Looking for a 32" 1080p for computer use

Ihaveworms

Ukfay Ancerkay
Joined
Jul 25, 2006
Messages
4,758
I am looking for a 32" HDTV that does 1080p. I want to be able to do regular desktop use and gaming. My primary usage for a computer is gaming, but I also do school papers/coding during the school year and watch movies from time to time. I am also considering getting a bluray drive for my computer and/or getting some HD service from my cable company. Because this LCD is going to be used for my computer monitor, I want to make sure it can display text clearly. I saw that some people were having issues with text displaying clearly on the Samsung LN32A650. Another one of my concerns is input lag. I have seen some of the higher end HDTV LCD 32" 1080p models have input lag around 15-30ms (Samsung LN32A650). To me, this would make quite a lot of difference in FPS games. Am I correct? What is your all's opinion on the input lag issue?

As of right now, I am using a vx2025wm 20.1" widescreen monitor. I did a input lag test by using this tool. I connected a CRT and my LCD to my video card and had the displayed clone and took pictures with my camera with a high shutter speed. The times were the same showing that I believe my LCD I have now has 0ms input lag. The test was very similar to this one here.

Budget +/- $1000~
 
Will press thebuy button soon but here is a small list of mine:

Panasonic LZ800 (leaning towards this one)
Toshiba RV530
Sony XBR6
Samsung 550 series

All are around 900-1100 and have 32" 1080p .....
 
It says it has PC input, is that DVI or VGA? How does it stack up to the Samsung 6 or 5 series.
 
It says it has PC input, is that DVI or VGA? How does it stack up to the Samsung 6 or 5 series.

It's VGA, but some guys in that avs thread said it only maxes out to 1280 x 1024, but all you need to do is get a hdmi >DVI cable and it will output to 1920x1080
 
I think it does from what I read .... any owners out here who can confirm the resolutions over VGA, DVI, HDMI ?
 
Well, I read over that thread. There isn't much feedback on if this TV is good for a PC monitor and/or gaming. I asked if anyone has some input lag benchmarks and hopefully someone will post some.
 
Well, I read over that thread. There isn't much feedback on if this TV is good for a PC monitor and/or gaming. I asked if anyone has some input lag benchmarks and hopefully someone will post some.

Always hard to get solid info on new displays. And user reviews should always be a little suspect, and even some professional reviews, because there are so many menu settings that can be screwed up. For example, some people complain about the grey scale on Samsung displays, but often this will be because HDMI level is set to low when it should be set to normal. (Making it worse, I think low is the default in some modes.)

In the A650 example above, text apparently is fine in PC mode, but distorted with AMP, which is the 120 Hz mode, which suggests AMP is not something worth paying for if primary usage is going to be with a PC. However, it could also be a matter of the graphics card and the display not syncing. (I had a sync problem with its predecessor, 71F, which wasn't fully resolved until I got a firmware update from Samsung. This sync problem pertained to 60 Hz PC mode though. And I ended up taking it back anyway, because AMP wasn't worth paying for, for my usage...)

Also wouldn't any display with 120 Hz (e.g., AMP) on cause a delay? After all, it's taking what is still a 60Hz signal and processing it to simulate a 120 Hz sourced signal. That's got to take some processor cycles.

Anyway, the Panasonic LZ800 has got an IPS panel, which certainly makes it worth a good hard look.

However, the best thing is to find a store with a good return policy so you can try it out and return it easily if you just can't make it work. (And ideally, there's some pro-reviews out there to help narrow down the choices along with user feedback, which can be great to sort out specific issues...)
 
the toshiba you listed has been used by quite a few people here and on the avs forum as a monitor. I did my research for a few weeks and pulled the plug on one yesterday. its cheaper then the panasonic i paid 730 shipped for mine
 
Will press thebuy button soon but here is a small list of mine:

Panasonic LZ800 (leaning towards this one)
Toshiba RV530
Sony XBR6
Samsung 550 series

All are around 900-1100 and have 32" 1080p .....

