Dew itt right
2[H]4U
- Joined
- Oct 28, 2005
- Messages
- 3,314
EDIT: The WC setup below is now listed on the FS threads HERE...
Well, this is my third water loop build and I definitely have to say it's the best and most thought-out configuration so far. I did a few things and used a product or two that most may have never seen used in this application before that turned out to be perfectly suited for watercooling. I'll also throw in a few ways I saved quite a bit of money so if you're getting ready to build your own loop – listen up!
The External Setup...
This idea started simply because I didn't have any room inside the case obviously for a 3x120mm radiator. Once I pick a spot out for it on the right side panel I thought to myself, “self, why don't you just put all the guts back here to free up space in the case?!”. After patting myself on the back for such a great idea, I began figuring out how the parts need to be laid out...
1) The radiator -- The radiator was mounted horizontally on the bottom of the panel simply because it was the only convenient spot to pass through to the interior of the case. Plus, having the water flow up thru the radiator instead of down help push the air bubbles on through to the reservoir instead of forming air pockets in the radiator.
2) The reservoir -- The reservoir was mounted with the barbs facing the left to prevent the tubing from ever having to cross itself to get to the pump. I'm not sure how most people configure their inlet/outlet ports on this res, but I made the middle port the inlet to help stop air from collecting under the divider (and obviously to keep from sucking air out to the pump) and I left the top port capped for use in filling and air bleeding.
3) The pump -- The pump was mounted below the reservoir to allow gravity to help feed the pump from the reservoir. This setup was originally done for a MCP355 to be mounted to the side panel but I decided to spend the extra money on the MCP655 to have flow control and a more quiet rig. This pump is secured to the top of the radiator with velcro (which is an extremely good vibration dampening material due to the loose connection).
4) The grommets -- As usual, grommets were used to allow the tubing to pass through the case. However with the pump and radiator fan outside, I also had wiring that needed to pass through. For this, I bought the smallest grommets I could find and used these small grommets to pass the wiring through the case. As you may see, I did have one extra grommet at the radiator outlet. My original intention was to pass back into the case. They do, however, have plugs for these types of mistaken holes at hardware stores, just haven't gotten around to it yet.
The Manifold...
I've seen pics of people using this concept of splitting the supply line with a series of tee's but I've never seen somebody actually use a real one-piece manifold with valves on each line. This creates innumerable possibilities as far as expansion and customization are concerned. The benefits...
1) Uniform fluid supply temps -- Separating all three supply lines means each water block is receiving the lowest temperature fluid it can receive as opposed to piping them in series where the heat from one block warms up the water and then runs through another block and another. This way the fluid is cooled by the radiator and goes directly to each individual block. Yes splitting the lines means lower flow to each individual component, but from my past experiences I noticed that supplying the waterblocks with cooler fluid does much more to lower temps than giving the block more fluid flow. Besides, this is kind of where my next point comes in...
2) Ability to balance each branch -- With each supply line having a valve, this allows you to partially close each valve in order to direct more flow to one area and less flow to another. For example, you not be very big on CPU OC'ing but you're a huge gamer! So you'll want to leave the GPU supply line fully open and partially close the CPU and chipset lines to direct more flow towards the video cards. (NOTE: The temperatures in my “results” section below are with the system unbalanced – all vales are fully open. You'll notice the CPU needs more fluid and the GPU's have fluid to spare.)
3) Temporarily concentrate fluid on one particular component -- With my 680i board, I can monitor the CPU, chipset (in BIOS), and GPU temps and balance the water until the temps are where I want them. Or if you want to find the max OC on your CPU, you can temporarily divert more water to the CPU to cool it better. Then when you want to max out your FSB or GPU you can again temporarily divert water to where it's needed most.
4) Less likely to leak -- You could make this manifold from 2 tee's, 1 elbow, and 3 valves but you'd be looking at making 14 connections where with a one-piece manifold you only make 4 connections (or 6 if you count reducing the inlet connection)
5) Room for expansion or a drain line -- If you're only using three branches now but want to use a fourth in the future, just buy a 4-way manifold at the start of the project and leave the valve closed on the last unused branch. Personally, i wish I would have bought a 4-way manifold and setup the unused port on the bottom as a drain line to eliminate the need to break a connection to drain the fluid.
