E6600 bottlenecking 8800gts 512mb?

Vycka

Weaksauce
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
83
Hello everyone,

I've just got my 8800gts 512mb and noticed that it's not performing that much better than my previous card. I decided to try overclocking the card, but I didn't get any decent results. So I overclocked my E6600 to 3.0Ghz just for the hell of it, and noticed a significant increase in the card's performance.

I realize that I kinda answered my own question here, but did anyone else had something like this and how much more should I(if I should) overclock my CPU to get rid of the bottleneck? I am kinda afraid of overclocking the CPU over 3Ghz, since I have stock cooling.

Sorry if this is a dumb/obvious question, but I am bit of a newbie in all this.
 
You did what some would say to do, OC the proc to 2.66ghz+ since @ least for Core 2 procs that's plenty for game performance anyways. Most games are mainly GPU-bottlenecked so with your "E6600 @ 3ghz", you could OC your vidcard a bit, that's what I would recommend. Maybe 690-720 core and 1980-2060(effective mhz) mem, it is luck of the draw so dont fret if u cant hit 750mhz core or w/e. I wouldn't OC your CPU more if/until you get a good HSF like the Xigmatek HDT-S1283 - $37, free shipping atm. Meets or beats a TRUE.
 
mainly? nope just slightly more gpu bound then cpu bound but you equaly need a fast cpu to keep up with games just has well has a fast gpu hench why many here recomend a quad core over a dual core because quads will last longer
 
You did what some would say to do, OC the proc to 2.66ghz+ since @ least for Core 2 procs that's plenty for game performance anyways. Most games are mainly GPU-bottlenecked so with your "E6600 @ 3ghz", you could OC your vidcard a bit, that's what I would recommend. Maybe 690-720 core and 1980-2060(effective mhz) mem, it is luck of the draw so dont fret if u cant hit 750mhz core or w/e. I wouldn't OC your CPU more if/until you get a good HSF like the Xigmatek HDT-S1283 - $37, free shipping atm. Meets or beats a TRUE.

That's the problem, I tried OCing my GPU to 800/2150 and noticed no performance gain whatsoever. Looks like that at 3.0Ghz it's still bottlenecked. I don't plan on having this CPU for more than a year, so its lifespan is expandable. How much more can I overclock it with stock cooling without risking any immediate damage?
 
What game(s) did you notice these results with?

3DMark06 and Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance.

He said what (real) GAMES did you notice this in?

3dMark 06 - benchmark that is skewed for different GPU's with different features so you buy the latest & greatest videocard. Actual game performance is MUCH different from 06 scores.

Supreme Commander is I think of the few games that actually can benefit from more than dual cores and does require a lot of CPU power. But it is completely atypical of nearly every other game.

Virtually all games out there now do fine with a 3.0Ghz Core 2 Duo. Yes, you get more performance with faster CPU's, but you should have enough horsepower for almost anything you throw at it with 3Ghz.
 
He said what (real) GAMES did you notice this in?
I think Supreme Commander is real enough? :p

3dMark 06 - benchmark that is skewed for different GPU's with different features so you buy the latest & greatest videocard. Actual game performance is MUCH different from 06 scores.
I agree, but this is not the point in this case. The point is that the card's performance clearly increases as I OC the CPU, this wouldn't happen with my old card. Be it a benchmark or a real game.

Supreme Commander is I think of the few games that actually can benefit from more than dual cores and does require a lot of CPU power. But it is completely atypical of nearly every other game.
Again, I agree. In my case though, I play on rather small maps, with 1 opponent just to test the video card's performance. CPU usage doesn't even get close to 100%.

Virtually all games out there now do fine with a 3.0Ghz Core 2 Duo. Yes, you get more performance with faster CPU's, but you should have enough horsepower for almost anything you throw at it with 3Ghz.
True enough, but it clearly couldn't handle the 8800gts[92].
 
...

what caused you to upgrade in the first place?

my current rig : x2 at 2.8 [5600+] - 8800gts 640mb - 4gb ozc - vista sp1 - 74gb raptor - dell 24" @ 1920x1200

the only game i have problems with is crysis

everything else i can wind out to my native res and load full of eye goodies and its smooth sailing

you threw the ambiguous out there - bottleneck, performing, significant...

but you didnt really tell us what you're getting or what you want...

do you have a problem with stuttering or clipping or tearing or ...?

inquiring minds want to know :)
 
So is your real question this. How fast of a cpu must you have before the GPU becomes the bottleneck and not the CPU? Is that what you really want to know?
 
