At what resolution will AA become irrelevant?

Atech

2[H]4U
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
3,946
I have been thinking about this.
At what resolution will AA become redundant/irrelevant?
And what will that mean for prefomance in games, when AA becomes and "outdated" feature and no longer will demand diespace or memory bandwidth?

How far away are we?
Or will we ever reach there and will AA in some sort always be needed?
 
Good question, I game at 1920x1200 and I usually never turn up AA, in my opinion, at those high resolutions, the jaggies are less visible, I'd rather crank up the AF.
 
the more pixels you have the less AA you need. maybe they will be able to make pixels even smaller enabling you to have the same monitor but larger resolution.
 
It's not just resolution that you have to look at. The screen size is important as well. You could play at resolution of 2100p and still need AA if you're playing on a 100" screen. I play on a 20" ws and the max res is 1680x1080 and I feel that AA is is necessary. I think 1920x1200 on a 24" ws and 2560X1600 on 30" ws would require AA as well, but some people don't mind some jaggies.
 
I agree with Skunt. I run 1920x1200 on a 24" and I feel that AA is necessary, but not very much, 4x max looks good to my eyes.
 
When we get 20" 2560x1600 monitors :)

I agree. The pixels have to be very small before the effect of AA becomes so neglible that you can turn it off.. But if you need something like 2560x1600 on a 20", what does that translate to for those with bigger displays or tv's? Considering the memory bandwidth and memory requirements of running at such insane resolutions, as well as the cost of producing displays with such small pixels, why not just enable AA and stick with the current pixel size instead?

My old 19" monitor only does 1280x1024. I find that 2x AA removes most of the jaggies - it's not perfect but the few remaining jaggies don't bother me that much. Also with games using alpha-test in alot of places, I prefer to enable 2x AA with supersampling transparency AA, rather than using something like 8x multisampling that leaves much of the scene with jagged edges still.
 
I would say when we start approaching 200+ ppi or so. My Lenovo laptop has a ~150 ppi display (1920x1200 @ 15.4in - same as the mentioned 2560x1600 @ 20in ;) ), and jaggies are still noticeable, but not really annoying like they are on my ~90 ppi desktop LCD (1280x1024 @ 19in).
 
I was running 2560x1600 and still felt AA necessary. So I will say high res and 100ppi is not enough.

Maybe 200ppi a above. Whatever it is, it doesn't exist yet.
 
I don't think AA will ever become an outdated feature. Unless of course, there's some other revolutionary tech that improves and/or replaces it, to a point where AA logic is no longer necessary in consumer's graphics hardware.

As far as my experience goes, I never played @ 2560x1600, but I did play @ 1920x1200 and 1600x1200 and the jaggies are still quite noticeable so, if possible, I will always enable AA. It bothers some people more than others obviously, but I'm definitely part of the ones that are bothered with it.

Graphics are not everything, but they are part of what can create a good and immersive experience. Jaggies can ruin that experience, though there are game engines that can disguise them better than others, without AA. But it mostly means blurring the image, which is even worse than jaggies IMO.
 
Try playing at 1280x720 on a 50 inch dlp. I need super sampling to get rid of everything. Cool thing is that with an 8800 gtx I can afford SSAA 8xs via nhancer.. I am happy with 720p entirely as long as I can use high aa levels. The huge screen and smooth framerates just suck you in.. My god, Grid at 720p with 8xs combined mode via nhancer.... WOW and stays slammed at 60fps accept for a few moments in replays.... ahhhhh..

Cant wait till the g280 hits... might be able to run 32xs at 720p and that means zero jaggies and flickery alpha textures. I prefer lower res and SSAA.
 
For me AA is always the last thing I turn up, and the first thing I turn off if I'm having performance issues.

It's nice to use, and is a visible improvement on 1920x1200 @ 24in, but native res, highest in-game quality settings, and AF all trump it in my book.
 
I play my game at 1900x1200. I still enable AA. I normally use 2xAA and 8xAF.

When i game at lower resolution i would use 8xAA.
 
i'd have to say that once i got my 24" 1920x1200 i noticed that in most games the 'jaggies' are much less offensive, but still visible of course. i notice myself less offended if i turn AA off for speed.

oh and i agree, AF is da bomb:) makes textures look like sex and the performance hit is quite small for what it does
 
800 x 600 gaming is bad enough to accidentally cut or injure yourself if you dont have AA.
 
I don't think it will become irrelevant, I think there will be new AA modes that will give higher quality and better performance. I do think that anything above 4x AA is overkill at high resolutions.
 
I think even with smaller pixel pitch at least some AA is still nice, particularly to reduce the motion of jaggies. Take for example a tree swaying in the wind. As the tree limbs sway, the steps (or jaggies) will crawl this way and that, which is not only highly distracting but makes the tree seem less solid. A little bit of AA goes a long way in reducing that effect.
 
nah 640x480 is where its at for Jaggies. I dont think 64x AA if its possible can get rid of the jaggies at this res heheh.
 
