Students Take File Swapping Quiz Before Using P2P

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Students at a Missouri university have to take a six question quiz before being able to use P2P programs on campus. The school says it is just trying to help the kids make an informed decision but the part that scares us is the impact this could have on your legal defense if you are targeted by the RIAA. It’d be hard to say you “didn’t know” if you aced the test wouldn’t it?

According to an Associated Press report, the Missouri University of Science and Technology now requires students to correctly answer six questions about digital copyright law before they can use peer-to-peer tools. If they pass the test, they get six hours of access to the software.
 
I just don't understand what the RIAA is expecting out of any of this. Are they expecting that eventually these terminally broke students will eventually stop downloading music, pull millions of dollars out of their collective asses and start paying for it? Especially in this economy, where student loans are becoming more expensive or even entirely impossible to get?

Whats the ultimate goal they expect to achieve, regardless of questions, quizzes or whatever?
 
I just don't understand what the RIAA is expecting out of any of this. Are they expecting that eventually these terminally broke students will eventually stop downloading music, pull millions of dollars out of their collective asses and start paying for it? Especially in this economy, where student loans are becoming more expensive or even entirely impossible to get?

Whats the ultimate goal they expect to achieve, regardless of questions, quizzes or whatever?

I have to agree with this question. If students stopped "pirating", where would they get their music? The answer is nowhere; they just wouldn't. It's not like they're magically going to start paying for CDs they can't afford.
 
I have to agree with this question. If students stopped "pirating", where would they get their music? The answer is nowhere; they just wouldn't. It's not like they're magically going to start paying for CDs they can't afford.
Do they work? That's how I paid for my music when I was going to school. Of course, the Internet wasn't around in those days, so I had to either buy it, copy it from friends, or record it from the radio.
 
I have to agree with this question. If students stopped "pirating", where would they get their music? The answer is nowhere; they just wouldn't. It's not like they're magically going to start paying for CDs they can't afford.

That is what the radio is for.

I went to college. I paid for it myself (still paying for it). I still purchased cds of bands that I liked. I listened to the rest on the radio. I couldn't get every cd that I liked, but I was still able to get one every few months. Now with iTunes you can even do better and only get the hit songs that you like and not get the rest of the albumn if you truely want maximize your list of known songs.

I think it is BS to think that going to college means you HAVE to steal music. That is about as stupid as the protect at a local college around me last year that bitched about students getting in trouble for drunk driving, public intoication and underage drinking. Acccording to the student's getting drunk off your ass and doing stupid stuff while drunk like that is part of the college experience. Thus they should be allowed to drink and drive and do what ever they want since they are college students. Same goes for drugs. They should be allowed to smoke pot and do other drugs if they want as that is just part of going to college.

When you to go college you are an adult and are entering the adult world. Any and all laws apply to you just as they do anyone else. It doesn't matter how much you or your parents spend for you to go, you still have to follow the laws set forth.

I for one see nothing wrong with this. Although I think making the student take it every time and only allowing a few hours of use might be a tad excessive. People not knowing it is wrong is a problem. I have had family members ask me about stuff like limewire or program like that thinking that it was perfectly legal to use and that the creator of the content was putting it out there for free for people. There were shocked to learn that it wasn't being done by the creator, the it wasn't legal, and that they could get fined if they were caught downloading stuff like that. Some know full well it is wrong, others know and don't care (like a large amount of this forum users). What i find funny is that people are for piracy, but against gamestop because gamestop takes money away from the game developer. What the hell do you think you downloading it for free does? At least with gamestop the company got money at least once.

Same with music and movies. While I think the fines are a little excessive at time, they are not meant to cover the cost of the music/movie itself but are to help deter people from piracy.
 
the radio argument is garbage...have you guys listened to it? i mostly stick to the news when i get in my car until i can change me deck that is. the only albums i buy are those that are under local artists (or searched through riaaradar) or overseas artists.
 
Do they work? That's how I paid for my music when I was going to school. Of course, the Internet wasn't around in those days, so I had to either buy it, copy it from friends, or record it from the radio.

I am willing to bet copying tapes from friends was the way it was done in the past.. When I was younger, the internet wasn't in the picture either. Most of my friends had a large collection of copied tapes, usually along with a few favorites they actually bought (which in turn were copied for others).

The internet is just a more widely distributable version of that, imo. And I am willing to bet these days most students have to work just to eat, much less having money for purchasing music.. I am willing to bet students do buy a certain amount of music also.. It's not like they are 100% purely pirating, else it would be hard to download any of it, since there wouldn't be anybody buying to make the copy!

