Blu-ray Numbers Too Low To Release

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you thought the death of HD DVD would help Blu-ray, you’d be wrong. Sales of stand alone players fell 40% at the beginning of the year, recovered 2% of that and has remained so low that NPD will not release actual numbers. Ouch.

In fact, sales of Blu-ray standalone players remain so low that NPD has not yet released actual numbers, for fear that it would be easy to identify individual retailers. The research group will start to give actual figures later this year, said Ross Rubin, director of industry analysis at NPD.
 
Those stats could be thrown off by people buyings PS3s for their players. Earlier in the week I saw an article talking about how many HDTVs were being purchased by gamers. These two things would seem to go together. For that tech savvy group, it would make sense for many to get a PS3 instead of a standalone player. In addition, the standalones can't be upgraded to new hardware versions (e.g. 1.1 and 2.0 in the future) but the PS3 can.

Of course I think the complaints about the cost of the hardware and the discs may have something to do with this as well.
 
Those stats could be thrown off by people buyings PS3s for their players. Earlier in the week I saw an article talking about how many HDTVs were being purchased by gamers. These two things would seem to go together. For that tech savvy group, it would make sense for many to get a PS3 instead of a standalone player. In addition, the standalones can't be upgraded to new hardware versions (e.g. 1.1 and 2.0 in the future) but the PS3 can.

Of course I think the complaints about the cost of the hardware and the discs may have something to do with this as well.

PS3 sales never stopped Sony from boasting higher BluRay sales versus HDDVD. They would be hypocritical if they started doing that now.
 
my friends parents just got a PS3 for a blu-ray player so +1 against standalone players...
 
Who could have guessed that when BR players *jumped* in price following the defeat of HD-DVD that people would stop buying them and wait for more sensible prices? I'm shocked, shocked I tell you.

:p
 
I'm too young to remember, but how long did it take DVD to gain support over VHS. Did DVD have slow and sluggish sales for the first couple of years it was on the market? A new type of media always take a while to become commonplace. The major draw back to blu-ray is the fact that most people need to upgrade their entire home theater just to use the new media, ie HDTV HTIB (or more expensive receiver and speakers) Which in the end costs more than the player itslef and most people aren't willing to spend that much.
 
Who could have guessed that when BR players *jumped* in price following the defeat of HD-DVD that people would stop buying them and wait for more sensible prices? I'm shocked, shocked I tell you.

:p

I guess I am not the only one who is still sad over the loss of HD-DVD.

HD-DVD seemed to be the format that would be best for consumers; players were cheaper, players were more standardized, and discs were cheaper.

I was half-expecting HD-DVD to come back from the dead following Blu-Ray's massive increase in prices. Maybe by "half-expecting" I mean to say "hoping."
 
this is what you get sony for not letting the CONSUMERS decide the format war. you know like most of the format wars of the past, either the consumers choose or hardware manufactures did dual-format devices. This is what you get for BUYING the format war.
 
It seems to be the consumer did choose by buying Blu-ray hardware.
This caused video producers to jump ship from HD-DVD and ultimately the demise of HD-DVD.
 
i am buying more hddvds in the past 2 months than before their demise. so sad......i hope sony burns in hell.
 
Who wants to pay $30 for a movie they'll watch once or twice? Add that additional movie cost to an expensive player and it's no wonder traditional DVD sales are still doing well. Let's face it, there's only a few movies a year that really deserve to be watched in Hi Def because of their great scenery or special effects. HD adds little to a serious plot based movie.
 
I guess I am not the only one who is still sad over the loss of HD-DVD.

HD-DVD seemed to be the format that would be best for consumers; players were cheaper, players were more standardized, and discs were cheaper.

I was half-expecting HD-DVD to come back from the dead following Blu-Ray's massive increase in prices. Maybe by "half-expecting" I mean to say "hoping."
I am shocked most at the fact that standalone Blu-Ray players are still $400 or more, and they are wondering why they are not selling.
they need to get down to below $200 for average consumers to start picking them up, for now only the movie buffs, gadgetiers and true movie enthusiasts are going to buy them. Most of them need, what One?
Especially with the HD upconvert players being $99 and the picture quality is pretty darn good. I know several people who are just as happy with their upconvert player as they would be with a HD player of any kind, and the disks are roughly half the price.

