TV tuner recomendations welcome

merc141

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
194
I was looking for something like this but have no idea as to the quality or details...

http://www.pinnaclesys.com/PublicSi...ers/PCTV+Analog_Digital+PVR/PCTV+HD+Stick.htm

I just wanted to watch TV (over the air - no cable) and wanted to burn video to DVD. I was also wondering if there was good software to burn to DVD from other formats... avi, wmv, divx ... it would be good to be < $80 or so....

Anyone have a good experience with some hardware like the pinnacle usb tuner, or card, your opinion is welcome.
 
I often see those pinnacle tuners for super-cheap at Fry's, but I haven't seen any reviews. I've heard the Hauppauge HVR-950 (also a USB HD tuner) is pretty good.

As for DVD authoring software, I don't have a clue. I'm sure someone else around here does, though.
 
HDHomeRun for ATSC/QAM and the ATI 550Pro for SD Cable/Over The Air....

ADDED: I use a ATI 550Pro to tune my analog cable, and the quality is at least as good as my Motorola DCT 6200 cable box, it may actually be a bit better too, I am super impressed, and the ATI 650, is supposed to be build on the 550Pro.....
 
If you had bothered to read any of the countless threads on "what tuner to get?!?" then you'd see that pinnacle's tuners are crap and aren't very well supported. That they are to be avoided (which probably explains why their so cheap.

You'd have also seen all the suggests on which tuner to get; suffice to say go to Newegg and look in the tuner section and get the card that Sapphire makes (ATI 650 based tuner) for under $60.
 
Yeah the SAPPHIRE Radeon Theatrix 650 PRO TV Tuner (Lite Retail) seems perfect...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16815310002

Unfortunately it seems that the "lite" version doesn't include any software. There is a driver cd but I think that is it. What other software would be needed? What software would be good to watch and record television with?

Can you not at least read ONE extra thread that would answer these questions? Or even the noobish Newegg reviews from the link you included above? There are many ways to setup "watching and recording television with," but they all require at least an ounce of effort.
 
There are several pieces of software that will let you watch/record TV on your computer. Many cards come with their own software packages, which CrimandEvil will attest are universally "crap". If you have Windows XP MCE or Vista home premium or Ultimate, they have such an application built-in. There are a few other free packages available for Windows--MediaPortal and GB-PVR come to mind. In addition, there are some commercial software packages like SageTV and BeyondTV (both of which, I believe, have free trial versions available, so you can test them out and see what you like).
 
With the amount of effort you put into your complaint lawrence131 you could have just easily listed some software titles instead....
 
I've got 3 ati 650pro cards and run beyondtv. Overall that setup will do whatever you need. The 650 has better sd clean up and captures over the air HD perfect. Beyondtv will take your shows and shrink them and burn them on dvd... great little setup.
 
Thank you for the replies, you guys are helping. Unfortunately I only have XP pro.

Can you not at least read ONE extra thread that would answer these questions? Or even the noobish Newegg reviews from the link you included above? There are many ways to setup "watching and recording television with," but they all require at least an ounce of effort.

What gave you the idea that I wasn't doing my own research into this? I value the opinions of people on hardocp and was hoping that someone had some insight or personal experience with TV tuners and/or software. If you do then you are welcome to share it.

Does the "lite" version include the Catalyst Media Center? I can't seem to find it (to download) anywhere on ATI's site. If it was included that would do the trick (at least until I could afford something else.)

I read somewhere that Cyberlink's PowerCinema v5 was very similar to CMC. It seems a little pricey though (Does it only come with a bundled tv tuner in the box?), as does Beyond TV. I don't really need the tivo-like functionality as I would only be using over the air analog and hd. However, it seems like picking up GB-PVR would be a no brainer.

Also does dscaler work with SAPPHIRE Radeon Theatrix 650 PRO TV Tuner? Its not on the list of supported cards. How is dscaler? Does it work well?

