm..battery life is actually better on the iPhone 3G. You can't compare battery life on the new iPhone running on a 3G network with the old iPhone running on 2.5G (EDGE)...it isn't apples to apples. At least 80% of the country is still not on 3G, so most people will most likely not be limited to the 5 hours of 3G talk-time the iPhone 3G is rated for. Running on a 2G network, the iPhone 3G is claiming to have 10 hours of talk-time...compared to the 7 hours the original iPhone can run for. Mossberg (source claiming weak battery) was running in an area that actually was using 3G, hence his '4 hours and 27 minutes' of talk time. Comparing that with the original iPhone's inability to even operate on a 3G network, I'd say it's a significant improvement. If you are in a 3G locale and will minimally use the internet, you could easily switch 3G off to bump your talk time back up closer to the 10 hours.

As for A-GPS, it should decrease the 'finding' time it takes for the mapping programs significantly.

I personally will be in line on the 11th. Even if A-GPS is only marginally faster, and assuming I was in a 3G locale (which I'm not), 5 hours of talk-time would still be the pants off my 3 hours with my RAZR.
 
My old phone has more features, and it's 4 years old

Yep, i was hoping apple would update the camera and allow some of the things the other manufacturers do, such as removable storage (microsd etc) and removable battery. Although the UI is still one of the nicest looking ones, apple need to concentrate on the updating the other features of the phone before i will bother putting down any money on it.

There is simply higher end/better phones available at lower prices.
 
They can't fit EVERYTHING into the phone, come on. Voice dialing, crappy camera, yeah iphone has it, but its still hands down the best phone device out there IMO.
Best phone out there? Your kidding right? my HTC 6800 has everything the iphone doesn't, and my GPS works in ALL PLACES. I can keep my phone alive for a day or longer with the ability to CHANGE batteries on the fly. Also i can upgrade the storage on my phone. Also it doesn't drop phone calls in rural area's. my data plan is also 25 bucks a month along with unlimited talking for another 75 bucks. so in total i pay about 100 bucks every month for the 2 phones my wife and i use.

iphone best phone.. LOL gimme a break.

Also i can cut and paste, and also send pics over txt if i want to. I've been able to attached to my exchange server since the PPC's where born. (somthing like 5 to 6 years ago?)

Plus i have full sliding keyboard. touch screen to go along with it. Voice dialing. EVERYTHING THAT A IPHONE DOES NOT HAVE.. and with the new Rev A firmware... oh ya...
 
I also forgot, Scroll wheel, countless APPS that i can install for free on my phone. I can VNC into my servers here at home or at work.

I have VLC Mobile, windows media player, adobe flash, PDF viewing, excel, word, you name it i can possibly get it for my phone.. The iphone is nothing but a trendy POS just like there overpriced macs.
 
I personally will be in line on the 11th. Even if A-GPS is only marginally faster, and assuming I was in a 3G locale (which I'm not), 5 hours of talk-time would still be the pants off my 3 hours with my RAZR.

I think that's the point that is being missed.

A review that runs along the lines of "it's a fine improvement to the original iPhone, but not enough to run out and buy a new one if you already have it" is NOT a bad review.

Especially given that most people don't already have one.

For those of us, like you and I, who skipped the first gen iPhones to 'wait for the bugs to be ironed out' and are still on RAZRs (or something even older), even the first-gen iPhone would have been a nice improvement, and now that they are cheaper and with more features...

...? Why would someone argue that's somehow worse?
 
I plan on getting one. The battery is my primary concern. Make it easy to recharge wherever I am and I will be a happy camper.
 
Sounds like you've had a bad experience with the device, or hate Apple as a company for some reason. Sorry to hear that. I never experienced any of those problems that you might have, or might have heard about. The battery lasted me 2 full days with normal use, or 1 day easy, with heavy use when I was testing the device. Charging at the end of the night by my bedstand was no problem with me.

