Apple vs. NYC: What's Really Going On

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I have received tons of “Apple sucks, looks what they are doing to NYC!” e-mail and, at first glance, it does look like Apple is trying to screw over the city of New York. Then, I read this news item at Engadget (written by a lawyer) that says this is exactly the way the process is “supposed to work.” So, as much as I wanted to kick Apple in the seeds, there is no call for it.

Unlike all those previous Apple trademark disputes, this isn't a true lawsuit, and Apple hasn't sued anyone -- the city of New York has filed a trademark application for the GreeNYC apple-shaped logo with the Patent and Trademark Office, and Apple has filed its opposition to that application. That's an important part of the trademark registration process, actually: every single trademark application has to go through a 30-day opposition period during which interested third parties can raise their objections.
 
My whole thing is, why are they bother trying to defend this trademark. This is not joe schmoe with a new apple-bashing blog that wants to use it. It's fracking NY, the BIG APPLE. The fact they even sent in their opposition is why they are and should be getting bashed. Yea yea its all part of the process, but you don't HAVE to file for opposition. Oh well, what has Apple done, positive, lately anyway?
 
New York City changes its nickname to Big Microsoft in retaliation.

Stay tuned for more news at 11.
 
I'm a little on the line for this one. Yes the system is working how it should work. BUT apple is only bitching because it is an apple. It looks nothing like theres, it is green and is a different shape all together. By this logic nobody other than Apple can have an apple for their logo or in their logo. If it was similar to theirs then I would agree with Apple (as hard as that would be) but in this case I feel that they are just trying to keep all other people from having any type of apple as a logo.
 
It's definitely a bit absurd when you consider that NYC isn't competing with Apple in any way.

But at least the system is working. I should hope anyway; it would be rather sad if Apple managed to prevent NYC's trademark from being granted.
 
It's definitely a bit absurd when you consider that NYC isn't competing with Apple in any way.

But at least the system is working. I should hope anyway; it would be rather sad if Apple managed to prevent NYC's trademark from being granted.

If that happened, the governer should stop apple products from being sold in NY. NY, the marketing center of the US... Hehe, that'll teach em!
 
I'm sorry, Apple doesn't get to own every iteration of anything that resembles a fruit we've had on the earth for thousands of years. This is simply your standard Apple arrogance, because there's really no other explanation since they look nothing like each other. I'd have no problem with this if it in fact actually looked like Apple's logo instead of a piece of fruit that once again Apple has no business "owning."
 
I'm sorry, Apple doesn't get to own every iteration of anything that resembles a fruit we've had on the earth for thousands of years. This is simply your standard Apple arrogance, because there's really no other explanation since they look nothing like each other. I'd have no problem with this if it in fact actually looked like Apple's logo instead of a piece of fruit that once again Apple has no business "owning."

Yeah, this has got me wondering. What is Apple's big deal here, and what in the WORLD do they hope to accomplish with this? I am fairly certain New York doesn't have any anti-apple intentions by applying for this logo .... weird. How can this be a positive thing for Apple? It will just alienate people, more than likely, and I doubt it will bolster current Apple fans' admiration of apple any more than it already is...
 
I think Steve Jobs is still all butthurt over Apple Corps. suing his ass back in the 70's for trademark infringement. It's not like NYC is going to be making computers anytime soon.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but hasn't "The Big Apple" been a pseudonym for NYC much longer than Apple corporation has been manufacturing computers? Also, they're not even in the same market. (Is a city a "market"?) Apple has no right, and I hope they get struck down by the office or in court, whatever it takes. This is pointless.

I hate when corporations get a huge hard-on about their own logo/product/system and go apeshit on anything and everything that could possibly be related to it as "OMGCopyright Infringement!!!" Seriously. They're not competing, and an entire city should surely beat out Apple Inc. Apple (computers) pulled the same crap with Apple (recording), who owns the rights to the Beatles' music, which is why they are never on Itunes.

Why can't people work together, or at least in parallel, instead of constantly against each other?
 
I'm really not surprised at this point. Kind of funny but also sad at the same time.
 
Ya don't use it ya lose it.

As the lawyer said, this is a completely normal process. Afaik companies who do not defend their trademarks lose rights to them over time. If I am wrong on that, then yes Apple is being pretty damn petty. Otherwise, RELAX guys. Some of you are just as bad as the "apple can do no wrong" fanboys, only in this case anti-fanboys.
 
Ya don't use it ya lose it.

As the lawyer said, this is a completely normal process. Afaik companies who do not defend their trademarks lose rights to them over time. If I am wrong on that, then yes Apple is being pretty damn petty. Otherwise, RELAX guys. Some of you are just as bad as the "apple can do no wrong" fanboys, only in this case anti-fanboys.

You know, I think I might just send in my letter of opposition. I might wanna use the green apple logo they have as my trademark some day!!! How DARE the city of New York take that away from me....
 
Ok, I understand that there is no lawsuit and it's simply Apply doing its paperwork to oppose the trademark, but really, Apple should not even be trying to slow this down. It's just bad publicity.

Ok, if it were some company that could harm apples reputation by using a similar logo, maybe they would have a point, but NO ONE is going to look at the NY green apple logo and confuse it with Apple Inc. Everyone knows New York is the "Big Apple." It has been referred as that for 80+ years. This is Apple fighting the wrong battle IMHO.
 
Ya don't use it ya lose it.

As the lawyer said, this is a completely normal process. Afaik companies who do not defend their trademarks lose rights to them over time. If I am wrong on that, then yes Apple is being pretty damn petty. Otherwise, RELAX guys. Some of you are just as bad as the "apple can do no wrong" fanboys, only in this case anti-fanboys.

I'd say the same for any company.
 
Back
Top