EU to Investigate Microsoft File Format Support

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The European Commission plans to investigate Microsoft's decision to add support for the Open Document Format to Office.

"The Commission will investigate whether the announced support of Open Document Format in Office leads to better interoperability and allows consumers to process and exchange their documents with the software product of their choice," the commission said in a statement reported by Dow Jones.
 
Wow these guys just won't get off Microsoft's back will they? It looks to me like M$ is one of the major sources of income for the EU.
 
Can someone explain how this would NOT lead to better interoperability?
 
I don't suppose the EU will investigate to make sure OpenOffice and Mac's equivalences and KOffice and WordPerfect and a slew of other office programs work with each other either :rolleyes:
 
Wow these guys just won't get off Microsoft's back will they? It looks to me like M$ is one of the major sources of income for the EU.

Might want to read the article. Just maybe.

They're not attacking Microsoft over the move, Microsoft did it as a concession to ease the monopoly situation. The EU is investigating the magnitude of the effect.
 
I don't suppose the EU will investigate to make sure OpenOffice and Mac's equivalences and KOffice and WordPerfect and a slew of other office programs work with each other either :rolleyes:

Nope, because, as said tens of thousands of times, those aren't in a monopoly position. Of course, you obviously didn't read the article either since you seem to ahve no clue as to the point of the investigation.
 
I did read the article, thank you for telling me what I do and think though, but I think I can do that on my own. Monopoly or no, you can't tell one company one thing and let all the others do whatever they want. It's stupid.
 
I did read the article, thank you for telling me what I do and think though, but I think I can do that on my own. Monopoly or no, you can't tell one company one thing and let all the others do whatever they want. It's stupid.

In tax-happy corporation-hating liberal wankers paradise you can, in fact, you must.
 
Monopoly or no, you can't tell one company one thing and let all the others do whatever they want. It's stupid.

Apparently you aren't familiar with the Sherman Antitrust Act, because that's exactly what it allows for. Antitrust law only applies to cartels and monopolies; if you're not one of those, then it doesn't apply.

Whether or not you agree with the law is another question, but there's no disputing what it is.
 
I did read the article, thank you for telling me what I do and think though, but I think I can do that on my own. Monopoly or no, you can't tell one company one thing and let all the others do whatever they want. It's stupid.

Yes you can, in fact, that's the law in almost EVERY country in the world, including the US. You obviously have comprehension issues since you have somehow come to the conclusion that me stating my observations "you SEEM to have no clue as to the point of the investigation" is me telling you what you're thinking.

In tax-happy corporation-hating liberal wankers paradise you can, in fact, you must.

You mean America? Because monopoly laws are thje only thing that keeps Microsoft and other monopolies in line in the US. Without them you'd be paying $100/gallon far gas, $5,000 for a CPU, and $200/month for your cellphone. Competition laws are the only reason competition exists.
 
I dont have a problem with anti-monopoly laws, I have a problem with everytime MS tries to do anything, the EU feels like they need to investigate it and look for financial hand outs.
 
I dont have a problem with anti-monopoly laws, I have a problem with everytime MS tries to do anything, the EU feels like they need to investigate it and look for financial hand outs.

Except, as I mentioned before, they're not investigating Microsoft for a monopoly violation here, they're investigating the magnitude of the concession made by Microsoft in regards to prior anti-trust complaints.
 
Except, as I mentioned before, they're not investigating Microsoft for a monopoly violation here, they're investigating the magnitude of the concession made by Microsoft in regards to prior anti-trust complaints.

In other words, if they don't like it, they'll sue again. Why don't EU just oust Gates and Ballmer and run the company themselves since that what it seems like they're doing anymore? Piss off with your attitude. I don't have to agree with what you say then have you turn around and insult me.
 
In other words, if they don't like it, they'll sue again. Why don't EU just oust Gates and Ballmer and run the company themselves since that what it seems like they're doing anymore? Piss off with your attitude. I don't have to agree with what you say then have you turn around and insult me.


Right on man, I am tired of the EU and what they are doing to Microsoft also, its pretty annoying story after story filing lawsuits and Microsoft has to pay out to appease the EU. Maybe we should do the same to EU companies.
 
It's not suing. It's a fine for non-compliance. If they're found to still be in non-compliance, then it's perfectly reasonable to fine them again.

If MS wants to operate in foreign countries then they need to abide by regional laws. They're welcome to stop doing business in the EU if they don't like the law.
 
from the link to "the sherman act" ....

"It shall be unlawful for any person engaged in commerce, in the course of such commerce, either directly or indirectly, to discriminate in price between different purchasers of commodities of like grade and quality, ..."

I don't think it does allow anyone to do what they like so long as they are not deemed to be a monopoly.

lol :)

the application of the law is selective ...apple may be fine now, for example..but, when the antitrust suit hits them in the future...their current practices will be used to support the future finding.
 
Here we go again.

Whaaaaaaaa MSFT doesn't support open stuff....
Whaaaaaaaa MSFT is supporting open stuff....
Whaaaaaaaa someone go to the EU ATM machine and get more cash, we're running low on blow and hookers.
 
Here we go again.

