Phoenix Mars Lander Follow-Up

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A bit of a follow up to yesterday’s post, the first images from the Phoenix Mars Lander have come in and they are rather remarkable when you think about what it took to get there. Everything looks great, despite the -114°F temperature, I can only imagine the things we will see in the coming weeks / months.
 
i'm one of those people that figure with all the financial troubles our country is battling, recessions and whatnot, the last thing we need to waste money on is sending stuff to Mars to see what is there............. WHY???????? Are we gonna send people there to live or something? Let's finish discovering all the neat crap right here on earth before we go worrying about Mars (of course, the only reason the US would care if life lived on Mars would be so we could march up there and tell them how to live, and attack them if they didn't listen to us)............
 
i'm one of those people that figure with all the financial troubles our country is battling, recessions and whatnot, the last thing we need to waste money on is sending stuff to Mars to see what is there............. WHY???????? Are we gonna send people there to live or something? Let's finish discovering all the neat crap right here on earth before we go worrying about Mars (of course, the only reason the US would care if life lived on Mars would be so we could march up there and tell them how to live, and attack them if they didn't listen to us)............

You're right, let's just toss out all this worthless science and go back to living in caves and eating raw meat.
 
You're right, let's just toss out all this worthless science and go back to living in caves and eating raw meat.

I think that is stretching it a bit... I don't think that spending money differently (ie not on space exploration) would put us back in the stone age. There is all kinds of worthwhile scientific exploration AND ADVANCEMENT that can/should still be done here on earth.
 
You're forgetting all the advancements in science that are a result of space exploration. ie, velcro
 
You're forgetting all the advancements in science that are a result of space exploration. ie, velcro

This. We're not just shooting probes into space for fun and pretty pictures, you know.

The complaint is also just a little bit silly to be making over a computer network.
 
The main purpose of the lander isn't just to take pictures,but to dig up and analyze the frozen water just below the surface at the polar cap.That's the key to the possibility of life once existing on Mars.
 
Are we gonna send people there to live or something? Let's finish discovering all the neat crap right here on earth before we go worrying about Mars (of course, the only reason the US would care if life lived on Mars would be so we could march up there and tell them how to live, and attack them if they didn't listen to us)............


jesus man, are you going to be alright? :confused:
 
It will also be doing a number of other things on the side. Part of the intent of going with a stationary design is that it allows the extra mass to be devoted to more & better instruments (plus, the area is relatively uniform and they're more interested in what's down instead of what's sideways). In addition to the water/life hunt, it will be gathering a variety of geological data and recording data on the local weather and the way the terrain is affected. Hopefully all will go well and it will also be able to record the onset of the Martian winter.

For an extremely obvious application of the research that could be performed on this sort of data, it could potentially tell us useful things about climate change and geology on Earth. No objections there, I hope?
 
The main purpose of the lander isn't just to take pictures,but to dig up and analyze the frozen water just below the surface at the polar cap.That's the key to the possibility of life once existing on Mars.

Exactly.

Which, I think you'll agree, has pretty major implications for how life got to be here. The better we understand how life can develop on planets - and Mars is the closest 'other planet' we can study - the better understanding we have of our own history.

Not to mention - if we find that life DOES exist on Mars, it opens up some interesting...possibilities. If it's simple self-replicating proteins, fine. But what if it's something more complicated, like outright bacteria, or even small micro-organisms? If that means that extraterrestrial life is COMMON...well, then. THAT opens a WHOLE new can of worms.

i'm one of those people that figure with all the financial troubles our country is battling, recessions and whatnot, the last thing we need to waste money on is sending stuff to Mars to see what is there............. WHY???????? Are we gonna send people there to live or something? Let's finish discovering all the neat crap right here on earth before we go worrying about Mars (of course, the only reason the US would care if life lived on Mars would be so we could march up there and tell them how to live, and attack them if they didn't listen to us)............

The bigger comment on this, though, is - what, exactly, is the purpose of life at all.

For all the "why not invest more in the US instead of space travel"...you *do* realize the US is going to be a rather bumpy piece of charcoal 'real soon now' (in an interstellar time scale, anyway). As will the entire surface of the Earth. And all life on it.

