Hard Drive and CD Drive only one IDE

at_viper

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 21, 2008
Messages
507
I only have one ide connector on my MoBo. I am wondering if i can use one ribbon to hook up my hard drive and my cd drive? I know I can get an ide controller or convert one of the sata connectors to ide for my hard drive. Any advice would be great.
 
IDE supports 2 drives on one cable. Its not the ideal setup, but you can put your HDD and your CD/DVD drive on the same cable.
 
Look at the back of the drives, where you plug the cable into. there should be some more pins and on top of the drive or at the manufacturers website it will list instructions on how/where to place a jumper. Set the jumper on the harddrive to MASTER and the jumper on the cd-rom (will also have jumper in the same area, read the outside of the cd-rom for settings info) to SLAVE

The IDE/PATA standard allows one master and one slave per channel.

SATA allows only one device per channel. (unless you use a multiplier, but thats another story).
 
Some drives may have a setting for master alone, and master with a slave present. Read all the jumper settings.

You can get an IDE to Sata converter. They cost 20-30 bux.

Or just get a new FAST sata drive and an external enclosure for the IDE drive for backup.

Don
 
I only have ide drives and am not willing to spend money I dont have so sata is out of the question. Thanks for the help though
 
Well, if you have a MOBO with only 1 ide connector, you have a fairly current system. You are definitely limiting yourself if you are running an older ide drive on this system.

That said, as you can see from the other posts, 1 HD can live happily with a CDrom drove with 1 port.

But start saving your pennies for a current sata drive as that will help you out considerably. Watch the Hot Deals forum for good buys.

Don
 
yeah putting the hard drive on the same ribbion as the cd-rom will limit speed tothe slowest device.

most likely that woud be udma 33 instead of udma 100 that the hard drive would be.

see why everyone says get a sata drive?
 
If you're not using the IDE drive as your system drive, you could just get an IDE controller card if you need extra ports. That way you don't have the hard drive and CD-Rom sharing the same one and slowing things down.

Try and find a PCI-Express one if they exist, that way it won't be hamstrung by any other PCI cards you have installed.
 
yeah putting the hard drive on the same ribbion as the cd-rom will limit speed tothe slowest device.

most likely that woud be udma 33 instead of udma 100 that the hard drive would be.

see why everyone says get a sata drive?
Sorry, that's just not true. It may have been the case years ago, but two devices running in DMA mode on a modern IDE controller will each operate at their own maximum speed.

If you're transferring data from one device to another, you could only do so at the rate dictated by the slower drive (and also the fact that an IDE interface only allows one device on the cable to be reading or writing at any given time), but that's a different argument...
 
If you're not using the IDE drive as your system drive, you could just get an IDE controller card if you need extra ports. That way you don't have the hard drive and CD-Rom sharing the same one and slowing things down.

Try and find a PCI-Express one if they exist, that way it won't be hamstrung by any other PCI cards you have installed.

Actually most controller cards will allow you to boot from the add in card. I have done it before.

You could also leave the hard drive plugged into the MOBO and plug the CD into the add in card.

I think the PCI bus has a through put of 133 MB/sec. An older IDE drive prolly runs less than 50 MB/sec. PCI wont be a bottleneck in this case.

Don
 
yeah putting the hard drive on the same ribbion as the cd-rom will limit speed tothe slowest device.

most likely that woud be udma 33 instead of udma 100 that the hard drive would be.

see why everyone says get a sata drive?

Sorry, that's just not true. It may have been the case years ago, but two devices running in DMA mode on a modern IDE controller will each operate at their own maximum speed.

If you're transferring data from one device to another, you could only do so at the rate dictated by the slower drive (and also the fact that an IDE interface only allows one device on the cable to be reading or writing at any given time), but that's a different argument...

please give me some type of source to colaborate your statement
 
yeah putting the hard drive on the same ribbion as the cd-rom will limit speed tothe slowest device.
I believe that was resolved with some of the latter specs of the IDE controllers. Way back when, you would have issues burning data to a CD drive from a hard drive on it's same cable, but that hadn't been a problem for a few years before most people switched over to SATA HDDs. The OP will be just fine using them on the same cable for now, until an upgrade to some SATA devices...which are all very cheap now.
 
please give me some type of source to colaborate your statement
No, I don't think I'll bother, as I'm under no obligation to do your research for you.

If you want to check it out for yourself, attach a PATA HDD and an optical drive to the IDE interface on your own motherboard, as master/slave on a single IDE cable (80-strand, for obvious reasons). Then go into Device Manager > IDE ATA/ATAPI controllers > (whichever IDE channel) > Advanced Settings, and take a look at the transfer modes available as well as the current transfer mode for each device. You can also run HDTach/HDTune or whatever you like on the HDD to confirm its transfer speeds.

Having said that, the JMicron controllers typically grafted onto motherboards whose chipsets don't support IDE natively can be less than stellar performers, at least where HDDs are concerned. If the OP has one of those, it might be as good a reason as any to switch to SATA if possible but, again, that's a different argument...
 
No, I don't think I'll bother, as I'm under no obligation to do your research for you.

If you want to check it out for yourself, attach a PATA HDD and an optical drive to the IDE interface on your own motherboard, as master/slave on a single IDE cable (80-strand, for obvious reasons). Then go into Device Manager > IDE ATA/ATAPI controllers > (whichever IDE channel) > Advanced Settings, and take a look at the transfer modes available as well as the current transfer mode for each device. You can also run HDTach/HDTune or whatever you like on the HDD to confirm its transfer speeds.

Having said that, the JMicron controllers typically grafted onto motherboards whose chipsets don't support IDE natively can be less than stellar performers, at least where HDDs are concerned. If the OP has one of those, it might be as good a reason as any to switch to SATA if possible but, again, that's a different argument...

u don't have to be rude about it but if ur gonna post some information then you should be prepared to back it up.
 
off topic, but all4amd, that 2400+ must be crying out mercy at 1.9v! lol, lanpart ULTRA B best board ever made
 
u don't have to be rude about it but if ur gonna post some information then you should be prepared to back it up.
Well, you didn't bother citing any sources for your own claims, and the way you said "please give me some type of source to coloborate [sic] your statement," as if it were something to which you were entitled as of right, came across as a little arrogant, and I reacted accordingly.

Anyway, I apologise for any rudeness. There's a Wikipedia article that explains it, and if you google for "independent device timing" you'll find plenty more information.

Hope that's all clear now.
 
Well, you didn't bother citing any sources for your own claims, and the way you said "please give me some type of source to coloborate [sic] your statement," as if it were something to which you were entitled as of right, came across as a little arrogant, and I reacted accordingly.

Anyway, I apologise for any rudeness. There's a Wikipedia article that explains it, and if you google for "independent device timing" you'll find plenty more information.

Hope that's all clear now.

i thought it was common knowledge since thats what i was taught. i havent kepted up with ide because the last system i owned only used ide for the dvd rom drive. thanks for the article, that clears up a few myths
 
Back
Top