It also sounds like the problems your talking about have more to deal with At&t then the iPhone. If so, i'm with you there, i'm not a fan of them, instead i'm happy with my little cheapy t-mobile phone and reliable service.

I have not had bad experience with either as I don't have AT&T nor do I own or want an iPhone. I am going off of the article there. Again, regardless of who is at fault, apple or AT&T, that is a negative. If the service sucks, the service sucks. Until you can use it on any network other than AT&T that is a feature of the phone. At work we have Sprint/Nextel. And I dont' care how well my phone work in the areas I got service, the phone didn't work where I needed it to thus the phone & service sucked. I would not have recommended to anyone that they get any phone from sprint that only uses the nextel service if they lived anywhere around me. Instead I would have to suggest one of the sprint pcs / nextel hybrids that work great in the area. It is nothing against the phone in that aspect but the phone + service. Same here. I don't care if the poor service is due to the iPhone or the AT&T network, either way you are buying the two hand in hand. Thus even if the phone is perfect in every other way, you get a crappy network thus the phone is crap. Same for the other features. Apple added the GPS feature, which from the sounds of it doesn't work if you are in a car or around building. I don't know who is at fault for this problem, but it is still a problem with the phone. Same as the rest of the stuff.

When you cant' use a feature, it doesn't matter who is at fault, you still can't use it.
 
Umm..battery life is actually better on the iPhone 3G.

Yes. Using EDGE has double the battery life of the current iPhone, and having 3G enabled gives the same battery life as the current one in EDGE. Sounds like better battery life to me.
 
I would love an iphone, but it lacks features I actually use on my current 'ancient' nokia :


1. MMS for texting pictures. Emailing them is not the same when you want an instant reaction from someone on the receiving end.

2. Video. Even simple video on my Nokia looks decent enough, and can be really useful in capturing that moment you just happen to be at. People say use a proper cam-corder or something.. Duh... I dont want to carry that around for the odd moment of hilarity.

3. The Camera... Oh the woeful camera of the iphone is stuck at 4yr old technology compared to the cameras on the Sony Ericson C902 model (plus many others).

4. High cost of ownership over a 2yr period compared to the other phones available.


The above are deal breakers.

No amount of fancy UI will fix those.
 
[RIP]Zeus;1032728696 said:
Best phone out there? Your kidding right? my HTC 6800 has everything the iphone doesn't, and my GPS works in ALL PLACES. I can keep my phone alive for a day or longer with the ability to CHANGE batteries on the fly. Also i can upgrade the storage on my phone. Also it doesn't drop phone calls in rural area's. my data plan is also 25 bucks a month along with unlimited talking for another 75 bucks. so in total i pay about 100 bucks every month for the 2 phones my wife and i use.

iphone best phone.. LOL gimme a break.

Also i can cut and paste, and also send pics over txt if i want to. I've been able to attached to my exchange server since the PPC's where born. (somthing like 5 to 6 years ago?)

Plus i have full sliding keyboard. touch screen to go along with it. Voice dialing. EVERYTHING THAT A IPHONE DOES NOT HAVE.. and with the new Rev A firmware... oh ya...

It's all opinions. Do I think that the iPhone/3G has the latest and greatest of all technology in it? Certainly not. It's as gimmicky as it is functional. However, it excels in several areas that the HTC/smartphones can't touch.
#1: Battery life. I had an 8125. Even with BT and WIFI off, best I ever got was around 3.5 hours talk time.
#2: Weight of the phone: It's significantly lighter than any of the true smartphones (8125/8525/8925/TyTN/Tilt/etc).
#3: Size: Ok, this is a potentially moot point...but it's approximatley 1/2 the depth of the rest of the devices listed above..including the Mogul. Everything else is within a fraction of an inch in size (height/width).
#4: A full-fledged web client: No other PDA can actually claim that their phone has a full-fledged browser built in. Again, minimal...since most sites have a good quality mobile version of their site.