The manifold (LINKED HERE) has (1) 3/4” PEX inlet and (3) 1/2” PEX outlets. The 3/4” PEX connection fits 5/8” ID tubing perfectly and the 1/2” PEX connection fits 3/8” ID tubing. To keep my loop all 3/8” ID I purchased a brass 3/4” PEX x 1/2” PEX adapter (at Home depot) and used a small (2” or so) piece of 5/8” ID tubing to connect the adapter to the manifold. This allowed all four connections to be with 3/8” ID tubing.
The whole shebang...
Well, now that the system is complete, here's a list of all the components it took to make the loop...
-(1) Swiftech MCR320 radiator (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech MCRES reservoir (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech MCP655 pump (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech Apogee GT Extreme CPU waterblock (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech MCW30 chipset waterblock (LINK)
-(2) Swiftech MCW60 GPU waterblocks (LINK)
-(2) Thermaltake CL-C0025 copper vga memory heatsinks (8-pack) (LINK)
-(1) Watts WPCM2-M3-08B copper PEX manifold (LINK)
-(1) 1/2" PEX x 3/4" PEX Brass Coupling (LINK)
-(1) 32oz. bottle of PrimoChill Ice Invisible Blue UV Reactive Non-conductive coolant (LINK)
-(10) Feet of Excelon RNT 3/8” ID 5/8” OD tubing (LINK)
-(3) 5/8” ID rubber grommets (LINK)
-(2) 1/4” ID rubber grommets (LINK)
-(10) polypropylene 3/8” elbows (LINK)
-(4) polypropylene 3/8” tees (LINK)
-(2) polypropylene 1/2”x3/8” reducers (LINK
The Results...
Testing conditions:
FSB: 415MHz
CPU: 3320MHz
RAM: 1,066MHz
GPU cores: 620MHz
GPU mems: 850MHz
--2 instances of SP2004 running simultaneously (Blend and Small FFT's)
--ATITool running artifact check
AIR COOLING (all fans at full speed)
...................idle......................load....
CPU............42.........................67.....
GPU1..........53.........................73.....
GPU2..........55.........................73.....
WATERCOOLING (radiator fans full speed)
...................idle......................load....
CPU............35.........................58.....
GPU1..........38.........................46.....
GPU2..........39.........................45.....
WATERCOOLING (radiator fans off)
...................idle
CPU............48
GPU1..........49
GPU2..........48
**The tests and temps above were done with all of the manifold branch valves fully open. As you can see, I need to divert a little more fluid towards the CPU. The GPU's are being cooled extremely well – a 27 degree drop from aircooling. I'm hoping to balance the temps out with the valves. It's too bad the I can't monitor the chipset temps. If it's monitored in the BIOS I may be able to just balance it based on idle temps.
Tips & Other Notes...
1) Tubing -- Instead of spending a small fortune for tubing at a PC website, try ebay, amazon, and laboratory supplies websites. I picked up a 100ft roll of Excelon RNT tubing (as good as if not better than Tygon) for $30 shipped! Then I turned around and sold what I didn't need for $0.75 which is still an awesome price for high quality tubing. I wound up actually making money and keeping 20ft for myself. Also, USPlastic.com sells MANY different types of Tygon tubing including the Tygon R-3603 that FrozenCPU sells except where it's $3.00/ft at FrozenCPU and most other PC-mod retailers it's only $1.49/ft at USPlastic.
2) Need a case window? -- After installing a sweet looking WC loop, you'll want a case with a side panel window to show it all off and to keep an eye out for leaks. When I bought my Cooler Master Centurion 5 a while back, I bought the model without the window because I wanted to install fans on the side panel. If you're ever in the same boat I was, before buying a do-it-yourself side panel window kit (and the tools needed to install it), check to see if the manufacturer sells and windowed side panel that you can buy by itself. I wound up finding my windowed side panel HERE at SVC.com for $9.99! It was cheaper that those DIY kits, obviously required less work, and looked more professional in the end.
3) Don't spend a fortune on plastic fittings -- At the PC modding websites you'll pay $1.50 or more easily for a single plastic elbow or tee fitting. I bought a couple dozen fittings at USPlastic.com for about 25% of the price! Most of the fittings I bought were around $0.40 a piece and you can choose between different types of plastics and different colors. They even have threaded fittings that I bought for my swiftech radiator although these are very prone to leaking because they do not have the lip above the threads to hold an o-ring down. Also know that the natural polypropylene fittings are UV reactive (a bonus I didn't know about until I installed them).