I've bought and returned every single one. Both the Toshiba and the Panasonic power supply make the annoying dog whistle sound of doom if you change the brightness lower than max, the Panasonic one is even worse because it does it at max brightness too. Theres no way I'm paying hundreds of dollars for a monitor that does that so I don't feel bad whatsoever about returning them. My LZ800 was also damaged in shipping, styrofoam was broken inside the box, bottom left and right corners are bad for backlight bleed where the styrofoam was broken. Somebody would have had to drop this thing from like 10feet in the air or more to break both sides of the styrofoam that holds the monitor in place. The buzzing power supply issue happens on non-damaged ones too though.

The XBR6 looks crappy no matter how you configure it in PC use (yes I know what I'm doing, they really didn't give a flip about PC performance when they made it and it's obvious). The Samsung a550 would be the best choice and it also has PIP so you can watch TV at the same time. The only problem is the Samsung and Sony both have tons of input lag which make them unsuitable for anyone that plans to game on it.

The LZ800 surprisingly seems to have worse colors than the a550 as well. If both were professionally calibrated the LZ800 would probably pull ahead being an IPS panel but the default Samsung calibration was better. The one thing that LZ800 has going for it is the input lag, I can't tell much a difference between input lag on it and on my Samsung 245bw 24" TN panel which has probably somewhere between 10-15ms input lag.

Another thing that boggles my mind is that the LZ800 has no controls to change RGB levels so you can't change that even if you want to. Oh yea the LZ800 black level is rather mediocre as well. I didn't think any of the monitors had good blacks except the Toshiba.
 
is there anyone else who has noticed the Toshiba noise at less than full brightness?
 
I've bought and returned every single one. Both the Toshiba and the Panasonic power supply make the annoying dog whistle sound of doom if you change the brightness lower than max, the Panasonic one is even worse because it does it at max brightness too. Theres no way I'm paying hundreds of dollars for a monitor that does that so I don't feel bad whatsoever about returning them. My LZ800 was also damaged in shipping, styrofoam was broken inside the box, bottom left and right corners are bad for backlight bleed where the styrofoam was broken. Somebody would have had to drop this thing from like 10feet in the air or more to break both sides of the styrofoam that holds the monitor in place. The buzzing power supply issue happens on non-damaged ones too though.

The XBR6 looks crappy no matter how you configure it in PC use (yes I know what I'm doing, they really didn't give a flip about PC performance when they made it and it's obvious). The Samsung a550 would be the best choice and it also has PIP so you can watch TV at the same time. The only problem is the Samsung and Sony both have tons of input lag which make them unsuitable for anyone that plans to game on it.

The LZ800 surprisingly seems to have worse colors than the a550 as well. If both were professionally calibrated the LZ800 would probably pull ahead being an IPS panel but the default Samsung calibration was better. The one thing that LZ800 has going for it is the input lag, I can't tell much a difference between input lag on it and on my Samsung 245bw 24" TN panel which has probably somewhere between 10-15ms input lag.

Another thing that boggles my mind is that the LZ800 has no controls to change RGB levels so you can't change that even if you want to. Oh yea the LZ800 black level is rather mediocre as well. I didn't think any of the monitors had good blacks except the Toshiba.
Well then, what do you use/recommend lol.
 
I've bought and returned every single one. Both the Toshiba and the Panasonic power supply make the annoying dog whistle sound of doom if you change the brightness lower than max, the Panasonic one is even worse because it does it at max brightness too. Theres no way I'm paying hundreds of dollars for a monitor that does that so I don't feel bad whatsoever about returning them. My LZ800 was also damaged in shipping, styrofoam was broken inside the box, bottom left and right corners are bad for backlight bleed where the styrofoam was broken. Somebody would have had to drop this thing from like 10feet in the air or more to break both sides of the styrofoam that holds the monitor in place. The buzzing power supply issue happens on non-damaged ones too though.