So its just the same old shit, different technology. Except now its more trackable and open, so they can bitch about it more. But I am willing to bet the RIAA is blowing a hell of a lot more money trying to stop it, than they would make if all students would suddenly stop downloading music. So what's the point (other than making themselves look like greedy uberdicks)?

I am just trying, and failing, to see the logic in all of this madness.
 
"They get six hours of access to the software. Students are limited to eight uses of peer-to-peer software a month during the academic year"


No really. What? Somehow I don't think I'd want to be the dean over there right now ;)
 
Same with music and movies. While I think the fines are a little excessive at time, they are not meant to cover the cost of the music/movie itself but are to help deter people from piracy.

And yet there are no equally life-altering, devastating penalties for corporations that break the law. Fining a person up to $30,000 per song would be like fining, say, the oil industry up to $50 billion per infraction if they broke the law.

I think the retarded fines actually kill it's effect as a deterrent, because it winds up being so much money that most people just laugh at the prospect of ever even seeing the kind of money they could be fined for copying a bunch of songs in their lifetimes. They are so infeasable so that there is no way for them to collect other than to settle for some much smaller amount.

It also doesn't help that the fact is these laws were written by RIAA lobbyists who paid large "donations" to lawmakers to pass them. There is nothing in them that actaully benefits society, and just gives the entertainment industry carte blanche to rape the very consumers that are their lifeblood. They either make the profits they expect, or sue for them. In my opinion I think it just kills creativity. Why make anything good, if you can churn out crap and sue to make a living.
 
...the impact this could have on your legal defense if you are targeted by the RIAA. It’d be hard to say you “didn’t know” if you aced the test wouldn’t it?
Isn't that the point? Don't break the law.

Now I'm not innocent, back in the day in college I downloaded a TON of stuff my fresman year. Then, 2nd week of sophmore, a kid 2 doors down was raided at 2:30am by the RIAA and columbus police. $50,000 settlement later, and I have never illegally downloaded again. It's worth my$10/disc or $.99/song to buy my music.
And I'm not rich.
 
Well, nest year I'm going to be a freshman at MS&T, my sister will be a junior there. I know that as part of room and board is a subscription music service everyone gets, where you can download entire albums for free, unlimited. Hence why the complaints by the music industry have gone down.

As for me, I'm not too worried about it, as between Tech net plus and ftp/http download servers, I shouldn't have much need for torrenting things.

what I'm guessing is that the quiz will be stupid and mindless, and they won't really care how long you actually use it. That's just a guess though. I'll always have the occasional weekend at home when I can torrent if need be.
 
I have to agree with this question. If students stopped "pirating", where would they get their music? The answer is nowhere; they just wouldn't. It's not like they're magically going to start paying for CDs they can't afford.

Oh they could afford it alright in most cases...
It's just still a moot point.
Alcohol trumps music for most college-age kids. lol
 
I don't understand the mentality that it is okay for students to download music because they don't have money. Why don't they have money? I was a college student not that long ago, and while I wasn't exactly living the life of luxury, I also wasn't starving. GET A JOB!

I paid for college myself and all the expenses that go along with it (rent, food, car, etc.). How did I accomplish such a Herculean feat? I worked. I waited tables 4 nights a week and was never broke. So get off your lazy ass and get a job like everyone else! :)

P.S. I really doubt that students don't have enough money for music. I think it would be more correct to say "they don't have enough money for music because they spent it on other crap that they couldn't easily steal."
 
I work for the IT department at my college, UCSD.

We require our residents to take a "p2p, antivirus, firewall, complex password" quiz before they are allowed to register for quarterly internet access.

Yes, the questions are dumb and easy to answer, but they are only there to illustrate our requirements of network security and network responsibility, i.e., you're ip address will link to your username if the RIAA should send us a subpoena; and we will have no choice but to comply with the law and hand over your identity. (Personally I think that is BS and plead the Fifth Amendment, but nobody in my department bought that).

Our quiz gets longer every year because residents don't really take the time to understand the consequences of their getting caught by the RIAA and the MPAA. The number of subpoena's this year is at a all time high, however much we might try to warn the residents.

The good thing is that some residents actually follow our advice and use free music subscriptions we offer. I even let them know how to strip the drm from it (shhh!).
 
Isn't that the point? Don't break the law.

Now I'm not innocent, back in the day in college I downloaded a TON of stuff my fresman year. Then, 2nd week of sophmore, a kid 2 doors down was raided at 2:30am by the RIAA and columbus police. $50,000 settlement later, and I have never illegally downloaded again. It's worth my$10/disc or $.99/song to buy my music.
And I'm not rich.
Scare tactics is one way that they try to deter people from downloading. I'd be a bit skeptical about it. Unless they're forcing people to actually pay the huge fines or sending them off to prison, I'd be more inclined to think these so-called "raids" are nothing more than a way to get the word out that they're "coming to get you" in the news. I don't doubt that it happens but I do doubt the severity of it.
 