3) Going UV? Get rid of the LED's! -- The UV light cast by UV cold cathodes is typically very soft. So soft that even a few LED's can wash out the glow from your UV reactive components. Regrettably, the blue leds shining on the motherboard and the red and green flashing LEDs on the top of my Crucial Ballistix Tracers really drown out the UV effect of my lights. I may just jump on a pair of regular Ballistix if I find a good deal. If you want a bold glow from your UV reactive components, get as many of the LED's out of your case as possible.
4) Making the MCW60 and 8600GT compatible -- At the time of this writing the only way to watercool an 8600GT is with a full coverage EK block that costs almost as much as the card does! The MCW60 is not listed as compatible with the 8600's, however the stock nVidia bracket's mounting holes line up perfectly with the 8600GT. The only problem was that the legs on the mounting bracket are a pinch too long and when mounted leave the surface of the block slightly off the GPU chip surface. The only ways to fix this are to (A) shorten the legs by grinding and hoping you don't screw up the threads inside too much or (B) to separate the mounting bracket from the block just enough to shorten the standoff distance from the bottom of the legs to the waterblock surface. I chose (B) so as to not permanently alter the waterblock.
. First unscrew the four screws on the top of the block, separating the copper base, derlin top, and metal bracket. Take one of those screws with you to your local Home Depot/Lowe's and find the fiber washers in the hardware isle in one of those tiny drawers. Get the smallest fiber washer their that the screw can pass through. Then reassemble the water block putting the washers between the derlin top and the mounting bracket. The washers won't sit flat, but when you start screwing the screws back in the washer will form to the contour of the derlin top and you'll have a nice tight fit. This should raise the mounting bracket off the block just enough to help the copper case make contact with the GPU chip surface. And don't forget to buy some memory heatsinks for the memory chips.
Finally, Some Pics...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Well, this is my third water loop build and I definitely have to say it's the best and most thought-out configuration so far. I did a few things and used a product or two that most may have never seen used in this application before that turned out to be perfectly suited for watercooling. I'll also throw in a few ways I saved quite a bit of money so if you're getting ready to build your own loop – listen up!
Disclaimer said:First things first: The 8600GT SLI setup -- Yes that's right, I have (2) 8600GT's in SLI. I get crap about this all the time. “Why'd you waste your money?! You should have gotten a 8800! They're the best video cards in the world! They make two 8600's cry like little girls! Blah blah blah...” Actually I had an Evga 8800GTS 640Mb Superclocked. I sold it and picked up these two cards for more than $100 less than the single 8800. The main reason for the switch was because, as a general rule, I try to never have any component over $200 in my case. This way if any given part breaks, I know I won't be out more than $200. This is especially true when watercooling because crap happens! Plus if one GPU breaks down I still have another to keep the system up and running. I'm very pleased with the performance of these two cards as well. I know benchmarks aren't the end-all say-all in performance, but these two cards OC'd on air did 9700 in 3DMark06 whereas my old 8800GTS Superclocked only did 9400 or so at stock (superclocked) settings. Plus I now have 1Gb of GPU memory instead of 640Mb. So please don't give me any crap about my SLI setup – I've heard it all before and I don't regret the switch one bit.
The External Setup...
This idea started simply because I didn't have any room inside the case obviously for a 3x120mm radiator. Once I pick a spot out for it on the right side panel I thought to myself, “self, why don't you just put all the guts back here to free up space in the case?!”. After patting myself on the back for such a great idea, I began figuring out how the parts need to be laid out...
1) The radiator -- The radiator was mounted horizontally on the bottom of the panel simply because it was the only convenient spot to pass through to the interior of the case. Plus, having the water flow up thru the radiator instead of down help push the air bubbles on through to the reservoir instead of forming air pockets in the radiator.
2) The reservoir -- The reservoir was mounted with the barbs facing the left to prevent the tubing from ever having to cross itself to get to the pump. I'm not sure how most people configure their inlet/outlet ports on this res, but I made the middle port the inlet to help stop air from collecting under the divider (and obviously to keep from sucking air out to the pump) and I left the top port capped for use in filling and air bleeding.
3) The pump -- The pump was mounted below the reservoir to allow gravity to help feed the pump from the reservoir. This setup was originally done for a MCP355 to be mounted to the side panel but I decided to spend the extra money on the MCP655 to have flow control and a more quiet rig. This pump is secured to the top of the radiator with velcro (which is an extremely good vibration dampening material due to the loose connection).