The XBR6 looks crappy no matter how you configure it in PC use (yes I know what I'm doing, they really didn't give a flip about PC performance when they made it and it's obvious). The Samsung a550 would be the best choice and it also has PIP so you can watch TV at the same time. The only problem is the Samsung and Sony both have tons of input lag which make them unsuitable for anyone that plans to game on it.

The LZ800 surprisingly seems to have worse colors than the a550 as well. If both were professionally calibrated the LZ800 would probably pull ahead being an IPS panel but the default Samsung calibration was better. The one thing that LZ800 has going for it is the input lag, I can't tell much a difference between input lag on it and on my Samsung 245bw 24" TN panel which has probably somewhere between 10-15ms input lag.

Another thing that boggles my mind is that the LZ800 has no controls to change RGB levels so you can't change that even if you want to. Oh yea the LZ800 black level is rather mediocre as well. I didn't think any of the monitors had good blacks except the Toshiba.

I'm sorry Roach but I'm going to have to call you out on this one. I call bullshi*, either that you have have some of the worst luck to the point it is almost comical. I'm not disputing your claims or making this personal. I'm just baffled at your luck. After going through 4 LCD's I'd have to say I would be as angry as you are. The only reason I chose to comment is because I've seen dozens of other PC enthusiasts who have used some of these LCD's you mentioned and had great results in these and the AVS forums. I'm not talking about simple user opinions. If you look at the PC usage write-ups in the specific forums for each of these models on AVS you'll see people have run a lot of tests in relation to PC usage, and even professional calibrators have posted their results in the forums. ( The650 did very well after calibration, maybe you should try that one)

I doubt you feel like reading 50+ pages of user tests/reviews/experiences on one specific TV but to make a long story short when it comes to user opinions you seem to be in the small minority as far as some of these issues go. First off the Toshiba and Panasonic high pitched sounds you mentioned... These are defects and not something that happen by design. So basically you got a lemon out the box. I've been around the Toshiba set and I haven't noticed any whine. Also from it's owners thread on AVS this issue doesn't seem to be widespread, and there are tons of users in there that will criticize every aspect of an lcd tv so if this issue was widespread believe me people would be talking. The only time I've even come across this whine was in Samsungs last generation of LCD's that were out in 06/07.. You should have contacted Toshiba or have the store exchange the TV.

The XBR6..Again I've seen other enthusiasts saying the exact opposite things that you are saying. Just a note. If I was looking for a TV I'd look at 50 user opinions/reviews before I made a choice as oppose to making a decision based on one user opinion. When it comes to LCD's that how it simply is.

I don't know about the 550, I've seen it in person but I wasn't really impressed. As far as black levels go calibration is everything. You complained about black crush in a previous thread. Black Crush=bad calibration for the most part.

Maybe you should try the 650 series, from what I've seen in person it looks better than all the LCD's you mentioned and input lag through vga was less than 8ms when measured. Has good blacks after calibration. But don't take my word for it as I'm just one user. I'd suggest you go to AVS where you can see the opinions from hundreds of other users who will report any potential problem. I'd suggest anyone in here do the same as opposed to listening to one person. Hope you find a good LCD though. I've been through a few myself and to be honest they were all quite good for PC use but nothing beats a CRT. Not even close. TN panels are quite mediocre too. Anyways good luck
 
Well, I did look on AVS forums. The 650 had some text fuzzyness when connected to a computer. To fix this, you would have to change the input to PC setting and that would increase the input lag to 32ms. Also, I have not found much input at all about the Panasonic used as a monitor (input lag benchmarks, etc.).
 
Well, I did look on AVS forums. The 650 had some text fuzzyness when connected to a computer. To fix this, you would have to change the input to PC setting and that would increase the input lag to 32ms. Also, I have not found much input at all about the Panasonic used as a monitor (input lag benchmarks, etc.).

