Intel to prevent Nvidia from making Nehalem chipsets

Obvsouly nVidia has to be able to run SLI with Nehalem, they don't have any choice. Intel is just giving them a hard time. I don't think that SLI means that much to them per se. Intel is in enough anti-trust trouble as it is, they won't be able to shut nVidia out without a massive and damaging law suit. At the same time Intel could counter on anti-competitve grounds as well.

Expect some type of deal before long.
 
Seriously... GET A GRIP!

The average person (read: 90% of the consumer desktop market) does not do all that. Most people dont do more than aim, internet, and music at the same time. Where in that do you need multi-core capabiliites? Even if you play a video game all you need is one core.

Fact of the matter is theres still a rather large base for single core pcs out there and if you seriously think the gpu is going to replace the cpu then you're dreaming.

RAWR!

...ok. You're right. But still, it's not going stop me from wanting to do stuff with my GPU!

Also, I never said the GPU was going to replace the CPU, EVER! Where did I say that!?!?

I'm not against the CPU at all! It's a great tool waiting to be used! I just think that having a GPU be used to perform encoding operations isn't a bad idea considering it is waaay faster in that area than even the best CPU.
 
Why?

What does nVidia have that AMD/ATI needs? At this rate, they can just sit back and watch as nVidia flops around like a dying fish out of water.


Good point, i was seeing it more as NVIDIA going to AMD/TI to become buddy buddy to make chipsets for AMD upcoming chips (i assume they arent having any licensing issues with AMD...), especially if AMD's new chip gave intel a run for their money...
 
nvidia should give intel and SLI license, then lock them out with a driver update.

:D Funniest thing I have read all day.

But locking out Nvidia means Intel is really getting hot headed. If they do lock Nvidia out and 3 months later Amd releases an Nahelem killer after years of being the underdog, Intel will fold (at least in the enthusiast dept.).
 
nvidia should just make mainstream CPU's and let Intel go f themselves

but i think in the end Intel will give nvidia the license
 
nvidia should just make mainstream CPU's and let Intel go f themselves

but i think in the end Intel will give nvidia the license

With Nvidia making the Computer on Die chip, im sure that is there plans, but IMO they are probably years off before coming out with something that is good. Its the same situation with Intel and there Larabee project, Intel wants to create video cards but are probably years off before coming out with something good.
 
I would rather Intel give more support for Crossfire/X rather than obsessing over SLI. Its already supported on a bunch of their boards, its an open standard, and it scales better than SLI.

Nvidia chipsets are hot garbage (literally) and SLI isn't that widespread to begin with. I'm especially sick and tired of hearing how awesome the 790i is (Maximum PC? I'm looking at you) despite that its eating your data out from under you (Google '790i' and 'data corruption' to see what I'm talking about).

I like CrossfireX (Hello multiple monitors AND multi GPU), now if only ATi would release a good card.
I'm not worried this will most likely get settled out before Nehalem shows up on the scene.

Don't even get me started on Maximum PC, Seriously they hate Vista because "OMG r benchmarkz are lower!! the world is ending" :rolleyes: (Alex St. John is guilty of being a Vista hater as well. Seriously why does this happen with ever MS OS?)
And they like any nVidia chipset no matter how shitty it is.
 
But locking out Nvidia means Intel is really getting hot headed.
You have that backwards. It is nvidia currently locking out Intel and AMD/ATI from SLI even though many chipsets can support it. It's an artificial limitation designed to prop up nvidia's mediocre chipset business.

Intel wants something (SLI enabled on its chipsets), nvidia wants something (a QuickPath license). Since 98% of computer gamers don't use SLI, guess who will blink first. :p This whole problem wouldn't exist if nvidia wasn't so unreasonable about being the exclusive supplier of SLI compatible chipsets.

The major +/- isn't between Intel and nvidia. In the vast majority of cases, what nvidia loses, ATI gains. With X2 and GX2-type cards, single slot SLI is possible even on Intel chipsets so it's not like there will be a mass defection.
 
Sometimes I lose faith in people.

Intel doesn't give a damn about SLI, its would be a nice bonus, and possibly a final pin in the coffin, but honestly they don't need it. They just want Nvidia to back off integrated or the low end. Nvidia can't make CPU to compete with Intel, however Intel could make GPU to compete with Nvidia, GET IT THROUGH YOUR MINDS, 99% of people will not play Crysis, 99% of people think a low end card is the greatest thing ever or are using laptops, people don't understand that laptop graphics are 1-2 generations behind desktops. Stop trying to make a niche market like us, important, in the end we DONT MATTER, We are nothing more than Test Tube Guinie pigs, that love paying for overpriced "high end" parts, love to pay off most of the R/D for that card, while they make money on the low end, that will be absolute rubbish in a couple of years, just to have an "experience", Hurray shiny. Go look up how Big Intel is, they could easily live without the enthusiast market, EASILY. And they have enough factories to rape Nvidia in the low end. And they will do so eventually.

