20 inch IPS vs. 24 inch *VA

pudge

n00b
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
7
What would you recommend for office use - 20 inch IPS or a 24 inch VA diplay?

The cost for the NEC 24 inch IPS is more than I care to spend.

I am updating from my CRT displays and trying to decide between using 20 inch IPS displays vs 24 inch VA displays.

My use is office (web, IM, email, word docs, presentation creation) and stock charts. No games and unlikely any movies. Family photos only.

I would use two 24 inch displays with one dedicated to stock charts, so I am concerned about viewing angles. If I purchase 20 inch IPS displays I would likely use three.

20 inch IPS display I am considering -
HP LP2065
Dell 20 inch Ultra Sharp

24 inch VA displays I am considering -
HP LP2465 Very good price at the moment ($575) with excellent return policy. But older.
LG 245WP Have been unable to find the 246WP.
Dell 2408 Cannot locate the 2407 that I see on recommended lists. The newest option.

My concern about the Soyo and Westy is the lack of stand adjustments and USB ports (I use a MacBook Pro).

Many here are far more experienced than I. So I would be interested to know ...

1) For my uses would you suggest buying 20 inch IPS or 24 inch VA display? and

2) Which specific monitor would you recommend?

Thanks in advance.
 
No gaming or photo work? Well, might as well go for a 24" *VA monitor. The color will be better than a TN and the desktop space improvement over a 20" is huge. You'll be able to have two MS Office docs open plus Mozilla and a stock chart.
 
Hi,

I offer some general thoughts...

I'm considering several 20s, too, or two 24s as upgrades...Added into the mix is that, along with long-short fund management, I also occasionally photograph weddings and events professionally (keep the fun alive!)...So IPS is a necessity for me.

If I recall, however, the problem with the Dell 20s, at least from what I've heard from a number of folks, is that the panel lottery makes it rough to rest assured you'll end up with an IPS panel...

But if you're not too demanding with images, VA displays can work very well. I've had shells around me while working (news/broadcast on one panel, charts on another, prices/strategy trials on another) and haven't suffered from anywhere near enough gamma/color shift to make anything difficult to understand. Some folks I know likewise manage investments and use quad displays, with one dedicated to Bloomberg and a mix on the others, and use widescreen TNs, 19/20-inch VAs, and some use IPS 30s - but they generally purchased them (or had them purchased by their firms) based on what they liked when they "looked at" the monitors - not based on the technical details we are wont to discuss on forums such as these.

I think, especially if you're actually managing money - as opposed to buying a few shares now and then - your desk habits, viewing angles, comfort level, and local (physical) tool emplacement might be more important than making sure you have one type of display technology or another. After all, it's just as possible to manage obscene amounts of money on an old Sammy 173p as it is on four new Dell 3008s (uh, yeah: overkill to me)! :p

Best,
ivy
 
I'll give you my $0.02.

I currently have a Dell 2007WFP S-IPS since December. Very briefly I got the 2407WFP which is a S-PVA. When I hooked it up the difference between the two was night and day to me. The 2007WFP was much more vivid, colorful, and just overall sharper.

I sold the 2407WFP and kept the 2007WFP.
 
I'll give you my $0.02.

I currently have a Dell 2007WFP S-IPS since December. Very briefly I got the 2407WFP which is a S-PVA. When I hooked it up the difference between the two was night and day to me. The 2007WFP was much more vivid, colorful, and just overall sharper.

I sold the 2407WFP and kept the 2007WFP.

Same here, although I went with the 4:3 Dell 2007FP (SIPS LG Panel), because many games still have problems with widescreen resolutions without hacks, and not all games are properly "hackable".
 
I can not recommend the LP2065, since i've already sent back 3 of them with irregular back lighting and uneven reddish colour tint from left to right.
It would be a dream-tft otherwise.
 
3 20" (1600x1200) monitors will give you 25% more pixels than 2 24's (1920x1200). IF you're using 1680x1050's you get 15% more pixels. In terms of screen area the 20's will get you 576/540 square inches vs 522. Any way you look at it the 3 20s give you more screen, IPS panels give better image quality as well so definately go with the 3 20's.
 