I don't doubt the severity of the fines or the way the c&d letter is worded, and it's worded in a way to make you almost wet your pants - a very good friend's cousin and uncle got hit by RIAA to the tune of around 30k. No c&d letter - which is what they send to students here first (and I've seen one firsthand), they got the You're busted, pay up or else letter.

OK, now this test thing. Student takes quiz, passes (have to!), gets a whole 6 hours (WhooHoo) and they can use it 8 times a month (for 6 hours each time) after taking the quiz AGAIN. Do they have to make an appointment to take the quiz again? is there a time limit - like you can only take the quiz on Tuesday from 2 to 4 pm?

Let's not talk about all the students being cheap, evil lawbreakers for a minute. Let's talk about the student who wants or needs, say, Linux or another open-source LEGAL program and the only way to get it is .. a torrent/p2p. 6 hours is NOT gonna cut it for things like this.

This whole thing imho is just one more strong arm, bullying tactic by RIAA (+MPAA/ASCAP since they're just as bad) and telling the colleges, hey, you control your students ... who are paying how much a semester once they're accepted? ... or we'll control them and hold you responsible for what they do, including suing you. That means we get even MORE money!!!

What really annoys me is none of these lawsuits and/or fines seem to be going anywhere but in the pockets of lawyers, lobbyiests and RIAA/MPAA/ASCAP. I'm not reading or hearing anywhere that the artists allegedly damaged by said torrent/p2p use are getting a penny out of any of this.

IF someone's caught d/l something illegally and fines really have to be instituted, how about ... the cost to legally d/l that song is $2; we're gonna ask (actually they order) you to remove the song from your hdd and fine you $4 per song. And that second $2? Get it to the artists who RIAA is supposedly protecting. Heck, that'd be more than anyone makes selling music legally. What is it iTunes pays? something like 5 cents per song?
 
That is what the radio is for.

I went to college. I paid for it myself (still paying for it). I still purchased cds of bands that I liked. I listened to the rest on the radio. I couldn't get every cd that I liked, but I was still able to get one every few months. Now with iTunes you can even do better and only get the hit songs that you like and not get the rest of the albumn if you truely want maximize your list of known songs.

I think it is BS to think that going to college means you HAVE to steal music. That is about as stupid as the protect at a local college around me last year that bitched about students getting in trouble for drunk driving, public intoication and underage drinking. Acccording to the student's getting drunk off your ass and doing stupid stuff while drunk like that is part of the college experience. Thus they should be allowed to drink and drive and do what ever they want since they are college students. Same goes for drugs. They should be allowed to smoke pot and do other drugs if they want as that is just part of going to college.

When you to go college you are an adult and are entering the adult world. Any and all laws apply to you just as they do anyone else. It doesn't matter how much you or your parents spend for you to go, you still have to follow the laws set forth.

I for one see nothing wrong with this. Although I think making the student take it every time and only allowing a few hours of use might be a tad excessive. People not knowing it is wrong is a problem. I have had family members ask me about stuff like limewire or program like that thinking that it was perfectly legal to use and that the creator of the content was putting it out there for free for people. There were shocked to learn that it wasn't being done by the creator, the it wasn't legal, and that they could get fined if they were caught downloading stuff like that. Some know full well it is wrong, others know and don't care (like a large amount of this forum users). What i find funny is that people are for piracy, but against gamestop because gamestop takes money away from the game developer. What the hell do you think you downloading it for free does? At least with gamestop the company got money at least once.

Same with music and movies. While I think the fines are a little excessive at time, they are not meant to cover the cost of the music/movie itself but are to help deter people from piracy.

Because the radio has uber quality tracks, and you can also control what you're listening to at the same time! :rolleyes:

This is not the 1950s, the RIAA/MPAA are just fighting an uphill battle. I do not support artists that do not need my money, I would much rather donate the money to disaster victims. Keep feeding the artists so they can live a more glamorous life, I hear they are really struggling these days.
 
Because the radio has uber quality tracks, and you can also control what you're listening to at the same time! :rolleyes:

This is not the 1950s, the RIAA/MPAA are just fighting an uphill battle. I do not support artists that do not need my money, I would much rather donate the money to disaster victims. Keep feeding the artists so they can live a more glamorous life, I hear they are really struggling these days.
So where is the incentive for people to make music? They gotta get paid somehow...:rolleyes:
 
I don't doubt the severity of the fines or the way the c&d letter is worded, and it's worded in a way to make you almost wet your pants - a very good friend's cousin and uncle got hit by RIAA to the tune of around 30k. No c&d letter - which is what they send to students here first (and I've seen one firsthand), they got the You're busted, pay up or else letter.
If you haven't got the money to pay for the fines then what do they propose? Take away your computer? I can't see prison time because that costs the state a lot of money. Imagine if they busted everybody and no one could afford the hefty fines. Those letters got BS written all over them.
 