(prices are estimates based on local information, yes if you shop hard enough you can find anything cheaper. but most common shoppers pick up such items based on local advertising, or reputable Etailers on the web, bestbuy, newegg, buy.com, and similar. Not everyone is willing to buy from Chang Yao's hottronics.com)
 
Sony needs to drop the prices on the movies and the players, unless Sony wants another UMD/Mini Disc on their hands.
 
I'm too young to remember, but how long did it take DVD to gain support over VHS. Did DVD have slow and sluggish sales for the first couple of years it was on the market?

It happened a lot faster than DVD-Bluray is happening, at least i read somewhere back then when i purchased my first DVD player (early adopter) that it was one of the fastest techs to gain ground quickly. But DVD had a lot of advantages over its predecessors

- Significantly better picture quality and audio quality
- No loss of quality over time
- No more rewinding/fastforwarding etc
- Extras

Bluray has improved picture quality only for the majority of people i know with it. Sure there are better audio, but most people i know are still using 5.1ch sound systems and cant tell the difference between 5.1DD and the HD audio formats.

Also a lot more people (at least my friends) that buying movies in whatever format is useless unless you really plan on watching them multiple times. In the past ive had a collection of over 500 original DVD's. Some ive watched 10 times, most of them (probably 95%) have been in once though, so i could have saved a lot of money/house space, by just renting them. There's a few i will pick up in bluray, but apart from maybe 20-25 movies released in the last 20 years that will be it.
 
I'm too young to remember, but how long did it take DVD to gain support over VHS. Did DVD have slow and sluggish sales for the first couple of years it was on the market? A new type of media always take a while to become commonplace. The major draw back to blu-ray is the fact that most people need to upgrade their entire home theater just to use the new media, ie HDTV HTIB (or more expensive receiver and speakers) Which in the end costs more than the player itslef and most people aren't willing to spend that much.

My recollection was that the move from VHS to DVD didn't take too long. The leap from VHS to DVD in terms of image quality and ease of use was colossal. There was much more incentive to make the move back then because you got so much more for your money. The leap from standard DVD to BR is too incremental to be considered a value to anybody other than videophiles.

DVD over VHS:

Quantum leap in image quality
Fast access to segments (movie sections - chapters)
Slow motion/still frame was crisp
Price - I purchased my first DVD player for $249 while good VHS players were $179
Tape sucks - Fast forward/rewinding, bulk, fragility, etc.

I'd like to enter the HD arena but there is no value in it (for me). Standard DVD movies in widescreen format offer fantastic image quality. HD is great but it's nowhere near the leap in image quality as DVD did had over VHS.
 
The PS3 is definitely "hurting" standalone sales. There is no doubt about it.

I, myself, bought a PS3 for Bluray... and just in the last month have had 3 friends do the same. What's really interesting is that even though none of us bought it to play games... _all_ of us are ;-)

I _really_ don't like Sony. I mean _really really really_ don't like them, for many different reasons. But you know what? I love my PS3. It is a great piece of hardware. It works great as a media streamer from my PC (photos, music and videos). I love playing games on it (GT5P being my favorite so far). It has an open architecture (It can run Linux... plus ANYTHING USB just plugs in and works... including my steering wheel, USB webcams, mice, keyboards.... ditto for bluetooth as well (headsets, mics, etc.). And it is great as a movie player (especially since it can be updated... like the just added DTS-HD-MA support!).

Seriously... it's a great machine. I don't know how Sony got their shit together and got this thing out the door.

Sure... it has it's drawbacks... like the currently limited PSN Store (need to provide high-def movie rentals like on XBox), and the Six-Axis was a terrible idea (which they are now rectifying with the Dual-Shock3). But overall, for $400, this is a great piece of kit.

I can't see why anyone would get a standalone player at this point in time...

Friedmud
 
HD-DVD Fanbois jumping back into the finished war... 3....2....1....

Everything has had low sales this quarter, look at the economy. You think people are doing to toss $500 towards a video player in this times of the economy when everyone is basically fearing the loss of thier jobs and how they are going to make payments?

Lets talk after the rebate checks.
 