It's not an "if", just a "when". Our sun is a T Tauri Population I star, meaning it's lifespan is about 4 billion more years. At which point, it will expand into a red giant whose outer diameter will be further out than Earth's orbit. (Not to worry, though, there will already be no life on Earth - as the sun ages, it will briefly start burning much brighter. In a few hundred million years, the surface of Earth will be mostly molten rock, anyway.) Again, "when", not "if" - we can look into the sky and see this same process happening, and having happened, hundreds of times. The sun just isn't a limitless fuel source (every SECOND, actually, it burns 4 MILLION tons of matter!).

SO, really, what is the point of life on Earth AT ALL? The only clear thing I can think of is "to leave". To take our version of what "life" is to other planets, to other solar systems.

And, obviously, you can only do that with a lot of experience in space travel. Granted, in human terms, we have a LOT of time, but...well, how often does 'putting something off to the last minute' work out for ya? :p Especially when we have to evacuate an entire planet of all life! :eek:
 
Our sun is a T Tauri Population I star, meaning it's lifespan is about 4 billion more years.

T Tauri = a type of variable star. The Sun was this type of object early in its life, but is not currently. The Wikipedia article you appear to be drawing on is ambiguous on several points if you're not used to the terminology. There's an interesting article by the AAVSO on these objects here.

Pop I = high metallicity. It's highly improbable that life could arise in a Pop II or Pop III system at all since the initial metallicity of the star is the same as the nebula it forms from, and thus determines what is available to form planets out of.

The Sun formed around 4.5 billion years ago. In around another 5 billion years, it will undergo helium flashes (its hydrogen supply runs down and it undergoes processes that ignite helium fusion). This will cause a substantial reduction in mass as material is ejected, and the reduction in gravitational binding energy will cause the expansion into a red giant. This is often referred to as the end of the Sun's life because it corresponds to it leaving the main sequence, but it will actually persist for quite a while longer before resulting in a white dwarf or other remnant.

Of course, we're screwed much sooner than that without space travel. Asteroids, CMEs, or just climate change due to Earth-based issues or solar variation. But unless we're unlucky, we probably have much longer than the total time humans have been around and kicking to do something about it. On the other hand, right now we would be severely pressed to even repeat the moon landing. Tricks like altering the orbit of an asteroid with a gravity tug are something we can't hope to do without the experience from missions like this, even aside from the scientific and technological impact that translates into things like video games and fast cars to placate taxpayers.
 
Of course, we're screwed much sooner than that without space travel. Asteroids, CMEs, or just climate change due to Earth-based issues or solar variation.

Those are also obvious - and on the time scale we are talking about, odds are extremely high one or more will occur a few more times before the sun lights us up.

However, for those who argue 'divine intervention will keep the odds in our favor', arguing anything that might not happen is an uphill battle. (Although given how many times we already KNOW we've been hit by climate-changing meteors in the planet's lifetime already, and how many more we are likely to be hit by before the sun eats us up...)

In any case, though - the sun will definitely incinerate the planet. No "odds" about that - it's an absolute certainty and serves as a DEFINITE end point that we HAVE to be off the planet by then.

But unless we're unlucky, we probably have much longer than the total time humans have been around and kicking to do something about it. On the other hand, right now we would be severely pressed to even repeat the moon landing.

And that's part of the point. Just leaving the problem 'to future generations' isn't the greatest idea. It ends up moving us backwards in capability. The ability to loft humans (animals, and things) off the planet in a meaningful way brings quite a PROFOUNDLY different set of hurdles to overcome that we aren't likely going to address via other means.

With no interest in space exploration - just 'taking care of our immediate needs', I'm sure we will be amazingly advanced by the time "it's too late"...in an 'immediate needs' way. Probably have cured every form of disease. Can transfer our consciousness into clone bodies, or directly into whatever form the global communication network takes at that point. Even fusion power will be a quaint relic of the past.

But solving none of those introspective problems helps us get off the planet.

