Looking to upgrade from 7600GT...

W.O.T. Stang

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 4, 2003
Messages
363
So i've heard that the 9600GT have come out and was surprised to see they were only averaging $170. I haven't read any of the reviews yet, but are they truly the next generation of Geforce? I briefly browsed the forums and have noticed some reviews with people saying they are not much faster then an 8600GT, and that some of the 8600 models are actually faster. Any links of reviews to support this?

Anyway, what would be my best bang for the buck upgrade? I'm looking to get a card that can average above 40 fps @ 1440x900 (native LCD) with medium-high settings. I've been getting into the higher end games lately (bioshock, crysis, UT3..etc) as well as being an avid WoW player with maxed settings @ 1440x900. I dont need something that gets 100 fps at all times (while it would be nice if the price was right).

Would a plain 8600GT be a worthwhile upgrade, or should i go with a 9600GT? Basically, is there that much difference between the two?
 
Isn't that motherboard AGP?

If so, neither of the cards you mentioned will work. (they're PCI-E)

On a side note, the 9600GT is MUCH faster than the 8600GT.
 
Ah, in that case, get the 9600GT.

No doubt about it, ask anyone here.

(If you can spare another 40 bucks or so, step up to the 8800GT)

Either way, get ready for a huge increase in performance. :)
 
Ah, in that case, get the 9600GT.

No doubt about it, ask anyone here.

(If you can spare another 40 bucks or so, step up to the 8800GT)

Either way, get ready for a huge increase in performance. :)

Huge Increase? Sounds like what i'm looking for :)

So basically :

9600GT is slower then an 8800GT? But worlds above my 7600GT (obviously)

I guess I was just confused at first that the 8800GT was faster then the 9600GT, Are there any technical advantages to get a 9 series card over an 8? (new pixel shaders, graphics capabilities.. things like that?)
 
The 8600GT would hardly be an upgrade for you. The 9600GT is the lowest step-up I'd suggest.
 
Huge Increase? Sounds like what i'm looking for :)

So basically :

9600GT is slower then an 8800GT? But worlds above my 7600GT (obviously)

I guess I was just confused at first that the 8800GT was faster then the 9600GT, Are there any technical advantages to get a 9 series card over an 8? (new pixel shaders, graphics capabilities.. things like that?)

Yes, the 8800GT is faster than the 9600GT.

As far as I know, the 9600GT doesn't offer any additional features. I could be wrong though.... Wait for confirmation from a third party.
 
A 9600GT card will be good and enough to comfortably play those games you mentioned at 1440 x 900 Res. As long as you don't increase FSAA and AF in the games then your good on the FPS. Since the 9600GT has only 64 stream processors as opposed to 112 on the 8800GT, it will be crippled when upping AA and AF. If you have both these features at low settings or disabled you should be good. Don't bother even tampering with these settings in Crysis. It really slows down when you enable AA even only 2X. You can do Med and some High settings at 1440 x 900 in Crysis. UT3 you will have not a problem as that game runs at very high FPS.
 
Thanks guys. After hearing that I did a little research on my own and found this for $190 after rebate + shipping. Seems to be an outstanding deal considering the prices of the others. Any comments on this particular card or other opinions?

A 9600GT card will be good and enough to comfortably play those games you mentioned at 1440 x 900 Res. As long as you don't increase FSAA and AF in the games then your good on the FPS. Since the 9600GT has only 64 stream processors as opposed to 112 on the 8800GT, it will be crippled when upping AA and AF. If you have both these features at low settings or disabled you should be good. Don't bother even tampering with these settings in Crysis. It really slows down when you enable AA even only 2X. You can do Med-High settings at 1440 x 900 in Crysis. UT3 you will have not a problem as that game runs at very high FPS.

Right now I play around with crysis at 800x600 at max settings (just because it looks SO good) at around 20 fps. 1440x900 can be done with low settings, but everything just looks all muddy without at least medium detail (which slow me to about 8 fps average)

UT3 will do around 20-25 average FPS on medium-high settings, which is just on a playable level, but can lag a bit when the action heats up or the maps are open (the large bridge vehicle capture the flag map comes to mind). I do like mild AA/AF settings (sort of spoiled on them after using a Geforce 3 for a long time before the 7600GT). But I'm perfectly happy if i can get at least 35-40FPS at 1440x900 2AA/ 4/8AF. But of course, more is always better. :)
 
For Crysis and UT3 game, I would get an 8800GT card for those instead of a 9600GT. The mere 64 shader processors struggle when you go higher in Res and especially when AA or AF are enabled.
 