Nvidia chipsets SUCK, albeit I liked NF4, I wouldn't even want AMD to take them if they were free. Nvidia better license and make money from SLI, its really that simple, Intel is more worried if they get to big, and become monopoly status again. Either Nvidia works with Intel and trades off, which is likely to happen or otherwise they will get raped on the bottomline. Unfortunately since AMD tripped while it was ahead, unless theres a revolution in the coming years, Intel will dominate.
 
Nvidia chipsets SUCK, albeit I liked NF4, I wouldn't even want AMD to take them if they were free. Nvidia better license and make money from SLI, its really that simple, Intel is more worried if they get to big, and become monopoly status again. Either Nvidia works with Intel and trades off, which is likely to happen or otherwise they will get raped on the bottomline. Unfortunately since AMD tripped while it was ahead, unless theres a revolution in the coming years, Intel will dominate.

Maybe the Intel nvidia chipsets suck, but I love my nforce 590 SLI - its great.
 
Sometimes I lose faith in people.

Intel doesn't give a damn about SLI, its would be a nice bonus, and possibly a final pin in the coffin, but honestly they don't need it. They just want Nvidia to back off integrated or the low end. Nvidia can't make CPU to compete with Intel, however Intel could make GPU to compete with Nvidia, GET IT THROUGH YOUR MINDS, 99% of people will not play Crysis, 99% of people think a low end card is the greatest thing ever or are using laptops, people don't understand that laptop graphics are 1-2 generations behind desktops. Stop trying to make a niche market like us, important, in the end we DONT MATTER, We are nothing more than Test Tube Guinie pigs, that love paying for overpriced "high end" parts, love to pay off most of the R/D for that card, while they make money on the low end, that will be absolute rubbish in a couple of years, just to have an "experience", Hurray shiny. Go look up how Big Intel is, they could easily live without the enthusiast market, EASILY. And they have enough factories to rape Nvidia in the low end. And they will do so eventually.

Nvidia chipsets SUCK, albeit I liked NF4, I wouldn't even want AMD to take them if they were free. Nvidia better license and make money from SLI, its really that simple, Intel is more worried if they get to big, and become monopoly status again. Either Nvidia works with Intel and trades off, which is likely to happen or otherwise they will get raped on the bottomline. Unfortunately since AMD tripped while it was ahead, unless theres a revolution in the coming years, Intel will dominate.

Guess what? Nvidia will just continue to make chipsets for AMD cpu's. Nvidia doesn't give a damn what cpu their video boards use. Intel needs the performance crown for their ego - and for that, they will give the license to Nvidia. Where is the performance bottleneck and advances being made now? The GPU. The Nvidia Nehalem chipset will be awesome. It doesn't matter what specs on the cpu Intel witholds - moving the memory controller to the cpu die will eliminate a lot of interfacing problems.
 
Guess what? Nvidia will just continue to make chipsets for AMD cpu's. Nvidia doesn't give a damn what cpu their video boards use. Intel needs the performance crown for their ego - and for that, they will give the license to Nvidia. Where is the performance bottleneck and advances being made now? The GPU. The Nvidia Nehalem chipset will be awesome. It doesn't matter what specs on the cpu Intel witholds - moving the memory controller to the cpu die will eliminate a lot of interfacing problems.

Yea but AMD < Intel, and Intel's market share is significantly higher. So Nvidia will be hurting and badly.
 
Nvidia seems to have a far better track record w/ the AMD chipsets anyways - the NF4 and NF5 series were pretty good

Intel chipsets from Nvidia, however, have been power hungry and hot and full of bugs and issues. And look at how 45nm quads are being locked out from certain boards

Anyways, what Intel has is the QuickPath Interconnect for Nehalem and they don't want to give that up to Nvidia. Intel claims its not about SLI, but the little rivalry and dispute between the two is deeper than that - from the CEO of Nvidia's comments and so on.

For all of you saying Nvidia can just make a CPU - sure, but where's their license for x86 or to compete against them? Its probably why they're trying to work closer with VIA since they're reallly the only company out there with the license that can possibly help them
 
Yea but AMD < Intel, and Intel's market share is significantly higher. So Nvidia will be hurting and badly.

No, Nvidia does not rely on chipset production much at all, just gpu's. My Nvidia video card will work just fine with Nehalem. How is Nvidia hurting?
 