4) The grommets -- As usual, grommets were used to allow the tubing to pass through the case. However with the pump and radiator fan outside, I also had wiring that needed to pass through. For this, I bought the smallest grommets I could find and used these small grommets to pass the wiring through the case. As you may see, I did have one extra grommet at the radiator outlet. My original intention was to pass back into the case. They do, however, have plugs for these types of mistaken holes at hardware stores, just haven't gotten around to it yet.
The Manifold...
I've seen pics of people using this concept of splitting the supply line with a series of tee's but I've never seen somebody actually use a real one-piece manifold with valves on each line. This creates innumerable possibilities as far as expansion and customization are concerned. The benefits...
1) Uniform fluid supply temps -- Separating all three supply lines means each water block is receiving the lowest temperature fluid it can receive as opposed to piping them in series where the heat from one block warms up the water and then runs through another block and another. This way the fluid is cooled by the radiator and goes directly to each individual block. Yes splitting the lines means lower flow to each individual component, but from my past experiences I noticed that supplying the waterblocks with cooler fluid does much more to lower temps than giving the block more fluid flow. Besides, this is kind of where my next point comes in...
2) Ability to balance each branch -- With each supply line having a valve, this allows you to partially close each valve in order to direct more flow to one area and less flow to another. For example, you not be very big on CPU OC'ing but you're a huge gamer! So you'll want to leave the GPU supply line fully open and partially close the CPU and chipset lines to direct more flow towards the video cards. (NOTE: The temperatures in my “results” section below are with the system unbalanced – all vales are fully open. You'll notice the CPU needs more fluid and the GPU's have fluid to spare.)
3) Temporarily concentrate fluid on one particular component -- With my 680i board, I can monitor the CPU, chipset (in BIOS), and GPU temps and balance the water until the temps are where I want them. Or if you want to find the max OC on your CPU, you can temporarily divert more water to the CPU to cool it better. Then when you want to max out your FSB or GPU you can again temporarily divert water to where it's needed most.
4) Less likely to leak -- You could make this manifold from 2 tee's, 1 elbow, and 3 valves but you'd be looking at making 14 connections where with a one-piece manifold you only make 4 connections (or 6 if you count reducing the inlet connection)
5) Room for expansion or a drain line -- If you're only using three branches now but want to use a fourth in the future, just buy a 4-way manifold at the start of the project and leave the valve closed on the last unused branch. Personally, i wish I would have bought a 4-way manifold and setup the unused port on the bottom as a drain line to eliminate the need to break a connection to drain the fluid.
The manifold (LINKED HERE) has (1) 3/4” PEX inlet and (3) 1/2” PEX outlets. The 3/4” PEX connection fits 5/8” ID tubing perfectly and the 1/2” PEX connection fits 3/8” ID tubing. To keep my loop all 3/8” ID I purchased a brass 3/4” PEX x 1/2” PEX adapter (at Home depot) and used a small (2” or so) piece of 5/8” ID tubing to connect the adapter to the manifold. This allowed all four connections to be with 3/8” ID tubing.
The whole shebang...
Well, now that the system is complete, here's a list of all the components it took to make the loop...
-(1) Swiftech MCR320 radiator (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech MCRES reservoir (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech MCP655 pump (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech Apogee GT Extreme CPU waterblock (LINK)
-(1) Swiftech MCW30 chipset waterblock (LINK)
-(2) Swiftech MCW60 GPU waterblocks (LINK)
-(2) Thermaltake CL-C0025 copper vga memory heatsinks (8-pack) (LINK)
-(1) Watts WPCM2-M3-08B copper PEX manifold (LINK)
-(1) 1/2" PEX x 3/4" PEX Brass Coupling (LINK)
-(1) 32oz. bottle of PrimoChill Ice Invisible Blue UV Reactive Non-conductive coolant (LINK)
-(10) Feet of Excelon RNT 3/8” ID 5/8” OD tubing (LINK)
-(3) 5/8” ID rubber grommets (LINK)
-(2) 1/4” ID rubber grommets (LINK)
-(10) polypropylene 3/8” elbows (LINK)
-(4) polypropylene 3/8” tees (LINK)
-(2) polypropylene 1/2”x3/8” reducers (LINK
The Results...
Testing conditions:
FSB: 415MHz
CPU: 3320MHz
RAM: 1,066MHz
GPU cores: 620MHz
GPU mems: 850MHz
--2 instances of SP2004 running simultaneously (Blend and Small FFT's)
--ATITool running artifact check
AIR COOLING (all fans at full speed)
...................idle......................load....