This is why we run an internal torrent tracker that doesn't tracker users. Put that in your pipe and smoke it IT guys.
 
So where is the incentive for people to make music? They gotta get paid somehow...:rolleyes:
Exactly, imagine if copyright hadn't existed back in Shakespeare's time! He probably would have never written all those terrific plays! Oh wait, copyright didn't exist back then, and it was still a sustainable profession.

Copyright's purpose is not to reward the artist per se, but to encourage to creation of science and art. As long as art and science are still being produced (and they are in great quantities) we needn't worry about increasing incentives for the producers. Nowhere in the law does it mention anything about copyright being a moral right to profit.

If you don't believe me, then you can verify for yourself in the constitution (emphasis mine):
The Congress shall have Power [. . .] To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.
 
I 100% support this. College students should always be encourage to, you know, buy (gasp!) their music rather than stealing it.

I know everyone here hates the RIAA. In fact, I also dislike them. Think of this: if no one pirated music, the RIAA would have no reason to exist.

Piracy is stealing, just like breaking into a store and stealing a CD or DVD. Alternatively, perhaps a better analogy is that piracy is like photocopying books rather than buying your own copies. Most tech-savy people fail to realize this. I think most actually do understand that they are stealing but keep making up illogical arguments to avoid feeling guilty.

For example, the "but corporations are never punished for what they do wrong!" argument is pretty popular. That is one of the worst arguments I've ever heard. Let's say for purposes of example that 90% of all US criminals never face consequences (an outrageously high assumption). Clearly the best solution to that problem is to let the other 10% get away with their crimes just to be fair. I hope everyone sees the sarcasm there.

Another popular argument is that piracy simply allows one to choose whether he feels the artists and music studios deserve money for a song. Sorry, but that's not your decision. You can't just walk into McDonald's, eat a Big Mac, decide that you didn't like it, and walk out without paying, can you?

I am also against torrents and P2P completely. They hog huge amounts of bandwidth and decrease the quality of Internet service for others who are trying to perform meaningful, legal activities. And, let's face it, 99.9% of torrent users do it for piracy. Don't give me that "open information sharing" crap. The other 0.1% do it for porn, which isn't exactly a good reason to keep P2P around. I wouldn't mind

I'm sure we all agree that we dislike Comcast's throttling and bandwidth capping. Just consider this: if no one used P2P, Comcast wouldn't be doing that, would they?

Sorry for the long post. I'm just getting a little fed up with hearing the same horribly illogical pro-piracy arguments every other day.
 
If you haven't got the money to pay for the fines then what do they propose? Take away your computer? I can't see prison time because that costs the state a lot of money. Imagine if they busted everybody and no one could afford the hefty fines. Those letters got BS written all over them.

If they lose in court, the judge could order levies on property or garnishment of wages. I agree it is more about scaring people though. The RIAA doesn't care about $50k, they just know that the downloaders do.
 
I 100% support this. College students should always be encourage to, you know, buy (gasp!) their music rather than stealing it.

I know everyone here hates the RIAA. In fact, I also dislike them. Think of this: if no one pirated music, the RIAA would have no reason to exist.

Piracy is stealing, just like breaking into a store and stealing a CD or DVD. Alternatively, perhaps a better analogy is that piracy is like photocopying books rather than buying your own copies. Most tech-savy people fail to realize this. I think most actually do understand that they are stealing but keep making up illogical arguments to avoid feeling guilty.

For example, the "but corporations are never punished for what they do wrong!" argument is pretty popular. That is one of the worst arguments I've ever heard. Let's say for purposes of example that 90% of all US criminals never face consequences (an outrageously high assumption). Clearly the best solution to that problem is to let the other 10% get away with their crimes just to be fair. I hope everyone sees the sarcasm there.

Another popular argument is that piracy simply allows one to choose whether he feels the artists and music studios deserve money for a song. Sorry, but that's not your decision. You can't just walk into McDonald's, eat a Big Mac, decide that you didn't like it, and walk out without paying, can you?

I am also against torrents and P2P completely. They hog huge amounts of bandwidth and decrease the quality of Internet service for others who are trying to perform meaningful, legal activities. And, let's face it, 99.9% of torrent users do it for piracy. Don't give me that "open information sharing" crap. The other 0.1% do it for porn, which isn't exactly a good reason to keep P2P around. I wouldn't mind

I'm sure we all agree that we dislike Comcast's throttling and bandwidth capping. Just consider this: if no one used P2P, Comcast wouldn't be doing that, would they?

