Samsung LNxxA650 Your thoughts?

vengence

Level capped
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Messages
18,469
I'm looking at getting this. I know the diffrerence between it and the 750 is bells and whistles. (Not worth the price imho) I think I heard (or read, or maybe just imagined) it is a diffrent pannel than the 550. I saw one of these at circuit city. Looked insanely good compared to the stuff next to it. Black looked black. From looking around there is a pioneer that has a better black but doesn't do green real well I hear.

When I bought my Samsung 245BW I got into "analysis paralysis" by over analyzing everything. I'm not a videophile or an audiophile. Are there any MAJOR issues I need to be concerened with on this set? I'll be connecting it to FIOS so I'm not worried about the annoying spin wheel thing on the remote.
 
It did have issues with random shut downs but I am sure they fixed that. Your best bet is http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1007540 . I have been looking at this model for awhile and where I am there is 1000 dollar difference between 530/550 and the 650. For that money I rather go with the 530. So for the differences I see between the 550 and the 650 is the 650 screen has more gloss to it. A bit better contrast, 120 Hz if you like that and I believe a 10bit panel. It's an excellent screen, you can't go wrong. All screens have faults if you look hard enough.
 
It did have issues with random shut downs but I am sure they fixed that. Your best bet is http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1007540 . I have been looking at this model for awhile and where I am there is 1000 dollar difference between 530/550 and the 650. For that money I rather go with the 530. So for the differences I see between the 550 and the 650 is the 650 screen has more gloss to it. A bit better contrast, 120 Hz if you like that and I believe a 10bit panel. It's an excellent screen, you can't go wrong. All screens have faults if you look hard enough.

I am well aware all screens have faults. Which is why I'm trying not to over analyze. They did fix the random shutdown problem. I'll need to make sure the firmware version though if I buy it online though.
 
I'm looking at getting this. I know the diffrerence between it and the 750 is bells and whistles. (Not worth the price imho) I think I heard (or read, or maybe just imagined) it is a diffrent pannel than the 550. I saw one of these at circuit city. Looked insanely good compared to the stuff next to it. Black looked black. From looking around there is a pioneer that has a better black but doesn't do green real well I hear.

When I bought my Samsung 245BW I got into "analysis paralysis" by over analyzing everything. I'm not a videophile or an audiophile. Are there any MAJOR issues I need to be concerened with on this set? I'll be connecting it to FIOS so I'm not worried about the annoying spin wheel thing on the remote.

Have last year's 65F Samsung LCD for my computer, which has a similar screen coating to the A650. In daylight especially, it does give the appearance of a deeper black. I think that aspect is great.

However, if it's for pure TV use, the Pioneer Kuro, with its far superior native contrast ratio and black level is still the champ...

(If it's a bright room though, LCD might be better. And for computer use, I still worry about plasma image retention...)
 
Have last year's 65F Samsung LCD for my computer, which has a similar screen coating to the A650. In daylight especially, it does give the appearance of a deeper black. I think that aspect is great.

However, if it's for pure TV use, the Pioneer Kuro, with its far superior native contrast ratio and black level is still the champ...

(If it's a bright room though, LCD might be better. And for computer use, I still worry about plasma image retention...)

It'll be for TV / Next gen Console use. I'll watch a lot of sports on it.

On the Kuro, I've heard it's green is poor.

Another one of the reasons I was looking at the Samsung was the closed captioning is suppose to phenominal. My wife is legally deaf, she wears hearing aids and for the most part is just like anyone else. But she doesn't hear the TV real well so we leave CC on. Of course, trying to talk to her when she doesn't have them in is like talking to a brick wall... lol.
 
It'll be for TV / Next gen Console use. I'll watch a lot of sports on it.

On the Kuro, I've heard it's green is poor.

Another one of the reasons I was looking at the Samsung was the closed captioning is suppose to phenominal. My wife is legally deaf, she wears hearing aids and for the most part is just like anyone else. But she doesn't hear the TV real well so we leave CC on. Of course, trying to talk to her when she doesn't have them in is like talking to a brick wall...

I'd go to the store and have them activate closed captioning. Also check out viewing from angles and if the amount of desaturation is tolerable, which can be an issue with LCD, depending on how your furniture is layed out...
 
I'd go to the store and have them activate closed captioning. Also check out viewing from angles and if the amount of desaturation is tolerable, which can be an issue with LCD, depending on how your furniture is layed out...

I did, the viewing angle on it was insane for an LCD.
 
I saw the 650 series at BB not too long ago, looked amazing in person. I am actually looking at the 550 in 52".
 
I did, the viewing angle on it was insane for an LCD.

I thought the a650 I saw on display looked great. (The bright overhead lighting was quite LCD friendly though.)

Viewing angles (extreme ones anyway) did suffer compared to the Panasonic plasma mounted above the a650.

(Found the screen coating on the Panasonic very disappointing though. Apparently some of last years model's had a much better coating...)
 
Their is no major issue with this TV anymore (since the random power on/off fix).

The main differences between the 650 and the 750 are (listed by imporvements in the 750):

Much improved 3:2 pulldown
DNIE+
DLNA certified
1GB internal storage
Can play movies via wiselink
ToC affected by ambient light

Disadvantages of 750:
Non-swivel base


switchg3ar FWIW a few days ago my Samsung rep came into the store to give me and the guys I work with a training. After a little pressing he confirmed that everything in the 50 series is made by Samsung, but he could "neither confirm nor deny" that the 30 series are outsourced like Sony's M series or Toshiba's new CV500's. Also FWIW I plan on buying a 46A650 in about a month. My third shipment of them should be in by then and I think most of the bugs will be worked out. It's an absolutaly phenomenal panel.
 
DNIE+ is a slighty improved DNIE, which is a Samsung technology that makes colors more vibrant (http://www.chooseyourtv.com/dnie.html). 3:2 pulldown is the technical term for making movies shot at 24fps (dvd, Blu-ray's) work on a tv that runs at 60 fps (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3:2_pulldown#2:3_pulldown). On a 120hz TV it is debateable if this feature is worth it.

DLNA is a little different beast though. The TV has an rj-45 connection on it. If you have a wired network in your home and have things like a DLNA certified TV hooked up via HDMI to a DLNA certified Blu-ray player and "Oh Noes!" you want to make yourself some popcorn in the kitchen or are feeling tired and want to go to sleep. You could pause the Blu-ray connected to your main TV, go into your kitchen or bedroom and if you have another DLNA certified TV in that second room you can resume playback of the Blu-ray on the second TV. Here's a few other examples of what it can do: http://www.dlna.org/digital_living/possibilities/

And I still haven't decided between the 650 and the 750 :mad:
 
Wouldn't buy a TV based on DNIE. (Except for making sure it has the ability to turn DNIE off.) With DLPs anyway, it was a negative that originally held the Samsung sets back...
 
Back
Top