I went from a 7600GT to an 8800GT just recently and I wish I had gotten a GTS or GTX. It's a HUGE upgrade but it still has problems with 4xAA at 1920x1200 and of course, it's still a slideshow in Crysis at high settings.

Even at lower res why not spend the extra $10 ($180) and get an 8800GT on sale and after MIR, it's like coffee money for one day. Overclocking a 8800GTS would be even more fun if you're going to hold onto the thing for more than a year.
 
I went from a 7600GT to an 8800GT just recently and I wish I had gotten a GTS or GTX. It's a HUGE upgrade but it still has problems with 4xAA at 1920x1200 and of course, it's still a slideshow in Crysis at high settings.

Even at lower res why not spend the extra $10 ($180) and get an 8800GT on sale and after MIR, it's like coffee money for one day. Overclocking a 8800GTS would be even more fun if you're going to hold onto the thing for more than a year.

Glad to hear I'm not the only one that thinks an 8800 GT isn't enough for 1920x1200. But then... I didn't think a single 8800 GTX was enough. So I got another.
 
When it comes to Crysis, a single isn't enough for 1920x1200 either. It's arguable that even with SLI, you're going to be in for a disappointment compared to the performance you'd be getting with other games.
 
Glad to hear I'm not the only one that thinks an 8800 GT isn't enough for 1920x1200. But then... I didn't think a single 8800 GTX was enough. So I got another.

That depends on how much you want. I'm running 1920x1200 (no AA to AAx2 depending on game) with single 2900 pro@xt bought for 140 euro.

And BTW i was upgrading from 7600gt and diffrence was really HUGE ( I mean going from 1280x1024 in witcher everything at low with 15-20 fps to 1920x1200 with everything high at 30-40 and capable of turning AAx2 in less demanding areas)

PS. Altrough I'm not playing this boring sightseeing game known as Crysis :D
 
So i'm thinking about going with this. Any suggestions? Do I want to spend the extra little bit on G94 (i believe it is?), is it worth it?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130317
review: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/evga_e-geforce_8800_gts_ssc_review/

I'm basically looking for the best performance I can get under $250, as my 7600GT is starting to fall behind with a widescreen resolution on newer games with high settings. It's so hard to find the best value for the price because so many of these cards seem so close together in performance. I figured a 640mb card with a 320 bit bus would also be a nice advantage.
 
No, that card is the old GTS (G80) since you want to spend a max of $250 you're options should be 1) pick up a used 8800 GTX for ~$250 (I've seen them go that low but may be hard to find) or 2) Buy an 8800 GT or GTS (G92!) make sure you don't buy G80, the new 8800 GTS is just about on par with an 8800 GTX and can be had for ~200 AR these days.

heres the card you want MSI 8800 GTS (G92) OC w/ free game for $200 + shipping
 
No, that card is the old GTS (G80) since you want to spend a max of $250 you're options should be 1) pick up a used 8800 GTX for ~$250 (I've seen them go that low but may be hard to find) or 2) Buy an 8800 GT or GTS (G92!) make sure you don't buy G80, the new 8800 GTS is just about on par with an 8800 GTX and can be had for ~200 AR these days.

heres the card you want MSI 8800 GTS (G92) OC w/ free game for $200 + shippingURL]


That's exactly the mistake I didnt want to make! Thank you so much!
 
No problem, I blame nvidia for the confusing as hell naming. Just remember to get a card with 512mb of memory (or 768 if going GTX) and you'll be fine :p
 
the best performance for under 250 would be 2 9600gt's for 220. Look in hot deals for the link.
 
personally i'd go with a 8800gt.

2 years ago i bought a 7600gt for $201 and - $30 rebate.
just bought a 8800gt for $208 and - $30 rebate. - probably can find a better deal on the 8800gt by a lil bit, but prices have been fluctuating alot
 
personally i'd go with a 8800gt.

2 years ago i bought a 7600gt for $201 and - $30 rebate.
just bought a 8800gt for $208 and - $30 rebate. - probably can find a better deal on the 8800gt by a lil bit, but prices have been fluctuating alot

What's better? A G92 8800 GTS or a G92 8800GT? Still confused on the GTS vs. GT suffix.

From what i'm reading on this initial review I found, the 512meg G92 GTS outperforms the 512meg GT.

http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/nvidia_geforce_8800_gts_512mb/
 
The 512MB GTS (128 SPs, higher clocks) is better than the 512MB GT (112 SPs, lower clocks, bad stock cooling). The 320MB and 640MB GTSs, based on the older revision G80 core (96 SPs, lowest clocks) are slower than the 512MB GTs and GTSs. The 8800 GTX is still arguably better than any of the above, and the 8800 Ultra, better still due to its higher clocks, but not really worth the price premium.

