Are Terabyte HDs alright?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Azureth

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Feb 29, 2008
Messages
5,323
Right now I have 2 HDs (one is a 75 gig raptor drive which I regret getting>_>), and I need to get a third to put all my data I need, however, I am wanting to format and upgrade to Vista, so I'm considering just buying a TB HD, that way I'll have space for everything I could want on one drive (I also have a 500 GB External drive). Would that be fine, or is there anything bad about them I should know about?
 
i´ve recently bought a 1TB WD hard drive and have no problems whatsoever, i´m actually happy with it.
 
Id suggest the WD GP line, if speed isnt an issue, itll work just fine as a storage/archive drive, I just wouldnt use one as my OS drive.
 
I use a Hitachi Deskstar 7k1000 1TB drive... it is actually faster than my 74 gb raptor by a good chunk.
 
No, I mean why'd he say "I just wouldnt use one as my OS drive."?

Because the WD GP drive ratchets its spindle speed down to 5400RPM when it's "idle." I can't speak from personal experience, but the fear is that you may attempt to perform an intensive task and the drive won't be able to speed back up to 7200RPM.
 
Because the WD GP drive ratchets its spindle speed down to 5400RPM when it's "idle." I can't speak from personal experience, but the fear is that you may attempt to perform an intensive task and the drive won't be able to speed back up to 7200RPM.

From the benchmarks I've seen, the thing is slow 24/7, not just when its idle. It was my understanding that each of those "5400-7200rpm" drives spins at a fixed rate somewhere in that range, and the 1TB model was closer to the low end.
 
yeah the 1TB drives spin at 5400 during idle, 50% load, full search, pretty much any point in time that they are not powered off & they are in use...that's they're speed :cool:

I think they're great to get if you have a little extra cash. otherwise, 500 & 750 GB drives are outstanding for the $, and will still run at 7200rpms. I would not favor either based off an anticipated speed advantage/deficit from 5400vs7200 tho, the platter storage densities are significant enough to make up the difference.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top