What I want to know is how fast the CPU must be to release the card's full potential? And if the E6600 can be that CPU with decent overclocking. As it stands now, it's clear that the CPU is directly limiting the performance of the GPU.

I mean, be it 3dMark06 or Supreme Commander, the CPU doesn't get used above 60%-70% overclocked or not, but the framerates are significantly lower when it's not OC'd. This, along with the fact that OCing the GPU makes absolutely, completely no difference in the framerates(or 3dmark scores) whatsoever until the CPU is OC'd to over 3.3ghz(yea, I tried it and it didn't burst into flames or anything :p), has lead me to believe that the CPU is directly limiting the performance of my GPU. I hope this clarified something :p.

Another edit: significant means as much as 15-20 fps.
 
seems like c2d are not up to its job in gaming atm. imagine how much strain it would put when you pair a e6600 with a 9900 nv or 4000 series cards
 
seems like c2d are not up to its job in gaming atm. imagine how much strain it would put when you pair a e6600 with a 9900 nv or 4000 series cards

The poor thing just couldn't handle those. Oh yea, my last GPU was 8800gts 640mb. I managed to get a really good deal for it and so decided to upgrade.
 
thats probably why your not noticing a big difference in gaming because you when from a 8800gts 640 to a 8800gts 512
 
I was kind of wondering what that was as well. I aswell am going to say you shouldn't really use stats from the 3dmark tests. The reason being is there is no top end for the CPU scores. So your final results would be much higher after a CPU overclock because of the CPU intensive scores would go so much higher. If you are looking at a strict effect of a GPU upgrade you should only compare the GPU results.

As for gaming there is a couple of things where you can see what is limiting you. Open up games and run them at super low res and you will notice that yes no matter what you do with your GPU the frames you get will be for the most part the same because there isn't really much stress on the GPU, and a lot more of the stress being moved over to the CPU. If you move up the resolution to very high levels (being 1680*1050 and above) you will notice more effect in the GPU's capabilities. This is because you have now shifted the focus of the stress to the max the GPU can handle and it no longer is limited by the CPU.

A 3.0GHz e6600 is more than enough for today's games to run just fine. I play my games just fine at 2.8GHz, and don't really see much difference when gaming at 3.5GHz (when encoding though...then there is a difference).

It really comes down to what you are expecting for a difference between the two and the actual difference in reality between the two cards.... there is a difference between the 8800GTS 640 and the 512, but it's really not huge.
 
Sounds like you're having other problems. I have friends running less of a proc with the 8800GTS 512, and aren't having CPU bottlenecks.
Have you checked drivers all around? Besides SupCom, what GAMES have you played that you notice a performance improvement from simply OC'ing your proc?
 
I was kind of wondering what that was as well. I aswell am going to say you shouldn't really use stats from the 3dmark tests. The reason being is there is no top end for the CPU scores. So your final results would be much higher after a CPU overclock because of the CPU intensive scores would go so much higher. If you are looking at a strict effect of a GPU upgrade you should only compare the GPU results.
Yes, yes, I am looking only at the GPU results.

As for gaming there is a couple of things where you can see what is limiting you. Open up games and run them at super low res and you will notice that yes no matter what you do with your GPU the frames you get will be for the most part the same because there isn't really much stress on the GPU, and a lot more of the stress being moved over to the CPU. If you move up the resolution to very high levels (being 1680*1050 and above) you will notice more effect in the GPU's capabilities. This is because you have now shifted the focus of the stress to the max the GPU can handle and it no longer is limited by the CPU.

I will do that, although my max. res is only 1280x1024.

The difference between G80 GTS and G92 GTS has been quite big for me so far, and I am not even running the G92 at its full potential it seems.
 
Sounds like you're having other problems. I have friends running less of a proc with the 8800GTS 512, and aren't having CPU bottlenecks.
Have you checked drivers all around? Besides SupCom, what GAMES have you played that you notice a performance improvement from simply OC'ing your proc?