In my opinion the 8800 GTS 512MB is the best price to performance, due to the 8800 GT's horrible stock cooling (insufficient single slot cooler) and the added cost of replacing it, as well as its having more SPs and higher clocks by default.
 
I upgraded from a BFG 7600GT OC to a Galaxy G92 8800GTS 512M boxing week. I think the 7600GT was a fantastic card for the money and it wasn't until I wanted to play Bioshock and Crysis that I felt I needed to upgrade. I'm a pretty casual gamer and the 7600GT did the job well enough. I usually game in 1600x1200 or 1280x1024 on an FD Trinitron CRT.

For the prices I had access to at the time and in my country, I'm quite happy I got the GTS over the GT. It was within something like $20-$30 of what I could find a 512M GT for and the cooling is much better (stock) and the performance is a little better.

The GT is an attractive option but I don't think you'd be disappointed with a G92 GTS either. Check the physical space in your case to accommodate the double slot, the length, and check your power supply ratings. FWIW, I'm running an E6400, P5B-E, 750G Seagate, BenQ 1640, Audigy 2ZS, Leadtek tuner card, G92 GTS and 2G OCZ Platinum on a 465W Enermax.
 
I upgraded from a BFG 7600GT OC to a Galaxy G92 8800GTS 512M boxing week. I think the 7600GT was a fantastic card for the money and it wasn't until I wanted to play Bioshock and Crysis that I felt I needed to upgrade. I'm a pretty casual gamer and the 7600GT did the job well enough. I usually game in 1600x1200 or 1280x1024 on an FD Trinitron CRT.

For the prices I had access to at the time and in my country, I'm quite happy I got the GTS over the GT. It was within something like $20-$30 of what I could find a 512M GT for and the cooling is much better (stock) and the performance is a little better.

The GT is an attractive option but I don't think you'd be disappointed with a G92 GTS either. Check the physical space in your case to accommodate the double slot, the length, and check your power supply ratings. FWIW, I'm running an E6400, P5B-E, 750G Seagate, BenQ 1640, Audigy 2ZS, Leadtek tuner card, G92 GTS and 2G OCZ Platinum on a 465W Enermax.
 
I upgraded from a BFG 7600GT OC to a Galaxy G92 8800GTS 512M boxing week. I think the 7600GT was a fantastic card for the money and it wasn't until I wanted to play Bioshock and Crysis that I felt I needed to upgrade. I'm a pretty casual gamer and the 7600GT did the job well enough. I usually game in 1600x1200 or 1280x1024 on an FD Trinitron CRT.

For the prices I had access to at the time and in my country, I'm quite happy I got the GTS over the GT. It was within something like $20-$30 of what I could find a 512M GT for and the cooling is much better (stock) and the performance is a little better.

The GT is an attractive option but I don't think you'd be disappointed with a G92 GTS either. Check the physical space in your case to accommodate the double slot, the length, and check your power supply ratings. FWIW, I'm running an E6400, P5B-E, 750G Seagate, BenQ 1640, Audigy 2ZS, Leadtek tuner card, G92 GTS and 2G OCZ Platinum on a 465W Enermax.

Thank you for your input. I'm pretty much sold on the MSI 8800GTS 512 at this point. I've read numerous reviews and it seems that it will handle more then i can throw at it at 1440x900 and be plenty future proof until i upgrade my entire computer in a year or two.

That being said.. I'm wondering about power requirements. Any suggestions? I have a 500w PSU at the moment that's capable of 18A on 12V1 and 16A on 12V2. Obviously that's 34A combined, and I'm wondering if that will be enough to feed this power hungry card?
 
Thank you for your input. I'm pretty much sold on the MSI 8800GTS 512 at this point. I've read numerous reviews and it seems that it will handle more then i can throw at it at 1440x900 and be plenty future proof until i upgrade my entire computer in a year or two.

That being said.. I'm wondering about power requirements. Any suggestions? I have a 500w PSU at the moment that's capable of 18A on 12V1 and 16A on 12V2. Obviously that's 34A combined, and I'm wondering if that will be enough to feed this power hungry card?

Should be fine. And I would go with the 8800GTS 512 and not look back.
 