/agreed

Dot pitch and game engine play a huge roll. With mu 24" Gateway COD4 @ 1920x1200 does not need 4x AA but I like how it looks cleaner, but Racedriver: Grid definately needs 4xAA.

With that Codemasters engine the difference in night and day.
 
Generally when gaming I don't notice the need for AA at 2560x1600 *but* it does make things look better when I really look at it with care
 
i play at 1680x1050 on my dell 15" notebook with an 8600m GT and I never feel the need to turn AA on. Look so smooth. I prefer to play WoW on that compared to my 1900x1200 24inch. I've even seen some ads for 15" notebooks with 1900x1200 resolution.
 
When we get 20" 2560x1600 monitors :)
IBM and others have marketed 22" monitors with WQUXGA (3840x2400) resolution since the beginning of the decade. I believe that exceeds your proposed 20" WQXGA display. See link below...

I was running 2560x1600 and still felt AA necessary. So I will say high res and 100ppi is not enough.

Maybe 200ppi a above. Whatever it is, it doesn't exist yet.
204 ppi has been around since 2001... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T221
 
I think even with smaller pixel pitch at least some AA is still nice, particularly to reduce the motion of jaggies. Take for example a tree swaying in the wind. As the tree limbs sway, the steps (or jaggies) will crawl this way and that, which is not only highly distracting but makes the tree seem less solid. A little bit of AA goes a long way in reducing that effect.

That's a huge factor then even high resolution can't take away - that crawling look you get is, for me, really annoying.
 
For me AA is always the last thing I turn up, and the first thing I turn off if I'm having performance issues.

It's nice to use, and is a visible improvement on 1920x1200 @ 24in, but native res, highest in-game quality settings, and AF all trump it in my book.

Frankly I do things the opposite way. AA is one of the first things in my book because I can't stand that shimmering effect you get from foliage, thin lines like power lines or from anything where you see several parallel lines close together. It's the most visually offensive thing that can appear on the screen and it's especially bad in modern games with dire overuse of bloom lighting (like say, for instance, every game based on UE3).
 
The real answer is when the pixel, realtive to my eye is no larger than 0.3 arc-minute

If you game on a 20" WS at 2', the answer is 7374x7148 (461 pixels per inch)
If you game on a 20" WS at 3', the answer is 5012x2819 (313 pixels per inch)
If you game on a 20" WS at 4', the answer is 3785x2129 (237 pixels per inch)

The short answer, for no AA, you would have to game @ 9' for a 20" 1680x1050 LCD

If you game on a 24" WS at 2', the answer is 8721x4905 (454 pixels per inch)
If you game on a 24" WS at 3', the answer is 5973x3360 (311 pixels per inch)
If you game on a 24" WS at 4', the answer is 4524x2545 (235 pixels per inch)

The short answer, for no AA, you would have to game @ 9.5' for a 24" 1920x180 LCD

Pixels sure are a bitch...aren't they.
 
AA is the last thing I turn up or the first thing I turn off. My 19" 1600x1200 seems to not be effected. Plus when I am playing a game, I don't usually notice jaggies.
 
AA is the last thing I turn up or the first thing I turn off. My 19" 1600x1200 seems to not be effected. Plus when I am playing a game, I don't usually notice jaggies.


Another opposite showing how subjective this is. I will turn off many other things like shadows before I sacrifice AA. Nothing looks more distracting and fake than Jaggies.

Jaggies must go.
 
as long as computer text and graphics and displays are raster-based there will always be a need for anti-aliasing. very simple.
 
IBM and others have marketed 22" monitors with WQUXGA (3840x2400) resolution since the beginning of the decade. I believe that exceeds your proposed 20" WQXGA display. See link below...

204 ppi has been around since 2001... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T221

That beast was in no way meant for the average people. The fact that it's first customer was the DoE says as much. It would probably take another ten years before something suitable for the consumer market arrives.
 
well... the graphics card performance required to play a game at 3840x2400 resolution is a lot more than 1900*1200 with 4xAA

and the 4xAA would still probably look better
 
well... the graphics card performance required to play a game at 3840x2400 resolution is a lot more than 1900*1200 with 4xAA

and the 4xAA would still probably look better

For jaggies maybe the 4xAA would win out, but the 3840x2400 would look much better overall.
 
Why not? The jaggies are still clearly visible. If you can afford to run it w/o taking a performance hit then why not go for it.

AA is a Z instruction, so it can't be done on traditional TV signals. but yeah, like a DLP projector or something hooked up to a sweet rig (my dream machine :), run AA on that sucker.
 
depends are your screen size and distance from screen. probably never. or unless computer graphics technology becomes more advanced and completely eliminates aliasing artifacts thus no more need for AA.
 
Back
Top