Obviously, I'm not saying "OMG, WERLD IS ENDING!!1!ONE" and that we must devote 100% of our resources to space exploration. That's equally silly. Merely that devoting NONE of them to space exploration in favor of 'taking care of our own problems back home' is simply a recipe for collective suicide, It's important that we don't lose any of the capability for space travel that we already have, and it would certainly be a sound idea to keep [i\advancing it[/i] as much as possible - rather than the alternative.
 
i'm one of those people that figure with all the financial troubles our country is battling, recessions and whatnot, the last thing we need to waste money on is sending stuff to Mars to see what is there............. WHY???????? Are we gonna send people there to live or something? Let's finish discovering all the neat crap right here on earth before we go worrying about Mars (of course, the only reason the US would care if life lived on Mars would be so we could march up there and tell them how to live, and attack them if they didn't listen to us)............

LOL...then get us Canadians to do all the shitty dirty work--then say later on we didn't do fuck all anyways LOL
 
i'm one of those people that figure with all the financial troubles our country is battling, recessions and whatnot,
Request a refund for the mission (cost: ~$460 million). You should be due about $2 for your contribution if you have a better than average salary.

With all the old people dying, why waste money on them when young people could get better use of the health care system? :cool:
 
jesus man, are you going to be alright? :confused:

No he's not, and forsaking an off-topic argument lets just label him one of the bleeding liberals out there that feels everything is solved by talking. To bad we don't live in a world that you could just sit down with your common enemy and work it all out over a bud light and some pretzels.
 
T Tauri = a type of variable star. The Sun was this type of object early in its life, but is not currently. The Wikipedia article you appear to be drawing on is ambiguous on several points if you're not used to the terminology. There's an interesting article by the AAVSO on these objects here.

Pop I = high metallicity. It's highly improbable that life could arise in a Pop II or Pop III system at all since the initial metallicity of the star is the same as the nebula it forms from, and thus determines what is available to form planets out of.

The Sun formed around 4.5 billion years ago. In around another 5 billion years, it will undergo helium flashes (its hydrogen supply runs down and it undergoes processes that ignite helium fusion). This will cause a substantial reduction in mass as material is ejected, and the reduction in gravitational binding energy will cause the expansion into a red giant. This is often referred to as the end of the Sun's life because it corresponds to it leaving the main sequence, but it will actually persist for quite a while longer before resulting in a white dwarf or other remnant.

Of course, we're screwed much sooner than that without space travel. Asteroids, CMEs, or just climate change due to Earth-based issues or solar variation. But unless we're unlucky, we probably have much longer than the total time humans have been around and kicking to do something about it. On the other hand, right now we would be severely pressed to even repeat the moon landing. Tricks like altering the orbit of an asteroid with a gravity tug are something we can't hope to do without the experience from missions like this, even aside from the scientific and technological impact that translates into things like video games and fast cars to placate taxpayers.

LMAO!!! I have got another question for you people, instead of What is life? What is human?
 
In my opinion we should multiply NASA's funding by 10 or maybe even 15. Space travel is basically the holy grail of our species. Without it we are pretty much screwed in the end.
 
imo, the usa should invest more in space science, that will be frontier of the future. Hopefully it will spark some interest in society to be interested in science and engineering again... Compared to china and india, the united states is turning out pitifully low numbers of engineers and scientists. In order to maintain leadership throughout the world, you must be at the forefront of technology. If anything that should be cut, it should be on all the military bases overseas that we don't need and stop going off in wild adventures over in the middle east.
 
less money for stupid pointless wars and more money for NASA.
I saw the landing live on SciHD, pretty cool stuff. Very exciting. The idea of creating a probe and landing it exactly where you want on another planet is pretty damn cool. And to think they did this in the 70's too!
 
Definitely awesome. I agree that NASA needs a bigger budget. Space is our species future after all. The trick is to do it without raising taxes. We all know the gov't needs to go on a budget/unjustified war diet. NASA would be an excellent place for some of those funds; besides paying off the huge debt the gov't has spent us into. I'm just glad they didn't confuse metric and standard measurements with this lander. :)
 
We need to go out to Saturn and steal that moon it has which is 98% water. Drag it to mars and give it a soft landing.... BAMM instant new world.

We can actually build the equivalent of an "Impulse Engine" right out of startrek now. using nuclear reactors and iron as the "plasma" that gets ejected... you know, every action has an equal but opposite reaction. Blasting iron atoms out the back at near the speed of liht, we'd be able to putz around the solar system easily. Say, 2 weeks to Mars instead of a year or more.

