Better CPU or Better VGA Card?

ADRENALIN_2099

Gawd
2FA
Joined
Apr 26, 2008
Messages
927
I am upgraging my computer soon, Right now i have a C2D E6400 @2.13, GeForce 7900 GS and 4gb or RAM.

Would it be better if i waited until the new (45nm) CPUs become more available to up grade or should i wait until the new generation (9900 and so on) get released to upgrade?

i was thinking to buy a q6600 and a 8800GT later on.

but as have read, a better GPU is better that a better CPU.

so what i was thinking of doing was around June i will get a new vid card then come December i will get a new cpu.....


what do you guys think?
 
In my opinion, unless you do video work or anything that can take advantage of it, quad core cpu's are an utter waste of cash. Hell, most of today's software barely has support for 2 cores. I would go for the 8800GT and buy ram or w/e u were trying to say, and then overclock your E6400 closer to 3 ghz. Hope this helped =)
 
VGA would be better. You can find G92 GTS around 200 bucks.

ur CPU is FINE

and then, you will upgrade to nehalem next year or so.
 
In my opinion, unless you do video work or anything that can take advantage of it, quad core cpu's are an utter waste of cash. Hell, most of today's software barely has support for 2 cores. I would go for the 8800GT and buy ram or w/e u were trying to say, and then overclock your E6400 closer to 3 ghz. Hope this helped =)
You are acting like a quad core is expensive when they clearly arent and this is the same ignorant advice people gave a couple years ago in regards to dual core. Yeah there may only be a handful of games that utilize a quad core but its a better investment. I do agree that in the OPs situation that his cpu is sufficient and he clearly needs a modern gpu if he cares about gaming.
 
Yea, thats what i was thinking, buy a new vid card and when nehalem gets around ~250-300 ill get a quad.

Since the only thing i do in my pc it watch movies, do school papers, and game, Ill save up the cash ( but if i nail the deal that i might get a q6600 for like 130 bucks ill bite) get the a new better, and better cooler (im running on a stock HSF) and get it to 3 ghz and leave it a at that.

Thanks for the help guys

ps i do think that a quad would be better, but i think ill wait until the next generation gets here....then its time to buy some DDR3 since thats all it will use.
 
soo weird ADRENALIN_2099 that is the exact same spec of my computer. And, I am currently debating on the same thing. I have decided like everyone else is saying to simply purchase a new video card. The ones I am looking at are the 8800 GTS (g92) and maybe an 8800GTX/Ultra if they drop below 300 again.

But yeah if you can overclock your CPU for sure do it. I can easily get mine to about 2.6 and I don't think we will gain that much performance if we switch.
 
In my opinion, unless you do video work or anything that can take advantage of it, quad core cpu's are an utter waste of cash. Hell, most of today's software barely has support for 2 cores. I would go for the 8800GT and buy ram or w/e u were trying to say, and then overclock your E6400 closer to 3 ghz. Hope this helped =)
Agreed. I'm currently in the process of selling off my Q6600 because ever since I got a 500gb Hard Drive I find myself encoding less and less movies. Hell a C2D can encode from DVD to Ipod in about 30min.
 
soo weird ADRENALIN_2099 that is the exact same spec of my computer. And, I am currently debating on the same thing. I have decided like everyone else is saying to simply purchase a new video card. The ones I am looking at are the 8800 GTS (g92) and maybe an 8800GTX/Ultra if they drop below 300 again.

But yeah if you can overclock your CPU for sure do it. I can easily get mine to about 2.6 and I don't think we will gain that much performance if we switch.


i was actually looking in ebay and you can get a 8800 gtx for like 200-250 just have to look around and be patient. I dont know what you guys think about buying electronics in ebay....
 
i was actually looking in ebay and you can get a 8800 gtx for like 200-250 just have to look around and be patient. I dont know what you guys think about buying electronics in ebay....

No way I cannot justify purcashing something like that from e-bay. Call me old-fashioned but no place to return it, problems, warranty, and soo many ways to get screwed. I have never purchased anything from e-bay and prolly never will.
 
i am actually watching a new unopened C2d 4500 thats almost finished and its at 20+15 shipping
if it dosent go past 30 ill buy it since its just 45 bucks i cant get F*** over that bad if anything goes wrong. since im going to build my little brother a new pc, i might drop it in my rig and test it out.....if i win it at that price that is
 
You are acting like a quad core is expensive when they clearly arent and this is the same ignorant advice people gave a couple years ago in regards to dual core. Yeah there may only be a handful of games that utilize a quad core but its a better investment. I do agree that in the OPs situation that his cpu is sufficient and he clearly needs a modern gpu if he cares about gaming.