Sorry for the long post. I'm just getting a little fed up with hearing the same horribly illogical pro-piracy arguments every other day.

A) Comparing the stealing of tangible goods to piracy is like comparing an apple to an orange.

B) P2P isn't only used for illegal activities. Im surprised someone who has been on these forums 3 years doesnt realize that.

Try not to believe all those RIAA commercials(Your post is almost entirely made up of comparisons/ so called "logic" the RIAA uses in their commercials)
 
Piracy is stealing, just like breaking into a store and stealing a CD or DVD. Alternatively, perhaps a better analogy is that piracy is like photocopying books rather than buying your own copies. Most tech-savy people fail to realize this. I think most actually do understand that they are stealing but keep making up illogical arguments to avoid feeling guilty.

Oh so I take it you don't own an mp3 player or copy any of your cd's onto a computer? Because according to their laws if you rip a cd onto your own computer you just committed a $10,000 x 12 fine, I believe if you go from there to an MP3 player thats x 2. They want you to rebuy music for each device, your not even allowed to copy the music into a different format you basically have rights to listen to that exact cd.

I am also against torrents and P2P completely. They hog huge amounts of bandwidth and decrease the quality of Internet service for others who are trying to perform meaningful, legal activities. And, let's face it, 99.9% of torrent users do it for piracy. Don't give me that "open information sharing" crap. The other 0.1% do it for porn, which isn't exactly a good reason to keep P2P around. I wouldn't mind

Are you also against HTTP and FTP? Where do you draw the line on data transfer protocols? Not liking P2P is a ridiculous opinion, it is no more inherently evil then anything else we use. For example Blizzard uses P2P to distribute patches in WOW, and people really do download open source items and linux distributions.

I'm sure we all agree that we dislike Comcast's throttling and bandwidth capping. Just consider this: if no one used P2P, Comcast wouldn't be doing that, would they?

Oh I am so sure that if it wasn't for P2P Comcast wouldn't be screwing customers. Just like if it wasn't for those damn terrorists the US wouldn't have to go to war and try to take away all of our freedoms. Get real, people/organizations have agendas and use hot topics to justify them, open your eyes and read between the lines.

The truth of the matter is that the music industry is handling change about as poorly as can be imagined. On top of this they have enough money to pass whatever laws they see fit. Honestly do you think copying one cd is worth over $100,000 worth of fines? That's ridiculous, some people won't save that much in a life time.
 
I just graduated from UMR (err, MST), and they have been having issues with the dorm internet access (campus internet is very fast) since my first year.

Originally, a few a-holes were torrenting all the time resulting in 20 people using half of the capacity resulting in people getting dropped packets and abysmal speed. Then they instituted caps (10GB/month and speed caps per day). I actually thought this was fair (you could contact them for bandwidth for academic uses). Then they blocked all p2p unless you specifically requested it. Last I saw, they took away the caps and just split the available bandwidth equally among all those using it. This was not fast enough to even watch a youtube video without pausing it to buffer.

On another note, there was for a number of years an http search index of all campus shares called seek42 which got shut down a year or 2 ago (I've heard there may be technical reasons for this, pinging too often or such). It was replaced by a campus only torrent index which was also shut down.

I just set up a VNC server at home and used AIM to send myself anything I wanted :cool:. AIM sends were suspiciously faster than most other uses. Oh well, I'm not going back :D
 
Piracy is stealing, just like breaking into a store and stealing a CD or DVD. Alternatively, perhaps a better analogy is that piracy is like photocopying books rather than buying your own copies. Most tech-savy people fail to realize this. I think most actually do understand that they are stealing but keep making up illogical arguments to avoid feeling guilty.

No, copyright infringement is not stealing (other than perhaps in some very colloquial sense of the word). Even if you think both are unconditionally wrong, they're still distinct actions. Legally, they're about as similar as rape and murder, but then you wouldn't try to claim that those two are the same thing.

Also note that not everyone has the same hyper-restrictive opinions on what intellectual rights should be. The thought that some people actually believe that making a mix-tape/cd for a friend (or downloading a song) is immoral seems absolutely absurd to me.

And for the record, I work for a company where my only output is copyrighted material, so it's not as if I'm not a stakeholder in copyright law and IP enforcement.
 
Also note that not everyone has the same hyper-restrictive opinions on what intellectual rights should be. The thought that some people actually believe that making a mix-tape/cd for a friend (or downloading a song) is immoral seems absolutely absurd to me.
Opinion, morals and choice have nothing to do with it though. The law has everything to do with it. We the citizens do not have the right to interpret the law, that's the court's job.
 
