iPhone Price Artificially Lowered?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
PCWorld says that the new improved $199 iPhone price is due to Apple foregoing its normal revenue sharing plans and AT&T subsidizing phones in hopes of selling more phones with higher priced data plans.

To translate for us mere mortals: they're artificially lowering the cost of the iPhone so they can sell more, and hence make up for the difference in cost. This does raise some questions, however: for example, it suggests that the price is subsidized in all 70 countries in which the iPhone is going to be on sale, since Steve Jobs said that the price would be a "maximum of $199" globally.
 
High Price = Sell Less, but for more money
Low Price = Sell More, but for less money.

It's their job to figure out the middle ground for the price to maximize sales. Isn't that what their doing?
 
High Price = Sell Less, but for more money
Low Price = Sell More, but for less money.

It's their job to figure out the middle ground for the price to maximize sales. Isn't that what their doing?

I think they lowered the price so they can meet their claims of cornering the market... which clearly was impossible with a 600 phone when they started to sell them.
 
I think they lowered the price so they can meet their claims of cornering the market... which clearly was impossible with a 600 phone when they started to sell them.

QFT

They thought they could waltz in and steal RIM's market with a mediocre phone solely on zelotism, but failed. Now they're trying to buy the market.
 
It's their job to figure out the middle ground for the price to maximize sales. Isn't that what their doing?

Last year Apple prevented subsidies from other cell phone carriers. Subsidizing happens with pretty much every phone out there unless you are buying an unlocked one. The iPhone obviously wasn't meant to be unlocked but people did it anyway. Either way, Apple prevented carrier subsidizing because they did not want to undercut the pricing on iPods with the iPhone.

Now that they are pushing OS X Touch as a platform for developers to create applications on, the story is different. The iPhone is the trojan horse for that operating system and Apple's goal is to get it into as many peoples hands as possible, hoping to create the de facto mobile operating system in the process. This will be at the expense of the iPod, no question. An 8GB iPhone with all of that hardware technology, features, and functionality, now costs as much as an 8GB iPod nano. There is obviously a tradeoff with what will potentially be a higher cell phone bill with unlimited data for some people, and there isn't 100% overlap between iPod and iPhone customers, but in the end it will eat into some iPod sales.

There is also the fact that iPod sales growth has flatlined for the last two years. They are still selling lots of them, but they have been selling the same number per quarter for two years now. Growth is dead there, but there is still tons of room left for them in handsets. If it means losing a few iPod sales in the process, it must be worth cannibalizing those.
 
At $200 they are still too exspensive in some corporate environments. Where I work, the carriers give away the Blackberrys. In the end, I don't really know if phones are a good fit for Apple unless they can make money from the services.
 
The original iPhone never launched in Sweden, but this one will at the same date as in the US. I'm concerned for the monthly fee though, it's probably going to be very high and I don't like that Apple are signing exclusive deals with companies you don't want.
 
It's not cheaper at all though. You're paying $10 more a month on a 2 year contract, so in the long run it's actually 20% more expensive then the iPhone 1.0.

They really pulled a PR coup on this one though, everyone is talking about how "cheap" the new iPhone is when the cost has just been moved someplace else.
 
It's not cheaper at all though. You're paying $10 more a month on a 2 year contract, so in the long run it's actually 20% more expensive then the iPhone 1.0.

I've never had a 3G data plan. Are they generally more expensive than EDGE-only data plans? If 3G is more expensive, will there be an option to subscribe EDGE only?
 
Low Price = Make the money back on usage charges over 2 years!; AT&T, @30/month min.
 
There are plenty of 3G phones that have no increase in cost per month for unlimited data plans.
I own 3 of them, and from the looks of it the iPhone will be the only 3G phone on AT&T that is going to charge you more....since for some reason the iPhone needs its own friggin plan instead of playing nice with everyone else.

Get over yourself please
 
It's not cheaper at all though. You're paying $10 more a month on a 2 year contract, so in the long run it's actually 20% more expensive then the iPhone 1.0.

They really pulled a PR coup on this one though, everyone is talking about how "cheap" the new iPhone is when the cost has just been moved someplace else.

I see, AT&T gets no revenue sharing anymore plus they are subsidizing hardware costs now, so now data plans go up $10 a month to compensate. Lame.
 
as a hacked/cracked iphone user, i'm interested in seeing how much i can get the new iphone for WITHOUT a plan...

that will pretty much tell us all that we need to know...

and yea, i was under the assumption that you didn't actually have to pay more for the internet SERVICE if it used a 3G tower over an EDGE one... but CopyCat confirmed it for me.... what a scam...
hopefully if i can get a hold of a new iphone to crack/hack i'll be able to happily use it on the suncom network in 3G regardless....

i don't even know if they have 3G in my area... something to check for sure...



on another note, anyone interested in an unlocked iphone? :/
 
I see, AT&T gets no revenue sharing anymore plus they are subsidizing hardware costs now, so now data plans go up $10 a month to compensate. Lame.