Whaaaaaaaa MSFT doesn't support open stuff....
Whaaaaaaaa MSFT is supporting open stuff....
Whaaaaaaaa someone go to the EU ATM machine and get more cash, we're running low on blow and hookers.

hahaha, nice, that made my day.:D
 
I think while they are at it they need to invesitgate weither or not burying yourself alive in a large tank of concrete will kill you or not.

Here I will save them some time and money on their investigation to Microsoft's decision.

Will Microsoft supporting more file types thus allowing people to use other programs and still work with people using Office be helpful? Yes

Will this force more people to use Office? No

Will this allow you to start using more programs other othan Office if you want? Yes

Is this a good choice? yes

Is it helpful to end users? yes

Should it be allowed to be done without ainyone starting any shit about it? yes

Ok, study done.
 
Hm, this is interesting. I don't really see what's to "investigate" here. I'll just sit back and watch this one go through. If it some how manages to get to where the EC lays down a fine or something, my initial reaction will be that it's absurd, but will have to see the reason they cite for it. Who knows what law they'll find from like 1952 that they'll skew into being able to get money from MS on.
 
You mean America? Because monopoly laws are thje only thing that keeps Microsoft and other monopolies in line in the US. Without them you'd be paying $100/gallon far gas, $5,000 for a CPU, and $200/month for your cellphone. Competition laws are the only reason competition exists.

Wow you are stupid. :p
 
Here we go again.

Whaaaaaaaa MSFT doesn't support open stuff....
Whaaaaaaaa MSFT is supporting open stuff....
Whaaaaaaaa someone go to the EU ATM machine and get more cash, we're running low on blow and hookers.

Made....my....day!! :D
 
I don't think this takes much investigating. Native OpenDocument support = more choices for the consumer.
 
Who even wants ODF files? :p Other than slashbots, I have never seen anyone ask for it. IRL I have never seen anyone even mention ODF.

File compatibility doesn't go away just because some future product will include support, likely not even as the default format (of course someone could change the default... individually). Internally, companies and even most home users will save in whatever default format their program uses, making the occasional exception to convert when necessary to send in a specific format. The inertia of current formats (not just MS Office formats) will not change for a long while.

IMO, it's mainly sour grapes. As long as the "de facto" format isn't made by MS, it's all A-OK. Think about all the non-open formats you use every day and the total lack of complaints about those that are not made by MS.
 
I think .doc and .pdf are the only non-documented formats that I use on a regular basis...
 
lol too funny, harp on Apple some more and their closed Itunes system, or did the EU get Apple to let people use Itunes songs on any other player yet?
 
Competition laws are the only reason competition exists.

ORLY?

i haven't taken any econ yet (and i don't really plan to) but i do believe you are wrong. if there is more than one company that makes products for a sector of a market, there is competition. law didn't really govern it until things started getting out of hand (Standard Oil is a prime example). feel free to correct me if i'm ignorant though.
 
without regulation, competition would not exist. It isnt as profitable as consolidation and stagnation, in the short term.
 
Can someone explain how this would NOT lead to better interoperability?

it all stems from how it is implemented. MS have a history of breaking compatability.
JAVA for one
Internet for another...

The list goes on. The EU are welcoming this move from MS, But due to their experience from MS not delivering on what they said they are causious. NOT to mention MS "bought" their fileformat MSOOXML as an ISO standard YET they don't even implement it...


I think .doc and .pdf are the only non-documented formats that I use on a regular basis...

*.doc yes, *.pdf no. Adobe handed that over to ISO, and they handed it over fully (no binary blobs, everything fully documented...)


Who even wants ODF files? :p Other than slashbots, I have never seen anyone ask for it. IRL I have never seen anyone even mention ODF.

File compatibility doesn't go away just because some future product will include support, likely not even as the default format (of course someone could change the default... individually). Internally, companies and even most home users will save in whatever default format their program uses, making the occasional exception to convert when necessary to send in a specific format. The inertia of current formats (not just MS Office formats) will not change for a long while.

IMO, it's mainly sour grapes. As long as the "de facto" format isn't made by MS, it's all A-OK. Think about all the non-open formats you use every day and the total lack of complaints about those that are not made by MS.
Who wants ODF? I dunno... Governements around the world (as yes that includes America as well...)
Gov'n actually asked for an open file format since their eyes were being opened to vendor lockin. ODF already existed and they submitted it to ISO and got accepted. Microsoft responded with MSOOXML (docx....) but what they submitted is a fucking mess.

MS ended up buying the ISO (investigations ongoing into this to fine MS over this).
The problem is there is NO implementation of MSOOXML ISO standard in existance. MS have even stated they will NEVER support it in their office programs (and used a perverted form of it for their docx...).

Due to this gov'n around the world are moving to ODF (since it is the only fully documented, fully open, fully supported open format in-use) MS had to respond via adding support
 
Exavior + eeyrjmr both make sense.. almost all the rest didnt even read the article or didnt understand it.. you just saw the headline and blacked out, didnt you?

Everyone together:
"They took our jobs!"
"Dey Tuk R Jarbs!"
"Durk our durrr!"
 
lol too funny, harp on Apple some more and their closed Itunes system, or did the EU get Apple to let people use Itunes songs on any other player yet?

