Why IPS if most use MVA / TN?

mattcham

n00b
Joined
Apr 11, 2008
Messages
6
If most clients use cheaper PVA or TN panels (as most consumers do), doesn't that mean that a graphic artist using an IPS panel will not see what the client actually sees?

Should artists tweak their work to look good on PVA or TN because what looks good on IPS may end up looking bad (eg. black crush) on PVA? (I've noticed this with my own work)

As an analogy: If I use a nice color monitor to create my work but most of my clients just use black and white grayscale monitors, then isn't my use of a color monitor actually a disadvantage for me?
 
Because you want the best source material versus garage in, garage out.
 
In general you still want a monitor that is accurate as possible to insure that the color you are using is really the color you want. Not all TN panels and VA panels display the same colors, they can appear different on each and every monitor like purple appearing blue while on some monitors that same purple may appear more pinkish. If you use the crappy LCD on a $400 Dell or Toshiba laptop it really is a hit or miss in terms of getting the colors right but if you use a properly calibrated desktop monitor(even TN is fine as long as it has good colors) you will be more confident that your colors are a lot more accurate.

Colors matter a lot more in prints compared to web design where the picture on the monitor has to match what is on the printed paper.
 
Its a bit like saying that music should be recorded with more bass because many people cant afford bassy hifis.
The problem is that the source material will no longer be set to a standard that will work well with a decent hifi and you might end up having to reduce the overall recording level to reduce bass saturation.

Its best to stick to the purest method of reproduction so there is a standard that TV (and hifi) manufacturers can work towards.
 
You can't guarantee what others will see in any situation, anyway. For all you know they have some whacky bugged color profile installed, or have their gamma way up, or who knows what else.

Best to make your graphics as high quality as possible, so everyone can enjoy them to the limits of their own monitor. Plus I don't know what self-respecting artist of any kind would say "Its okay to make crappy art, most people can't tell the difference anyway."
 
If most clients use cheaper PVA or TN panels (as most consumers do), doesn't that mean that a graphic artist using an IPS panel will not see what the client actually sees?

Unless all your clients have the same monitor/mis-calibration and you use the same you won't match up anyway, so you may as well go with the best and most accurate monitor to produce standardized results.

That way your clients that have calibrated and best hardware will also see the best closest matching results. They are likely your most picky clients as well. Those with cheap uncalibrated monitors likely don't care and if they do, you can point out you are using a good properly calibrated monitor and they will get better results with better setup.

Also if using a monitor with inconsistent viewing angles (gamma/tonal shifts) how can you even know what is consistent for yourself when it shifts across the screen. If you are serious about imaging work get a good HW calibrateable IPS screen like an NEC 2490uxi SV, with essentially perfect viewing angles and 12 bit lut internal HW calibration.
 
Let me put it in perspective for you...

My 206BW - TN panel of course - displays whites as a kind of light almond color.

My 20WMGX2 displays whites as well, white. Blacks are indeed black. The difference is night and day, hence the reason I use my 206BW for viewing Anime and websites exclusively.
 
Back
Top