The 32" version of the a650 doesn't have AMP best I can tell. So, I don't think your single link post at the beginning of the thread would apply. Or in other words, the 32" might be better with regard to lag without the 120Hz/AMP processing...
 
With regard to your second link, osserpse has updated his original comment:

HDMI in the second HDMI port with the label PC results in the SAME amount of lag as VGA: THAT MEANS 0 MS LAG! Awesome. The only problem is no AMP. But that's a compromise, because VGA also has no amp.

So, maybe that's promising, but I can't speak for subsequent posts beyond that. (The thread is very long...)
 
Hows the text sharpness at 1080p?

If its sharp like a good dell monitor, I am sold :)
 
In principle, it should be perfectly sharp. Have to make sure it is set up to match pixels 1:1 though and that the PC is giving it exactly the signal specified in the manual. (My computer and a 4071 disagreed on this and I had to define a custom signal to make the TV happier. And there was the issue of the firmware update. On the otherhand, the 4065 and my computer synced up right away.)

Samsung provides a PC mode, which greys out non-relevant configuration options (e.g,. sharpness, tint) and makes the TV function essentially as a big computer monitor. Guess turning those options off helps with lag too from osserpse's experience repeated above...

Of course, the pixels are a lot bigger on a big TV panel, so that might make it look less sharp to you...
 
What about those Sharp Aquos LC-32GP3U's? How do they stack up against the competition?
 
With regard to your second link, osserpse has updated his original comment:

HDMI in the second HDMI port with the label PC results in the SAME amount of lag as VGA: THAT MEANS 0 MS LAG! Awesome. The only problem is no AMP. But that's a compromise, because VGA also has no amp.

So, maybe that's promising, but I can't speak for subsequent posts beyond that. (The thread is very long...)
Oh I did not see this. How come this person is getting these results then?
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showpost.php?p=13897520&postcount=9179
 
The only problem is the Samsung and Sony both have tons of input lag which make them unsuitable for anyone that plans to game on it.

The A550 is rated at 5ms. I don't see how that's not fast enough for gaming. Worth noting that the A550 increases the response time if you enable game mode on a particular input. Also worth noting that the 32'' and 37'' versions of the A550 line use a different panel than the larger sets.
 
What about those Sharp Aquos LC-32GP3U's? How do they stack up against the competition?

Not the best choice for PC use, because they arrange the pixels in a different pattern than that of a traditional computer monitor. And this diminishes clarity a bit.
 
...Also, do you know what AMP is? I see it mentioned constantly in that thread.

I don't have in depth knowledge, however, per Samsung:

Your action-packed sports and movies have never looked this real. Auto Motion Plus 120Hz technology virtually eliminates any motion blur and creates smooth transitions between frames. What’s the secret? Auto Motion Plus calculates the image between frames and inserts it, creating a non-repetitive transition from one to the next. The result is a clearer picture you have to see to believe.

Film is generally shot pretty slow (24fps), which helps create the surreal, dreamy, quality, of it. AMP synthesizes a higher frame rate to create more fluid motion. It's controversial though, because some people think it makes film look too much like video. However, some other folks love it.
 
The A550 is rated at 5ms. I don't see how that's not fast enough for gaming. Worth noting that the A550 increases the response time if you enable game mode on a particular input. Also worth noting that the 32'' and 37'' versions of the A550 line use a different panel than the larger sets.


Pixel response and input lag are two different things.
 
Pixel response and input lag are two different things.
Very true. Nowa' days, pixel response doesn't seem to be much of a problem any more.

I don't have in depth knowledge, however, per Samsung:

Your action-packed sports and movies have never looked this real. Auto Motion Plus 120Hz technology virtually eliminates any motion blur and creates smooth transitions between frames. What’s the secret? Auto Motion Plus calculates the image between frames and inserts it, creating a non-repetitive transition from one to the next. The result is a clearer picture you have to see to believe.

