Vista’s UAC Catches Rootkits Before Installation

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Looks like Vista’s much-maligned User Access Control or UAC has one benefit for a savvy user: it can detect rootkits before they install. AV-Test.org conducted a test of popular antivirus programs to see how well they detected rootkits and the tester had to turn off UAC on the Vista test systems because it detected every rootkit used in the test.

Once on a PC, rootkits can bury themselves quietly, but they have to get to that point first. As long as users interpret prompts from the UAC system attentively, or those messages haven't in some way been spoofed, rootkits struggle to jump to the PC without drawing attention to themselves.
 
in before "but l337 computer people like me are too smart to get rootkits!!!11one!eleven!"

I hope this stops all of the "UAC is useless" threads at least for a little while.
 
Linux had OSX have had UAC-like features for a long time..UAC does far more than babysit computer newbies.
 
True, but it is still annoying as hell at times. :D Especially when it asks again and again for the same program every time you open it. My temp monitoring software, that came with my mobo, comes to mind. Of course that is the fault of the software programmers and not MS. Still would like an "always allow" button.

It is about time people started actually looking at what those prompt were saying. If you are surfing the web and UAC just pops up, plz hit "cancel". That should become the standard practice as opposed clicking "allow"
 
UAC was always a good idea that worked, it's just a non-user-friendly implementation.

To prevent stupid users from automatically allowing everything they should reverse the function of the buttons like: ALLOW uac to stop this keylogger from being installed...

:p
 
I'm glad to see this on the front page.... It's about time UAC gets a little good press!!

 
XP can do the same thing. It's called sandboxie.

UAC is good though. I'm glad the OS population out there will have more default security. Those botnets need to die.
 
While UAC does earn its praise for stopping such things, I do have to question if it truly is not possible to implement some kind of means to reduce the amount of annoyance associated with it? I mean, seriously, doesn't it just drive you up the wall after awhile? I know I would be. At the very least have something detect when i actually want an application to run, maybe monitoring the fact that I have double clicked an icon, or as someone said, an always allow option.
 
Yes, I've always believed that you were only an "xp expert" if the first thing you do when you install vista is to turn off uac.

Bugger it, I'm just going to say it, you're a dumbarse noob if you turn of uac.

I also could say "Well DUH", to the story, but it is good to bring a behind the scenes thing to attention. :) Uac just enables so much needed security (for the regular masses). Especially to IE by making it sandbox. It's a great thing to stop the botnets (as mentioned above), in their tracks, and to stop other identity/security theft methods as well.

But my one and only beef with it is that the prompt seems to just take too long to appear. I know what it's doing, but man, it should be instantanious. They need to speed it up.

As for an "always allow", as also been mentioned above, to apply to certain programs, that just opens uac up and makes it useless. It could be expolited to be applied to any program to always allow, and have other programs masquerade as the one you have flagged to always allow.

Sure they could write a complex hashing/encryption algorithm to ensure only the program you allow is the right one, but computers arn't fast enough. But maybe the next gen of coming gpgpus could be put to that use.
 
What good would UAC be if it didn't prompt as often? You would have no mechanism to determine if an action was user initiated or performed through malicious code. It's chatty but the way Windows is structured, that's what we have to deal with. If MS were to redesign the kernel and all of its subsystems and throw out the legacy bullshit then I'm pretty sure they would be able make Windows secure without the intrusive prompts. Let's hope they implement a more elegant solution in Windows 2007.
 
True, but it is still annoying as hell at times. :D Especially when it asks again and again for the same program every time you open it. My temp monitoring software, that came with my mobo, comes to mind. Of course that is the fault of the software programmers and not MS. Still would like an "always allow" button.
The only problem with this is if a user-level malware program changed the path of the shortcut icon or something... Pokes a huge hole in the "Always Allow" logic.

XP can do the same thing. It's called sandboxie.
No, it can't. Sandboxie can, XP can't.
We aren't talking about third-party apps here. 99% of people wouldn't install or know how to install that anyway.