I would go with the 8800GT and if at all possible from BFG. A friend has one and they use there own cooler with a copper base instead of the stock aluminum that most use. the card stays very cool.
 
i upgraded my 7900gt to 8800gt, sure it was a lot of improvements, but i'm not satisfied,
playing Titan Quest:IT, 1152x864 75Hz, my fps goes down to 60 fps and below when AA more than 4x, i don't consider that to be a smooth gameplay, i want a constant >70 fps !.
i mean, c'mon, at 1152x864? it's not a high res gaming, what's with everybody saying 8800gt eat everything you throw at it @ 1600x1200 and below.
 
nösferatu;1032322723 said:
i upgraded my 7900gt to 8800gt, sure it was a lot of improvements, but i'm not satisfied,
playing Titan Quest:IT, 1152x864 75Hz, my fps goes down to 60 fps and below when AA more than 4x, i don't consider that to be a smooth gameplay, i want a constant >70 fps !.
i mean, c'mon, at 1152x864? it's not a high res gaming, what's with everybody saying 8800gt eat everything you throw at it @ 1600x1200 and below.

...Titan Quest was not exactly written by geniuses. These are the same devs that thought a crash to desktop with no error message was a great way to prevent piracy. If that's the only title that runs poorly for you I'd be much quicker to blame the game than your GPU.

Also, 18A on a single rail is really underpowered for your system, considering the OCs.
 
Also, 18A on a single rail is really underpowered for your system, considering the OCs.

in that case, i'm still looking for a good cheap psu.

fyi, titan quest is not the only one, also marvel:ultimate alliance, even at 1024x768.
ah, and thanks for looking into my problem.
 
...Titan Quest was not exactly written by geniuses. These are the same devs that thought a crash to desktop with no error message was a great way to prevent piracy. If that's the only title that runs poorly for you I'd be much quicker to blame the game than your GPU.

Also, 18A on a single rail is really underpowered for your system, considering the OCs.

ha! I can understand wanting to run any/every game with no skips, but someone bitching about fps below 70!? lol gimme a break, grow a pair or find another topic to complain about :p

It sounds like it'll be fine
 
ha! I can understand wanting to run any/every game with no skips, but someone bitching about fps below 70!? lol gimme a break, grow a pair or find another topic to complain about :p

It sounds like it'll be fine

you should've at least tried what i experienced, when playing that game at 50ish fps, makes everything blurry when you move your character, effectively makes you hard to make focus on game objects (monster, chest etc) therefor you'll likely feels like you're reading a 500 pages full-text book after playing an hour or less.


..and sorry to op, just like to share my experience.
 
On PSU's with 2-4 12v rails, 18A is common. You are fine with that psu as long as it's a decent brand/model that didn't lie about it's output on the label. The reason you combine the 12v rails is because the graphic card takes some from the PCIe x16 slot on the motherboard (12v1) and the rest from the PCIe 6 pin connector (12v2).
 
To the OP: consider an update of your SBLive! sound card too. New sound cards aren't all that pricey and, if you have decent speakers, can really add to your game because of the number of voices that can be used at the same time and hardware support for higher versions of EAX (assuming you have a surround setup of 4.1 or higher). A non-value edition SBLive is a high quality card, but is limited compared to a good Audigy2 or X-Fi. If you want to save some coin, look for a used Audigy 2ZS instead of buying a new X-Fi.
 
To the OP: consider an update of your SBLive! sound card too. New sound cards aren't all that pricey and, if you have decent speakers, can really add to your game because of the number of voices that can be used at the same time and hardware support for higher versions of EAX (assuming you have a surround setup of 4.1 or higher). A non-value edition SBLive is a high quality card, but is limited compared to a good Audigy2 or X-Fi. If you want to save some coin, look for a used Audigy 2ZS instead of buying a new X-Fi.

Yeah, i've been very lazy about upgrading sound cards. I've had this one since 00-01 or so. But I use a decent pair of headphones primarily, with no external surround sound setup, so i've never had the motivation to upgrade.

As far as the PSU i'm using: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817182016

I know it's not the favored PSU, but I built this last system on a budget, and was used to having low amperage PSU's that came with a case. I've had no issues with it at all, and I couldnt be happier with it.

Thanks for all your help guys.. card should be here by monday night. I couldnt be more pleased!
 
That PSU is meh... personally I wouldn't trust it, but I've had bad experiences with Rosewill. It should be enough to power a single 8800GT, just don't try to SLI...
 
I'd stick with PC-Power&Cooling, Antec, Corsair, and Ultra's non-modular PSU's to name a few(the Ultra X-finity 500 watt SLI psu I have is running well w/ no probs, so don't say they're crap. lol). Stick to big name brands with trusted reviews.
 
Back
Top