Opinion, morals and choice have nothing to do with it though. The law has everything to do with it. We the citizens do not have the right to interpret the law, that's the court's job.

So what do we citizens do when the laws are unjust and the government is corrupt?
 
So what do we citizens do when the laws are unjust and the government is corrupt?
Three:
1) Leave
2) Become the government and change it from the inside
3) change the government

But thank goodness we don't live in a place like that, so it's a moot point.
 
fine, don't like the radio. then pay $10 per month or what ever it is for napster or any of the other pay per month for unlimited music services.

That the cost of going out to eat one a month.

There are still plenty of legal ways for a college student to get music.
 
Most tech-savy people fail to realize this. I think most actually do understand that they are stealing but keep making up illogical arguments to avoid feeling guilty. I know its illegal and I dont feel guilty at all. Even after all the piracy they are still making more money than me. ;)

Another popular argument is that piracy simply allows one to choose whether he feels the artists and music studios deserve money for a song. Sorry, but that's not your decision. You can't just walk into McDonald's, eat a Big Mac, decide that you didn't like it, and walk out without paying, can you? There are ways to do that....its not the way I ordered it, I want my money back.
I am also against torrents and P2P completely. They hog huge amounts of bandwidth and decrease the quality of Internet service for others who are trying to perform meaningful, legal activities. And, let's face it, 99.9% of torrent users do it for piracy. Don't give me that "open information sharing" crap. The other 0.1% do it for porn, which isn't exactly a good reason to keep P2P around. I wouldn't mind. What's wrong with porn??? Oh and I have downloaded plenty of torrents that were legal programs I wanted to try without keycrackers. I imagine alot of other do too.
I'm sure we all agree that we dislike Comcast's throttling and bandwidth capping. Just consider this: if no one used P2P, Comcast wouldn't be doing that, would they? Yes they would, they would just pack more customers onto the network and have to throttle anyway instead of investing in making the network better.

See above
 
I knew my post would generate a lot of heat so here I go with the explanations...

A) Comparing the stealing of tangible goods to piracy is like comparing an apple to an orange.

This is what I consider the pirate's fallacy. Look, when you want some new computer parts, what must you do? Pay for them. When you need a new car, what must you do? Pay for it. When you buy food and clothing, what must you do? Pay for them. It's the same with music and movies. Digital media does not change the basic economic system that has run society since the beginning of intelligent life: you work, you earn money, you buy things with it. If you're getting something that's not free without paying for it, you're stealing.

Let's check out the Dictionary.com definition of the verb "to steal":

Dictionary said:
to take (the property of another or others) without permission or right

You only have permission from the owner of a song (the music studios, as evil as they may be) to dowload it if you have paid money for it.

B) P2P isn't only used for illegal activities. Im surprised someone who has been on these forums 3 years doesnt realize that.

Yes, P2P has legal uses. And you know what, if P2P was only used for legal purposes, or even if it was used for one-third legal purposes, I would be happy. But when my bandwidth is capped because someone else is using godly amounts of bandwidth in his attempt to undermine the economic system that has kept society running for the past ten thousand years, I'm not happy. IMO, the legal uses of P2P do not outweigh its negative effects, not even close.

Try not to believe all those RIAA commercials(Your post is almost entirely made up of comparisons/ so called "logic" the RIAA uses in their commercials)

I hate the RIAA because they keep their lawsuit money for themselves rather than giving it to the ones who really deserve it, the artists. Much of their logic regarding piracy, however, is perfectly fine. If the RIAA sued massive pirates (rather than individuals who downloaded two songs), settled for reasonable fines (rather than ridiculous of unproven "damages"), and paid that money to the artists of the songs (rather than their own rich executives and lawyers), I wouldn't dislike them so much.

Oh so I take it you don't own an mp3 player or copy any of your cd's onto a computer? Because according to their laws if you rip a cd onto your own computer you just committed a $10,000 x 12 fine, I believe if you go from there to an MP3 player thats x 2. They want you to rebuy music for each device, your not even allowed to copy the music into a different format you basically have rights to listen to that exact cd.

This is one area where I think you are absolutely correct. If you buy music once you should be able to put it on multiple devices that you own. IMO, one purchase per person is perfectly fine and not stealing in the least. Once again, here I think you are right and the law and/or RIAA is dead wrong.