Nvidia's chipset division will be hurting, which is an area Nvidia wants to expand, but otherwise they make the majority of their money off their GPU's anyways
 
No, Nvidia does not rely on chipset production much at all, just gpu's. My Nvidia video card will work just fine with Nehalem. How is Nvidia hurting?

SLI is a technical crown jewel for nVidia. Not being able to produce multi-GPU solutions for Nehalem would effectively turn that jewel to glass.
 
SLI is a technical crown jewel for nVidia. Not being able to produce multi-GPU solutions for Nehalem would effectively turn that jewel to glass.

So, by magic sli won't work on AMD cpus? The jewel is still there.
 
With the Nehalem numbers that Anandtech previewed, AMD better have a K8 repeat or else Intel is going to be years ahead of them
 
With the Nehalem numbers that Anandtech previewed, AMD better have a K8 repeat or else Intel is going to be years ahead of them

same goes with their video cards. we will know VERY soon how far behind amd/ati really is, and i have a feeling its even greater then what we will see at first...
 
So, by magic sli won't work on AMD cpus? The jewel is still there.

with preliminary buggy board numbers like nehalem is posting...why would you consider an AMD cpu?

SLi is about having the fastest PC on the block, you simply cannot do that with a ATi video card or a AMD cpu.....if you want the fastest thing around the only choice up until now has been C2D and NV

same goes with their video cards. we will know VERY soon how far behind amd/ati really is, and i have a feeling its even greater then what we will see at first...

i think you are correct...
 
For all of you saying Nvidia can just make a CPU - sure, but where's their license for x86 or to compete against them? Its probably why they're trying to work closer with VIA since they're reallly the only company out there with the license that can possibly help them


I guess they couldn't go to IBM, since AMD is working with IBM already? or do you think IBM would care?

AMD + NVIDIA both getting supplied by IBM....... could be an interesting fight against intel

AMD+IBM vs intel
NVIDIA + IBM vs Intel

if anyone could put a dent in intel i would think IBM would be somewhere in that?
 
IBM is a shadow of its former self, so I highly doubt it. The only real win IBM did was making the processors for all the 3 consoles, Wii, Ps3, and 360.
 
AMD processors and ATI video cards were not (currently) designed to be the fastest, nor the mobo chipsets. They are designed to be power efficient (why IBM likes them) and the video cards have the highest quality video playback/decoding available making them more ideal for HTPC's, not gaming rigs. Being able to run CrossfireX and having multiple monitors going is also a plus for compatibility/expandability, something that SLI cannot do with GeForce cards (only expensive Quadro FX's can do this). I have to admit, ATI video cards look way better and crisper with HD playback and image quality than NVIDIA cards do, and I'm an NVIDIA enthusiast. A HD2400XT looks way better than my 8600GT does as far as image quality goes. Now, I'm into video editing and with RapiHD (using CUDA) on the brink of release, sticking with NVIDIA is a smarter choice for what I am doing. It doesn't make them any better or worse though.

Granted AMD has fallen behind, but for those who want a quiet, cool, low-power, high-quality image/video processing machine will go for AMD, not Intel (in most cases) or NVIDIA.

I have a feeling AMD/ATI will fall into the above niche (high-quality image, low-power consumption), with Intel in the performance area (possibly with future video cards), and NVIDIA in the super-computing area (via CUDA and Tesla).
 
I cant believe people still think this is about SLi. I gave you people the link, quoting intel, saying that this is not about SLi.

This is about 1 of two things, ether integrated graphics, and or, the UMPC market that both intel and nvidia+via are now venturing into, but im guessing its because of the integrated graphics part. Intel controls 35% of the "graphics" market simply because they are the default option. Altho intel motherboards are more stable than NV chipsets, nvidia motherboards have gotten better and more stable every "generation", now they still aren't at the level of Nforce 4/5 AMD, but I feel thats going to change once intel moves to CSI, no more memory controller on the motherboard, no more potential corruption issues related to it on NV boards. This is why intel is scared to play ball here.

Nvidia already has a proven track record at the discrete GPU segment, and they were making gains in the integrated gpu sector on both sides. Intel stands to loose billions of dollars in revenue if nvidia has anything even remotely close to success in the integrated gpu department. Its really another anti-competitive power play here.
 
With the Nehalem numbers that Anandtech previewed, AMD better have a K8 repeat or else Intel is going to be years ahead of them

Except noone really needs that kind of computing power to playing games. Seriously how many games run too slow on cpus like 3Ghz core 2 or stuff like 3 Ghz quads ?

I also don't see nehalem affecting integrated GPU sales all that much before 2010 or 2011 - before they start mass producing nehalem core celerons and pentium 21x0 equvalents.
 
Back
Top