For those complaining about the frequency of prompts- I'd like to hear how to improve it. Not totally rejecting what you're saying- I just haven't seen anyone offer a better solution.
It prompts for system-wide changes. Period. I really don't know what else you'd do, without decreasing the level of protection it gives you.
 
Of course that is the fault of the software programmers and not MS. Still would like an "always allow" button.

If MS gave one of those none of the crapware that currently springs a popup every time would get fixed, and we'd be just as far away from being able to run as non-administrator without pulling our hair out as we were in the win2k era.

IF what you wanted was possible Ten-Tee Soft's Faq for the Omfgwtfinator would read as follows:

Q: The Omfgwtfinator won't run of I'm logged on as a non administrator.

A: Change your account to be an admin. In Vista also add the Omfwtfinator to the UAC always allow list.


Meanwhile the Omfgwtfinator would continue to be one of the crapware apps that make actually running as nonadmin impossible.
 
I don't think people every said that UAC was useless, they said it was annoying. And if its annoying enough that they don't use it is worthless. This does have as much do with developers as it does UAC though. I do think Microsoft will be improving on this, it is a need feature.
 
If MS gave one of those none of the crapware that currently springs a popup every time would get fixed, and we'd be just as far away from being able to run as non-administrator without pulling our hair out as we were in the win2k era.

IF what you wanted was possible Ten-Tee Soft's Faq for the Omfgwtfinator would read as follows:

Q: The Omfgwtfinator won't run of I'm logged on as a non administrator.

A: Change your account to be an admin. In Vista also add the Omfwtfinator to the UAC always allow list.


Meanwhile the Omfgwtfinator would continue to be one of the crapware apps that make actually running as nonadmin impossible.


I was in particular talking about an older temp monitoring program designed with Xp in mind. One that is likely to never be updated or fixed. I understand that convincing crap ware app writers to fix their code is one of the goals of UAC. Just wish that there was a way to not see a UAC prompt for that particular piece of software. It is the only piece of regularly used software that gives me a UAC prompt that I have left.
It was merely a wish, one I don't expect to be granted. Kind like that thing with the super models. ;)
 
You can also use suDown or anything else that drops rights.

Kaspersky: "Vista less secure than XP" If UAC is disabled, Vista is actually even less secure than XP. Strange, huh?

I think they are comparing XP limited user account to Vista default account. If you create a limited user account for Vista it is just as secure as XP limited user account.
Vista default account is admin level with UAC and not limted user and if you do turn off UAC then you should also create a limited user account, which is even worse than putting up with UAC under default account IMO.
 
UAC detractors: pwned.

Agreed. My friends all run with it off and laugh at me for leaving it on. But, eventually, when they tell their parents/less computer-savvy friends to turn it off and they get screwed having to clean up a mess, I'll say "I told you so."
 
"Kaspersky: "Vista less secure than XP" If UAC is disabled, Vista is actually even less secure than XP. Strange, huh"

Yuor link is to the rebuttal that claims it is a bald faced lie :)
 
I know lol I should rtfa before posting and realizing that headline comments can't be edited. Still, I can't wait til Windows 7 comes out of Vista alpha. : D
 
While UAC does earn its praise for stopping such things, I do have to question if it truly is not possible to implement some kind of means to reduce the amount of annoyance associated with it?

It's already less annoying than the implementation in Ubuntu and OSX. What more do you want? I never see it other than when I'm installing software or running old games that require admin privileges. I just turn it off while I set up a new machine and turn it back on when I'm done.
 
While UAC does earn its praise for stopping such things, I do have to question if it truly is not possible to implement some kind of means to reduce the amount of annoyance associated with it? I mean, seriously, doesn't it just drive you up the wall after awhile?
UAC really isn't bad. I have left it on since day one, including all the way back to when I first started using Vista around Beta 2 in December 2005.

UAC is simply warning that applications are attempting to do elevated actions, including installing programs. I don't see a prompt to install a program as annoying. I have to type in a password in OS X or Linux to do the same thing. Getting a warning before running a program is really the application's fault for doing things that have been recommended against for several years. Even MS is guilty of that in some of its own applications, and virtually nothing I have installed gives a UAC prompt when run.