C&C3(every graphics setting maxed out), HoMM5(maxed out again). I am pretty sure it would be the same with any other game. Anyway, I have all the latest drivers with the exception of the CPU itself. But I don't think it even needs drivers, does it? I couldn't find any.

Anyway, even the dude from the PC store told me that I would need a quadcore for this GPU. I suppose he was right. I didn't believe him back then.

I am going to bed now, see ya tomorrow... I hope.
 
So is your real question this. How fast of a cpu must you have before the GPU becomes the bottleneck and not the CPU? Is that what you really want to know?

Depends what game. FPS=not as much, I think. RTS=more as large scale rendering?
 
I forgot to mention what many of you forget can play a role in CPU gaming performance, L2/L3 cache, The 6MB E8400 @ 3ghz gets 5-20 more FPS than the 4MB cache E6750 depending on the game. Anyways, I say just OC the proc to 3-3.2ghz(highest stable OC, which isn't phenomenal given stock cooling and the E6600 is 2.4-2.6 stock so it could hit 3.4-3.6ghz with a good HSF imo) and OC the GPU/Vram to a good stable speed. btw supreme commander is a tough game for PC's and it may need a patch to realize performance improvements, try other games. and young_boy, yes RTS games (large scale games in general) like fast CPU's while FPS's usually just need a fast GPU and the CPU just needs to be 2.4ghz+(for C2Q, or 2.66ghz+ for a C2D), it all depends on the game/program.
 
Um if supreme commander is all you're worried about. 2 vs 4 cores will be more important than a slight gpu increase or overclock. That game is just very cpu bound. Not sure what clock specifically you might need to max out, try 3.6 if you are daring?
 
You don't need a quad core, thats stupid as games are barely made to use two cores. (referring to unleashing the full power of a 8800GTX)
The CPU is not a bottle neck, the faster CPU speeds just helps the GPU move along thats the only reason why you get a better score.
It was the same when the E6600 was brand new two years ago and you had a X1800XT/X1900XTX as you would get the same increase in performance as you are seeing now with your 8800GTS(92), there is no way the X1900XTX was being being held back because of the processor, just like the 8800GTS(92) is not being held back now.
Supreme Command heavy CPU use, and 3dMark06 has a benefit in its score from the CPU alone.

Instead of thinking "man my cpu sucks as its slowing my GPU down", the reality is "Whoa my CPU rocks as overclocking it really helps my FPS and performance".
 
OP if you plan on keeping your CPU a lil longer and want to increase the speed to be less of a bottleneck for your GPU jus buy a good third party CPU Cooler and bring that puppy up to at least 3.5ghz. That extra 500mhz boost will help in a mostly CPU bound game like SupCom. I'm pretty sure if you played some FPS at higher resolutions then your GPU will be the bottleneck. At the moment your best bet is just to invest at least $50 and get a good third party CPU Cooler. The one I use in my sig is great and only cost me $40.99 @ newegg. When I had my E6750 I was able to OC to 3.5ghz as a test and it was stable and temp peaked at 54 degrees idled at 38. Just my two cents.
 
OP if you plan on keeping your CPU a lil longer and want to increase the speed to be less of a bottleneck for your GPU jus buy a good third party CPU Cooler and bring that puppy up to at least 3.5ghz. That extra 500mhz boost will help in a mostly CPU bound game like SupCom. I'm pretty sure if you played some FPS at higher resolutions then your GPU will be the bottleneck. At the moment your best bet is just to invest at least $50 and get a good third party CPU Cooler. The one I use in my sig is great and only cost me $40.99 @ newegg. When I had my E6750 I was able to OC to 3.5ghz as a test and it was stable and temp peaked at 54 degrees idled at 38. Just my two cents.

I have my E6600 @ at 3.26Ghz with 1.31875. I don't really know what the voltage should be, tbh. About 55C idle and 67C under load.
 
Xigmatek HDT-S1283 - $37, free shipping right now. Meets or beats a TRUE.
If you get any HSF, I RE-recommend the Xig, it's just 1mm shorter in height than a TRUE but fits in a CM690 if that's any indication. The TRUE is only good with a good fan, only 1 heatsink I know can run passive, the Gemini2(Cooler Master, afaik).
 
Back
Top