If you're only going to use it in the office, you won't care between IPS or VA or even TN, so I'll just recommend you save your money and get a nice 22" TN. I have a 20" IPS and TN from Dell and for office use I would take the TN.
 
3 20" (1600x1200) monitors will give you 25% more pixels than 2 24's (1920x1200). IF you're using 1680x1050's you get 15% more pixels. In terms of screen area the 20's will get you 576/540 square inches vs 522. Any way you look at it the 3 20s give you more screen, IPS panels give better image quality as well so definately go with the 3 20's.
So far the consensus seems to favor the 20" monitors.

Would the 4:3 or wide screen be preferable for office work? Would a 1680x1050 allow for two documents (or 2 web pages) side by side in a manner similar to the 24"?
 
If you're only going to use it in the office, you won't care between IPS or VA or even TN, so I'll just recommend you save your money and get a nice 22" TN. I have a 20" IPS and TN from Dell and for office use I would take the TN.
Looks like I may have typed too soon.

Why would you take the TN for office work? The size advantage of the TN?
 
Looks like I may have typed too soon.

Why would you take the TN for office work? The size advantage of the TN?
The advantages of IPS or VA aren't nearly worth the cost for an office environment, that's why TN LCDs is always a good choice for office use.
If you're going for 20"-22" I recommend TN, anything bigger you may benefit from IPS or VA viewing angles. VA usually has some color shifting problems with some displays and IPS is expensive beyond 20" so it's hard to recommend.
 
Something else to keep in mind with "widescreen" panels when diagonal screen size is less than 24" - you're screen is going to seem somewhat squished. What I mean is the screen is obviously substantially shorter in height on a widescreen 20" panel vs. a 20" non-widescreen (vertical pixel count @ only 1050 on 2007WFP) which is only about as tall as a regular 17" monitor. This results in less actual screen real estate than a standard 20" monitor and may not be the best choice for office applications.

Any way you look at it the 3 20s give you more screen, IPS panels give better image quality as well so definately go with the 3 20's.

This is the choice I'm leaning towards at the moment. But what's this "panel lottery" with Dell 2007FP? There's a 50/50 chance I may not end up with an S-IPS panel? Is this also the case with the 2007WFP or only do you only run the risk of getting a S-PVA with the FP model?
 
Something else to keep in mind with "widescreen" panels when diagonal screen size is less than 24" - you're screen is going to seem somewhat squished. What I mean is the screen is obviously substantially shorter in height on a widescreen 20" panel vs. a 20" non-widescreen (vertical pixel count @ only 1050 on 2007WFP) which is only about as tall as a regular 17" monitor. This results in less actual screen real estate than a standard 20" monitor and may not be the best choice for office applications.



This is the choice I'm leaning towards at the moment. But what's this "panel lottery" with Dell 2007FP? There's a 50/50 chance I may not end up with an S-IPS panel? Is this also the case with the 2007WFP or only do you only run the risk of getting a S-PVA with the FP model?

The 2007FP panels are by and large, SIPS panels.
Just make sure that the serial number ends with an L.
I know, easier said than done.
I was fortunate in that a buddy of mine used to work at Dell, so he ensured that I would get one.

As for the 2007WFP, it's almost exclusively a SIPS panel, unless Im mistaken.

However, for the reasons stated above, I would prefer the 1600x1200 4:3 2007FP over the 1680x1050 with less real estate 2007WFP.
 
TN panels have very good horizontal viewing angles, better than my 26in Acer 8 bit....TN's are fine for office use IMO, but I prefer 8 bit panels for games and video.
 
TN panels have very good horizontal viewing angles, better than my 26in Acer 8 bit....TN's are fine for office use IMO, but I prefer 8 bit panels for games and video.

On the contrary.
TN panels have horrible all-around viewing angles.
 
On the contrary.
TN panels have horrible all-around viewing angles.

Perhaps older ones really sucked horizontally, but the newer ones are supposed to be better, and I've seen a 226bw in action, and FYI, it's horizontal was okay, even it's vertical was minor if not non-existent as the sole user.
 
However, for the reasons stated above, I would prefer the 1600x1200 4:3 2007FP over the 1680x1050 with less real estate 2007WFP.