Film is generally shot pretty slow (24fps), which helps create the surreal, dreamy, quality, of it. AMP synthesizes a higher frame rate to create more fluid motion. It's controversial though, because some people think it makes film look too much like video. However, some other folks love it.

Correct me if I am wrong, but games would not really benefit from this running at higher frame rates than film (or just computer games in general). Also, it may even degenerate game play on lets say a fast FPS in simulating frames that aren't really there.
 
...Correct me if I am wrong, but games would not really benefit from this running at higher frame rates than film (or just computer games in general). Also, it may even degenerate game play on lets say a fast FPS in simulating frames that aren't really there.

If I recall, some people have remarked favorably on using AMP with console games.

However, I'd be worried that such additional processing would add lag. (But I don't know how much...)

One reason CRT's remain popular is the high true frame rates they support (85, 100, even more). But fake frames...no, it doesn't seem like a great thing intuitively, but it would be worth getting more feedback though...
 
Is this how it works with pretty much all LCD's that claim 120hz technology? I think one of the Sony LCD's has something similar, but I may be mistaken.

I would love to upgrade from my Benq fp241w to a 32", but it has to be perfect for games, since that is what I spend most of my time doing on the computer. The Benq ghosts pretty bad in FPS's whenever you are in a dark room and move around, it doesn't do it in bright scenes though, only in dark ones, otherwise I would by 100% happy with this monitor.
 
Is this how it works with pretty much all LCD's that claim 120hz technology? I think one of the Sony LCD's has something similar, but I may be mistaken.

I would love to upgrade from my Benq fp241w to a 32", but it has to be perfect for games, since that is what I spend most of my time doing on the computer. The Benq ghosts pretty bad in FPS's whenever you are in a dark room and move around, it doesn't do it in bright scenes though, only in dark ones, otherwise I would by 100% happy with this monitor.

I think so, especially in the sense that none of them actually accept a true 120Hz input.
 
Well, I am used to my LCDs 60hz. So this would only look better in terms of picture quality to me, right?
 
really it's all personal preferences on hdtv's. i'm in the market for one too. but i'm looking at 37 or 40's right now. it's hard to find a 32 at 1080p, if your lucky to find good ones then... good. HOWEVER most of 1080p tv's are 37+ in sizes. I'd suggest you to look into the sony xbr series, they are really good from what i've seen so far. i might get one of those, depending on $$ in few weeks.

here's what im going to do. i'm going to walk into bestbuy or sears with my computer, and plug it into several hdtv's i'm interested in and test em out. Whichever i liked best, i'll get it. Maybe you should try that.
 
really it's all personal preferences on hdtv's. i'm in the market for one too. but i'm looking at 37 or 40's right now. it's hard to find a 32 at 1080p, if your lucky to find good ones then... good. HOWEVER most of 1080p tv's are 37+ in sizes. I'd suggest you to look into the sony xbr series, they are really good from what i've seen so far. i might get one of those, depending on $$ in few weeks.

here's what im going to do. i'm going to walk into bestbuy or sears with my computer, and plug it into several hdtv's i'm interested in and test em out. Whichever i liked best, i'll get it. Maybe you should try that.
Well, I haven't had that hard of a time finding 1080p TVs in 32". I agree that most are over 32", though. I first have been researching which would be good for gaming. I always research what products I want to buy before even stepping into a store. Then, I will go test it out myself.

This samsung 32" 650 series sounds pretty darn good to me.
 
here's what im going to do. i'm going to walk into bestbuy or sears with my computer, and plug it into several hdtv's i'm interested in and test em out. Whichever i liked best, i'll get it. Maybe you should try that.

This is a horrible idea. Store displays are set to be overly-bright and overly-saturated, because people are trained to think post-processed images look good and desirable. When you take the set home and configure it, you're going to wind up with a wildly different picture.
 
Back
Top