But Nasa needs a budget. Imagine if we had spent Bush's $7 TRILLION debt on Nasa instead of Iraq etc.
 
most off the great discoveries of the last 200 years were found by people looking for some thing else up until the 1910+ most physcists did not belive in the atom Einstien had to his dying day a big problem with quantum theory which now is the basis for our civilization from an electronics point of view. the big difference between relegion and science is that the former has stopped asking questions of its dogma will the latter is based constantly questioning its.
 
In my opinion we should multiply NASA's funding by 10 or maybe even 15. Space travel is basically the holy grail of our species. Without it we are pretty much screwed in the end.

You have my vote. ;)

I would just like to add: would it kill NASA (or the University of AZ) to go to Best Buy and get a cheap digital camera for this thing? I assume the cool color images will be coming at some point, but it is much easier to be excited by high resolution color images.


(Yes, I know about the limits of using spaceflight certified hardware and such. I am being facetious)
 
I would just like to add: would it kill NASA (or the University of AZ) to go to Best Buy and get a cheap digital camera for this thing? I assume the cool color images will be coming at some point, but it is much easier to be excited by high resolution color images.

(Yes, I know about the limits of using spaceflight certified hardware and such. I am being facetious)

It's not just a matter of certification. Normal electronics will get trashed by the radiation / pressure / temperature / acceleration involved.
 
Nasa definitely needs a bigger budget, the future of the human race is out in the stars. Given that the nearest habitable planet is likely many many light years away, we as a species need to further our technology to allow us to explore and find another world on which live. Earth 1.0 is getting full.
 
You guys want the Chinamen and Ruskies to plant their flags on Mars first?
 
Technically, there are flags on our rovers :eek::p:D

The camera is not the issue, they used a very good one. The issue is communications bandwidth and transmission power.

A certain party doesn't believe in space exploration or Nasa and has been slowly undermining it for almost 30 years. See, many of the members ... shhhhh... don't actually believe in science or other such nonsense, it keeps bursting bubbles in thier little bubbly heads.

The first thing a REAL program of Mars exploration would do would be to send a ring of communications/GPS satelites up. They would then be able to send images fast and furious and be powered by large solar panels to get thier power. The little rovers would then only have to employ the juice to get up to one of the repeater stations.... not all the way to earth. The GPS equivalent function could give the rovers very accurate positioning.

Next we would send HUNDREDS of rovers. :cool:

Of course we would also be replacing Hubble with a KECK level device, placed at L2 powered a pack of nukes, equivalent to dozens of Cassini's... Maintained by our interplanetary transport ship built in orbit to stay there are perform maintainence and replacement of satelites, and to do things like delivering the hundreds of rovers for mars, and open up research on Venus as well.

It should be able to then see out far enough to realize... there WAS NO BIG BANG. There was a big whooosh, and the universe is actually infinite in both time and distance, but that's a different story. But a larger telescope will be able to see beyond what is the theoretical size of the universe, posing the question, how come there is more of the same shit farther out than can be accounted for? It's already obvious, but tiptoed around. Hubble see's objects 15 billion lightyears out, entire galaxies filled with 2nd and 3rd generation stars who themselves required 10-15 billion years to develop, putting the real age of the currently visible universe beyond 30 billion years.

So I say.... BRING BACK TANG!!!! :eek:
 
the big difference between relegion and science is that the former has stopped asking questions of its dogma will the latter is based constantly questioning its.

Oh? Ever hear of doubting Thomas?

Most people don't realize but it states in the bible to ask questions of your faith, only a fanatic accepts without question.

On the other hand, I'm assured every day that global warming is going to wipe us out.... and to ignore any facts to the contrary.
 
Oh? Ever hear of doubting Thomas?

Most people don't realize but it states in the bible to ask questions of your faith, only a fanatic accepts without question.

On the other hand, I'm assured every day that global warming is going to wipe us out.... and to ignore any facts to the contrary.

This is really more of a General Mayhem topic...although if you come in there, we'd be glad to discuss it with you. :D
 
Back
Top