Are you also against HTTP and FTP? Where do you draw the line on data transfer protocols? Not liking P2P is a ridiculous opinion, it is no more inherently evil then anything else we use. For example Blizzard uses P2P to distribute patches in WOW, and people really do download open source items and linux distributions.
As I said before, the negatives of P2P really do outweigh its positives, unlike the other protocols you've mentioned. Yes, patches and Linux distros are good things that exist on P2P networks, but the networks foster many more bad things than good things. IMO, when a service has more illegal uses than legal uses, the provider of that service is responsible for preventing the illegal uses.

If P2P providers would actually do something about the amount of piracy (not to mention child porn) on their networks

Your argument is somewhat akin to suggesting that dealing drugs is okay because someone might need them for rare medical conditions.

Oh I am so sure that if it wasn't for P2P Comcast wouldn't be screwing customers. Just like if it wasn't for those damn terrorists the US wouldn't have to go to war and try to take away all of our freedoms. Get real, people/organizations have agendas and use hot topics to justify them, open your eyes and read between the lines.

That comment makes me think twice about continuing to argue with you. I've found that people who believe as you do - that society's problems are only excuses for corruption and conspiracies - are extremely closed to any sort of opposing opinions at all. Nevertheless, I will give you the benefit of the doubt and state my response to this comment.

Whether you like it or not, problems do exist in society. It is the responsibility of government to attempt to solve those problems. Unfortunately, in most cases, those solutions require compromises. Claiming that government (or a private company) is only using an external problem as an excuse to further its own agenda is one of the worst things you can do simply because you are creating the very corruption your are complaining about. Think about it: let's assume that the war in Iraq really is the government's best attempts to solve a dangerous terrorism problem. Would you be able to tell the difference between that and your supposed conspiracy? No evidence exists to differentiate the two - the US is losing billions of dollars a year in Iraq and the price of oil is higher than ever. When there are no clear indicators to differentiate the positive case and the negative case, you must assume the positive case! Otherwise, you create a world in which the government or the relevant private institution cannot do anything good. Using your logic, if the government really is fighting a war for oil and money, you see the negative action and criticize it. However, if the government really is fighting a war to protect the nation from a serious threat, you assume said threat must be a cover-up and still see a negative action and criticize it. There is nothing the government can do, good or bad, to make you see a positive action. Effectively, you have created a world for yourself in which positive actions cannot exist. You must not create such a situation.

On another note, after seeing 9/11, do you really think that terrorism is not a problem? Or are you one of those who believe 9/11 was an inside job?

The truth of the matter is that the music industry is handling change about as poorly as can be imagined. On top of this they have enough money to pass whatever laws they see fit. Honestly do you think copying one cd is worth over $100,000 worth of fines? That's ridiculous, some people won't save that much in a life time.

I 100% agree with you. The music industry is not handling the digital revolution correctly, and $100,000 for one CD is absolutely ridiculous. Piracy is still wrong, however, even if the music industry's handling of it is also wrong.

No, copyright infringement is not stealing (other than perhaps in some very colloquial sense of the word). Even if you think both are unconditionally wrong, they're still distinct actions. Legally, they're about as similar as rape and murder, but then you wouldn't try to claim that those two are the same thing.

Please see my response to this above.

Also note that not everyone has the same hyper-restrictive opinions on what intellectual rights should be. The thought that some people actually believe that making a mix-tape/cd for a friend (or downloading a song) is immoral seems absolutely absurd to me.

I believe digital rights are just like rights to any other property. If I spent many hours on digital material, I would hate for everyone to copy and enjoy it without rewarding my for my hard work. Some artists may not share this view, but if they don't, that's what the Creative Commons license is for. Jonathan Coulton is an excellent example.

And for the record, I work for a company where my only output is copyrighted material, so it's not as if I'm not a stakeholder in copyright law and IP enforcement.

As I said, you are free to decide how your digital property can be distributed. I'm sure you'll agree, however, that the users of your digital property cannot make that decision on their own. If you say that anyone wanting to use you material must pay $1.00, John Doe down the street can't say "nah, I don't think I will".
 
Piracy is stealing, just like breaking into a store and stealing a CD or DVD. Alternatively, perhaps a better analogy is that piracy is like photocopying books rather than buying your own copies. Most tech-savy people fail to realize this. I think most actually do understand that they are stealing but keep making up illogical arguments to avoid feeling guilty.
Why would one feel guilty at all? It's there to download, thus they have a choice. If you abide by some set of morals that says that it's 'stealing' then maybe you shouldn't do it. That's for the person doing it to decide, not anyone else. The laws may state that it's illegal to do it, but the chances of getting busted for it are slim to none. Have you ever run a red light? Same thing.

Another popular argument is that piracy simply allows one to choose whether he feels the artists and music studios deserve money for a song. Sorry, but that's not your decision. You can't just walk into McDonald's, eat a Big Mac, decide that you didn't like it, and walk out without paying, can you?
Yes you can. If the food is cold or the service is terrible you can usually get your money back. Make a scene, threaten to sue, etc. In most cases, the manager would rather give you your money back rather than have someone yelling in their restaurant.