I don't if your being sarcastic but, it sounds like your agreeing with the policy. Keep In mind that they make tons of money off of the subscription, it can be hard to get one under $50 a month and they only need $8 a month or so to make back the subsidy. The fact it they subsidize every phone out there, I really don't know why they would need to increase the monthly bill to subsidize this one.
 
The iPhone had a cheaper data plan than any other PDA phone initially.

They are bringing it up to the same level as a data plan that you'd get with a blackberry curve. I think the only reason they had it $10 cheaper was because people paid full price for the phone but still signed up for 2 years of service.
 
The iPhone had a cheaper data plan than any other PDA phone initially.

They are bringing it up to the same level as a data plan that you'd get with a blackberry curve. I think the only reason they had it $10 cheaper was because people paid full price for the phone but still signed up for 2 years of service.

I just don't understand why people would sign a contract without the payout. Its like signing your soul over for a Donut. What besides the privilege of touching the iPhone did people gain out of signing a 2 year prior to this.
 
I don't if your being sarcastic but, it sounds like your agreeing with the policy. Keep In mind that they make tons of money off of the subscription, it can be hard to get one under $50 a month and they only need $8 a month or so to make back the subsidy. The fact it they subsidize every phone out there, I really don't know why they would need to increase the monthly bill to subsidize this one.

I'm not being sarcastic, nor am I agreeing with the policy (who wants to pay more?), I am simply going over reasons as to why AT&T is doing this. Before they were splitting revenue with Apple and not subsidizing hardware. Now they aren't sharing any revenue and they are eating $200 on every iPhone sold. You'd think that not splitting revenue with Apple would make up for the subsidy but they go ahead and jack up the price on data anyway, wtf.
 
The iPhone had a cheaper data plan than any other PDA phone initially.

They are bringing it up to the same level as a data plan that you'd get with a blackberry curve. I think the only reason they had it $10 cheaper was because people paid full price for the phone but still signed up for 2 years of service.

You know, I forgot about this, the unlimited data plan on the iPhone was actually cheaper than the other smartphone plans they offered. Now that the iPhone is being subsidized it makes sense to make the data plan the same price as well. Either way, AT&T will still be making money hand over fist on this as a two year contract continues to be mandatory.
 
I'm not being sarcastic, nor am I agreeing with the policy (who wants to pay more?), I am simply going over reasons as to why AT&T is doing this. Before they were splitting revenue with Apple and not subsidizing hardware. Now they aren't sharing any revenue and they are eating $200 on every iPhone sold. You'd think that not splitting revenue with Apple would make up for the subsidy but they go ahead and jack up the price on data anyway, wtf.

But I guess my point is that they offer a subsidy on every phone. Not just some, but every phone. Why they would need to jack up the price just to make up for something they already do on everything else, along with the fact that they no longer give apple any revenue, just doesn't make sense. Add the fact that most Data plans are for phones that can be tethered it also makes sense that the iPhone would have a cheaper costs (its verifiabile given that actual data downloaded to a phone would less then the amount used if it was a modem). Now unless the phone can, without being hacked, be used as a modem I see absolutely no reason for the extra cost.
 
But I guess my point is that they offer a subsidy on every phone. Not just some, but every phone. Why they would need to jack up the price just to make up for something they already do on everything else, along with the fact that they no longer give apple any revenue, just doesn't make sense.

Like it was mentioned before, in the subscription breakdowns for the iPhone the unlimited data plan (the only option for the iPhone, btw) was already cheaper it was for the other smartphones that AT&T provided. Now that AT&T are subsidizing the iPhone, they are jacking up the data rate plan on them to bring them all in line with each other.

And I totally agree with you that no more revenue sharing with Apple should already make up for their initial loss on the subsidy.
 
so can we still buy the phone thru apple store? i dont like getting that data///

No, the only way (initially) to get the phone is at an AT&T or Apple store and you must sign up for a plan. Now can you not sign up for a plan and pay a higher price, I do not know.
 
well i guess its better than paying the whole lump sum initially. its like financing with no interest (kinda)
 
I only company that seems to referenced in any of these articles is AT&T. I wonder if Rogers (Canadian provider) is going to be following suit with wacky agreements like AT&T. All I want to do is buy the phone outright.

I could care less about data plans/ internet on phones, and the WiFi is a backup of push comes to shove.

Also in Canada data prices are going to have to change drastically for this device to be successful. Right now Rogers just "lowered" the data plans to 15mb/ month for $15 and $1/mb thereafter, or $60/month for 1gb. Quite a ripoff right now.
 
Sorry for the double post. I can't edit my spelling/ grammer mistakes on front page news. :D

------

Change. "I" to "The"
 
High Price = Sell Less, but for more money
Low Price = Sell More, but for less money.

It's their job to figure out the middle ground for the price to maximize sales. Isn't that what their doing?


apple should try that with their computers.
 
i will never buy an iphone.. i'm pretty happy with my new q9c.. much smaller and i have no desire to constantly rub my finger all over my screen. call me old fashioned but i still prefer buttons
 
So what is drawing you to buy an iphone then???

