Graphic Designer doing color correction work looking for display.

spume

n00b
Joined
Jul 16, 2006
Messages
26
Hi there folks, I have a friend who does graphic work for print. A lot of freelance work for DVD packaging. To make a long story short she does most of her work on a macbook (not pro) and she is finding that her display color is not accurate enough. She was on the verge of ordering a 20" apple cinema display. But 600 beans for a 20" seems extreme. Is there a good 20" display option for her? Price is not a huge issue as she is willing to spend the 600 but I just wanted to find out if there were better options as Apple products tend to be outrageously priced.

On a side note is there a program to help calibrate displays to get the closest to the true color for this type of work?

Thanks a ton in advance.
 
You'd want to go for an IPS panel if color accuracy is important, but LCD's in terms of quality are expensive. 20" IPS panels are non existant almost, although there are a few but have been discontinued. Only the 24" + range sports IPS panels now-a-days. But expect to pay mucho denero...The top contender would be the Nec 2490WUXI for around 1200-1500. The Planar PX2611W or the doublesight DS-236N wouldn't be that bad of a choice...Cheaper in the 600-850 range or so, and much more screen real estate. But since this is also a laptop...The IGP is a big issue in terms of resolution, and how reliably it'd be able to run a 2nd display with such a large res of 1920x1200 (for 24" + monitors).

She's in a tight predicament to tell you the truth...From my past experience with helping people set up a laptop running to a second display, it hasn't always been the best of results....But it was mostly due to having my friends literally leave their laptops on 24/7, and noticing some screen jumping/distortion being displayed after a while on the 2nd display...Possibly overheating, not sure..

But yea, she's in a tough spot...LCD's are generally QUITE expensive if you do color critical work and need quality. My work needs very accurate colors, and I just luckily picked up a Nec 20WMGX2 for 195 bucks, 20" IPS panel, discontinued, but Ig ot it refurbed. But even this beauty of a monitor in color accuracy has faults, some bad banding on gradients makes it difficult for me in color critical scenarios involving gradients..and since I do a lot of soft painting styles with a low hardness in photoshop, I notice a lot of the banding...So I actually have a CRT setup next to me as well to check what it looks like, but use the LCD for everything else.

Honestly though, CRT's are pretty much the best color accuracy you can get at a low cost, unless you have money to spend. Even at the top of the chain, the Sony GDM FW900 demolishes the top end LCD's, even though you can get it for 150-350 used....But a chance of getting a dud. CRT's on the cheap will offer better color accuracy then cheap LCD's.....Check out that doublesight monitor I stated, I haven't read too heavily into it, but it uses the same panel as the planar px2611w...Might work out well for her, there is a dedicated thread for it as well. But do keep in mind though regarding resolutions and the power/performance of her laptops IGP.
 
To get any monitor showing colours correctly it will need calibrating with a hardare device such as the Eye One Display 2 or Spyder 3.

This would help on a laptop but laptop screens aren't the best and the keeping the viewing angle constant with a laptop is hard.

The Apple Cinema Displays are long in the tooth now. They haven't been updated since launch and much better monitors are available. For colour critical work it is best to get monitor with internal high bit LUTs such as the NEC xx90 series/Lacie/Eizo monitors but they aren't cheap.
 
If you want real, accurate colour, you need to be willing to spend many of the dollars. As the others mentioned, an IPS LCD is the way to go. The Apple LCD is IPS, but Apple really overcharges for their displays IMO, especially since they are older panels.

In addition to a good LCD, you also want a calibration tool. Even really good monitors aren't right on in their default state. They need to be calibrated to really have accurate colours. For that matter, you want not only a monitor calibrator, but a printer calibrator as well. You want to be able to give Photoshop and Indesign accurate profiles for both the display and print devices so it can match everything.

Another consideration for print media is to get a wide gamut monitor. sRGB, which is the space normal monitors cover, misses out on a non-trivial portion of the ISOCoated print space. If you get a wider gamut monitor, you can cover most or all of that. Photoshop being fully colour managed deals just fine with these devices.