The last thing people complain about is trying to write to system folders, or folders that the normal user does not have access to. This is really what some people see as pointless warnings. I've repeated it several times, but if you're getting UAC prompts for regular folders, simply add your user to the ACL and give access to that folder. If you need to regularly write to system folders (Program Files, Windows, etc), open a cmd prompt as admin.
 
I ask this all the time: HOW would you make it less annoying, without compromising security?

For starters, don't ask me to confirm stupid stuff and don't ask me to confirm things multiple times. That trains the user to hit okay to virtually everything and thus makes it useless.
 
I ask this all the time: HOW would you make it less annoying, without compromising security?

That is easy. If I double click on a program, RUN THE DAMN THING WITHOUT ASKING. If I'm in the Control Panel and I double click on something, RUN THE DAMN THING WITHOUT ASKING. Basically, if the user directly executes the program, run it without the stupid UAC, but if a program tries to exec another program, then pop up UAC. Its pretty simple. Its also incredibly annoying to get like 3 boxes popping up asking you to make sure you want to run a program, so annoying...

Gee, where are all the UAC haters at? Hmmm....

Right here. This really doesn't make me change my mind about UAC. A program with a good idea but a shitty implementation is still a shitty program.
 
That is easy. If I double click on a program, RUN THE DAMN THING WITHOUT ASKING. If I'm in the Control Panel and I double click on something, RUN THE DAMN THING WITHOUT ASKING. Basically, if the user directly executes the program, run it without the stupid UAC, but if a program tries to exec another program, then pop up UAC. Its pretty simple. Its also incredibly annoying to get like 3 boxes popping up asking you to make sure you want to run a program, so annoying...
This is a good idea although I'd like to know if a media/office file I was opening was asking for user rights escalation. ;)

I think this will become much less of a problem once(if) software writers start coding with vista in mind.
 
That is easy. If I double click on a program, RUN THE DAMN THING WITHOUT ASKING. If I'm in the Control Panel and I double click on something, RUN THE DAMN THING WITHOUT ASKING. Basically, if the user directly executes the program, run it without the stupid UAC

Thus completely eliminating the security benefits of UAC...

Do you even use Vista? You don't get UAC popups for regular programs you've installed unless you go into the shortcut properties and enable the "run this program as an administrator checkbox" or right click on a shortcut and select "run as administrator." Everything in the control panel should be locked down by UAC. You have to put in your password every time you want to change those settings under Ubuntu/OSX.
 
True, but it is still annoying as hell at times. :D Especially when it asks again and again for the same program every time you open it. My temp monitoring software, that came with my mobo, comes to mind. Of course that is the fault of the software programmers and not MS. Still would like an "always allow" button.

It is about time people started actually looking at what those prompt were saying. If you are surfing the web and UAC just pops up, plz hit "cancel". That should become the standard practice as opposed clicking "allow"

If you right click the executable that is causing this problem and select the "always run as administrator" option under the compatibility tab, you should get rid of the annoyance.

This is good for programs you use frequently and know that no one using the computer will mind if it starts automatically.
 
Everything in the control panel should be locked down by UAC. You have to put in your password every time you want to change those settings under Ubuntu/OSX.

Not true, you can set "click lock to prevent further changes" in any of the vital OS X System Preferences items to toggle whether or not you get prompted for the admin password.

Otherwise I agree with everything you said, and IMO UAC is a good thing. Microsoft really stepped up to the plate in bringing their security up to the other operating systems out there.
 
If you right click the executable that is causing this problem and select the "always run as administrator" option under the compatibility tab, you should get rid of the annoyance.

This is good for programs you use frequently and know that no one using the computer will mind if it starts automatically.


Tried that a long time ago. I don't know if that works in Vista32, but for that temp software, it does not work for Vista64. Prompt comes up every time. It's OK, only a slight annoyance.
 
UAC isn't useless, but as mentioned, its so annoying it might as well be useless.
 
Back
Top