However, as you noted above...there are some basic areas in which the iPhone is lacking in a HUGE way:
#1: Cut/Paste. This could come in a firmware update/software update. It's not a hardware-driven function, so I would *hope* to see this soon.
#2: Camera. 2MP...it's a decent camera, so I really can't complain. However, it's only good for still shots. Of course...who in their right mind depends on their phone's camera for high-quality shots? That's a little...um...silly.
#3: Bluetooth profiles. It has basic capabilities...but stereo and tethering should, without a question, be supported. Especially for an acclaimed *multimedia* device from Apple. Again, this could come in a firmware update since it's not hardware dependent (iPhone & iPhone 3G both have BT 2.0 with EDR...so the hardware IS there).

There are other areas...and it's all dependent on your needs. However, I'm not planning on converting to RIM soon, so the iPhone or the Tilt (I'm AT&T...which works great in every area that I go to) are my only real options...since I need WIFI and I *want* bluetooth. Video recording I could care less about. However, I will miss my slide-out keyboard!
 
I think that's the point that is being missed.

A review that runs along the lines of "it's a fine improvement to the original iPhone, but not enough to run out and buy a new one if you already have it" is NOT a bad review.

Especially given that most people don't already have one.

For those of us, like you and I, who skipped the first gen iPhones to 'wait for the bugs to be ironed out' and are still on RAZRs (or something even older), even the first-gen iPhone would have been a nice improvement, and now that they are cheaper and with more features...

...? Why would someone argue that's somehow worse?

Beats me. I love my RAZR...and would happily stick to it if I could get WIFI on it...but that might look a little odd on such a small display! I could even deal with the battery life...but hey...isn't more *most always* better? :)

The review isn't truly bad...it's just not shown in a very subjective manner. I believe that at least 1 of the authors could have explained more of their reasoning and eluded to what their preference would be, given that they would not *choose* the iPhone.
 
...
When you cant' use a feature, it doesn't matter who is at fault, you still can't use it.

Amen. Again, I will be getting the iPhone, but if AT&T wasn't prominent in my area and didn't have a good reputation (again, in my area and the areas I travel), then I wouldn't waste my time (or money).

I think before responding to your original message, we all need to step back and think about what you are saying; it's dead-on. If the phone doesn't work for your service provider, then technically, it sucks. The phone doesn't, necessarily... However, the combination does, and you should stay away from it completely.

That said, unless they release a CDMA/1xRTT version of the iPhone, Verizon and Sprint/Nextel (along with a few others not on GSM) are completely at a loss...and the iPhone would be a monumental waste of time/money for those people.
 
Your HTC uses Windows Mobile, worst mobile OS out there, period. Fail.

Hmmm... Windows Mobile 6 worked much better than 5 for me on my 8125.. However, it wasn't without it's periodic lock-ups. On that vein, I have never had another phone that I actually had to reboot other than for firmware updates...which would make it the most problematic phone I've had. However, taking into account that this happened less than once a month, and that it only took a minute to reboot, it didn't pose a large enough problem *for me* to want to ditch it and call it a bad phone.

I loved my 8125, but it just was time to move on... Epic fail...nah...just could've been better ;-)
 
I would love an iphone, but it lacks features I actually use on my current 'ancient' nokia :


1. MMS for texting pictures. Emailing them is not the same when you want an instant reaction from someone on the receiving end.

2. Video. Even simple video on my Nokia looks decent enough, and can be really useful in capturing that moment you just happen to be at. People say use a proper cam-corder or something.. Duh... I dont want to carry that around for the odd moment of hilarity.

3. The Camera... Oh the woeful camera of the iphone is stuck at 4yr old technology compared to the cameras on the Sony Ericson C902 model (plus many others).

4. High cost of ownership over a 2yr period compared to the other phones available.


The above are deal breakers.

No amount of fancy UI will fix those.