I know this is bordering on off-topic, but would this antenna be appropriate for an apartment --indoors (for use with the sapphire card)? I would mainly want good VHF reception but good UHF and FM would be a bonus. Would this antenna be alright? I know this antenna gets good hd but will it get VHF?

http://www.radioshack.com/product/i...057.2032187.2032189.2032205&parentPage=family

It seems as far as indoor antennas go this gets recommended:

http://www.radioshack.com/product/i...057.2032187.2032189.2032204&parentPage=family

What do you think? Replies are welcome.
 
Catylist media center is a rebadged version PowerCinema 4. My sapphire came with PowerCinema 5 OEM, which lets you watch tv but has no support for the online program guides. Additionally, PowerCinema is an absolute pile of crap. You can buy the full version of PowerCinema 5 from Cyberlink's website, but i don't know why anyone in their right mind would do that.

DScaler works, i just downloaded it and tried.
 
I read somewhere that Cyberlink's PowerCinema v5 was very similar to CMC. It seems a little pricey though (Does it only come with a bundled tv tuner in the box?), as does Beyond TV. I don't really need the tivo-like functionality as I would only be using over the air analog and hd. However, it seems like picking up GB-PVR would be a no brainer.
My advice is always "try the free stuff first, and if it doesn't work, then go out and buy something". Just because it's free doesn't mean it's no good. I haven't used GB-PVR before, but MediaPortal is pretty mature and has lots of plugins and flexibility.
 
Generally USB tv tuners don't work too well...

Also, the only experience I have with Pinnacle is their PCI HDTV tv tuner, and let me tell you -- it sucks, and thus my opinion of Pinnacle is that I will never buy another product from them ever again. For the year that the product has been out, they have not fixed a highly documented issue with sound not being in sync with TV in Vista's Media Center. You can read all about it and the numerous complaints in the forums.
 
I will second PowerCinema v5 being a stinking pile. The windows media center editions (vista and MCE) are both pretty decent and cost almost the same as some of the other tv solutions. ChrisTV works pretty well, but the free edition has a very annoying logo at the top.
As far as cards the ATI 550-650 has worked pretty well for me. I have had two Pinnacles (one consumer one pro grade) the consumer line one worked after I found a site that had rewritten the driver, but generally was very poor quality. Their pro grade equipment was very nice for doing capture / composition work.
 
Here is my input regarding tuners:
1. Hardware-
Don't bother with a usb tuner, unless it has hardware encoding like the ati 650pro usb. Also don't bother with any tuners that do not have hardware encoding- its just not worth the money. The sapphire 650pro lite is an amazing deal on newegg for $60, you should get that or the hauppauge (sp?) 1600. You should really get something with ATSC what with the new laws, and both do it. I have the hauppauge and its great. I had an ATI 550pro and I liked it (no HD), but it was more susceptible to interference from computer internals than other cards in my custom ultra small form factor pc.

2. Software- GBPVR ftw. Period. It does everything in the world- records shows, converts them to any format you want, live tv... anything you can think of. The interface looks just like a tivo, but better. It also has a built in web server that allows you to administer your recordings from anywhere in the world, and its great, especially while at work. I love GBPVR.

3. Antennas- if you have the space in the attic, get an attic antenna. We picked one up from home depot for $15 on clearance last month, and it gets every HD station in the area. Its great. The bunny ears (even amplified ones) don't compare.
 
first of all this is my first tv tuner, so i have nothing to compare it to.....
i kept hearing about the great picture on the sapphire theatrix 650 pro, so i bought one. i just find the picture quality isnt so hot on analog. there doesnt seem to be any way to adjust the card via a control panel and im wondering what else i should do to improve the quality. addons? tweaks? im using mce2005 so if theres any addons or changes i should amke in there please let me know. thanks.
 
first of all this is my first tv tuner, so i have nothing to compare it to.....
i kept hearing about the great picture on the sapphire theatrix 650 pro, so i bought one. i just find the picture quality isnt so hot on analog. there doesnt seem to be any way to adjust the card via a control panel and im wondering what else i should do to improve the quality. addons? tweaks? im using mce2005 so if theres any addons or changes i should amke in there please let me know. thanks.