I want to replace my aging Ipod, and cell phone. Both of which are going on 3+ years old.

I also like that they are combined into one device and I won't have to carry around two different devices.

Also the video playback interests me, although I am not sure if I will use that function.

The internet function is nice but I would rather not spend $60+/month for a feature I will hardly use. That is why I just want to buy one out right because I like my cell contract that I have now ($10/month).
 
I don't understand the big deal. AT&T subsidizes the iPhone so they can sell more, but raise the cost of the 3G plan by $10. Why's this news worthy?
 
I only company that seems to referenced in any of these articles is AT&T. I wonder if Rogers (Canadian provider) is going to be following suit with wacky agreements like AT&T. All I want to do is buy the phone outright.

I could care less about data plans/ internet on phones, and the WiFi is a backup of push comes to shove.

Also in Canada data prices are going to have to change drastically for this device to be successful. Right now Rogers just "lowered" the data plans to 15mb/ month for $15 and $1/mb thereafter, or $60/month for 1gb. Quite a ripoff right now.

Looks like Rogers has made a deal with Apple.
 
and of course they fuck up the most important thing of all (aside from GPS and 3G), LETTING PEOPLE CHOOSE THEIR OWN DAMN CARRIER FOR THEIR APPLE MADE PHONE/IPOD/COMPUTER.

I should have the freedom to choose whose bending me over with my pants down over data fees and whatnot, i have verizon and i cant leave it, but i would love to ditch their crappy phones for an Iphone, damnit apple, just ditch the one carrier thing already!
 
Don't blame Apple.. blame the American market for Cellphones. Myself I am more interested in the Samsung Omnia when that gets released.. 5.0 mega pixel camera, Anti shake lense, 2 batteries that are removable! and more storage options. then the Iphone 2.0.
 
iPhone price comparison.
The iPhone is more expensive over the course of two years than the current EDGE iPhone, but compared to other phones it is very comparable to what you are paying for in the end. Spring seems to be the "it" place to get great deals on monthly plans, but where I live we had nothing but problems, maybe we can try them again. Though the question is, is the 3G speed worth the extra money, only you can decide that.
 
Don't blame Apple.. blame the American market for Cellphones. Myself I am more interested in the Samsung Omnia when that gets released.. 5.0 mega pixel camera, Anti shake lense, 2 batteries that are removable! and more storage options. then the Iphone 2.0.

no, i blame apple, they didnt have to sign an exclusive with ATT, it was apples products,. moreso than samsung, LG and other companies more duty bound to cowtow to the american cell phone service to keep in a good relationship apple could have very easily chosen to sell it as a phone for any service, or at least any service for one technology (i still have verison so an all GSM phone wouldnt have helped me, but at least THEN it would be the cell phone companies fault).
 
QFT

They thought they could waltz in and steal RIM's market with a mediocre phone solely on zelotism, but failed. Now they're trying to buy the market.

Yea and RIM is really starting to take off in the consumer market. For years they pretty much left it alone. The pearl is really getting peoples attention. Sucker is as small as a standard phone but has the features that people want from a smartphone minus the full keyboard(can't stand its half keyboard). I know with one of my clients 1 of them picked it up because they liked it. I installed BES server for him to sync it up with exchange and after he had it a few weeks the other 2 owners ran out and got the same pearl phones for themselfs. They were so happy to trash their treos it wasn't funny. Rim has made it clear they are going to fight apple and ms in this game by the new phones and the focus on the consumer market they now have.

At $200 they are still too exspensive in some corporate environments. Where I work, the carriers give away the Blackberrys. In the end, I don't really know if phones are a good fit for Apple unless they can make money from the services.

With BES you end up paying around 100 bucks a user cal. You can get them for less in bulk but I want to say it will still be 60 to 80 bucks a cal(been a while since I checked on bulk pricing) Depending on what kind of deal you get with the blackberry it doesn't come out that much higher. That being said you still can't copy and paste on the iphone from my understanding and the lack of third party support means it still has a long ways to go. Also it doesn't really have a push mail solution yet(I don't consider the yahoo push imap crap an option in a business enviroment). Yes apple has licensed activesync from MS which is a nice touch but until I see it in action I'll hold back any comments on it. Just don't know how long it will take them to get the bugs out. Also BES has a lot of controls in it for managing and controlling the phones that no one has been able to touch yet. Server 08 is suspose to have a better setup for activesync but it needs windows mobile 6.1 to work. BES supports the features on phones that have been out for years. They still own the market. It will be a few years before MS can really take them in it although they are really starting to have some killer options. You are right about apple not really being ready for the corporate market, I just don't agree with your reason why.
 
Well, considering At&t hasn't figured out whether non-upgrade eligible people will be able to buy the new iphone I may end up waiting. I called the store today and the girl their told me they may charge full price for the phone with a contract if someone is not within their upgrade period.
 
Back
Top