CPU............42.........................67.....
GPU1..........53.........................73.....
GPU2..........55.........................73.....
WATERCOOLING (radiator fans full speed)
...................idle......................load....
CPU............35.........................58.....
GPU1..........38.........................46.....
GPU2..........39.........................45.....
WATERCOOLING (radiator fans off)
...................idle
CPU............48
GPU1..........49
GPU2..........48
**The tests and temps above were done with all of the manifold branch valves fully open. As you can see, I need to divert a little more fluid towards the CPU. The GPU's are being cooled extremely well – a 27 degree drop from aircooling. I'm hoping to balance the temps out with the valves. It's too bad the I can't monitor the chipset temps. If it's monitored in the BIOS I may be able to just balance it based on idle temps.
Tips & Other Notes...
1) Tubing -- Instead of spending a small fortune for tubing at a PC website, try ebay, amazon, and laboratory supplies websites. I picked up a 100ft roll of Excelon RNT tubing (as good as if not better than Tygon) for $30 shipped! Then I turned around and sold what I didn't need for $0.75 which is still an awesome price for high quality tubing. I wound up actually making money and keeping 20ft for myself. Also, USPlastic.com sells MANY different types of Tygon tubing including the Tygon R-3603 that FrozenCPU sells except where it's $3.00/ft at FrozenCPU and most other PC-mod retailers it's only $1.49/ft at USPlastic.
2) Need a case window? -- After installing a sweet looking WC loop, you'll want a case with a side panel window to show it all off and to keep an eye out for leaks. When I bought my Cooler Master Centurion 5 a while back, I bought the model without the window because I wanted to install fans on the side panel. If you're ever in the same boat I was, before buying a do-it-yourself side panel window kit (and the tools needed to install it), check to see if the manufacturer sells and windowed side panel that you can buy by itself. I wound up finding my windowed side panel HERE at SVC.com for $9.99! It was cheaper that those DIY kits, obviously required less work, and looked more professional in the end.
3) Don't spend a fortune on plastic fittings -- At the PC modding websites you'll pay $1.50 or more easily for a single plastic elbow or tee fitting. I bought a couple dozen fittings at USPlastic.com for about 25% of the price! Most of the fittings I bought were around $0.40 a piece and you can choose between different types of plastics and different colors. They even have threaded fittings that I bought for my swiftech radiator although these are very prone to leaking because they do not have the lip above the threads to hold an o-ring down. Also know that the natural polypropylene fittings are UV reactive (a bonus I didn't know about until I installed them).
3) Going UV? Get rid of the LED's! -- The UV light cast by UV cold cathodes is typically very soft. So soft that even a few LED's can wash out the glow from your UV reactive components. Regrettably, the blue leds shining on the motherboard and the red and green flashing LEDs on the top of my Crucial Ballistix Tracers really drown out the UV effect of my lights. I may just jump on a pair of regular Ballistix if I find a good deal. If you want a bold glow from your UV reactive components, get as many of the LED's out of your case as possible.
4) Making the MCW60 and 8600GT compatible -- At the time of this writing the only way to watercool an 8600GT is with a full coverage EK block that costs almost as much as the card does! The MCW60 is not listed as compatible with the 8600's, however the stock nVidia bracket's mounting holes line up perfectly with the 8600GT. The only problem was that the legs on the mounting bracket are a pinch too long and when mounted leave the surface of the block slightly off the GPU chip surface. The only ways to fix this are to (A) shorten the legs by grinding and hoping you don't screw up the threads inside too much or (B) to separate the mounting bracket from the block just enough to shorten the standoff distance from the bottom of the legs to the waterblock surface. I chose (B) so as to not permanently alter the waterblock.
. First unscrew the four screws on the top of the block, separating the copper base, derlin top, and metal bracket. Take one of those screws with you to your local Home Depot/Lowe's and find the fiber washers in the hardware isle in one of those tiny drawers. Get the smallest fiber washer their that the screw can pass through. Then reassemble the water block putting the washers between the derlin top and the mounting bracket. The washers won't sit flat, but when you start screwing the screws back in the washer will form to the contour of the derlin top and you'll have a nice tight fit. This should raise the mounting bracket off the block just enough to help the copper case make contact with the GPU chip surface. And don't forget to buy some memory heatsinks for the memory chips.
Finally, Some Pics...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Last edited: