EA Sued For “Blatant Anticompetitive Conduct”

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A couple of gamers in Washington, DC and California have filed a lawsuit against Electronic Arts claiming the company has exhibited “http://www.hardocp.com/news.html?news=MzI5OTcsLCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdCwsLDE=” in the way that it has cornered the market on football games.

Electronic Arts already has antitrust issues on its plate, given that the company is currently seeking federal approval to acquire Take-Two Interactive. Last week that plate got a little more crowded when a pair of gamers in Washington, DC and California filed suit against the publisher in the US District Court of Northern California, alleging "blatantly anticompetitive conduct" in the way that it has cornered the football-gaming genre.
 
given that the company is currently seeking federal approval to acquire Take-Two Interactive

Does this mean they're planning a hostile take-over of Take Two in the light of the fact that TT refused to sell to EA a couple months ago?
 
They single-handedly destroyed Sega's (later 2K Games') 2K series of NFL games. There is NO NFL alternative to Madden 2008, despite the 2K series having always been the superior game. No one can afford to go up against EA, so they were able to snag an exclusive NFL license. They are using extremely monopolistic practices and they need to be stopped.

NFL 2K practically reinvented the sports gaming genre, and we should all thank Sega for that.
 
They single-handedly destroyed Sega's (later 2K Games') 2K series of NFL games. There is NO NFL alternative to Madden 2008, despite the 2K series having always been the superior game. No one can afford to go up against EA, so they were able to snag an exclusive NFL license. They are using extremely monopolistic practices and they need to be stopped.

NFL 2K practically reinvented the sports gaming genre, and we should all thank Sega for that.

AMEN BROTHER!
 
Madden was/is a better game to play than 2k, that said I think this is a good. Someone has to take Wal-mart jr down a notch.
 
And just like Intel, EA will get away with it or just end up paying the fines, because they have more money...
 
i dont care if its true or not, i just want to see EA get slapped around like the bitches they are. they piss me off.
 
EA is being anticompetitive because they got the *license* to use a bunch of names?

Last time I check, the rules to football was free. o_O
 
EA is being anticompetitive because they got the *license* to use a bunch of names?

Last time I check, the rules to football was free. o_O

playing a game with the actual players of the league will ALWAYS sell more than some made-up roster of players. if that wasn't the case, why spend the time trying to get the license?

i hope they get em at least for that shit.
 
I hope EA gets dismantled. They are a monopoly in football games and have very sketchy business practices. If the government wasn't so ignorant when it comes to electronic properties and video games, they should have stopped this when EA bought the exclusive rights from the NFL and avoided this whole fiasco.
 
I just want everyone here to understand, I agree that EA is a monopolistic company, there are no doubts there. The problem is that the NFL was the one who went looking to sell an exclusive license, it wasn't that EA called them and said here's a bunch of money, we want you all to ourselves, it was a bidding war, and like everyone has said, EA had more money to spend, and so, they got it. End of story, this lawsuit holds no water. Unfortunately.
 
EA is being anticompetitive because they got the *license* to use a bunch of names?

Last time I check, the rules to football was free. o_O

See, this kinda shit is what I'm talking about. This is probably what the lawmakers would think and it completely the misses the point with the relationship of the consumer, the product, and video games. AKA it's not that easy or simple anymore.
 
playing a game with the actual players of the league will ALWAYS sell more than some made-up roster of players.

That's the consumer's fault. I don't see any anti-competitiveness when the consumer buys a game based off of a brand.
 
I just want everyone here to understand, I agree that EA is a monopolistic company, there are no doubts there. The problem is that the NFL was the one who went looking to sell an exclusive license, it wasn't that EA called them and said here's a bunch of money, we want you all to ourselves, it was a bidding war, and like everyone has said, EA had more money to spend, and so, they got it. End of story, this lawsuit holds no water. Unfortunately.


Wrong wrong wrong.

"The deal, one EA admits to having lobbied for over the past few years, is an exclusive five-year licensing deal granting EA the sole rights to the NFL's teams, stadiums, and players. However, the publisher and Players Inc. denied a similar deal was in the works in May 2004, even requesting publications that ran the story run public retractions. "

http://www.gamespot.com/news/2004/12/13/news_6114977.html

EA may have won, but it's not as simple as the NFL "went looking to sell an exclusive license". Yes, it was a bidding "war" (how can it be competitive when the others weren't even competition $ wise? It was more like a gimmick to avoid lawsuits).

EA created the initial conversation with exclusivity and NFL properties. Of course they did this knowing no one else could outbid them. Big deal the NFL opened it up to a bidding war when no one else even had a chance? That's just a ploy, and apparently, people fall for it.
 
this is worth suing over? does that mean i can sue a TV station got having exclusive rights to a show or sporting league? can i sue wal mart for being the only place i can buy certain (crap) music albums?
 
With EA having the exclusive rights to all recognizable football leagues (arena, college, NFL) and attempting to forcibly overtake the only company who served as competition in that market I can definitely see the grounds for an "anticompetitive conduct" lawsuit. Too bad it will probably never make it to the courts. :(
 
I forsee difficulty in proving that "Electronic football games that use the names for real NFL players" is a valid monopoly.
 