I'm having a hard time deciding between widescreen and standard 4:3. I would agree that for office apps 1600x1200 would be preferable. Although some people like widescreens for Excel and stuff because you can see more columns, etc. So I reckon widescreen does have some advantages. But do you also prefer the 1600 x 12200 (4:3) resolution for gaming? I thought widescreen was all the rage for gamers, no?

Same here, although I went with the 4:3 Dell 2007FP (SIPS LG Panel), because many games still have problems with widescreen resolutions without hacks, and not all games are properly "hackable".

But then I read something like this and it confuses me. I here most gamers go for and prefer widescreen displays ( I here a lot of gamers wanting 24" screens because 1920 x 1200 is awesome for gaming ). But the above statement seems to indicate 4:3 displays are better. I know most any office apps will run just fine on either screen format. But is widescreen really a problem for gamers?
 
I'm having a hard time deciding between widescreen and standard 4:3. I would agree that for office apps 1600x1200 would be preferable. Although some people like widescreens for Excel and stuff because you can see more columns, etc. So I reckon widescreen does have some advantages. But do you also prefer the 1600 x 12200 (4:3) resolution for gaming? I thought widescreen was all the rage for gamers, no?

?

Mate forget about 4.3 rubbish for gaming and video.
Nearly every modern game is WS, and any game worth a damn is easy to hack to WS.
A 24 at 1920x1200 is where PC greatness begins.....it ends up at 52inches or so, LOL
 
I'm having a hard time deciding between widescreen and standard 4:3. I would agree that for office apps 1600x1200 would be preferable. Although some people like widescreens for Excel and stuff because you can see more columns, etc. So I reckon widescreen does have some advantages. But do you also prefer the 1600 x 12200 (4:3) resolution for gaming? I thought widescreen was all the rage for gamers, no?

Widescreen gaming still hasn't caught on.
Like at least half of the games released even to this day, do not feature proper wide-screen support.
For example, many EA games lack native wide-screen resolutions altogether, whereas other games such as BioShock (which would would assume should not have any problems at all due to its simultaneous console release), still lacks a proper fov perspective on wide-screen PC displays.

The list goes on and on of games, devs, and publishers whom do not properly support widescreen yet.
For that reason, forums such as http://www.widescreengamingforum.com/ exist to address the literally hundreds of problems users have with games and their widescreen monitors.

Simply not worth the headache in my eyes, nor am I willing to sacrifice the extra screen real estate (overall less viewing area on a 20" 1680x1050 when compared to a 20" 1600x1200).


But then I read something like this and it confuses me. I here most gamers go for and prefer widescreen displays ( I here a lot of gamers wanting 24" screens because 1920 x 1200 is awesome for gaming ). But the above statement seems to indicate 4:3 displays are better. I know most any office apps will run just fine on either screen format. But is widescreen really a problem for gamers?

At the 24" level, sure widescreen gaming becomes more appealing, even if you have to put up with the aforementioned problems, since you get an overall larger screen in general.

However, then you need a powerful video card to be able to handle games at the 1920x1200 resolution.

As far as 22" panels go, don't even waste your time or money.
All with the exception of 2 or so suck (those 2 happen to cost > $1000 and use SIPS panels).
 
Perhaps older ones really sucked horizontally, but the newer ones are supposed to be better, and I've seen a 226bw in action, and FYI, it's horizontal was okay, even it's vertical was minor if not non-existent as the sole user.

If you think the 226bw looks nice, that simply just means that you don't have much to compare it to. It's all relative, and based on perspective (no pun intended).

Ive used a 226bw extensively at work.
It's dithering algorithm still falls noticably and painfully short of reproducing the full 8-bit color spectrum, and is made evident by its:
a) ugly banding
b) its weak Vertical Viewing Angle (160 degrees)
c) its weak Horizontal viewing angle (160 degrees)

By comparison, SIPS panels feature viewing angles of ~ 179 Degrees Horizontal, 179 Degrees Vertical, with 0 banding.

Basically, unless you intend on sitting absolutely still and not moving your head around too much, then its tolerable.
Of course I say that because I have been using nothing but SIPS panels at home for the last 4 years (and a Sony Trinitron CRT before that), so it's extremely easy for me to not only see the flaws in the 226 TN panel, but also to be disgusted by them.

Mate forget about 4.3 rubbish for gaming and video.
Nearly every modern game is WS, and any game worth a damn is easy to hack to WS.
A 24 at 1920x1200 is where PC greatness begins.....it ends up at 52inches or so, LOL

If only that were the case.
Allow me to once again refer to:
http://www.widescreengamingforum.com/wiki/index.php/Main_Page

The reason that site exists and is such a popular and prevalent haven for widescreen gamers is because half the time their games simply dont work properly on their displays.
For example, for games that don't have native widescreen support, you either have to hack the ini file, or make command line changes, or both, and in several cases your just out of luck altogether (most notably in older games).

Then there are the numerous issues such as:
1) widescreen resulting in the vertical axis being reduced in order to increase the horizontal one (this occassionally happens in "NATIVE" widescreen games too, not just those that you have to hack)
2) stretching which makes everything look wider than need be

I mean, I like tweaking as much as the next guy, but it gets to be a bit much to have to wait weeks sometimes for some guy to come up with the a hack which allows me to play my game, and even then, not entirely as it should be.
Devs simply haven't adopted widescreen monitors en masse when it comes to PC gaming -- it's not their display format of choice at this point.
4:3 is always, always, a guarantee to work properly out of the box on the other hand.
 
You do realize you can run a 4:3 resolution scaled on a 16:10 monitor? And simply have black-bars on the side?

Then for the games that you can "hack" and take advantage of the 16:10... you can use that resolution?

I think it's silly to get a 4:3 monitor for the sole reason that "not all games support widescreen resolutions"...
 
You do realize you can run a 4:3 resolution scaled on a 16:10 monitor? And simply have black-bars on the side?

Then for the games that you can "hack" and take advantage of the 16:10... you can use that resolution?

I think it's silly to get a 4:3 monitor for the sole reason that "not all games support widescreen resolutions"...

Yes I am fully aware of that.
But that only makes sense on 24" and up monitors.

I mean, why buy a wide-screen monitor, a 22" to be precise, which already offers less real estate space than a 20" 4:3 panel, only to have to cut off the sides of the image to squeeze the rest of it in.

A 24" on the other hand (and up) is a whole different story.
And yet, thee are still many variables to consider
a) Do I want to *HAVE* to upgrade my video card once a year whether i like it or not in order to game comfortably at my 1920x1200 native res ..... or
b) Should I scale down to 1600x1200 or lower, and thereby defeat the purpose of having a widescreen monitor if I am going to mimic a 20" 4:3 panel instead
c) More and more 24" monitors these days are MVA/PVA panels, and therefore automatically inferior to SIPS panels, that are readily available in the 20" sizes in the form of Dell UltraSharp's

I mean, it's not just a simple matter of picking up the largest display and going home with it, you do have to after all factor in not only the extra cost of the larger monitor, but also its native resolution which demands the most cutting edge of hardware PERPETUALLY, and then on top of that, chances are very likely that you will end up with an inferior panel anways, due to most 24" on the market being MVA/PVA's.

It's a natural dichotomy, you give and take with those larger widescreens.

As for the 22" ones, don't even get me started.
Every single one of them are junk, save for the whole 2 out there that use SIPS panels.
The rest are TN trash.
 
If only (widescreen gaming being the norm) were the case.
Allow me to once again refer to:
http://www.widescreengamingforum.com/wiki/index.php/Main_Page

The reason that site exists and is such a popular and prevalent haven for widescreen gamers is because half the time their games simply dont work properly on their displays.
For example, for games that don't have native widescreen support, you either have to hack the ini file, or make command line changes, or both, and in several cases your just out of luck altogether (most notably in older games).

I think it's silly to get a 4:3 monitor for the sole reason that "not all games support widescreen resolutions"...

...

c) More and more 24" monitors these days are MVA/PVA panels, and therefore automatically inferior to SIPS panels, that are readily available in the 20" sizes in the form of Dell UltraSharp's

I agree with both of you there. ;) I've been lucky and all my games work at 16:10 natively out of the box though; I play RPG's and RTS's though, not FPS's though. That also means that VA panels' slight lag compared to the other technologies matters to me not a whit, while I realize it might to FPS gamers, especially online. Picture quality on a VA might not be up to IPS standards, but it's still miles ahead of a TN. I'll take a 24" VA over a 20" IPS monitor any day though, albeit I'd take either over even a 28" TN. :D

I mean, why buy a wide-screen monitor, a 22" to be precise, which already offers less real estate space than a 20" 4:3 panel, only to have to cut off the sides of the image to squeeze the rest of it in.