My dad has a PS3, and 3 or 4 of my friends are going to get one when they get their tax checks (hopefully tomorrow, since we haven't received them yet). I only own 1 Blu-Ray movie, and that is Planet Earth, totally worth it (even though I don't actually own a Blu-Ray player, I will get one when I can pick up a Blu-Ray burner for $99 and disks are $3/ea). However I wouldn't buy any other Blu-Ray movies other than LOTR or the Star Wars collection (when they come out), and maybe some other classic action movies that I like to watch from time to time like Aliens, Terminator, Predator, etc.

I doubt that my dad will ever actually buy a Blu-Ray movie, considering he doesn't have many DVD's either, but you better believe that he makes the most out of Netflix. I asked him about it and he said that most of the movies are still DVD but that he gets a new BR movie about once a week.
 
When they start making Blu Ray players better than the PS3 or cheaper than the PS3, then they'll actually sell some stand alone Blu Ray players. Until then Sony sells a lot of PS3s. Myself?

I was in the HD-DVD camp, but hadn't bought anything yet... when Blu Ray won I sucked it up and bought the best Blu Ray player on the market. The PS3. I also bought GH3 and CoD4, but I hardly play either (since I'm a WoW junkie). I bought GTA4 the other day, when WoW raiding is done for the week tonight I'll give that a go.

Other than that, my PS3 has been a glorified Blu Ray player. I'm on the 2 at a time plan from Netflix and have yet to buy a Blu Ray movie (though there's a few on my list to buy whenever they go on sale). If it wasn't for the Blu Ray thing on the PS3, I still wouldn't even own a console gaming system of any kind. My PC is for gaming.
 
I can't see why anyone would get a standalone player at this point in time...

Friedmud

Me either. Considering both are $400...

Nevertheless - I personally don't want a console because I don't like console games.
 
Right now the content is just too exspensive for many to justify the cost. Plain old DVD's work fine for me and many can rent hi-def movies from their cable/satellite providers without getting off the couch. I really don't see BluRay as being a market force before the next thing comes along.
 
Who wants to pay $30 for a movie they'll watch once or twice? Add that additional movie cost to an expensive player and it's no wonder traditional DVD sales are still doing well. Let's face it, there's only a few movies a year that really deserve to be watched in Hi Def because of their great scenery or special effects. HD adds little to a serious plot based movie.

Very true...and from personal experience, unless you have a massive TV (which most households have 40" or less), that 720p is more than adequate, and with upscaling DVD players that actually do a respectable job at it, the desire for Blu-ray is more of a "maybe if I have the cash to burn" purchase than anything.

Honestly, I'm willing to bet that 80% of the Blu-ray players being purchased are PS3s and not standalone units. That right there would indicate a dead format, as a standalone unit is often superior in output quality than an "all-in-one" solution is, and this was in fact an upgrade where output quality was the only concern.

VHS to DVD was more clear-cut since DVDs don't have the wear issues VHS had.
 
I think that their not giving consumers credit for being smart about what they buy. I think most people know that BD Live is not implemented in almost all players except for the PS3. And even if the format is updated at least you can count on the PS3 firmware update to keep up with the times. Why buy an expensive player now when sometime this fall it won't be able to play some of the content with BD Live discs?
I'm sure most people pick up a PS3 instead of a regular Blu Ray player when given the choice because of this and it was the main selling point for me when I got mine.
 
i know when i have a customer looking into blu-ray players, i always point them in the direction of the ps3. i dont really understand why anyone would get anything else other than a 20gb ps3 either; they are the same price as the basic stand-alone blu-ray player from sony, they are future-proof via console updates, they play games in addition to movies, and they have full access to all of sony's online features via wi-fi. imo, it's the best blu-ray player out there.
 
Not to say slumping Blu-ray stand alone is not something to worry about. Because the adoption is important for them.
I think we need to be looking at the big picture though.

1. Since winning this format war, I have yet to see an advertising blitz on Sonys part. I feel they are waiting for a larger adoption of HDTVs before really pushing Blu-ray hard.
2. Speaking of adoption of HDTVs, it will come. 47" and lower HDTVs are dropping in price like nobodies business and when a larger portion of new HDTV buyers comes into play I bet BR drives start to pick up pace.
3. The PS3. It is undeniable that people are buying the PS3 as a Blu-ray player...and why shouldn't they. At this point its one of the cheapest and still one of the best for that function along with the added bonus of everything else on the system.

So while it isn't a great place to be, I hardly feel it is as dire as this news posting makes it out to be.
 