You say that in jest, but I believe they're looking into it. France certainly was...
 
Found some links regarding the EU investigating Apple over antitrust violations. As much as you guys like to harp on the EU, they're not totally crazy.

Links:
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20070311-eu-commissioner-criticizes-ipod-itunes-tie-in.html
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17920298/

You'll also note that they're only investigating Apple in areas where they arguably have a monopoly (ie. portables music players, online music store). Some of you guys have difficulty understanding that antitrust law inherently applies a different standard to companies who are monopolies or are in trusts.
 
Found some links regarding the EU investigating Apple over antitrust violations. As much as you guys like to harp on the EU, they're not totally crazy.

Links:
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20070311-eu-commissioner-criticizes-ipod-itunes-tie-in.html
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17920298/

You'll also note that they're only investigating Apple in areas where they arguably have a monopoly (ie. portables music players, online music store). Some of you guys have difficulty understanding that antitrust law inherently applies a different standard to companies who are monopolies or are in trusts.

I get that feeling abt this place to...
They seem to think an attack on MS/ any american company is wrong EVEN tho said company is only being investigated because they are potentially violating local laws... laws they know about
 
I get that feeling abt this place to...
They seem to think an attack on MS/ any american company is wrong EVEN tho said company is only being investigated because they are potentially violating local laws... laws they know about

No, we don't think that.
We think that some of the stuff the EU has nailed MS on was legit, but now every time MS does anything the EU wants to investigate and try to find a reason to fine them.
 
ORLY?

i haven't taken any econ yet (and i don't really plan to) but i do believe you are wrong. if there is more than one company that makes products for a sector of a market, there is competition. law didn't really govern it until things started getting out of hand (Standard Oil is a prime example). feel free to correct me if i'm ignorant though.

In markets with low entry barriers, there will always be some competition. On the other hand, when you look at markets with high entry barriers, such as microprocessors, oil, or video cards, there are next to no new startups.

Take Intel and AMD for example.

First off, let it be noted that IBM refused to deal with Intel unless they allowed AMD to produce competing hardware, specifically because of monopoly concerns, which is the only reason Intel isn't currently a monopoly.

*Disclaimer: I don't know the exact timeline for AMD vs Intel, so the below year is a guess.*

Fast forward to lets say... The year 1995. AMD is now cutting into Intel's profits, despite being much much smaller. What should Intel do about it? With competition laws, Intel cuts their profit margins repeatedly to slow AMD's profits. Since Intel has the massive amount of cash, they can survive easily on thinner margins, AMD on the other hand doesn't and is forced to be more frugal with thier money. Regardless, AMD still provides serious competition.

Now what happens without competition laws? There are a few different possiblities.
A) Intel cuts prices until they're in negative margins. They take billions in losses to prevent AMD from competing. Without cash reserves of the magnitude Intel has, AMD is forced to cut research and take out massive loans to be able to continue to exist. Intel easily forces them into bankruptcy.

B) Intel launches a campaign to stop large scale purchasing of AMD processors. All major purchasers around the world are offered bonuses for not selling AMD products, or in some cases are told that purchasing anything AMD will result in a complete cut-off of Intel products. AMD can't get the sales numbers to fund research/chip fabs. *Note: Intel has already been found guilty of attempting this in some countries, and is currently facing investigations in many others.*


C) Intel buys AMD.

Whether A, B, or C, the result is the same. Competition is dead for another decade until another serious competitor arises and, likely, ends up repeating the same scenario.

Any time you require tens or hundreds of millions of dollars to enter an industry competition is going to be sparse. In any long term run, there are going to be companies that perform poorly at the same time as their competitiors perform well. Without competition laws to protect these companies during their downswings they would be quickly destroyed until only one or two remains, or, in the case of something like OPEC, until they collude and behave as a monopoly.
 
No, we don't think that.
We think that some of the stuff the EU has nailed MS on was legit, but now every time MS does anything the EU wants to investigate and try to find a reason to fine them.

AND Rightly so due to their past attitude and behaviour!!

They cannot be trusted as they have shown time and time again w.r.t. legal ruling in Europe (rulings that the US gov'n back btw).
They drag their feet, delay paying fines, not provide what was asked for

With such an attitude to gov'n legislation YES MS should be under the Microsoft. If/When Microsoft re-gain the EU trust they will not be so closely watched. Until that time every thing they do will be looked at

Just like every other company that is found guilty in the EU. In fact like individuals..
IF I don't do my income tax correctly and the tax offices investigates me not only do I have to pay any back-tax, not only do I have to pay a fine BUT for the next few years I would have to goto the local tax office and go through my tax details EVERY YEAR until the tax office think they can trust me again

Same goes for companies, MS have shown time and time again they will try to flaunt EU legal rulings and thus EU (just like any other country.. even yr precious U.S.A. you do know they are still being watched do you and that the date for such "watching" was extended in the US yet you don't bitch abt that... the word for that is hypocrisy) believes that MS must be mothered since they cannot be trusted to adhere to rules (let alone rulings) by themselves

All countries do this
 
Back
Top