Deal breakers...for you. Which I think it's great that you know what's worth shooting for..and what's not. It does irk me a little about being *required* to purchase a data plan (and the only option is the unlimited plan for an additional $30 a month) just to get the phone, but it is something that I've been considering...so it was either $30/month for iPhone, or $40~$50/month for a WM6 smartphone...which hurts any way I look at it.
 
expensive data plans, no mms, everyone has one and i like being unique :) my own opinion :)

as for me, waiting on N96 from Nokia so that i can continue to stick with tmobile.
 
expensive data plans, no mms, everyone has one and i like being unique :) my own opinion :)

as for me, waiting on N96 from Nokia so that i can continue to stick with tmobile.

N96...great phone (based on reviews/specs). Yeah...if you want T-mobile, then iPhone is not for you.

Just out of curiousity...how is $30 for unlimited internet cheap? For AT&T customers, this is a pretty sweet offer. $20 was better...but didn't offer 3G (if you live in a 3G locale).
 
The review isn't truly bad...it's just not shown in a very subjective manner...

Wait, what?

If I'm reading a review to find out how a product performs, it better damn sure be from an objective point of view!
The reason I like [H] reviews so much is because their reviews are consistently informative, well-written and objective. If I knew [H] was going to give every ATi product a bad review, I wouldn't read [H] reviews for ATi products, plain and simple.

IMO, reviewer biases don't make for good reviews.
 
My bad, I meant objective...not subjective. The review was still slighted my the guy that claimed weak battery life. He's a big RIM fan, but I still don't know of any 3G phone that, while on a 3G network, has 4 1/2 hours of battery life.
 
The not being able to view mms messages sent to you directly on your phone is still bogus on that beautiful screen (it always kinda irked me on my 1st gen) and I think the camera isn't actually half bad but obviously they should beef it up a bit.
 
N96...great phone (based on reviews/specs). Yeah...if you want T-mobile, then iPhone is not for you.

Just out of curiousity...how is $30 for unlimited internet cheap? For AT&T customers, this is a pretty sweet offer. $20 was better...but didn't offer 3G (if you live in a 3G locale).

Little confused by the above comment, but, then, deciphering mobile phone plans was never a strong suit of mine - I'm just a software architect, after all. :rolleyes:

My reading of their advertised plans suggests that it's $70/month for:
- 450 'anytime' minutes (big deal, we've never used more than 2 or 3 hundred - I think we have something like 5,000 rollover minutes on our phones at the moment)
- 5000 night and weekend minutes
- Unlimited data

...or are you slicing that plan up to comment on the 'data only' part of the plan?
 
I loved my 8125, but it just was time to move on... Epic fail...nah...just could've been better ;-)

First off, your posts in this thread are awesome, very level headed and unbiased. :)

I've used every smartphone out there and Palm PDAs before that. Windows Mobile has always bothered me as slow and very poorly laid out compared to the competition. That HTC makes phones that are so cheaply constructed is no help. Blackberries are tanks in comparison.

So yeah, could have been better, much better. ;)
 
i have a cell phone... its just a cell phone. i think it has a camera that has been used like once to take a picture of stuffed animals humping to use as a background...i was probably drunk.

i never understood the whole crazy powerful cell phone, i'd rather spend that money on pc hardware, a good laptop, or a good camera. Instead of trying to cram a bunch of things into something thats original purpose is to be a phone.
 
i have a cell phone... its just a cell phone. i think it has a camera that has been used like once to take a picture of stuffed animals humping to use as a background...i was probably drunk.

i never understood the whole crazy powerful cell phone, i'd rather spend that money on pc hardware, a good laptop, or a good camera. Instead of trying to cram a bunch of things into something thats original purpose is to be a phone.

To each his own. Some people, like yourself, only need a phone to make calls. Others find features that (for example) allow you to check their e-mail account or access their stock portfolio while they are away from their desk (or any other computer.) I, for one, don't have enough pockets to carry a phone, camera, GPS device and wifi-enabled laptop with me all the time (my laptop bag heavy and automatically labels me a geek:D).

Only having to carry a single device makes my life a lot easier.
 
Back
Top