The hardware is only as good as the MPEG2 codec used with it. Since your using MCE2k5 I'd highly suggest paying $20 and buying a copy of NV's Purevideo codec; then you'll see how great it is.
 
The hardware is only as good as the MPEG2 codec used with it. Since your using MCE2k5 I'd highly suggest paying $20 and buying a copy of NV's Purevideo codec; then you'll see how great it is.

i understand that. but even if i get the nvidia purevideo codec, how do i get mce 2005 to use it by default? do i need to uninstall the klite codec pack and lose the functionality of the other codecs, or does the nvidia codec install itself as the default somehow?
 
i understand that. but even if i get the nvidia purevideo codec, how do i get mce 2005 to use it by default? do i need to uninstall the klite codec pack and lose the functionality of the other codecs, or does the nvidia codec install itself as the default somehow?
Oh, shit. You've got more problems then you even know.

1.) Remove Klite and all the garbage it installs... if you can. Kilte is garbage and causes more playback problems.

2.) Install CCCP and the newest FFDShow tryout.

3.) Install the Purevideo codec.

4.)???????

5.) Profit! Well, maybe. It all depends on badly Klite fucked up your system and how it handles video.
 
Oh, shit. You've got more problems then you even know.

1.) Remove Klite and all the garbage it installs... if you can. Kilte is garbage and causes more playback problems.

2.) Install CCCP and the newest FFDShow tryout.

3.) Install the Purevideo codec.

4.)???????

5.) Profit! Well, maybe. It all depends on badly Klite fucked up your system and how it handles video.


ok. does cccp give me pretty much the same functionality as klite with all the diff codecs? i dont really care for the htpc but im just curious.
ive just always used klite and its never given me problems, but ill take it off the htpc and try out your recommendations. even so, installing cccp, ffdshow and the nvidia purevideo codec, how will mce2005 know to use nvidia purevideo and not some other codec from the cccp pack??

is there anything else that would interfere with this? i also have power dvd deluxe 7.3 on there. should i just take it off? i dont really need it now anyways it was just there to see if it worked any better than mce2005 but it didnt as far as i could see.


edit: i uninstalled klite, powerdvd, and installed the 3 progs you directed. it seemed to make a nice difference. thanks for the tips. i assume i was to install both cccp and ffdshow with all default settings? or should i have installed some of the other options? are there any other settings i should change using ccp/ffdshow/nvidia purevideo?
 
Here is my input regarding tuners:
1. Hardware-
Don't bother with a usb tuner, unless it has hardware encoding like the ati 650pro usb. Also don't bother with any tuners that do not have hardware encoding- its just not worth the money. The sapphire 650pro lite is an amazing deal on newegg for $60, you should get that or the hauppauge (sp?) 1600. You should really get something with ATSC what with the new laws, and both do it. I have the hauppauge and its great. I had an ATI 550pro and I liked it (no HD), but it was more susceptible to interference from computer internals than other cards in my custom ultra small form factor pc.

If you choose the Sapphire-branded ATi 650Pro Lite (or one of many other PCI tuner cards based on the ATi Theatre 650 chipset), be advised that it lacks separate tuner/receivers for analog and digital broadcasts. Instead, it has a hybrid tuner/receiver which is software-switchable between analog and digital broadcasts, and whose digital tuner section doesn't work properly in Windows Media Center (consistently poor digital signal-strength readings). And the versions of the Catalyst Media Center software which came bundled with many of those cards predate Windows Vista, so those versions of the software might not be fully compatible with Vista.

By the way, I have the WinTV HVR-1600 PCI card in my main rig. It can pick up both analog and digital broadcasts without having to manually switch between the two (due to its dual-tuner/receiver design, called a "combo"). The digital section is a good performer, but the analog broadcast section leaves a bit to be desired in terms of image quality.
 
If you choose the Sapphire-branded ATi 650Pro Lite (or one of many other PCI tuner cards based on the ATi Theatre 650 chipset), be advised that it lacks separate tuner/receivers for analog and digital broadcasts. Instead, it has a hybrid tuner/receiver which is software-switchable between analog and digital broadcasts, and whose digital tuner section doesn't work properly in Windows Media Center (consistently poor digital signal-strength readings). And the versions of the Catalyst Media Center software which came bundled with many of those cards predate Windows Vista, so those versions of the software might not be fully compatible with Vista.
More: http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1290018

Not sure about the low digital performance thing; considering where I live I get pretty good OTA HD but due to the lack of channels I get (live in boulder, co and the nearby mountains make OTA of any kind incredibly hard) I don't really use it for an OTA HD tuner. Either way I think my Sapphire 650 Lite has performed very acceptably when I was playing with it for OTA but ultimately I decided that if I'm going HD then I'm going with one of Hauppauge's HD PVR tuners that takes component input for true, real HD goodness.
 
ok. does cccp give me pretty much the same functionality as klite with all the diff codecs?--- how will mce2005 know to use nvidia purevideo and not some other codec from the cccp pack??
Klite is pretty much a collection of cracked/hacked/free codecs; its your typical grab bag of video/audio codecs with several that all do the same thing (which can cause instability, lower image quality because two or more codeces are trying to decode the same video, etc).

MCE, the XP based ones, don't come with an MPEG2 decoder and rely on third party MPEG2 decoders; only certain MPEG2 codecs are certified to work with MCE and for MCE to even see the codec it has to be certified for MCE. If it's not certified then it doesn't work with MCE. CCCP doesn't have an MPEG2 codec (even though it can decode MPEG2 video) much less one that is certified to work with MCE.
is there anything else that would interfere with this? i also have power dvd deluxe 7.3 on there. should i just take it off? i dont really need it now anyways it was just there to see if it worked any better than mce2005 but it didnt as far as i could see.
Regular DVDs: no, go ahead and get rid of it.
HD DVD/Blu Ray: keep it cause its the only way you can watch these discs on your HTPC.
edit: i uninstalled klite, powerdvd, and installed the 3 progs you directed. it seemed to make a nice difference. thanks for the tips.
Cool, glad I could point you to the right path. :)
i assume i was to install both cccp and ffdshow with all default settings?
Yup, the defaults should work fine. CCCP does include FFDShow but it's usually a version that is a little out of date. The latest Tryouts tend to be better/faster for certain video formats.
or should i have installed some of the other options? are there any other settings i should change using ccp/ffdshow/nvidia purevideo?
Other options? You mean like Haali? Should have installed that too if thats what you mean. As for options to tweak, yeah, theres options to tweak but I hope you have some time cause it took me the better part of a weekend to tweak everything so that it worked the way I wanted it too (and then I had to move the HTPC to Vista HP and more tweaking). I'd suggest getting comfortable with the default settings first, they seem fine with you then just leave them there but if you get curious or you feel that something just isn't right then we can talk about tweaking.
 
Yeah the SAPPHIRE Radeon Theatrix 650 PRO TV Tuner (Lite Retail) seems perfect...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16815310002

Unfortunately it seems that the "lite" version doesn't include any software. There is a driver cd but I think that is it. What other software would be needed? What software would be good to watch and record television with?

I can't seem to find anywhere that actually sells this card. The link to newegg is "deactivated" and while a google search for this finds references to the card I can't actually find anywhere that's selling it. Is this card recalled or obsolete or something?
 
I also use the ATI 550Pro:D on my HTPC and it is an excellent tv tuner capture device.
 
Back
Top