Personally, well, I'd recommend what I bought: an NEC 2690WUXi with the Spectraview kit. It is a very expensive monitor, like $1300, but well worth it. For that money you get a really good wide gamut 26" IPS screen, and a colourimetre that is matched to it and can directly calibrate it's hardware.

You get that and then get a print calibration device, and you are likely to find that your on screen images are just about dead identical to your print images, provided you have proper lighting (have a look at Bluemax to buy that) for viewing your proofs.

As I said, not cheap in any way shape or form, but it will get you truly accurate colour. The big screens are also nice because you can do two letter sized pages side by side with room to spare for the program's controls.

If you can't spend that much, there are cheaper solution, but not necessarily a whole lot. Part of the problem is that you really do need to get a colourimetre and those are a couple hundred right there. As a similar, but cheaper alternative you could try a Doublesight DS-263N with a Spyder 3 Elite. The DS is the same panel as the NEC, just less high end features and the Spyder is a good colourimetre (with Mac support). However that's still $700 for the display and $200 for the puck. Personally, I'd say pay the extra $400 to get the NEC solution (I did) but I can understand if you don't want to.

However, IMO, it really is worth it. Way back in the day I was the webmaster for my university's newspaper and I remember the hell that was colour matching with random equipment and no tools. I feel it really is worth it to get a quality display, colourimetre, and a spectrocolourimetre (printer calibrator). It is expensive, I'd bet you'll be near $2000 when done, but it means that you can really have real soft proofs on your monitor. You can be confident that what you see is what will print out, and that you'll get the same thing back from the web press.
 
Hi there folks, I have a friend who does graphic work for print. A lot of freelance work for DVD packaging. To make a long story short she does most of her work on a macbook (not pro) and she is finding that her display color is not accurate enough. She was on the verge of ordering a 20" apple cinema display. But 600 beans for a 20" seems extreme. Is there a good 20" display option for her? Price is not a huge issue as she is willing to spend the 600 but I just wanted to find out if there were better options as Apple products tend to be outrageously priced.

On a side note is there a program to help calibrate displays to get the closest to the true color for this type of work?

Thanks a ton in advance.

Is there a good 20" display option for her?

Closest to minimal budget - for professional color critical work:

Standart color gamut
The good.
The better.
The best.

Wide color gamut
The only and the best


On a side note is there a program to help calibrate displays to get the closest to the true color for this type of work?

The best (NECs only)
The very good
The good


But 600 beans for a 20" seems extreme
For professional color correction work the minimal budget is close to $1000 (smallest monitor+calibration kit)

General classification.
 
Would a Dell 2005fpw do the trick for the time being? It's a S-IPS panel and on par with the 20" Cinema display she was going to get. I would probably run her 250 or so.
 
If you want a cheap 20" isp monitor then I think this is the way to go.

http://www.directron.com/lcd2090uxibk.html

I just got one my self and I really like it. Could use a bit more contrast, but the colors are very accurate and for $250 I really can't complain.

If not this then I would definitely get the doublesight D-263n. Only a hundred bucks more than the apple and from what Ive read about it, a huge step up!
 
Do keep in mind though that not all people like wide gamut displays. Yes it can display more of the color space, but things tend to look oversaturated in a non PS environment that doesn't detect the wide gamut....So it's a trade off...VERY rich colors, but not a lot of people like that, considering images being viewed outside of photoshop will look extremely saturated....choice is yours on that one..

I'd go with a Nec whatever you decide to do...Damn good monitors...Don't try to cheap out either though, Make sure you get a goody....With TFT LCD Technology, you really get what you pay for unlike CRT's...even low end budget crt's can give great color accuracy, but when compared to a low cost LCD..it's a joke in regards to TN Panels color accuracy. Banding can be an issue, so make sure you look and read around and get something good. There is no perfect LCD out there, they all have strengths and weaknesses..The key is to research and pick out a monitor that has strengths that suit your needs.....Take your time..and read around on the forum, there are tons of dedicated threads to specific monitors....Just use the search function ^_^.
 
Back
Top