You can argue anything will benefit him in the future. Right now, its a waste of cash. I see people ditching their "old" Q6600's for newer quad core models. People have the misconception that they are noticeably faster in non-optimized programs. Their "old" Q6600's were never even being taken advantage of fully in the first place.
 
You can argue anything will benefit him in the future. Right now, its a waste of cash. I see people ditching their "old" Q6600's for newer quad core models. People have the misconception that they are noticeably faster in non-optimized programs. Their "old" Q6600's were never even being taken advantage of fully in the first place.
You see people? Who the one person in this thread that said that? lol. Waste of cash? People blow more money on one night of going out then the difference in price between a quad and dual core cpu.

Of course everybodys needs are different but if I was building a new pc from scratch and didnt want to upgrade the cpu for a couple years then a quad core would make the most sense. You can oc the quad core but you cant add more cores to the dual core.
 
A C2D at around 2.7GHz will get the max from an 8800GT in most games so the cheapest upgrade is to clock the CPU as far as it will go and get an 8800GT / GTS.
You will know you are CPU limited if overclocking the graphics card doesnt give hardly any benefit.
ie a 10% gfx overclock gives much less than 10% extra framerate
 
Agree with most of the people above me, just OC your CPU and get that 8800 GT... Most games out right now are gpu limited, not cpu, so getting that gpu is going to be better...
 
The E6400 is already a fine CPU. Getting a P35 board and a decent heatsink would allow you to OC it. Other then that, depending on your resolution and the games you play, 9600GT/8800GT/8800GTS 512/9800GTX.
 
thank you very much for all your input guys!

I will be looking to purchase my 8800 gt or GTS

so far i like there 2 from MSI :
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127329
&
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127325

i think the $20 more for the GTS is worth it. What do you guys think?

MSI's warranty policy is 3 years labor 2 years parts. I know EVGA and XFX have lifetime but i think that is enough. I've only had (Knocks on wood) one video card crap out on me, and that was my Leadtek 6800 GT (http://www.bjorn3d.com/read.php?cID=660) ans since i already had my 7900 gs i didnt bother to RMA or replace it.
 
Glad you liked my post of the 2 MSI cards, I agree $20 to go GTS is a fine decision, I myself purchased a 88GTS recently, I'd rather have xtra performance than not quite enough(GTS compared to GT, not that the GT doesn't have enough performance). As for that HDT-S1283.......it's pwnage, I do say 3ghz for you sounds good to me, although you might need a Voltage bump to hit 3.2ghz(400FSB to match 800mhz ram 1:1)s, @ least you could start with what imo is a safe/easy OC of 2.66ghz(333FBS*8 multi). I see you have 800mhz mem, so u also don't have to worry about your ram not keeping up OC-wise(1:1 FSB:RAM ratio anyways).
 
Get the 8800GT and OC your current processor. Right now a higher clock speed on a dual core is better than a lower clock speed on a quad.
 
well i just want to update.

I got my Xigmatek HDT-S1283 and right now i am running at 3.00 (8x375) it maxes out at 62 C after 8 hours of orthos (prime95 x2) here in the Dominican Republic with a 34c noon ambient temp (no AC was on).

i bought a Palit NE/9600T+0152 9600 GT to hold me out until the next gen card come out (ill buy one in august). I got it at 120 after rebate.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814261002
 
Well I have a Quad Core and hope the gaming industry finally optimes the code for it. This would change alot.

When the Graphics Cards is concerned, a 8800 GTS is enough for any game, except crysis.
 
+1 to that....
Welcome to last month.. you might want to read the thread before you post. Not only was the posts you quoted FROM last month, but the op has posted what he has decided to do.. :rolleyes:
 
If I had a choice between, say, a system with a Q6600 and an 8800GT and one with an E6600 and an 8800GTX, I would choose the latter simply because the faster graphics card opens up additional settings. You can upgrade or overclock your CPU as much as you want, and you may get additional frames per second, but that won't give you the extra power you need to increase the resolution or anti-aliasing. Those settings really depend on things like graphics card memory, bandwidth and GPU clock speed.
 
Back
Top