Yeah, I was disappointed with my Samsung 20" widescreen for the same reason. Coming from a 17" standard-aspect-ratio screen, I gained nothing vertically, and some horizontally where it's less useful except when watching movies. A slight upgrade in panel quality, but both TN's. I still think that widescreen sucks when browsing websites or editing documents, but that's where a pivot feature (like on my new 24") comes in handy. :)
 
Well I do HD Video Editing, and watch a lot of HD movies, I've only ran into a couple games that didn't run in 16:10

I think Starwars Battlefield was one of them... and maybe Starcraft? (Don't remember, haven't played it recently)

And... I just ordered my second 24" Soyo for under $300... I'll take 2 x 24" monitors for $600 especially if they're MVA/PVA... I-SPS is not worth it imo... 3-4x the cost for a bit better colors? Buy a CRT if you need "perfect colors"... I needed relatively good color reproduction, and 1920 vertical lines, Soyo was perfect.
 
I'll take 2 x 24" monitors for $600 especially if they're MVA/PVA... I-SPS is not worth it imo... 3-4x the cost for a bit better colors? Buy a CRT if you need "perfect colors"...

It's not just better colors; IPS also has the advantages of no color shift (ala TN panels) and no gamma shift (ala VA panels). Just like CRT's again albeit. ;) Still, LCD panels have the advantages of a smaller footprint and much less power consumption, not to mention greater available of non-refurb non-used high-end monitors, which to some people might be worth the hefty premium of IPS over CRT monitors. They are only really needed for professional or prosumer photographers/video-editors/graphics-artists and those with lots of money who must have the best at any cost though. For everybody else, VA's are a good compromise, and there are lots of people who are happy enough with TN's, no matter how crappy they are.
 
It's not just better colors; IPS also has the advantages of no color shift (ala TN panels) and no gamma shift (ala VA panels). Just like CRT's again albeit. ;) Still, LCD panels have the advantages of a smaller footprint and much less power consumption, not to mention greater available of non-refurb non-used high-end monitors, which to some people might be worth the hefty premium of IPS over CRT monitors. They are only really needed for professional or prosumer photographers/video-editors/graphics-artists and those with lots of money who must have the best at any cost though. For everybody else, VA's are a good compromise, and there are lots of people who are happy enough with TN's, no matter how crappy they are.

I don't know who started this theory about the superiority of IPS over PVA in this forum, but it keeps perpetuating itself and repeated again and again. As someone who owns most of the highest end monitors, including IPS and PVA, I can tell you that the theory simply isn't true. Some of the highest end and most expensive monitors such as the Eizo CG301W and the Samsung XL30 are PVA, not IPS. The Samsung PVA panel in those monitors is MUCH better than the LG IPS panel in the Dell 3008WFP which is the latest and greatest IPS panel. I've compared them extensively, and the PVA panel performs better in all areas. There is absolutely nothing inferior about PVA technology, and in fact the best PVA LCD monitors perform better than the best IPS monitors that I've tried.
 
On scaling down new games - you can always stick to the WS resolutions. Depending on what you have (and test it out first) sometimes 16:9 will look better. E.g. for some reason 1280x720 looks ALOT better than 1280x800 on my 2405. OTOH, a common resolution for laptops, 1440 x 900, looks great on the 2405 as well - that's a 16:10 resolution.

*And, not to say it again, but this is ALL personal preference. While I was happily gaming away at 1440x900 for the longest time, the minute I go my 8800GT, I took TF2 to max res. Now I'm spoiled haha. I'd say on most 24", you can easily dip down to the 1680x1050 and still get the "native resolution" look, even though it's obviously not native res. When you go below 1680, however, temper your expectations accordingly.
 
If you think the 226bw looks nice.

I never said it looked nice, I said it's horizontal viewing angles are pretty good...eom.
Also, who gives a damn about old low detail games.....large LCD's are for HD stuff....eom2.
 
Back
Top