HD-DVD Fanbois jumping back into the finished war... 3....2....1....

Everything has had low sales this quarter, look at the economy. You think people are doing to toss $500 towards a video player in this times of the economy when everyone is basically fearing the loss of thier jobs and how they are going to make payments?

Lets talk after the rebate checks.

No need to re-hash that, Ockie. We all know that the consumers lost the "war".

I suspect most of those rebate checks are going towards credit card debt - that a lot of BR Fanbois contributed to...;)
 
Players are too expensive, movies are too expensive, and the movies released suck. Fix these three things and you might sell something. I am still enjoying my $200 HDDVD player with the ten free movies on the other hand.
 
I also think lower prices are on the horizon, and that will spark more purchases as well.
Cause lets be honest, those things are still pretty pricey
 
I guess I am not the only one who is still sad over the loss of HD-DVD.

HD-DVD seemed to be the format that would be best for consumers; players were cheaper, players were more standardized, and discs were cheaper.

I was half-expecting HD-DVD to come back from the dead following Blu-Ray's massive increase in prices. Maybe by "half-expecting" I mean to say "hoping."

No, you misunderstand. Yes, I have a HD-DVD player (for $89 I knew in November that even if HD-DVD failed I was getting a bargain) but what I was expressing is that the consumer (and my) expectation after HD-DVD fell was that Blu would move its prices down aggressively to become the standard, forstalling efforts to push streaming HD distribution.

Instead standalone player prices rose. So, people are waiting for common sense to return.

Winning the early adopter (aka price is no object) war is not the same as convincing people to jump from $49 DVD players to $500 Blu-ray players or $400 PS3s.

I myself am stepping aside. I've dropped cable and now get $0/month HD over the air :)mad: Comcast), am not buying any more clearance HD-DVDs, and am waiting. I don't care who steps up with a reasonable product whether it's Blu or a streaming/download service with full bit rate or something else, but I'm not throwing my money at half-ass solutions.
 
Yep it has to be because of the ps3 :) Since its cheaper than most blu-ray standalones.. and not only you get blu-ray with the ps3 but a great gaming system too :D although it puts out too much heat :eek: but at least it dosen't over heat and crashes :D ... and yea even at fry's well at least the one here uses ps3 to demo blu ray movies on their hi-def tvs :)
 
This is getting old. Don't want to buy Blu-ray? Then don't. Can't afford it because it expensive? Oh well then. Those that complain really need to find something else to do.

Sony like every other corporation out there is out to make money. Their business model says that they can sell the players for that price and the market will bare it. If not then they will lower the price. Why people take it personal when that the Blu-ray players are expensive is beyond me. Why people think they know better than the "evil" corporation is beyond me. Why people feel they are entitled to cheap electronics is beyond me.

Too many people like talking out of their asses.:rolleyes:
 
Owning both standards, I've actually purchased less Blu-ray and more HD DVD's since they dropped out of the race. I've paid no more than $8 or $10 for my HD DVD titles, all brand new or in like new condition from Amazon, Deep Discount, and other random closeout sales. I am still waiting for Blu-ray titles to come down in price. It is hard to even find them used for under $15, good titles that is. And on that topic, they need to start releasing some good movies.
 
VThat right there would indicate a dead format, as a standalone unit is often superior in output quality than an "all-in-one" solution is, and this was in fact an upgrade where output quality was the only concern.

Instead, in this case the PS3 is a superior player to standalone Blu-Ray players, offering equal PQ and sound quality, superb upscaling of SD DVDs, and seamless firmware upgradability. The standalone units are pooched when later features are unveiled.
 
Too many people like talking out of their asses.:rolleyes:

...a position in which you seem highly qualified to speak.

I don't read where anybody is criticizing people for purchasing BR players/PS3 units. I thought this discussion centered on the low sale figures of stand alone BR players and possible explanations for the poor sales. But as long as we're talking out of our asses, your contribution to the subject is welcome.
 
Sounds like Blu-ray is going to go the way SACD and DVD-Audio format war went. Both formats lost.

Or, Blu-ray the new Laser Disk.
 
Standalone Blu-Ray players are still too expensive. Period. Early adopters have long since bought their players (or PS3s), and the rest of the public is waiting for the price to drop.
 
Back
Top