As a NON console owner I applaud this if only just to have them open up just a little bit.
They took Madden 09 off the PC
They took NASCAR of the PC (where over 1/2 of the new ACTUAL drivers learned the tracks (mainly Papyrus but still..)
They bought out Origin and from that we have UO and.. THAT'S IT, no wing commander,strike commander etc.

I just want EA to say sorry for something in their lives
 
Used to be a decent NASCAR sim on the PC market, then EA bought exclusivity. So, Papyrus goes away and now another season passes with an updated console version and no love for the PC.
 
Does anyone here play Madden? They are the more boring game ever. Once you play one, you've played them all.
 
Its funny but EA is actually taking a lot more risks now with some of their game franchises. Activision seems to have flipped positions and taken on the role that EA did just two years ago. While EA has recently been releasing innovative games for their respective genres like skate and Rock Band, not to mention the upcoming Spore, Activision is more than happy to crank out yet another yearly rehash of Tony Hawk and Guitar Hero (and are now regrouping to catch up with the EA counterparts I just mentioned). And even though IMO it wasn't nearly as good as Burnout 3 or 4, at least EA took a chance doing something radically different with Burnout Paradise.

This isn't to say that EA has stopped recycling, but these days they aren't nearly as guilty of it as Activision.
 
That's the consumer's fault. I don't see any anti-competitiveness when the consumer buys a game based off of a brand.

you don't see anti-competitiveness when a consumer has no choice when they used to before the exclusive license was given to EA? its not what the consumer has done, its what EA has done. its not like the other games didn't sell...in fact i think they had a fairly good base of players.
 
Does anyone here play Madden? They are the more boring game ever. Once you play one, you've played them all.

i don't. i'd love to know how they justify paying $50-60 for a game every year when they don't update enough. good thing i hate football. course i have to deal with the shitty selection of MLB games. :p
 
Used to be a decent NASCAR sim on the PC market, then EA bought exclusivity. So, Papyrus goes away and now another season passes with an updated console version and no love for the PC.

The fact that Papyrus had the ability of running close to 43 cars in multi-player (or close to) and EA had 8! as their top, and are STILL not even closer to what Papyrus did in N2003.

The new one looks like a joke, and unless I am totally wrong (possibly) no damage model, at least from the video they are airing on tv and the few screen shots I have seen
 
The fact that Papyrus had the ability of running close to 43 cars in multi-player (or close to) and EA had 8! as their top, and are STILL not even closer to what Papyrus did in N2003.

The new one looks like a joke, and unless I am totally wrong (possibly) no damage model, at least from the video they are airing on tv and the few screen shots I have seen

Exactly. A great game 5 years ago was forced off the market and their alternative is garbage and not updated like Papy's was. For that alone, I can't forgive EA. Then, they released 2142 and it has so many bugs.... sigh.

:mad:
 
Does anyone here play Madden? They are the more boring game ever. Once you play one, you've played them all.


Thats because every madden is the same, they only change names and player stats.


Ahh EA and its madden curse will live on forever....sadly
 
you don't see anti-competitiveness when a consumer has no choice when they used to before the exclusive license was given to EA? its not what the consumer has done, its what EA has done. its not like the other games didn't sell...in fact i think they had a fairly good base of players.


If the non NFL games sold, I don't think we would be in this position because no one would care. It's the dolts that continually buy EA's football game just because they somehow have more fun because someone's name is tagged on the back of the shirt is the problem.

It's NFL's choice to give the license to EA exclusively. What you should do is tell people not to buy Madden and write a letter to NFL how dissatisfied you are. NFL does whatever the hell they want with their intellectual property.

People act like NFL IS football, but it's not.

P.S. go sue EA for having the Fifa license since 93 while you're at it because they haven't done much there either.
 
It is more fun playing with real NFL players and teams. It's not just the names, it's the statistics, the fact that you can play with/against your favorite/most hated teams and players.

As for FIFA: WRONG. They have to license every team separately, FIFA does not control them. They get the license to use the FIFA name, along with FIFA-related titles such as the FIFA World Cup. All players and teams are licensed separately, that's why there are many teams missing from EA's FIFA games. There is also Pro Evolution Soccer, which rivals FIFA 08 for the total number of national teams (FIFA 08 has more licensed leagues). There's also Winning Eleven, with a few teams. Unfortunately for Pro Evolution Soccer, they do not have permission to use real player names for the national teams of several big boys (notably Germany, France, England, Netherlands, Brazil).
 
EA single-handedly destroyed Westwood Studios, the makers of the Command & Conquer series. Even with C&C 3, the others like Generals really left a bad taste with the big C&C fans
 
It's about friggin time.

I've played the Madden games since Madden '93 on the Sega. They've always been great fun.

Then came NFL 2K5 by 2K games....

This was the most FUN football game I have ever played. It was so well-done, so addicting, that I ended up playing multiple seasons in a franchise, which I had never really been compelled to do before. I also had a blast playing it online, which I had also never felt compelled to do before.

The game never got old. I couldn't wait to see what extras 2K6 had in store..!

But EA took that away. EA, I hope you get ripped a new one over this, you deserve it.
 
The best thing gamers can do in this situation is not buy an EA produced NFL game. Once EA stops making money on it, they'll sell it off.
 
Back
Top