Downloading music is no different than what I did before the Internet became popular. Where was the RIAA back when me and my friends made copies of CDs, cassettes, and 45s/LPs? It was the same thing, yet now it's considered stealing and breaking the law? Where was the MPAA when I made copies of movies I rented on VHS?

I am also against torrents and P2P completely. They hog huge amounts of bandwidth and decrease the quality of Internet service for others who are trying to perform meaningful, legal activities. And, let's face it, 99.9% of torrent users do it for piracy. Don't give me that "open information sharing" crap. The other 0.1% do it for porn, which isn't exactly a good reason to keep P2P around. I wouldn't mind

No one would deny that piracy is rampant on p2p and torrents, but file sharing could be anything. Blame the cable and DSL companies, not file sharers. With their 15Mbps or higher packages, they are encouraging it. Who else needs those kinds of download speeds?
 
This is what I consider the pirate's fallacy. Look, when you want some new computer parts, what must you do? Pay for them. When you need a new car, what must you do? Pay for it. When you buy food and clothing, what must you do? Pay for them. It's the same with music and movies. Digital media does not change the basic economic system that has run society since the beginning of intelligent life: you work, you earn money, you buy things with it. If you're getting something that's not free without paying for it, you're stealing.

I call it 'sharing' or 'borrowing'. If a friend or relative brings over a CD or DVD, am I stealing the product because I watched or listened to it? Getting it off p2p, torrent, etc. is no different. In both cases, I didn't pay for it. In both cases, someone else already payed for it. I don't recall a single case where someone got fined for 'borrowing' a DVD or CD. The way I get the content doesn't matter because the end result is same. I never paid for it but someone else did. This is not illegal because nothing was stolen. I can borrow a friend's car, their computer, etc. I can borrow their friend's car or computer, etc. And I can go on and on.

Digital media does change things because it's easier to make copies and distribute. The RIAA and MPAA can change the way the distribute their content but refuse to do it. I guess it's easier to raise prices and use scare tactics than do something that would solve the problem for good. They're fighting a losing battle.
 
This is what I consider the pirate's fallacy. Look, when you want some new computer parts, what must you do? Pay for them. When you need a new car, what must you do? Pay for it. When you buy food and clothing, what must you do? Pay for them. It's the same with music and movies. Digital media does not change the basic economic system that has run society since the beginning of intelligent life: you work, you earn money, you buy things with it. If you're getting something that's not free without paying for it, you're stealing.

When you can clone computer parts, cars, food, or clothing at little to no cost, I will consider the analogies even remotely applicable. You also make a fallacy yourself, namely that because something has "always" been done a certain way, that makes it right and proper and that it should never be changed. If we were to live by that credo, we would still be hunters and gatherers.

I think that the whole notion that a person or corporation can own ideas (patents) or even a specific application of an idea (copyrights) ludicrous. Nevertheless, I do believe that artists/musicians/programmers should be paid too, just not with the extremist system today that will soon try to charge us for singing in the shower. Perhaps the old patronage system was better though, or some new model that doesn't just enrich the lawyers and the incumbents, but actually encourages new works, not just extracting money for old works ad infinitum.
 
I believe digital rights are just like rights to any other property. If I spent many hours on digital material, I would hate for everyone to copy and enjoy it without rewarding my for my hard work. Some artists may not share this view, but if they don't, that's what the Creative Commons license is for. Jonathan Coulton is an excellent example.
But here's the thing, I don't believe morally that anyone has all these hyper-restrictive copyrights that law currently grants. I believe that moral fair dealing rights are grossly under-represented by the law (and I live in a country which comparatively represents them well!). I simply do not believe anyone has a right to tell me I cannot make a mix tape for a friend. This is a different concept than someone licensing a work under the creative commons and "letting" me make a mix tape; it's that I had the right to begin with, regardless of what the author feels.

As I mentioned earlier, I do earn my living by spending "many hours on digital material" and I feel that current copyright law is ridiculously oppressive. Attempting to appeal to my sympathy for the IP creator isn't going to be particularly effective, since I am one myself.
 
TDigital media does not change the basic economic system that has run society since the beginning of intelligent life: you work, you earn money, you buy things with it. If you're getting something that's not free without paying for it, you're stealing.

Also, copyright is at most 400 years old in western civilization. It's hardly been around since the "beginning of intelligent life" as you put it. People could freely copy anything they wanted before then. Copyright is not a moral right; it's a right that the government grants to help the progress of art and science.
 
Back
Top